Benjamin "Bibi" Netanyahu (
, also Binyamin Netanyahu, born 21 October 1949)
is the Prime Minister of
Israel
.
He previously held the same position from June 1996 to July 1999
and is currently the Chairman of the
Likud
Party. Netanyahu is the first (and, to date, only) Israeli prime
minister born after the State of Israel's
foundation.
Netanyahu
was Foreign Minister
(2002–2003) and Finance
Minister (2003–August 2005) in Ariel
Sharon's governments, but he departed over disagreements
regarding the Gaza
Disengagement
Plan. He retook the Likud leadership on 20 December
2005. In the
2006
election, Likud did poorly, winning twelve seats.
In December 2006,
Netanyahu became the official Opposition Leader in the Knesset
and Chairman
of the Likud Party. In August 2007, he retained the Likud
leadership by beating
Moshe Feiglin in
party elections. Following the
10 February 2009
parliamentary election, in which Likud placed second and
right-wing parties won a majority, Netanyahu formed a coalition
government. He is the brother of Israeli Special Forces commander
Yonatan Netanyahu, who died during
a hostage rescue mission, and
Iddo
Netanyahu, an Israeli author and playwright.
Family, education, and personal background
Related to
the Rabbi Eliyahu of Vilna on his
paternal side, Netanyahu was born in Tel Aviv
, to Cela
(Tsilah; née Segal) and Benzion
Netanyahu (original name Mileikowsky). His mother was born in
1912 in Petah
Tikva
, part of the future British Mandate of Palestine
that eventually became Israel
.
Though all
his grandparents were born in Lithuania, his mother's parents
emigrated to Minneapolis
in the United States
. Netanyahu's father is a former professor of
Jewish history at Cornell
University
, a former editor of the Hebrew Encyclopedia, and a former senior
aide to Zeev Jabotinsky, who has
remained active in research and writing into his 90s. His
paternal grandfather was Rabbi
Natan
Mileikowsky, a leading
Religious
Zionist rabbi and
JNF fundraiser.
Born in 1949 in Tel Aviv, Netanyahu was the first Israeli Prime
Minister to be born in the State of Israel.
(Yitzhak Rabin was
born in Jerusalem, but prior to the 1948 founding of the state.)
When Netanyahu was 14 years old, his family moved to the United
States and settled in Cheltenham, Pennsylvania, a suburb
of Philadelphia
, where he graduated from Cheltenham
High School
. In his childhood, an older relative also
named Binyamin was then called 'Bibi', and Netanyahu's family also
dubbed him 'Bibi.' To this day, he speaks
English with a pronounced
American accent.
Netanyahu's older brother,
Yonatan, was killed in
Uganda during
Operation
Entebbe in 1976. His younger brother,
Iddo, is a radiologist and writer. All three
brothers served in the
Sayeret Matkal
reconnaissance unit of the
Israeli
Defense Force – Benjamin from 1967 to 1972 as a captain.
He earned
a B.S. degree in architecture from the Massachusetts
Institute of Technology
in 1975, an M.S.
degree from the MIT Sloan School of Management
in 1977, and studied political science at Harvard
and
MIT. After graduate school, Netanyahu worked at
the Boston Consulting Group
in Boston,
Massachusetts
, and eventually returned to Israel.
Following
a brief career as a furniture company's chief marketing officer,
Netanyahu was appointed by Moshe Arens
as his Deputy Chief of Mission at the Israeli Embassy in Washington,
DC
in 1982. Subsequently, he became Israel's
Ambassador to the
United Nations,
serving from 1984 to 1988.
He was elected to the Knesset
in 1988, and
served in the governments led by Yitzhak
Shamir from 1988 to 1992. Shamir retired from politics
shortly after Likud's defeat in the 1992 elections. In 1993, for
the first time, the party held a primary election to select its
leader, and Netanyahu was victorious, defeating
Benny Begin, son of the late Prime Minister
Menachem Begin, and veteran
politician
David Levy (
Ariel Sharon initially sought Likud party
leadership as well, but quickly withdrew when it was evident that
he was attracting minimal support).
Netanyahu has authored several books, including two on fighting
terrorism. He has a daughter, Noa, from
his first marriage to Micki Weizman. His second marriage was to
Fleur Cates, who
converted to Judaism because
only her father was Jewish. He is now married to his third
wife, Sara, with whom he has two sons: Yair and Avner.
In the first half of 2008, doctors removed a small colon polyp that
proved to be benign.
Netanyahu became a grandfather on 1 October 2009, when his daughter
Noa Netanyahu-Roth (married to Daniel Roth) gave birth to a boy,
Shmuel.
Netanyahu is a fan of the soccer team
Beitar Jerusalem.
Prime minister (1996–99)
In 1996 Israelis elected their Prime Minister directly for the
first time. Netanyahu hired American
Republican political
operative
Arthur Finkelstein
to run his campaign, and although the American style of sound bites
and sharp attacks elicited harsh criticism from inside Israel, it
proved effective. (The method was later copied by
Ehud Barak during the
1999 election
campaign in which he beat Netanyahu.) Netanyahu won the
election,
surprising many by beating the pre-election favorite
Shimon Peres. The main catalyst in the downfall
of the latter was a wave of suicide bombings shortly before the
elections; on 3 and 4 March 1996, Palestinians carried out two
suicide bombings, killing 32
Israelis, with Peres seemingly unable to stop the attacks. Unlike
Peres, Netanyahu did not trust
Yasser
Arafat and conditioned any progress at the peace process on the
Palestinian Authority
fulfilling its obligations – mainly fighting terrorism, and ran
with the campaign slogan "Netanyahu - making a safe peace".
However, although Netanyahu won the election for Prime Minister,
Labor won the
Knesset elections,
beating the Likud–
Gesher–
Tzomet alliance, meaning Netanyahu had to rely on a
coalition with the
Ultra-orthodox
parties,
Shas and
UTJ (whose social welfare policies flew
in the face of his capitalistic outlook) in order to govern.
Upon his election, Netanyahu was the youngest person in the history
of the position. He had a rocky relationship with American
President
Bill Clinton, who made some
very unflattering remarks about him in the presence of
Aaron David Miller. The White House
spokesman at the time was
Joe Lockhart,
who described Netanyahu in an interview as "one of the most
obnoxious individuals you're going to come into - just a liar and a
cheat. He could open his mouth and you could have no confidence
that anything that came out of it was the truth."
As Prime Minister, Netanyahu negotiated with
Yasser Arafat in the form of the 1998
Wye River Accords.
No progress was made
regarding negotiations with the Palestinians, and although they
failed to implement agreed-upon steps of the Oslo Accords, Netanyahu turned over most of
Hebron
to
Palestinian jurisdiction. In 1996, Netanyahu and Jerusalem
's mayor Ehud Olmert
decided to open an exit for the Western Wall Tunnel. This sparked
three days of rioting by Palestinians, resulting in both Israelis
and Palestinians being killed.
As Prime Minister Netanyahu emphasized a policy of "three no(s)":
no withdrawal from the Golan Heights, no discussion of the case of
Jerusalem, no negotiations under any preconditions.
Netanyahu
was opposed by the political left wing in
Israel and also lost support from the right because of his
concessions to the Palestinians in Hebron
and
elsewhere, and due to his negotiations with Arafat
generally. After a long chain of scandals (including gossip
regarding his marriage) and an investigation opened against him on
charges of corruption (later acquitted), Netanyahu lost favor with
the Israeli public.
After being defeated by
Ehud Barak in the
1999
election
for Prime Minister, Netanyahu temporarily retired from
politics.
Political activity after 2000
In 2001, Netanyahu missed the opportunity to return to power since
he refused to run unless there were general elections, a move that
facilitated Sharon's entry into the race for Prime Minister.
In 2002, after the
Labor Party
left the coalition and vacated the position of foreign minister,
Prime Minister
Ariel Sharon appointed
Netanyahu as Foreign Minister.
On September 9, 2002, a scheduled speech by
Netanyahu at Concordia University in Montreal
, Quebec
was canceled
after hundreds of pro-Palestinian protesters overwhelmed security
and smashed through a security wall. Netanyahu escaped
unharmed and later accused the activists of supporting terrorism
and "mad zealotry."
Netanyahu challenged Sharon for the leadership of the
Likud party, but failed to oust Sharon.
Finance Minister, 2003–05
After the 2003 elections, in what many observers regarded as a
surprise move, Sharon offered the Foreign Ministry to
Silvan Shalom and offered Netanyahu the
Finance Ministry. Some pundits speculated that Sharon made the move
because he deemed Netanyahu a political threat given his
demonstrated effectiveness as Foreign Minister and that by placing
him in the Finance Ministry during a time of economic uncertainty,
he could diminish Netanyahu's popularity. Netanyahu accepted the
new appointment after Sharon agreed to provide him with an
unprecedented level of independence in running the ministry.
As Finance Minister, Netanyahu undertook an economic plan in order
to restore Israel's economy from its low point during the
al-Aqsa Intifada. The plan involved a move
toward more
liberalized markets,
although it was not without its critics. Netanyahu succeeded in
passing several long-in-the-queue reforms, including an important
reform in the banking system. However, opponents in the Labor party
(and a few even with his own Likud) viewed Netanyahu's policies as
"Thatcherite" attacks on the venerated Israeli social safety
net.
Netanyahu threatened to resign in 2004 unless the
Gaza pullout plan was
put to a referendum, but later lifted the ultimatum and voted for
the program in the Knesset.
He submitted his resignation letter on 7
August 2005, shortly before the Israeli cabinet voted 17 to 5 to
approve the initial phase of withdrawal from Gaza
.
Shortly thereafter he said he had rejected an invitation to serve
as Italy's finance minister, allegedly extended to him by Italian
billionaire businessman
Carlo De
Benedetti, who later said it was a joke.
Party leader, Likud
Following the withdrawal of
Ariel
Sharon from the Likud, Netanyahu was one of several candidates
who vied for the Likud leadership. His most recent attempt prior to
this was in September 2005 when he tried to hold early primaries
for the position of the head of the
Likud
party, while the party held the office of Prime Minister – thus
effectively pushing Ariel Sharon out of office. The party rejected
this initiative. Netanyahu retook the leadership on 20 December
2005, with 47% of the primary vote. In the
March 2006 Knesset
elections, Likud took the third place behind
Kadima and
Labor
and Netanyahu served as Leader of the Opposition.
On 14 August 2007, Netanyahu was reelected as chairman of the Likud
and its candidate to the post of Prime Minister with 73% of the
vote against far-right candidate
Moshe
Feiglin and World Likud Chairman
Danny
Danon. He opposed the
2008 Israel-Gaza cease-fire,
like others in the Knesset opposition. Specifically, Netanyahu
said, "This is not a relaxation, it's an Israeli agreement to the
rearming of Hamas... What are we getting for this?"
Following
Livni's election to head
Kadima and Olmert's resignation from the prime
minister post, Netanyahu declined to join the coalition Livni was
trying to form and preferred new elections, which were held in
February 2009.
Likud candidate, 2009 elections
Netanyahu was the Likud's candidate for Prime Minister in the
Israeli elections that took place on 10 February 2009, as
Tzipi Livni, the previous
Designated Acting
Prime Minister under the Olmert government, had been unable to
form a viable governing coalition.
During the race, Netanyahu's campaign
website was noted for its strong resemblance to that used the
previous year by United
States
President Barack Obama
to reach his supporters during his campaign, including colors,
fonts, icons, the use of embedded video, and social
networking options such as Twitter. Opinion polls showed Likud in the
lead, but with as many as a third of Israeli voters undecided. In
the election itself, Likud won the second highest number of seats,
Livni's party having outnumbered the Likud by one seat. A possible
explanation for Likud's relatively poor showing is that some Likud
supporters defected to
Avigdor
Lieberman's Yisrael Beiteinu
party. Netanyahu, however, claimed victory on the basis that
right wing parties won the majority of
the vote, and on 20 February 2009, Netanyahu was designated by
Israeli President Shimon Peres to succeed
Ehud Olmert as Prime Minister, and began his
negotiations to form a coalition government.
Despite right wing parties winning a majority of 65 seats in the
Knesset, Netanyahu preferred a broader centrist coalition and
turned to his Kadima rivals, chaired by Tzipi Livni, to join his
government. This time it was Livni's turn to decline to join, with
a difference of opinion on how to pursue the peace process being
the stumbling block. Netanyahu did manage to entice a smaller
rival, the Labour party, chaired by
Ehud
Barak, to join his government, giving him a certain amount of
centrist tone.
Netayahu presented his cabinet for a Knesset "Vote of Confidence"
on 31 March 2009. The 32nd Government was approved that day by a
majority of 69 lawmakers and the members were sworn in.
Prime Minister (2009– )
Upon the arrival of President Obama administration's special envoy,
George Mitchell, Netanyahu said
that any furtherance of negotiations with the Palestinians will be
conditioned on the Palestinians recognizing Israel as a Jewish
state, as this issue had not been sufficiently clarified. The
Palestinian position is to have a two state solution with no Jewish
settlements in
Judea and Samaria,
while insisting that Israel accept large numbers of Palestinian
refugees.
Three months after starting his term, Netanyahu remarked that his
cabinet already had achieved several notable successes, such as the
establishment of a working
national
unity government, and a broad consensus for a "
Two-state solution". The
Kadima-led opposition submitted a no-confidence
measure to the Knesset shortly after Netanyahu concluded his first
100 days in office.
A July 2009 survey by Ha'aretz found that most Israelis support the
Netanyahu government, giving him a personal approval rating of
about 49 percent, a spike from 28 percent prior to his Bar-Ilan
speech, which was in response to President Obama's
Cairo speech. At Bar-Ilan, Netanyahu had finally and
explicitly endorsed a "Demilitarized Palestinian State", after two
months of refusing to commit to anything other than a self-ruling
autonomy when coming into office.
As part
of his "economic peace", to boost the Palestinian economy, while
insisting not a substitute to political negotiations, Netanyahu has
lifted checkpoints in the West Bank
, in order to allow freedom of movement and a flow
of imports as a "highway to peace", a step that resulted in an
economic boost in the West Bank.
On 23
July 2009, speaking at an Egyptian embassy event in Israel,
Netanyahu welcomed the Arab
Peace initiative (also known as the "Saudi Peace Initiative"),
a long time all-Arab demand from the Israelis, stating that "The
Arab initiative provides a tailwind to the Peace Process", and also
lauded a call by Bahrain
's Crown Prince,
Salman bin Hamad bin
Isa Al Khalifa to normalize relations with Israel.
However, on 31 July, at a press conference with U.S Secretary of
State
Hillary Clinton, the Saudi
Foreign Minister,
Saud El
Faisal, rejected the U.S push for making Arab gestures toward
normalizing ties with Israel as 'confidence-building' measures,
stating that "'step-by-step' diplomatic approach, have not and will
not lead to peace", and that "temporary security arrangement as
well, so-called 'confidence-building' measures will not lead to
peace either." He added that a comprehensive approach is needed in
order to tackle the core issues of the conflict, that include "The
future of the Palestinian State, control over Jerusalem, the return
of the refugees to their country, and water and security
arrangements". He also argued that Israel was diverting attention
"From the occupation that had began on 1967, and the establishment
of a Palestinian State, towards secondary issues, such as flying
methods (referring to one of the gestures) and academic arguments,
and said that "It is time all the inhabitants of the Middle East
will live a normal life".
On 9 August 2009, speaking at the opening of his weekly cabinet
meeting, Netanyahu promised not to repeat the "mistake" of the Gaza
unilateral pullout, saying, "We will not repeat this mistake. We
will not create new evacuees", and adding that "the unilateral
evacuation brought neither peace nor security. On the contrary",
and that "We want an agreement with two factors, the first of which
is the recognition of Israel as the national state of the Jewish
people and [the second is] a security settlement. In the case of
Gaza, both of these factors were lacking". He also said, "Should we
achieve a turn toward peace with the more moderate partners, we
will insist on the recognition of the State of Israel and the
demilitarization of the future Palestinian state".
On 10
August 2009, two prominent political figures, Knesset Speaker Reuven Rivlin, a Likud
party member, and the chairman of Shas ultra
orthodox party, Eli Yishai, both from
Netanyahu's government, raised their voices in a joint tour in
Ma'ale
Adumim
, stating that "The battle over Jerusalem begins in
'Ma'ale Adumim'", and calling on the prime minister to continue
building in the blocks of settlements as was stated in the "Bush
letter", as well as continue to create a contiguous territory
between 'Ma'ale Adumim' and Jerusalem, "even if we don't convince
the Americans".
On 10
August 2009, in response to reports that Hezbullah was planning to exert efforts to attack
Israeli officials abroad, Netanyahu warned that "If Hezbullah will enter the (Lebanese
) government as an official factor, let it be clear
that the Lebanese government will be held responsible for any
attack carried out from its territory. Once they [Hezbullah]
are part of the government, the sovereign government of Lebanon is
the one responsible. I hope we will not be forced to make such
responses". However, he maintained his assessment that "There are
no 'winds of war' brewing in the North" the next day.
On 23 August 2009, Netanyahu announced in his weekly cabinet
meeting that negotiations with the Palestinians will begin in
September and will be officially launched on his visit to New York,
after he had accepted an invitation from President Barak Obama for
a "Triple Summit" there. He added that there is progress with
special envoy
George Mitchell,
though there is no full agreement on everything, and there will be
more rounds of meetings [until September]. On the same day, a
spokesman for PA President Mahmoud Abbas said there would be no
negotiations as long as there was any building going on in the
settlements.
On 26 August 2009, Netanyahu and special envoy George Mitchell met,
in what was perceived as a critical meeting towards an
understanding on a settlement freeze between Israel and the U.S, in
which they reaffirmed in a joint statement the need for a
meaningful negotiation between the Israelis and Palestinians that
will lead to a comprehensive peace agreement, and Abbas declared
the same day that he will be willing to meet with Prime Minister
Netanyahu at the U.N General Assembly, where Netanyahu had accepted
president Obama's invitation for a "triple summit", although he
said it will not necessary lead to negotiations.
Netanyahu was
reported to be in a pivotal moment over these understandings, that
were reported to include a compromise over permission on continuing
the already approved construction in the West Bank
, in exchange for freezing all settlements
thereafter, as well as continuing building in East Jerusalem, and at the same time stopping
the demolition of houses of Arab inhabitants there. It was
also reported that the U.S Administration was planning a "modest"
summit with a principle declaration and stiff timetable, rather
than a "Grand Plan".
On 4 September 2009, it was reported that Netanyahu was to agree to
settlers' political demands to approve more settlement
constructions before a temporary settlement freeze agreement took
place. White House spokesman
Robert
Gibbs expressed "regret" over the move; however, one U.S
official said the move will not "derail [the] train".
On 7 September 2009, Netanyahu left his office without reporting
where he was headed, his schedule was mysteriously cleared, and his
whereabouts were unknown for a several hours. The prime minster's
military secretary, Maj. Gen. Meir Kalifi, later reported Netanyahu
had visited a security facility in Israel. At the same time, a
Palestinian newspaper reported that Netanyahu had left for a visit
in an Arab state that does not have diplomatic ties with Israel.
On 9
September 2009, Yediot Aharonot
reported that the Israeli leader had made a secret flight to
Moscow
to try to
persuade Russian officials not to sell S-300 anti-aircraft missile
systems to Iran. The report caused a local media storm, with
angry journalists accusing Netanyahu’s office of lying. Headlines
branded Netanyahu a "liar" and dubbed the affair a "fiasco." It was
later reported that the PM's military secretary will be dismissed
due to the affair.
The Sunday
Times reported that the trip was made to share the names
of Russian scientists that Israel believes are abetting the Iranian
nuclear weapons program.
On 16 September 2009, special envoy George Mitchell arrived in
Israel for one of his last rounds before a triple summit at the
U.N. between President Obama, Netanyahu and PA president
Mahmud Abbas, in order to secure such a summit.
Despite shuttling between the Israelis and the Palestinians, he
failed to secure such a summit. However, it was reported that he
had expected his trip to be extended, that he would meet Prime
Minister Netanyahu again two days later, and that there might be a
three-way summit without relaunching the peace process, after which
negotiations on understandings between Israel and the U.S would
continue. On September 18, Netanyahu and Mitchell met again, but
failed to reach an agreement that will secure the summit. Later
that day,
Haaretz reported that Israeli
officials blamed the Palestinian Authority for thwarting the peace
talks.
On 20
September 2009, the White
House
announced that it will host a three-way meeting
between President Obama, Prime Minister Netanyahu and PA President
Mahmud Abbas, within the framework of
the United Nations
General Assembly, "in an effort to lay the groundwork for
renewed negotiations on Mideast peace." The meeting took
place on 22 September, in New York
. Afterwards, Netanyahu said that he agreed
with Abbas during the meeting that peace talks should be relaunched
as soon as possible.
On 24 September 2009, in an address to the United Nations General
Assembly in New York, Netanyahu said Iran poses a threat to the
peace of the world and that it is incumbent on the world body to
prevent the Islamic Republic from obtaining nuclear weapons. Waving
the blueprints for Auschwitz and invoking the memory of his own
family members murdered by the Nazis, Netanyahu delivered his most
passionate and public riposte yet to Iranian president Mahmoud
Ahmadinejad's questioning of the Holocaust, asking: "Have you no
shame?"
On 25 November 2009, Netanyahu announced a 10 month settlement
freeze plan, seen as due to pressure from the Obama administration,
which urged the sides to seize the opportunity to resume talks. U.S
special envoy George Mitchell said, "while the United States shares
Arab concerns about the limitations of Israel's gesture, it is more
than any Israeli government has ever done". In his announcement
Netanyahu called the move "a painful step that will encourage the
peace process" and urged the Palestinians to respond. However, the
Palestinians rejected the call.
Political views
Peace process
Prior to second term as Prime Minister
Netanyahu had previously called U.S.-backed peace talks a waste of
time, while at the same time refusing to commit to the same
two-state solution as had other Israeli leaders, until a speech in
June 2009. He repeatedly made public statements which advocated an
"economic peace" approach, meaning an approach based on economic
cooperation and joint effort rather than continuous contention over
political and diplomatic issues. This is in line with many
significant ideas from the
Peace
Valley plan. He raised these ideas during discussions with
former
U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice. Netanyahu continued to
advocate these ideas as the Israeli elections got nearer.Netanyahu
has said:
Right now, the peace talks are based only one thing,
only on peace talks.
It makes no sense at this point to talk about the most
contractible issue.
It's Jerusalem or bust, or right of return or
bust.
That has led to failure and is likely to lead to
failure again....We must weave an economic peace alongside a
political process.
That means that we have to strengthen the moderate
parts of the Palestinian economy by handing rapid growth in those
area, rapid economic growth that gives a stake for peace for the
ordinary Palestinians."
In
January 2009, prior to the February 2009 Israeli elections
Netanyahu informed Middle East envoy Tony Blair that he would
continue the policy of the Israeli governments of Ariel Sharon and
Ehud Olmert by expanding settlements in the West Bank
, in contravention of the Road Map, but not building
new ones.
June 2009 peace address, "Bar-Ilan Speech"
On 14
June 2009, Netanyahu delivered a seminal address at Bar-Ilan
University
(also known as "Bar-Ilan Speech"), at Begin-Sadat Center for
Strategic Studies, that was broadcast live in Israel and across
parts of the Arab world, on the topic of
the Middle East peace
process. He endorsed for the first time the notion of a
Palestinian state alongside
Israel. Netanyahu had immediately called a special government
meeting after Obama finished his
4 June
speech at Cairo.
Yedioth
Ahronoth has stated that Obama's words had "resonated
through Jerusalem's corridors".
As part
of his proposal, Netanyahu demanded the full demilitarization of
the proposed state, with no army, rockets, missiles, or control of
its airspace, and said that Jerusalem
would be undivided Israeli territory.
He stated that the Palestinians should recognize Israel as the
Jewish national state with an undivided Jerusalem. He rejected a
right of return for
Palestinian refugees, saying, "any demand for resettling
Palestinian refugees within Israel undermines Israel's continued
existence as the state of the Jewish people."
He also stated that a
complete stop to settlement
building in the West
Bank
, as required by the 2003 Road
Map peace proposal, would not occur but the expansions will be
limited based on the "natural growth" of the population, including
immigration, with no new territories taken in although, despite
this, Netanyahu still claimed that he accepted the Road Map.
He did not discuss whether or not the settlements should be part of
Israel after peace negotiations, simply saying that the "question
will be discussed".
In a response to
U.S. President Barack Obama's
statements in his
Cairo speech,
Netanyahu remarked, "there are those who say that if the Holocaust
had not occurred, the State of Israel would never have been
established. But I say that if the State of Israel would have been
established earlier, the Holocaust would not have occurred." He
also said, "this is the homeland of the Jewish people, this is
where our identity was forged."
He stated that he would be willing to meet
with any "Arab leader" for negotiations without preconditions,
specifically mentioning Syria
, Saudi Arabia
, and Lebanon
. In general, the address represented a
complete turnaround for his previously hawkish positions against
the
peace process.
Some right-wing members of Netanyahu's governing coalition
criticized his remarks for the creation of a Palestinian State;
believing that all of the land should remain under Israeli
sovereignty.
Likud MK
Danny Danon said that Netanyahu went "against
the Likud platform", while MK
Uri Orbach of Habayit
Hayehudi said that it had "dangerous implications"..
Opposition party
Kadima leader
Tzipi Livni remarked after the address that she
thinks Netanyahu does not really believe in the
two state solution at all; she thought
that he only said what he did as a feigned response to
international pressure.
Peace Now blasted
the speech, highlighting the fact that, in the group's opinion, it
did not address the Palestinians as equal partners in the peace
process. The Secretary General of
Peace
Now, Yariv Oppenheimer, said, "It's a rerun of Netanyahu from
his first term".
On August 9, speaking at the opening of government meeting
Netanyahu repeated his claims from the Palestinians: "We want an
agreement with two factors, the first of which is the recognition
of Israel as the national state of the Jewish people and (the
second of which is) a security settlement".
International reaction
Netanyahu's "Bar-Ilan Speech" provoked mixed reaction from the
International community:
- - The Palestinian
Authority rejected the conditions to a Palestinian State given
by Netanyahu. Senior official Saeb
Erekat said, "Netanyahu's speech closed the door to permanent
status negotiations". Hamas spokesman Fawzi Barhum said it reflected a "racist and
extremist ideology" and called on Arab nations to "form stronger
opposition". Palestinian
Islamic Jihad labeled it "misleading" and, like Hamas, demanded stronger opposition to Israel from
Arab nations. According to The
Jerusalem Post, some leaders advocated a third intifada in
response to the speech.
- - The Arab League dismissed the
address, declaring in a statement that "Arabs would not make
concessions regarding issues of Jerusalem and refugees" and that
"we know his history and style of evasion".
- - The
Czech
Republic
, which held
the presidency of the European Union
praised Netanyahu's address. "In my view, this is a step in
the right direction. The acceptance of a Palestinian state was
present there," said Czech Foreign Minister Jan Kohout, whose country held the EU's six-month
presidency at the time of the speech.
- - The Press secretary of President Barack Obama, Robert
Gibbs, said that the speech was an "important step forward".
President Obama stated that "this solution can and must ensure both
Israel's security and the Palestinians' legitimate aspirations for
a viable state".
- - Swedish Foreign Minister Carl Bildt
stated that "the fact that he uttered the word state is a small
step forward". He added that "whether what he mentioned can be
defined as a state is a subject of some debate".
- - France praised the speech but called on Israel to cease
building settlements in the West Bank. French Foreign Minister
Bernard Kouchner stated that "I can
only welcome the prospect of a Palestinian state outlined by the
Israeli Prime Minister".
- - The Foreign Ministry of Russia called the speech "a sign of
readiness for dialogue" but said that "it does not open up the road
to resolving the Israeli-Palestinian problem. The conditions on the
Palestinians would be unacceptable".
- - Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak
replied that he refuses to accept Israel's right to exist as a
Jewish state. He remarked, "You won't find anyone to answer that
call in Egypt, or in any other place". His Foreign Ministry issued
a more moderate response that the speech was "not complete" and
that they hope for another, "different Israeli proposal which is
built on the commitment to the two-state solution".
- - Syrian state media condemned the speech. A mouthpiece for the
government wrote that "Netanyahu has confirmed that he rejects the
Arab peace initiative for peace along with all the initiatives and
resolutions of the Security Council to relative peace".
- - Lebanese President Michel
Suleiman called for unity among Arab leaders, saying that "Arab
leaders should be more united and preserve the spirit of resistance
to face the Israeli stands regarding the peace process and the
Palestinian refugee issue." He called on the international
community to exert more pressure on the Israeli government to
accept the Arab Peace Initiative, as he said Israel still has a
will of military confrontation which can be proved in its
offensives on Lebanon and the Gaza Strip.
- - Jordanian Minister of State for Media affairs and
Communications, and Government spokesperson Nabil Sharif issued a statement saying "The
ideas presented by Netanyahu do not live up to what was agreed on
by the international community as a starting point for achieving a
just and comprehensive peace in the region".
Remarks about Iran
On 20 February 2009, after being asked to be the prime minister of
Israel, Netanyahu described Iran as the greatest threat that Israel
has ever faced: "Iran is seeking to obtain a nuclear weapon and
constitutes the gravest threat to our existence since the war of
independence."
Speaking before the UN General Assembly in New York on 24 September
2009, Netanyahu slammed Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's
speech at the forum, saying those who believe Tehran is a threat
only to Israel are wrong. "The Iranian regime", he said, "is
motivated by fanaticism… They want to see us go back to medieval
times. The struggle against Iran pits civilization against
barbarism. This Iranian regime is fueled by extreme
fundamentalism."
Comparing to Nazi Germany
Strongly
against Iran
's pursuit of
uranium enrichment, Netanyahu said "It’s 1938, and Iran is Germany, and Iran is racing to arm itself with
atomic bombs”. In an 8 March 2007 interview with
CNN, he asserted that there is only one difference
between Nazi Germany and the Islamic Republic of Iran, namely that
the first entered a worldwide conflict and then sought atomic
weapons, while the latter is first seeking atomic weapons and, once
it has them, will then start a world war.
Netanyahu repeated these remarks at a news conference in April
2008. Explaining that "where that [Nazi] regime embarked on a
global conflict before it developed nuclear weapons," he said,
"This regime [Iran] is developing nuclear weapons before it embarks
on a global conflict."
Books and articles
Books:
- The Jerusalem Alternative (Balfour Books, 2003) ISBN
978-0892215928
- A Durable Peace: Israel and Its Place Among the
Nations (Warner Books, 2000) ISBN 0-446-52306-2
- Fighting Terrorism: How Democracies Can Defeat Domestic And
International Terrorism (Diane Pub Co, 1995) ISBN
0-7881-5514-8
- A Place Among the Nations (Bantam, 1993) ISBN
0-553-08974-9
- Terrorism: How the West Can Win (Farrar Straus &
Giroux, 1986) ISBN 0-374-27342-1
- International Terrorism: Challenge and Response (The
Jonathon Institute, 1980) ISBN 0-87855-894-2
Articles:
References
- Hawas, Akram T. The new
alliance: Turkey and Israel. The fourth Nordic conference
on Middle Eastern Studies: The Middle East in globalizing world.
Oslo, 13–16 August 1998.
- US Welcomes Israeli Settlement Move, Urges
Palestinians to Enter Negotiations, Voice of America,
25 November 2009
External links