The
Argentina and Brazil football rivalry is a highly
competitive
sports rivalry that
exists between the national football teams of the two countries, as
well as their respective sets of
fans.
Games between the two teams, even those that are only
friendly matches, are often marked by notable
and sometimes controversial incidents. This Rivalry is also called
'The Battle of the South Americans'.
Origins
The origins of the football rivalry between Argentina and Brazil
can be traced to before football became so popular in both
countries.
During the colonization of the
Americas, Spain
and Portugal
often fought
each other to gain control over vast territories.
Today few remember wars and other political confrontations between
both countries, and only recall matches, victories, goals and other
sport-related incidents. Their
rivalry is found in almost all sports, but a
men's
football match between
Argentina and Brazil is one that neither side wants to lose, and
often acquires more importance than the championship within which
it takes place. To exemplify the intensity of this rivalry, is
enough to remember that after the 1946 incidents (
see below), the two teams did not
play against each other for ten years; either team would decline to
play a given cup so that they would never have to play against the
neighbouring country.
Games statistics
| Matches |
For Argentina |
Draw |
For Brazil |
Goals |
| 94 |
34 |
23 |
37 |
149/149 |
Since their first match in 1914, the national teams have played 93
matches counting friendlies,
World
Cup, and other official competitions (excluding matches between
youth sides).
Even
though there is a difference depending on whether the Argentine
Football Association
(AFA) or the Brazilian Football
Confederation (CBF) does the counting, the near-balance is not
in dispute. Of the 94 matches played between both national
teams, 24 were draws, 37 were Brazilian victories and 34 for
Argentina, with 149 goals for Argentina and 149 for Brazil. Only
counting World Cup matches Brazil is ahead with 2 wins, 1 draw and
1 loss, whereas in the Copa América, Argentina has 15 victories, 8
draws and 10 defeats. Of 51 friendly matches, 21 were for Brazil,
16 for Argentina and 14 were draws. Since the first match between
the two countries in 1914, the 1970s proved to be dark times for
Argentina, with 6 defeats, 4 draws and no victories.
Biggest wins are, for
Argentina 6–1 (at home in Buenos Aires
, 1940) and 1–5 (away at Rio de Janeiro
, 1939), for Brazil 6–2 (at home in Rio de Janeiro,
1945 and 1960) and 1–4 (away at Buenos Aires, 1960).
Argentina
and Brazil's last continental final match took place on July 15,
2007 at Estadio José Pachencho Romero
in Maracaibo
, Venezuela
and was the final match of Copa América 2007 which Brazil won by
the score of 3-0. The first goal was scored by
Júlio Baptista, while the second one was
an
own goal by
Roberto Ayala after a pass attempt by Brazil's
Daniel Alves, who also scored the last
goal.
The latest
match between the two teams was for the 2010 World Cup
qualifiers held on September 5, 2009 in Rosario
, Argentina
. Brazil won with two goals of
Luis Fabiano and the final score of 1-3.
Maradona and Pelé rivalry
Even though there is a number of players that people postulate as
the
best player of all time,
Maradona and
Pelé
are probably the most famous, and hold most of the votes among an
elite group that includes
Cruijff,
Zico,
Beckenbauer,
Garrincha,
Michel
Platini,
Ronaldo,
Romário,
Puskás, and
Di Stéfano.
The discussion about which of the two is the number one player of
all time proved to be never ending. Even though most consider them
as the best players of
their times, many consider the
comparison between them useless, as they played during incomparable
eras, and in different leagues.
Pelé was
given the title "Athlete of the Century" by the International
Olympic Committee
. In 1999
Time
Magazine named Pelé one of the
100 Most
Important People of the 20th Century.. Also, he was elected
Football Player of the Century, by France Football's
Golden Ball Winners in 1999,
Football Player of the
Century, by IFFHS
International
Federation of Football History and Statistics, 1999,
South
America Football Player of the Century, by IFFHS
International
Federation of Football History and Statistics. Pele's
1281 goals are recognized by FIFA as the highest total
achieved by a professional footballer. All of these goals have been
checked by more than one recognized statistic institution. Pele
played between 1957 and 1973 not just in official championships but
also in short term International Tournaments between European and
South American teams – a very common event in 1960s. Pelé is
the only footballer to have won 3 World Cup Championships.
The controversy reached a climax during the
FIFA century
awards in 2000, in which Maradona was voted
Player of the
Century in an official internet
poll, garnering 53.6% of the votes against
18.53% for Pelé. Criticism by many observers came by the fact that
many TV stations and Newspapers urged Argentines to vote for
Maradona in the Fifa awards, with one TV station even giving free
internet access, leading to claims of rigging. Shortly before the
ceremony, FIFA unexpectedly decided to add a second award and
appointed a "Football Family" committee composed of football
journalists that gave to Pelé the title of best player of the
century to make it a draw. This move was criticized in Argentina,
that suspected Pelé was rewarded for his constant support of FIFA,
in contrast to Maradona's frequent criticism. Others believe that
FIFA was considering issues other than football, notably Maradona's
drug problem. Maradona left the ceremony right after receiving his
award, and before Pelé was given his. An example of the fluent
cooperation between Pelé and the FIFA is the
FIFA 100 best players' list, supposedly created in
2004 by Pelé for FIFA's 100th anniversary, though many believe that
it was created by the FIFA Executive Committee following political
motivations. In that year Pelé was given the
FIFA Order of Merit for his
contributions to football.
In another internet poll that took place in 2002, Maradona received
another award from FIFA, as one of his goals was selected as the
World Cup Goal of the Century.
One of Pelé's goals received third place, while Maradona had a
second goal selected as fourth. Critics of those two internet polls
claim them to be highly susceptible to coverage bias, because of
the more common access to Internet by younger users who might not
have seen Pelé in action.
In spite of their frequent confrontations, usually through
quotations by the media, Pelé was the guest star of Maradona's TV
show
La Noche del 10 ("The Night of the #10"), where they
had a friendly chat and played a bout of headers.
Famous players and football figures often give their opinion on the
Maradona and Pelé rivalry, sometimes choosing one of the over the
other. Others prefer not to compare them, as they played in very
different times. Perhaps one of the most reliable comparisons
available is that by the
Ballon d'Or winners (elected
since 1956 by voters of several countries, and arguably greatest
ones to properly appreciate both players). Important note : Pelé
was elected Best Player of the Century for Ballon d'Or winners and
Maradona was the runner-up..
The table below presents factual data about both footballers
career:
| Criteria |
Pelé |
Maradona |
| Playing Position |
Forward |
Attacking Midfielder |
| National Team Appearances |
92 |
91 |
| Goals Scored in National Team |
77 |
34 |
| World Cup Wins |
3 |
1 |
| Total Goals Scored |
1280 |
258 |
| Total Matches Played |
1363 |
490 |
| Average Goals Scored per Match |
0.939 |
0.526 |
| Individual Titles |
* FIFA World Cup Golden
Ball , 1970 World Cup.
- São Paulo´s Football League
Top Scorer: 1957, 1958, 1959, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965,
1969, 1973.
- Athlete of the Century, elected by
International Olympic
Committee
: 1999
- Athlete of the Century, elected by world wide
journalists, poll by French daily L'Equipe: 1981
- Athlete of the Century, by Reuters News Agency:
1999
- UNICEF Football Player of the
Century: 1999
- FIFA
Player
of the Century: 2000
- Football Player of the Century, elected by France
Football's Golden Ball Winners : 1999
- Football Player of the Century, by IFFHS International
Federation of Football History and Statistics: 1999
- South America Football Player of the Century, by IFFHS
International
Federation of Football History and Statistics: 1999
- Laureus World Sports
Awards Lifetime Achievement Award from South African President
Nelson Mandela: 2000
- BBC
Sports Personality of the Year Overseas Personality, 1970
- BBC
Sports Personality of the Year Lifetime Achievement Award,
2005
|
*Golden Ball for Best Player of the FIFA U-20 World Cup: 1979
|
Incidents and historical matches
1937 incident
In the
South American
Championship 1937 (current Copa América), the rivalry between
both teams was already something of national pride. There were
verbal confrontations between both parties, and Argentine fans
often taunted the Brazilians by calling them
macaquitos
and making monkey sounds.
The final match, held in Buenos Aires
, was played between the two sides and was goalless
after ninety minutes. In additional time, Argentina scored
two goals. Questioning one of the goals and fearful for their own
safety (reportedly Argentine fans insulted the Afro-Brazilian
players in and outside stadium by calling them
macaquitos), the Brazilian players decided to leave the
stadium before the match was officially finished. The Brazilian
press has since called this match "jogo da vergonha" (
the shame
game).
1939 incident
In 1939
there were two matches between Argentina and Brazil, both of them
in Rio de
Janeiro
and for the Roca Cup. The first one, held in
January, ended 5–1 to Argentina.
A second match was held only one week later, with the Brazilian
team seeking revenge for the previous defeat. The match was
vibrating; first Brazil went ahead 1–0, then Argentina recovered to
lead 1–2, and Brazil then drew level at 2–2. Shortly before the end
of the match the referee, the same as in the previous match, gave a
dubious penalty to Brazil. Furious, Argentina player Arcadio López
verbally attacked the referee and had to be escorted out of the
pitch by police. The Argentine team, enraged by the actions of the
referee and the police, left the pitch. The penalty that gave
Brazil the 3–2 victory was scored without a goalkeeper, because the
entire Argentine team had already walked off the pitch.
1945 and 1946 incidents
In the 1945 match that Brazil won by 6 goals to 2, young Brazilian
Ademir Menezes fractured Argentine
Batagliero's leg. Though it seemed to be
only an unfortunate accident, the game was played roughly and
sometimes violently.
A few months later, the
South American Championship
1946 final again involved Argentina and Brazil. There was a
large media coverage, and the conviction that it would be a rough
match. Twenty-eight minutes after the beginning, when both teams
went for a free ball, Brazilian
Jair
Rosa Pinto fractured Argentine captain
José Salomón's
tibia and
fibula. General
disorder ensued, with Argentine and Brazilian players fighting on
the pitch with the police. The public invaded the pitch and both
teams had to go to the dressing rooms. After order was restored the
game continued, and Argentina won the match 2–0. Salomon never
recovered completely nor played professional football after the
incident.
The Group B of the Second Round was essentially a battle between
Argentina and Brazil, and it was resolved in controversial
circumstances. In the first round of group games, Brazil beat Peru
3-0 while Argentina saw off Poland 2-0. Brazil and Argentina then
played out a tense and violent goalless draw (also known as "A
batalha de Rosário (
The battle of Rosario)", so both teams
went into the last round of matches with three points. Argentina
had an advantage that their match against Peru kicked off several
hours after Brazil's match with Poland. Brazil won their match 3-1,
so Argentina could know that they had to beat Peru by four clear
goals to go through to the final. Argentina managed it with what
some saw as a suspicious degree of ease. Trailing 2-0 at half-time,
Peru simply collapsed in the second half, and Argentina eventually
won 6-0. Rumours suggested that Peru might have been somehow
illicitly induced not to try too hard (especially because the
Peruvian goalkeeper,
Ramón
Quiroga, was born in Argentina); but nothing could be proved,
and Argentina met the Netherlands in the final. Brazil, denied a
final place by Argentina's 6-0 win over Peru, took third place from
an enterprising Italy side and were dubbed "moral champions" by
coach
Cláudio Coutinho,
because they did not win the tournament, but did not lose a single
match either.
Group C, a true
Group of Death with
Brazil, Argentina and Italy, that World Cup history was made. In
the opener, Italy prevailed 2-1 over Argentina's side. Argentina
now needed a win over Brazil on the second day, but they were no
match as the Brazilian Team attacking game, characterised by
nimble, one-touch passing on-the-run, eclipsed the reigning World
Champions. The final score of 3-1 — Argentina only scoring in the
last minute — could have been much higher had Brazil centre-forward
Serginho not wasted a series of
near-certain scoring opportunities. Frustrated because of the poor
refereeing and the imminent loss,
Diego
Maradona kicked Brazilian player Joao Batista.
The last time both teams met in a World Cup match featured
Argentina defeating Brazil 1-0 with a goal from Claudio Caniggia
after a pass from Maradona. The end of the match was controversial
with Brazilian player Branco accusing the Argentina training staff
of giving him a bottle of water laced with tranquillizers while
they were tending to an injured player. This came years after
Maradona revealed the news on an Argentine television show. The
Argentinian Football Federation and the team coach of the time,
Carlos Bilardo, denied that the "holy
water" incident ever took place.
Argentina
defeated Brazil 3-2 in Santiago, Chile
in the first match of the final pool. 5
players were sent off:
Claudio
Caniggia and
Mazinho after tangling in
the 31st minute;
Enrique and
Márcio Santos for
another fight in the 61st minute, with one player leaving on a
stretcher; and
Careca III
in the 80th minute, 2 minutes after coming on as a
substitute.
Argentina
and Brazil finished 1-1 at the 8/final match, played in Guayaquil
. Brazil started winning the game, but
Leo Rodríguez drew with the head
after a corner kick at the second part. In the penalties,
Los
Gauchos defeated 5–4 and advanced to the quarter-finals.
Finally, Argentina obtained this tournament defeating Mexico in the
Final.
Held in
Uruguay
they met at the quarter-finals stage on July 17,
1995 . Brazilian
Tulio Costa
became famous for scoring a late equalizer five minutes from time
after controlling the ball with his left arm. Despite the obvious
foul, the referee (
Alberto Tejada
Noriega from Peru) claimed he did not see the incident and the
goal stood. The game finished with a 2-2 draw and Brazil went on to
win on penalties. The Argentine media labeled the incident as the
"hand of the devil".
Argentina, was winning by 2-1, but in a spetacular turn of events,
Adriano scored a goal in the last minute of the match, taking it to
the penalties, where Brazil won with Julio Cesar stopping an
impossible shoot from D'Alessandro. Brazil was playing with its
second team and this victory might be considered an underdog
one.
In 2005,
a year just before the 2006 World Cup
in Germany
, Brazil and Argentina participated in the Confederations Cup. Brazil entered
the competition for being the current World Cup champion at the
time; however, since Brazil had also won the Copa America the
previous year, runner-up Argentina was allowed to participate in
tournament.
In the semi-finals, Brazil eliminated host
nation Germany
, while Argentina eliminated Mexico
. This
competition was the first time the two rivals would meet in a final
game of a tournament sponsored by FIFA. In a surprising turn of
events, the Brazilian team won the game easily; thrashing the
Argentinians by a score of 4-1.
Adriano
scored twice for Brazil, along with
Kaka and
Ronaldinho; while
Aimar scored Argentina's only goal.
Desábato/Grafite 2005 incident
In a
Copa
Libertadores 2005 match,
after a tackle by the Brazilian club
São Paulo's player
Grafite, Argentine
Quilmes player
Leandro Desábato supposedly reacted
with a racist insult towards Grafite (who's nickname is that
because he's very dark skinned) even though the referee was
standing less than three feet away and wrote in his report that he
did not hear Desabato. In what was called by the Argentine media
"an extremely exaggerated reaction" and by their Brazilian
counterparts as "an exemplary reaction to a racist attack",
Desábato was arrested after the match, handcuffed, taken to the
local police station, and kept there for 40 hours. The entire
Quilmes team waited for Desábato in Brazil while he was held in
custody. With Desábato sent back to Argentina, and after a few days
of tension and media coverage of the event, Grafite finally dropped
the charges.
Even a friendly match without any titles or eliminations on the
line can mean headlines for this rivalry. In this case, 1994 World
Cup captain
Dunga had just recently been
appointed coach of the Brazilian team (replacing
Carlos Alberto Parreira) and a duel
against Argentina was considered his first real test against a
world class opponent.
In September 2006, the two squads met at
Arsenal's Emirates Stadium
in London, England
. Without much difficulty but with a lot of
class and style, Brazil once again thrashed the Argentinians by a
score of 3-0; with goals by
Elano and
Kaka.
Brazil
defeated Argentina 3-0 in Maracaibo, Venezuela
, at the final pool. Goals by Júlio Baptista,
Ayala (own goal) and Daniel Alves. Argentina was favorite for the
match, but the "Canarinhos" were superior.
2008 Summer Olympics - Beijing
Brazil never having won Olympic gold in football and Argentina the
defending champions met on August 19 in the semifinal game of the
Summer Olympics. The game, billed as a tête-à-tête between
Messi and
Ronaldinho former
Barcelona FC teammates, was in the end
a hard-fought clash between two historic rivals, marred by numerous
fouls and two ejections for Brazil. Argentina won convincingly,
3-0, and went on to beat Nigeria 1-0 in the final, being the first
in obtaining two consecutive gold medals in football in 40 years
and the third overall after the Olympic teams of Great Britain and
Uruguay.
2010 World Cup Qualifying matches
On
September 5, 2009, the two nations played their second leg in the
2010 World Cup Qualifying at the
Estadio Gigante de Arroyito in Rosario
; the same
stadium where they had played their 1978
World Cup match. The first result was a 0-0 tie in Brazil;
but the Brazilian team would qualify with a victory, if Ecuador
and Uruguay
did not win their matches during that leg; while
Argentina continued to struggle. The match was covered
intensily by the media in both countries due to comments made by
Diego Maradona in regards to both teams. Dunga and the Brazilian
squad, on the other hand, did not say much and decided to
concentrate on the game. The Brazilian team won the match by a 3-1
score, with goals by
Luisao (23') and
Luis Fabiano (30' and 68').
Datolo scored for the Argentinians (65'). Brazil won
what they considered a historical win (they had not won in
Argentinian soil since 1995) silencing a stunned crowd in Rosario.
And as a
result, they also won the qualification; as both Ecuador and
Uruguay lost to Colombia
and Peru
,
respectively. Argentina lost the following match to
Paraguay
(1-0), but was able to qualify by defeating Peru
(2-1) and Uruguay (1-0) in the final two legs of
qualification.
Club level
At club level, Argentine clubs show an important advantage over the
Brazilians. Argentine clubs have won 22
Copas Libertadores against 13, and are
tied with 9
Intercontinental Cups for
each one. The second most important
CONMEBOL championship, equivalent to the
European UEFA Europa
League, is the
Copa
Sudamericana (after the merger of
Copa
Conmebol,
Copa Mercosur and
Copa Merconorte, which replace
Supercopa Sudamericana) with
a slight advantage for Argentina. Other minor events include the
Recopa Sudamericana and the
defunct
Copa
Interamericana.
In the
international arena, the most successful Argentine clubs are
Boca (6 Libertadores and 3
Intercontinental Cups), Independiente (7
Libertadores and 2 Intercontinental Cups), Estudiantes (4 Libertadores and 1
Intercontinental Cup), Vélez (1
Intercontinental, 1 Libertadores, 1 Supercopa, and 1 Recopa),
River (2 Libertadores
and 1 Intercontinental Cup), and Racing
(1 Libertadores and 1 Intercontinental
Cup).Brazilians include Cruzeiro
(2 Libertadores, 2 Supercopa Sudamericana, 1
Recopa, 1 Copa Oro and 1 Supercopa Masters), Grêmio (2 Libertadores
and 1 Intercontinental Cup), São Paulo (3 Libertadores, 1
FIFA Club World Cup and 2 Intercontinental Cups), Flamengo (1 Libertadores and 1
Intercontinental Cup), Internacional (1 Libertadores and 1
FIFA Club World Cup), Corinthians (1 FIFA Club
World Cup) and Santos (2
Libertadores and 2 Intercontinental Cups).
Women's football
The
Brazil women's
national football team is a successful
women's football team, though not
as successful as the men's counterpart. It was runner-up in the
FIFA Women's World Cup of
2007, and a Silver Medal
at the
Olympic
games in
2004. In comparison,
Argentina does not have a professional (or even semi-professional)
women's football league; the members of the
Argentina women's
national football team are all amateur players despite their
clubs often being affiliated with prominent men's professional
clubs. Although the two teams usually have to battle for the top
qualification spots for
CONMEBOL when the
World Cup qualification comes around, this rivalry does not provide
the passion that men's matches encounter yet.
Brazil won every game of the
Sudamericano Femenino against
Argentina until
the 2006
edition, when Argentina finally beat them 2-0 in the final
group stage, awarding Argentina the championship. Argentina did not
participate in the 1991 South American competition and was second
to Brazil in the following 3 tournaments. Beginning with the 2003
edition, both champion and runner-up qualified for the World Cup.
As Argentina has not been past the group stages in the World Cup,
the two teams have not met in the
Olympic Football Tournament
yet.
Football culture
Depicting the football rivalry between the two
South American countries,
Maradona filmed a television commercial in
which he is wearing the Brazilian outfit, lined up with Brazilian
stars
Kaká and
Ronaldo, singing the
Brazilian national anthem before a
match. He then wakes up from the
nightmare, where he can
be seen wearing an Argentine national shirt in his bed, next to a
bunch of empty cans of
Guaraná
Antarctica, a Brazilian soft drink.
References
External links