Aleksandr Isayevich Solzhenitsyn ( , ) (December
11, 1918 – August 3, 2008) was a
Soviet
and
Russian
novelist,
dramatist, and
historian.
Through
his writings he made the world aware of the Gulag, the Soviet Union
's forced labor camp system – particularly
The Gulag Archipelago
and One Day
in the Life of Ivan Denisovich, his two best-known
works. Solzhenitsyn was awarded the
Nobel Prize in Literature in 1970.
He was
exiled from the Soviet Union in 1974. and returned to Russia
in
1994. Solzhenitsyn is the father of
Ignat Solzhenitsyn, a
conductor and
pianist.
Biography
In the Soviet Union
Early Years
Aleksandr
Solzhenitsyn was born in Kislovodsk
, RSFSR (now in
Stavropol Krai, Russia
) to a young
Ukrainian widow, Taisiya Solzhenitsyna
(née Shcherbak), whose father had risen, it seems, from
humble beginnings, much of a self-made man, and acquired a large
estate in the Kuban region by the northern
foothills of the Caucasus. During
World War I, Taisiya went to Moscow to
study. While there she met Isaakiy Solzhenitsyn, a young army
officer, also from the Caucasus region (the family background of
his parents is vividly brought to life in the opening chapters of
August 1914, and later on in the
Red Wheel novel cycle).
In 1918, Taisia became pregnant with Aleksandr. Shortly after this
was confirmed, Isaakiy was killed in a hunting accident. Aleksandr
was raised by his widowed mother and aunt in lowly circumstances;
his earliest years coincided with the
Russian Civil War; by 1930 the family
property had been turned into a
collective
farm. Solzhenitsyn stated his mother was fighting for survival
and they had to keep his father's background in the old Imperial
Army a secret. His educated mother (who never remarried) encouraged
his literary and scientific learnings and raised him in the
Russian Orthodox faith; she
died in 1944.
As early as 1936 Solzhenitsyn was developing the characters and
concepts for his epic work August 1914 – some of the chapters he
wrote then still survive .
Solzhenitsyn studied mathematics at Rostov State University, while at
the same time taking correspondence courses from the Moscow
Institute of
Philosophy, Literature and History (at this time heavily
ideological in scope; as he himself makes clear, he did not
question the state ideology or the superiority of the Soviet Union
before he had spent some time in the camps). On April 7,
1940, while at the university, Solzhenitsyn married a chemistry
student Natalia Alekseevna Reshetovskaya. They divorced in 1952 (a
year before his release from the
Gulag); he
remarried her in 1957 and they divorced again in 1972. The
following year he married his second wife, Natalia Dmitrievna
Svetlova, a mathematician who had a son from a brief prior
marriage. He and Svetlova (b. 1939) had three sons: Yermolai
(1970), Ignat (1972), and Stepan (1973).
WWII
During
World War II Solzhenitsyn served
as the commander of a
sound-ranging
battery in the
Red Army, was involved in
major action at the front, and twice decorated. A series of
writings published late in his life, including the early
uncompleted novel
Love the Revolution!, chronicle his WWII
experience and his growing doubts about the moral foundations of
the Soviet regime.
Imprisonment
In February 1945, while serving in
East
Prussia, Solzhenitsyn was arrested for writing derogatory
comments in letters to a friend, Nikolai Vitkevich, about the
conduct of the war by
Joseph Stalin,
whom he called "Oosatiy" ("the whiskered one,") "
Khozyain" ("the master"), and "Balabos", (
Odessa Yiddish for "the master"). He was
accused of anti-Soviet propaganda under
Article 58 paragraph 10 of the Soviet criminal
code, and of "founding a hostile organization" under paragraph 11.
Solzhenitsyn was taken to the
Lubyanka
prison in Moscow, where he was beaten and interrogated. On July 7,
1945, he was sentenced in his absence by
Special Council of the NKVD to
an eight-year term in a
labor camp. This
was the normal sentence for most crimes under Article 58 at the
time.
The first part of Solzhenitsyn's sentence was served in several
different work camps; the "middle phase," as he later referred to
it, was spent in a
sharashka,
special scientific research facilities run by Ministry of State
Security, where he met
Lev Kopelev, upon
whom he based the character of
Lev Rubin in his book
The First Circle,
published in a self-censored or “distorted” version in the West in
1968. In 1950, he was sent to a "Special Camp" for political
prisoners.
During his imprisonment at the camp in the
town of Ekibastuz
in Kazakhstan
, he worked as a miner,
bricklayer, and foundry foreman. His experiences at Ekibastuz
formed the basis for the book
One Day in the Life of
Ivan Denisovich. While there he had a tumor removed,
although his
cancer was not then
diagnosed.
In March
1953 after the expiry of Solzhenitsyn's sentence, he was sent to
internal exile for life at Kok-Terek in southern Kazakhstan
, as was common for political prisoners. His
undiagnosed cancer spread, until, by the end of the year, he was
close to death.
However, in 1954, he was permitted to be
treated in a hospital in Tashkent
, where his
tumor went into remission. These experiences became the
basis of his novel
Cancer Ward
and also found an echo in the short story "The right hand." It was
during this decade of imprisonment and exile that Solzhenitsyn
abandoned
Marxism and developed the
philosophical and religious positions of his later life; this turn
has some interesting parallels to
Dostoevsky's time in Siberia and his quest for
faith a hundred years earlier. Solzhenitsyn gradually turned into a
philosophically-minded Christian as a result of his experience in
prison and the camps. He repented for what he did as a Red Army
captain and in prison compared himself with the perpetrators of the
Gulag: "I remember myself in my captain's shoulder boards and the
forward march of my battery through East Prussia, enshrouded in
fire, and I say: 'So were we any better?'" His transformation is
described at some length in the fourth part of
The Gulag Archipelago ("The Soul
and Barbed Wire"). The narrative poem The Trail (written without
benefit of pen or paper in prison and camps between 1947 and 1952)
and the twenty-eight poems composed in prison, forced-labor camp,
and exile also provide crucial material for understanding
Solzhenitsyn's intellectual and spiritual odyssey during this
period. These "early" works, largely unknown in the West, were
published for the first time in Russian in 1999 and excerpted in
English in 2006.
After Liberation
After
Khrushchev's Secret
Speech in 1956 Solzhenitsyn was freed from exile and
exonerated. After his return to European Russia, Solzhenitsyn was,
while teaching at a secondary school during the day, spending his
nights secretly engaged in writing. In his Nobel Prize acceptance
speech he wrote, "during all the years until 1961, not only was I
convinced I should never see a single line of mine in print in my
lifetime, but, also, I scarcely dared allow any of my close
acquaintances to read anything I had written because I feared this
would become known."
In the 1960s while he was publicly known to be writing Cancer Ward,
he was simultaneously writing Gulag Archipelago. The KGB found out
about this..
Finally, when he was 42 years old, he approached
Alexander Tvardovsky, a poet and the
chief editor of the
Noviy Mir magazine, with the
manuscript of
One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich. It
was published in edited form in 1962, with the explicit approval of
Nikita Khrushchev, who defended it
and declared at the presidium of the Politburo hearing on whether
to allow its publishing, "There’s a Stalinist in each of you;
there’s even a Stalinist in me. We must root out this evil." The
book became an instant hit and sold-out everywhere. During
Khrushchev's tenure,
One Day in the Life of Ivan
Denisovich was studied in schools in the Soviet Union and
three more short works of Solzhenitsyn's, including his acclaimed
short story
Matryona’s Home, were published in 1963. These
would be the last of his works published in the Soviet Union until
1990.
One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich brought the Soviet
system of prison labor to the attention of the West. It caused as
much a sensation in the Soviet Union as it did the West—not only by
its striking realism and candour, but also because it was the first
major piece of Soviet literature since the twenties on a
politically charged theme, written by a non-party member, even by a
man who had been to Siberia for "libelous speech" about the
leaders, and still it had not been censored. In this sense, the
publication of Solzhenitsyn's story was an almost unheard of
instance of free, unrestrained discussion of politics through
literature. Most Soviet readers realized this, but after Khrushchev
had been ousted from power in 1964, the time for such raw exposing
works came quietly, but perceptibly, to a close.
Persecutions
Solzhenitsyn did not give in but tried, with the help of
Tvardovsky, to get his novel,
The Cancer Ward, legally
published in the Soviet Union. This had to get the approval of the
Union of Writers, and though some
there appreciated it, the work ultimately was denied publication
unless it was to be revised and cleaned of suspect statements and
anti-Soviet insinuations (this episode is recounted and documented
in
The Oak and the
Calf).
The
publishing of his work quickly stopped; as a writer, he became a
non-person, and, by 1965, the KGB
had seized
some of his papers, including the manuscript of The First
Circle. Meanwhile Solzhenitsyn continued to secretly
and feverishly work upon the most subversive of all his writings,
the monumental
Gulag
Archipelago. The seizing of his novel manuscript first
made him desperate and frightened, but gradually he realized that
it had set him free from the pretenses and trappings of being an
"officially acclaimed" writer, something which had come close to
second nature, but which was becoming increasingly irrelevant (the
circumstances of how he actually survived in this period without
any income from his books are obscure; he had quit his teaching
post when he broke through as a writer).
After the
KGB had confiscated Solzhenitsyn's materials in Moscow, during
1965–1967 the preparatory drafts of The Gulag Archipelago were turned into
finished typescript in hiding at his friends' homes in Estonia
. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn had befriended
Arnold Susi, a lawyer and former
Estonian Minister of Education in a
Lubyanka Prison cell. After completion the original
Solzhenitsyn's handwritten script was kept hidden from the KGB in
Estonia by Arnold Susi's daughter Heli Susi until the collapse of
the Soviet Union.
In 1969 Solzhenitsyn was expelled from the Union of Writers. In
1970, Solzhenitsyn was awarded the
Nobel Prize in Literature.
He could
not receive the prize personally in Stockholm
at that time, since he was afraid he would not be
let back into the Soviet Union. Instead, it was
suggested he should receive the prize in a special ceremony at the
Swedish
embassy in Moscow
.
The
Swedish government refused to accept this solution, since such a
ceremony and the ensuing media coverage might upset the Soviet Union
and damage Sweden's relations with the
superpower. Instead, Solzhenitsyn received his prize at the
1974 ceremony after he had been deported from the Soviet
Union.
The Gulag Archipelago was composed during 1958–1967. This
work was a three-volume work on the Soviet prison camp system,
though Solzhenitsyn never had all seven parts before himself at any
given time.
The Gulag Archipelago has sold over thirty
million copies in thirty-five languages. It was based upon
Solzhenitsyn's own experience as well as the testimony of 256
former prisoners and Solzhenitsyn's own research into the history
of the penal system. It discussed the system's origins from the
founding of the Communist regime, with
Lenin
himself having responsibility, detailing interrogation procedures,
prisoner transports, prison camp culture,
prisoner uprisings and revolts, and the
practice of
internal exile. The
Gulag Archipelago’s rich and varied authorial voice, its
unique weaving together of personal testimony, philosophical
analysis, and historical investigation, and its unrelenting
indictment of communist ideology made
The Gulag
Archipelago one of the most consequential books of the
twentieth century. The appearance of the book in the West put the
word
gulag into the Western political
vocabulary and guaranteed swift retribution from the Soviet
authorities.
During this period, he was sheltered by the
cellist Mstislav
Rostropovich, who suffered considerably for his support of
Solzhenitsyn and was eventually forced into exile himself.
In the West
On
February 12, 1974, Solzhenitsyn was arrested and on the next day he
was deported from the Soviet Union to Frankfurt
, West
Germany
and stripped of his Soviet citizenship. The
KGB had found the manuscript for the first part of
The Gulag
Archipelago and, less than a week later,
Yevgeny Yevtushenko suffered reprisals
for his support of Solzhenitsyn.
U.S. military attache
William Odom
managed to smuggle out a large portion of Solzhenitsyn's archive,
including the author's membership card for the
Writers' Union and Second World War military
citations; Solzhenitsyn subsequently paid tribute to Odom's role in
his memoir "Invisible Allies" (1995).
In Germany, Solzhenitsyn lived in
Heinrich Böll's house in
Cologne.
He then moved to Zurich, Switzerland
before Stanford University
invited him to stay in the United States
to "facilitate your work, and to accommodate you
and your family." He stayed on the 11th floor of the Hoover Tower
, part of the Hoover
Institution, before moving to Cavendish, Vermont
in 1976. He was given an honorary Literary Degree
from Harvard
University
in 1978 and on Thursday, June 8, 1978 he gave his
Commencement Address condemning, among other
things, materialism in modern western culture.
Over the next 17 years, Solzhenitsyn worked on his cyclical history
of the
Russian Revolution of
1917,
The Red Wheel. By
1992, four "knots" (parts) had been completed and he had also
written several shorter works.
Despite spending two decades in the United States, Solzhenitsyn did
not become fluent in spoken English. He had, however, been reading
English-language literature since his teens, encouraged by his
mother . More importantly, he resented the idea of becoming a media
star and of tempering his ideas or ways of talking in order to suit
television. Solzhenitsyn's warnings about the dangers of Communist
aggression and the weakening of the moral fiber of the West were
generally well received in Western conservative circles, alongside
the tougher foreign policy pursued by U.S. President
Ronald Reagan.
At the same time, liberals and secularists became increasingly critical of what
they perceived as his reactionary
preference for Russian
patriotism
and the Russian Orthodox
religion. Solzhenitsyn also harshly criticised what he saw
as the ugliness and spiritual vapidity of the dominant
pop culture of the modern West, including
television and much of popular music: "...the human soul longs for
things higher, warmer, and purer than those offered by today's mass
living habits ... by TV stupor and by intolerable
music."
Despite his criticism of the “weakness” of the West Solzhenitsyn
always made clear that he admired the political liberty which was
one of the enduring strengths of western democratic societies. In a
major speech delivered to the International Academy of Philosophy
in Liechtenstein on September 14, 1993, Solzhenitsyn implored the
West not to "lose sight of its own values, its historically unique
stability of civic life under the rule of law—a hard-won stability
which grants independence and space to every private citizen." In a
series of writings, speeches, and interviews after his return to
his native Russia in 1994, Solzhenitsyn spoke about his admiration
for the local self-government he had witnessed first hand in
Switzerland and New England during his western exile.
Return to Russia
In 1990, his Soviet citizenship was restored, and, in 1994, he
returned to Russia with his wife, Natalia, who had become a United
States citizen. Their sons stayed behind in the United States
(later, his oldest son Yermolai returned to Russia to work for the
Moscow office of a leading management consultancy firm).
From then
until his death, he lived with his wife in a dacha in Troitse-Lykovo (Троице-Лыково) in west
Moscow
between the dachas once occupied by Soviet leaders
Mikhail Suslov and Konstantin Chernenko.
Following the collapse of the Soviet Union, Solzhenitsyn called for
a restoration of the
Russian monarchy.
The writer, however, deplored what he considered Russia's spiritual
decline, increasingly adopting Western materialistic values, but in
the last years of his life he praised President Vladimir Putin for
Russia's revival.
After returning to Russia in 1994, Solzhenitsyn published eight
two-part short stories, a series of contemplative "miniatures" or
prose poems, a literary memoir on his years in the West (
The
Grain Between the Millstones) among many other writings.
All of Solzhenitsyn's sons became U.S. citizens. One,
Ignat, has achieved acclaim as a
pianist and
conductor in the United States.
Death
Solzhenitsyn died of heart failure near Moscow on August 3, 2008,
at the age of 89.
A burial service was
held at Donskoy Monastery,
Moscow
, on Wednesday, August 6, 2008. He was buried
on the same date at the place chosen by him in Donskoy necropolis.
Russian and world leaders paid tribute to Solzhenitsyn following
his death.
Legacy
The most complete 30-volume edition of Solzhenitsyn’s collected
works is soon to be published in Russia.
The presentation of
its first three volumes, already in print, recently took place in
Moscow
. On June 5, 2007 then Russian President
Vladimir Putin signed a decree
conferring on Solzhenitsyn the
State Prize of the Russian
Federation for his humanitarian work. Putin personally visited
the writer at his home on June 12, 2007 to present him with the
award. Like his father, Yermolai Solzhenitsyn has translated some
of his father's works. Stephan Solzhenitsyn lives and works in
Moscow.
Ignat Solzhenitsyn is the
music director of
The Chamber Orchestra of
Philadelphia.
KGB operations against Solzhenitsyn
On 19 September 1974,
Yuri Andropov
approved a large-scale operation to discredit Solzhenitsyn and his
family and cut his communications with
Soviet dissidents. The plan was jointly
approved by
Vladimir Kryuchkov,
Philipp Bobkov, and Grigorenko (heads
of First, Second and Fifth KGB Directorates).
The residencies in
Geneva
, London
, Paris
, Rome
and other
European cities participated in the operation. Among other
active measures, at least three
StB agents became translators and secretaries of
Solzhenitsyn (one of them translated the poem
Prussian Nights),keeping KGB informed
regarding all contacts by Solzhenitsyn.
KGB sponsored a series of hostile books about Solzhenitsyn, most
notably a "memoir published under the name of his first wife,
Natalia Reshetovskaya, but probably mostly composed by Service",
according to historian
Christopher Andrew. Andropov
also gave an order to create "an atmosphere of distrust and
suspicion between PAUK and the people around him" by feeding him
rumors that everyone in his surrounding was a KGB agent and
deceiving him in all possible ways. Among other things, the writer
constantly received envelopes with photographs of car accidents,
brain surgery and other frightening illustrations.
After the KGB
harassment in Zurich, Solzhenitsyn settled in Cavendish,
Vermont
, reduced communications with others and surrounded
his property with a barbed wire
fence. His influence and moral authority for the West
diminished as he became increasingly isolated and critical of the
Western individualism. KGB and
CPSU experts
finally concluded that he alienated American listeners by his
"reactionary views and intransigent criticism of the US way of
life", so no further
active measures
would be required.
Accusations of collaboration with NKVD
In his book
The Gulag
Archipelago Solzhenitsyn states that he was recruited to report
to the NKVD on fellow inmates and was given a code-name Vetrov, but
due to his transfer to another camp he was able to elude this duty
and never produced a single report.
In 1976,
after Solzhenitsyn was expelled from the Soviet Union
a report signed by Vetrov surfaced. After a
copy of the report was obtained by Solzhenitsyn he published it
together with a refutation in the
Los
Angeles Times (published 24 May 1976). In 1978 the same report
was published by journalist
Frank Arnau
in a socialist
Western German
magazine
Neue Politik. According to
Arnau the report was used in the prosecution and death sentence of
a group of Ukrainian nationalists incarcerated at Ekibastuz. In
1985 Solzhenitsyn was accused of collaboration in an open letter by
fellow prisoners Yakubovich and
Lev
Kopelev.
However,
according to Solzhenitsyn the report is a falsification by the
KGB
. He claimed that the report is dated 20
January 1952 while all Ukrainians were transferred to a separate
camp on January 6 and they had no relation to the uprising in
Solzhenitsyn's camp on January 22. He also claimed that the only
people who might in 1976 have access to a "secret KGB archive" were
KGB agents themselves. Solzhenitsyn also requested Arnau to put the
alleged document to a
graphology test but
Arnau refused.
In 1990 the report was reproduced in Soviet
Voyenno-Istoricheskiy Zhurnal among the memoirs of L.A.
Samutin, a former
ROA soldier and GULAG inmate
who was an erstwhile supporter of Solzhenitsyn, but later became
his critic. According to Solzhenitzyn publishing of the memoirs was
canceled at the request of Samutin's widow who stated that the
memoirs were in fact dictated by the KGB).
Views on Atheism, History and Politics
Solzhenitsyn on the failing of atheism:
Over a half century ago, while I was still a child, I recall
hearing a number of old people offer the following explanation for
the great disasters that had befallen Russia: "Men have forgotten
God; that's why all this has happened."Since then I have spent
well-nigh 50 years working on the history of our revolution; in the
process I have read hundreds of books, collected hundreds of
personal testimonies, and have already contributed eight volumes of
my own toward the effort of clearing away the rubble left by that
upheaval. But if I were asked today to formulate as concisely as
possible the main cause of the ruinous revolution that swallowed up
some 60 million of our people, I could not put it more accurately
than to repeat: "Men have forgotten God; that's why all this has
happened.
Edward E. Ericson, Jr., "Solzhenitsyn – Voice from the Gulag,"
Eternity, October 1985, pp. 23, 24.
Historical views
During
his years in the west, Solzhenitsyn was very active in the
historical debate, discussing the history of Russia
, the
Soviet
Union
and communism. He
tried to correct what he considered to be western
misconceptions.
On Russia and the Jews
Solzhenitsyn also published a two-volume work on the history of
Russian-Jewish relations (
Two Hundred Years Together 2001,
2002). This book stirred controversy and some viewed it as
antisemitic. This book became a best-seller in
Russia. Solzhenitsyn begins his book with a plea for "patient
mutual comprehension" on the part of Russians and Russian Jews. The
author writes that the book was conceived in the hope of promoting
"mutually agreeable and fruitful pathways for the future
development of Russian-Jewish relations."
There is sharp division on the allegation of
antisemitism. From Solzhenitsyn's own essay
"Repentance and Self-Limitation in the Life of Nations", he calls
for Russians and Russian Jews alike to take responsibility for the
"renegades" in both communities who supported a totalitarian and
terrorist regime after 1917. At the end of chapter 15, he writes
that Jews must answer for the "revolutionary cutthroats" in their
ranks just as Russians must repent "for the pogroms,
for...merciless arsonist peasants, for...crazed revolutionary
soldiers." It is not, he adds, a matter of answering "before other
peoples, but to oneself, to one's consciousness, and before
God."
Similarities between
Two Hundred years together and an
antisemitic essay titled “Jews in the USSR and in the Future
Russia”, attributed to Solzhenitsyn, has led to inference that he
stands behind the anti-Semitic passages. Solzhenitsyn himself
claims that the essay consists of manuscripts stolen from him, and
then manipulated, forty years ago. However, according to the
historian
Semyon Reznik, textological
analyses have in fact proven Solzhenitsyn's authorship.
In 1984
Solzhenitsyn was interviewed by Nikolay Kazantsev, a monarchist Russian-Argentinian journalist, for
"Nasha Strana", a russophone newspaper in Buenos-Aires
. In the interview he said: "We (Russia) are
walking a narrow istmus between Communists and the World Jewry.
Neither is acceptable for us... And I mean this not in the racial
sense, but in the sense of the Jewry as a certain world view. The
Jewry is embodied in "Fevralism" (i.e. democracy). Neither side is
acceptable to us in the case the War breaks out." He also described
the United States as a "province of Israel".
A prominent dissident writer
Vladimir
Voynovich, interviewed for
Radio
Freedom on the first anniversary of Solzhenitsyn' death, has
stated that Solzhenitshyn harbored antisemitic sentiments all his
life, as attested by the 1964 manuscript he later developed into
"200 Years Together", and that he deliberately concealed them,
because he knew this would have prevented him from receiving the
Nobel Prize.
On new Russian "democracy"
In his recent political writings, such as
Rebuilding
Russia (1990) and
Russia in Collapse (1998),
Solzhenitsyn criticized the oligarchic excesses of the new Russian
'democracy,' while opposing any nostalgia for Soviet communism. He
defended moderate and self-critical patriotism (as opposed to
extreme nationalism), argued for the indispensability of local
self-government to a free Russia, and expressed concerns for the
fate of the 25 million ethnic Russians in the "
near abroad" of the former Soviet Union. He also
sought to "protect" the national character of the Russian Orthodox
church and fought against the admission of Catholic priests and
Protestant pastors to Russia from other countries. For a brief
period, he had his own TV show, where he freely expressed his
views. The show was cancelled because of low ratings, but
Solzhenitsyn continued to maintain a relatively high profile in the
media.
The West
Delivering the commencement address at Harvard in 1978, he called
the United States spiritually weak and mired in vulgar materialism.
Americans, he said, speaking in Russian through a translator,
suffered from a "decline in courage" and a "lack of
manliness." Few were willing to die for their
ideals, he said. He condemned both the United States government and
American society for its “hasty” capitulation in Vietnam. He
criticized the country’s music as intolerable and attacked its
unfettered press, accusing it of violations of privacy. He said
that the West erred in measuring other civilizations by its own
model. While faulting Soviet society for denying fair legal
treatment of people, he also faulted the West for being too
legalistic: "A society which is based on the letter of the law and
never reaches any higher is taking very scarce advantage of the
high level of human possibilities."
Shortly after his death, professor
Richard
Pipes, a history professor at Harvard, wrote of him:
"Solzhenitsyn blamed the evils of Soviet communism on the West. He
rightly stressed the European origins of Marxism, but he never
asked himself why Marxism in other European countries led not to
the gulag but to the welfare state. He reacted with white fury to
any suggestion that the roots of Leninism and Stalinism could be
found in Russia’s past. His knowledge of Russian history was very
superficial and laced with a romantic sentimentalism. While
accusing the West of imperialism, he seemed quite unaware of the
extraordinary expansion of his own country into regions inhabited
by non-Russians. He also denied that Imperial Russia practiced
censorship or condemned political prisoners to hard labor, which,
of course, was absurd.".
Russian culture
In his 1978 Harvard address, Solzhenitsyn argued over Russian
culture, that the West erred in "denying its autonomous character
and therefore never understood it "
Communism, Russia and nationalism
Solzhenitsyn emphasized the significantly
more oppressive character of the Soviet totalitarian regime, in comparison to the
Tsarist Russian
Empire
. He asserted that Imperial Russia did not
practice any real
censorship in the style
of the
Soviet Glavlit, that political
prisoners typically were not forced into
labor camps in spite of the existence of the
katorga, and that the number of political
prisoners was only one ten-thousandth of those in the Soviet Union.
He noted that the Tsar's
secret service was
only present in the three largest cities, and not at all in the
army.
He
compared Bolsheviks with Jacobins of the Reign of Terror of France
.
He believed that revolutionary violence comes from the teachings of
Karl Marx and
Friedrich Engels, arguing
Marxism is violent. His conclusion is
Communism will always be
totalitarian and violent everywhere it exists,
not just in a specific country. He considered purely Russian
conditions to be of secondary importance.
According to Solzhenitsyn,
Russians were
not the ruling nation in the Soviet Union. He believed that all
ethnic cultures have been oppressed in favor of an
atheistic Soviet culture. Russian culture was even
more oppressed than the smaller minority cultures, since the regime
was more afraid of ethnic uprisings among Russians than among other
peoples. Therefore, Solzhenitsyn argued, Russian
nationalism and the
Orthodox Church should not be
regarded as a threat by the West but rather as allies.
Solzhenitsyn said that for every country, great power status
deforms and harms the national character and that he has never
wished great power status for Russia. He rejected the view that the
USA and Russia are natural rivals, saying that before the [Russian]
revolution, they were natural allies and that during the American
Civil War, Russia supported Lincoln and the North [in contrast to
Britain and France, which supported the Confederacy], and then they
were allies in the First World War. But beginning with communism,
Russia ceased to exist and the confrontation was not at all with
Russia but with the Communist U.S.S.R.
World War II
Solzhenitsyn criticized the Allies for not opening a new front
against Nazi Germany
in the west earlier in World War II. This resulted in Soviet
domination and oppression of the nations of
Eastern Europe. Solzhenitsyn claimed the
western democracies apparently cared little about how many died in
the east, as long as they could end the war quickly and painlessly
for themselves in the west. While stationed in East Prussia as an
artillery officer, Solzhenitsyn witnessed war crimes against the
civilian German population by Soviet "liberators" as the elderly
were robbed of their meager possessions and women were gang-raped
to death. He wrote a poem entitled "
Prussian Nights" about these incidents. In
it, the first-person narrator seems to approve of the troops'
crimes as revenge for German atrocities, expressing his desire to
take part in the plunder himself. The poem describes the rape of a
Polish woman whom the Red Army soldiers mistakenly thought to be a
German.
Stalinism
In his
Gulag Archipelago
Solzhenitsyn rejected the view that it was
Stalin who created the Soviet
totalitarian state.
He argued that it was
Lenin who started the mass executions, created a planned economy, founded the Cheka which would later be turned into the KGB
, and started
the system of labor camps later known as
Gulag.
Mikhail Sholokhov
Solzhenitsyn was the most prominent of the Nobel Laureate
Mikhail Sholokhov's many detractors. He
alleged that the work which made Sholokhov's international
reputation,
And Quiet Flows
the Don was written by
Fyodor
Kryukov, a
Cossack and
Anti-Bolshevik, who died in 1920, possibly in
retaliation for Sholokhov scathing opinion re "One Day of Ivan
Denisovich". Solzhenitsyn claimed that Sholokhov found the
manuscript and published it under his own name. These rumors first
appeared in the late 1920s, but an investigation upheld Sholokhov's
authorship of "Silent Don" and the allegations were denounced as
malicious slander in
Pravda.
A 1984 monograph by
Geir Kjetsaa and
others demonstrated through statistical analyses that Sholokhov was
indeed the likely author of
Don. And in 1987, several
thousand pages of notes and drafts of the work were discovered and
authenticated.
During the second world war, Sholokhov's archive was destroyed in a
bomb raid, and only the fourth volume survived. Sholokhov had his
friend Vassily Kudashov, who was killed in the war, look after it.
Following Kudashov's death, his widow took possession of the
manuscript, but she never disclosed the fact of owning it. The
manuscript was finally found by the Institute of World Literature
of Russia's Academy of Sciences in 1999 with assistance from the
Russian Government. An analysis of the novel has unambiguously
proved Sholokhov's authorship. The writing paper dates back to the
1920s: 605 pages are in Sholokhov's own hand, and 285 are
transcribed by his wife Maria and sisters.
The Sino-Soviet Conflict
In 1973, near the height of the
Sino-Soviet conflict, Solzhenitsyn sent a
Letter to the Soviet Leaders to a limited number of upper
echelon Soviet officials. This work, which was published for the
general public in the Western world a year after it was sent to its
intended audience, beseeched the Soviet Union's authorities to
Give them their ideology! Let the Chinese leaders glory
in it for a while. And for that matter, let them shoulder the whole
sackful of unfulfillable international obligations, let them grunt
and heave and instruct humanity, and foot all the bills for their
absurd economics (a million a day just to Cuba), and let them
support terrorists and guerrillas in the Southern Hemisphere too if
they like. The main source of the savage feuding between us will
then melt away, a great many points of today's contention and
conflict all over the world will also melt away, and a military
clash will become a much remoter possibility and perhaps won't
take place at all [author's emphasis].
Vietnam war
Once in America, Solzhenitsyn urged the United States to continue
its involvement in the
Vietnam
War.
In his commencement address at Harvard University in 1978 (
A
World Split Apart), Solzhenitsyn alleged that many in the U.S.
did not understand the
Vietnam War. He
rhetorically asks if the American antiwar proponents now realize
the effects their actions had on Vietnam: "But members of the U.S.
antiwar movement wound up being involved in the betrayal of Far
Eastern nations, in a genocide and in the suffering today imposed
on 30 million people there. Do those convinced pacifists hear the
moans coming from there?"
During his time in the West, Solzhenitsyn made a few controversial
public statements: notably, he characterized
Daniel Ellsberg as a traitor.
Kosovo War
Solzhenitsyn strongly condemned the bombing
of Yugoslavia during the Kosovo War,
saying "there is no difference whatsoever between NATO
and Hitler."
The Holodomor
Solzhenitsyn said that Ukrainian efforts to have the 1930s famine,
the
Holodomor, recognised as a
genocide against Ukrainian
people is an act of
historical revisionism. He believed
that the famine was caused by the
nature of the Communist
regime, under which all peoples suffered. It was not an assault
by the Russian people against the people of Ukraine, and that the
wish to view it as such is only a recent development, according to
him
Western culture
...there also exists another alliance — at first
glance a strange one, a surprising one—but if you think about it,
in fact, one which is well-grounded and easy to
understand.
This is the alliance between our Communist leaders and
your capitalists.
This alliance is not new.
The very famous Armand
Hammer, who is flourishing here today, laid the basis for this
when he made the first exploratory trip into Russia, still in
Lenin's time, in the very first years of the
Revolution.
And if today the Soviet Union has powerful military and
police forces—in a country which is by contemporary standards
poor—they are used to crush our movement for freedom in the Soviet
Union—and we have western capital to thank for this
also.
Testimony to the
U.S. Congress, July 8, 1975.
Until I came to the West myself and spent two years
looking around, I could never have imagined to what an extreme
degree the West had actually become a world without a will, a world
gradually petrifying in the face of the danger confronting it...All
of us are standing on the brink of a great historical cataclysm, a
flood that swallows up civilization and changes whole
epochs.
Modern world
He described the problems of both East and West as "a disaster"
rooted in
atheism and
Dechristianisation. He referred to it as
"the calamity of an autonomous, irreligious humanistic
consciousness."
It has made man the measure of all things on
earth—imperfect man, who is never free of pride, self-interest,
envy, vanity, and dozens of other defects.
We are now paying for the mistakes which were not
properly appraised at the beginning of the journey.
On the way from the Renaissance to our days we have
enriched our experience, but we have lost the concept of a Supreme
Complete Entity which used to restrain our passions and our
irresponsibility.
Published works and speeches
- The
Solzhenitsyn Reader: New and Essential Writings, 1947-2005,
edited by Edward E. Ericson, Jr. and Daniel J.
Mahoney, ISI Books (2009)
- A Storm in the
Mountains
- One Day
in the Life of Ivan Denisovich (1962; novella)
- An Incident at Krechetovka Station (1963; novella)
- Matryona's Place
(1963; novella)
- For the Good of the Cause (1964; novella)
- The First Circle
(1968; novel)
- Cancer Ward (1968; novel)
- The Love-Girl and
the Innocent (1969; play),
aka The Prisoner and the Camp Hooker or The Tenderfoot
and the Tart.
- Nobel Prize delivered speech (1970)The speech was delivered
to the Swedish
Academy
in writing and not actually given as a
lecture.
- August 1914 (1971). The
beginning of a history of the birth of the USSR in an historical novel. The novel centers on
the disastrous loss in the Battle of Tannenberg
in August, 1914, and the ineptitude of the military
leadership. Other works, similarly titled, follow the story:
see The Red Wheel (overall
title).
- The Gulag
Archipelago (three volumes) (1973–1978), not a memoir, but
a history of the entire process of developing and administering a
police state in the Soviet Union.
- Prussian Nights
(Finished in 1951, first published in 1974; poetry)
- Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn's speech at the Nobel Banquet at the City Hall in
Stockholm, December 10, 1974
- Aleksandr Isaevich Solzhenitsyn, A Letter to the Soviet
leaders, Collins: Harvill Press (1974), ISBN
0-06-013913-7
- The Oak and the
Calf (1975)
- Lenin in Zürich (1976; separate publication of
chapters on Lenin, none of them published
before this point, from The Red
Wheel. They were later incorporated into the 1984 edition
of the expanded August, 1914.)
- Warning to the West (1976; 5 speeches (translated to
English), 3 to the Americans in 1975 and 2 to the British in
1976)
- Harvard Commencement Address (1978) link
- The Mortal Danger: Misconceptions about Soviet Russia and
the Threat to America (1980)
- Pluralists (1983; political pamphlet)
- November 1916 (1983;
novel in The Red Wheel sequence)
- Victory Celebration (1983)
- Prisoners (1983)
- Godlessness, the First Step to the Gulag.
Templeton Prize Address, London, May 10 (1983)
- August 1914 (1984; novel, much-expanded edition)
- Rebuilding Russia (1990)
- March 1917 (1990)
- April 1917
- The Russian Question (1995)
- Russia under Avalanche (Россия в обвале,1998;
political pamphlet) (Complete text in Russian:)
- Two Hundred Years
Together (2003) on Russian-Jewish relations since 1772,
aroused ambiguous public response.
See also
Notes
References
- Björkegren, Hans, and Kaarina Eneberg Aleksandr
Solzhenitsyn: A Biography, Henley-on-Thames: Aiden Ellis,
1973. ISBN 0-85628-005-4.
- Daprà Veronika: "A.I. Solzhenitsyn: The Political Writings."
Università degli Studi di Venezia, 1991; Prof.Vittorio Strada,
Dott.Julija Dobrovol'skaja;
- Ericson, Edward E. Jr. and Klimoff, Alexis, The Soul and
Barbed Wire: An Introduction to Solzhenitsyn, ISI books,
2008.
- Guardian (London). August 3, 2008.
- Mahoney, Daniel J., Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn: The Ascent From
Ideology, Rowman & Littlefield, 2001.
- Moody, Christopher. Solzhenitsyn. Edinburgh: Oliver
& Boyd, 1973. ISBN 0-05-002600-3.
- Nivat, Georges, Le phénomène Soljénitsyne, Fayard,
2009.
- Pontuso, James F., Assault on Ideology: Aleksandr
Solzhenitsyn’s Political Thought 2nd ed. Lanham, Md. Lexington
Books, 2004. ISBN 978-0739105948
- Scammell, Michael Solzhenitsyn: A Biography. London:
Paladin, 1986. ISBN 0-586-08538-6.
- Thomas, D.M.: Alexander Solzhenitsyn: A Century in his
Life. New York 1998, St. Martin’s Press. ISBN 0312180365
- Victor A. Pogadaev. Solzhenitsyn: Tanpa Karyanya Sejarah Abad
20 Tak Terbayangkan – "Pentas", Jil. 3, Bil. 4 Oktober-Disember
2008. Kuala Lumpur, hlm. 60–63
Further reading
- Biographies
- Reference works
- Edward J. Brown, “Solzhenitsyn and the Epic of the Camps,” in
his Russian Literature Since the Revolution (Cambridge, Mass.:
Harvard University, 1982), pp. 251–291
- Michael Lydon, “Alexander Solzhenitsyn,” in his Real Writing:
Word Models of the Modern World (New York: Patrick Press, 2001),
pp. 183–251
- Mahoney, “Solzhenitsyn on Russia’s ‘Jewish Question,’” Society
(November–December 2002): 104–109
- Rufus W. Mathewson, Jr., “Solzhenitsyn,” in his The Positive
Hero in Russian Literature (Stanford, Cal.: Stanford University
Press, 1975), pp. 279–340
- Mary McCarthy, “The Tolstoy Connection,” Saturday Review, 16
September 1972, pp. 79–96
- Modern Fiction Studies, special Solzhenitsyn issue, 23 (Spring
1977)
- David Remnick, “The Exile Returns,” New Yorker (14 February
1994): 64–83
- Leona Toker, “The Gulag Archipelago” and “The Gulag Fiction of
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn,” in her Return from the Archipelago:
Narrative of Gulag Survivors (Bloomington: Indiana University
Press, 2000), pp. 101–121, 188–209
- Dariusz Tolczyk, “A Sliver in the Throat of Power,” in his See
No Evil: Literary Cover-Ups and Discoveries of the Soviet Camp
Experience (New Haven, Conn. & London: Yale University Press,
1999), pp. 253–310
- Transactions of the Association of Russian-American Scholars in
the U.S.A., 29 (1998)
- Urmanov, ed., “Odin den’ Ivana Denisovicha” A. I.
Solzhenitsyna: Khudozhestvennyi mir. Poetika. Kul’turnyi kontekst
(Blagoveshchensk: BGPU, 2003)
- Zvezda, special Solzhenitsyn issue (June 1994)
External links
- The
official site
- Obituary from The Economist
- The Nobel Prize in Literature 1970
- The Nobel Prize Internet Archive's page on
Solzhenitsyn
- A World Split Apart: Solzhenitsyn's 1978
Commencement Address to the graduating class at Harvard University
- Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn: "Saving the Nation Is the
Utmost Priority for the State" Moscow News May 2,
2006
- Der Spiegel interviews Alexander Solzhenitsyn: 'I
Am Not Afraid of Death' Der Spiegel July 23, 2007
- Solzhenicyn.ru – most informative site about Alexander
Solzhenitsyn
- Vermont Recluse Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
- Solzhenitsyn’s autobiography from his non-official
site
- The introduction to the Book Gulag by Anne
Applebaum
- Russian Memorial website to Human Rights victims
- Solzhenitsyn: biography, photos, prose, interviews,
critical essays
- Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn – Obituary and public
tribute
- The Solzhenitsyn Reader: New and Essential
Writings, 1947–2005
- Alexander Solzhenitsyn's Profile
- Solzhenitsyn: Life in Cavendish Richard Svec, Town
Manager of Cavendish, VT, speaks of Solzhenitsyn. Audio. August 5,
2008
- The Leaders and the Dreamers – Russia
Profile