A
biblical manuscript is any handwritten copy of a
portion of the text of the
Bible. The word
Bible comes from the Greek
biblion (book);
manuscript comes from Latin
manu (hand) and
scriptum (written). Biblical manuscripts vary in size from
tiny scrolls containing individual verses of the Jewish scriptures
(see
Tefillin) to huge
polyglot codices
(multi-lingual books) containing both the Hebrew Bible (
Tanakh) and the
New
Testament, as well as
extracanonical works.
The study of biblical manuscripts is important because handwritten
copies of books can contain errors. The science of
textual criticism attempts to reconstruct
the original text of books, especially those published prior to the
invention of the
printing
press.
Hebrew Bible (or Tanakh) manuscripts
The
Aleppo Codex (
c. 920 CE)
and
Leningrad Codex (
c.
1008 CE) are the oldest complete Hebrew language manuscripts of the
Tanakh.
The 1947 find at Qumran
of the
Dead Sea scrolls pushed the
manuscript history of the Tanakh back a millennium from the two
earliest complete codices (see Tanakh
at Qumran). Before this discovery, the earliest extant
manuscripts of the
Old Testament were
in Greek in manuscripts such as
Codex Vaticanus and
Codex Sinaiticus. Out of the roughly 800
manuscripts found at Qumran, 220 are from the Tanakh. Every book of
the Tanakh is represented except for the
Book of Esther; however, most are
fragmentary. Notably, there are two
scrolls
of the
Book of Isaiah, one complete
(
1QIsa), and one around 75%
complete (
1QIsb). These
manuscripts generally date between 150 BCE to 70 CE.
Ancient
Jewish scribes developed many
practices to protect copies of their
scriptures from error. Their methods resulted in
significant variations among texts arising at an average rate of
just under one
consonant in every
1,500.
Extant Tanakh manuscripts
New Testament manuscripts
The
New Testament has been preserved
in more manuscripts than any other ancient work, having over 5,800
complete or fragmented
Greek
manuscripts, 10,000
Latin manuscripts and
9,300 manuscripts in various other ancient languages including
Syriac,
Slavic,
Gothic,
Ethiopic,
Coptic and
Armenian. The dates of these manuscripts
range from the 2nd century to the introduction of printing in
Germany in the 15th century. The vast majority of these manuscripts
date after the 10th century.
Every year, several New Testament manuscripts handwritten in the
original Greek format are discovered. The latest substantial find
was in 2008, when 47 new manuscripts were discovered in Albania; at
least 17 of them unknown to Western scholars.
When comparing one manuscript to another, with the exception of the
smallest fragments, no two copies agree completely throughout.
Note, however, that a single difference prevents agreement. There
has been an estimate of between 400,000 variations among all these
manuscripts (from the 2nd to 15th century) which is more than there
are words in the New Testament. This means less significant than
may appear since it is a comparison across linguistic boundaries.
More important estimates focus on comparing texts within languages.
Those variations are considerably fewer. The vast majority of these
are accidental errors made by
scribes, and
are easily identified as such:
an omitted
word,
a duplicate line, a
misspelling, a rearrangement of words. Some variations involve
apparently intentional changes, which often make more difficult a
determination of whether they were corrections from better
exemplars,
harmonizations between readings, or
ideologically motivated.
Palaeography
is the study of ancient writing, and
textual criticism is the study of
manuscripts in order to reconstruct a probable original text.
The difficulty in all of this, though, is in where the manuscripts
are coming from. Often, especially in monasteries, a manuscript
cache is little more than a former manuscript recycling center
where imperfect and incomplete copies of manuscripts were stored
while the monastery or scriptorium decided what to do with them.
There were several options. The first was to simply "wash" the
manuscript and reuse it. This was very common in the ancient world
and even up into the
Middle Ages; such
reused manuscripts are called
palimpsests. The most famous palimpsest is
probably the
Archimedes
Palimpsest. If this was not done within a short period of time
after the papyri was made, then washing it was less likely since
the papyri might deteriorate and thus be unusable. When washing was
no longer an option, then the second and third choices were either
burning (since they contained the words of Christ and the apostles,
prophets, and saints, and were thought to have had a higher level
of sanctity than secular literature ). Burning them was considered
more reverent than simply throwing them into the nearby garbage
pit, although that was not unheard of as in the case of
Oxyrhynchus 840). The third option was
simply to leave them in what has become known as a manuscript
gravesite.
When scholars come across manuscript
caches]], for example that at Saint
Catherine's Monastery
in the Sinai
(source of
the Codex Sinaiticus), or Saint Sabbas Monastery outside
Bethlehem
, they are not finding libraries, but storehouses of
rejected texts Sometimes, oddly, kept in boxes or back shelves in
libraries due to space constraints) which are unacceptable because
of their scribal errors and contain corrections inside the lines
possibly evidence of scribes at the monastery were comparing it to
what had to have been a master text. In addition, texts
thought complete and correct but which had deteriorated due to
heavy usage and/or had missing
folios would
also be placed in these
caches. Once in a
cache,
insects and dampness would often
continue deterioration.
Complete and correctly copied texts would usually be immediately
placed in use and thus usually wear out fairly quickly which would
require repeated recopying. Further, because manuscript copying was
highly costly when it required a scribe's attention for extended
periods, a
manuscript might only be made
when commissioned, in which case the size of the
parchment,
script
used, any illustrations (thus raising the effective cost), whether
it was one book or a collection of several, etc. would be
determined by the one commissioning the work. The idea of stocking
extra copies would probably have been considered at best wasteful
and unnecessary since the form and a
manuscript was more often than not customized to
the aesthetic tastes of the buyer. This is part of the reason why
scholars are more likely to find incomplete, and at times
conflicting, segments of manuscripts rather than complete and
largely consistent works.
Distribution of Greek manuscripts by century
|
New Testament Manuscripts |
Lectionaries |
| Century |
Papyri |
Uncials |
Minuscules |
Uncials |
Minuscules |
| 2nd |
2 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
| c. 200 |
4 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
| 2nd/3rd |
1 |
1 |
- |
- |
- |
| 3rd |
28 |
2 |
- |
- |
- |
| 3rd/4th |
8 |
2 |
- |
- |
- |
| 4th |
14 |
14 |
- |
1 |
- |
| 4th/5th |
8 |
8 |
- |
- |
- |
| 5th |
2 |
36 |
- |
1 |
- |
| 5th/6th |
4 |
10 |
- |
- |
- |
| 6th |
7 |
51 |
- |
3 |
- |
| 6th/7th |
5 |
5 |
- |
1 |
- |
| 7th |
8 |
28 |
- |
4 |
- |
| 7th/8th |
3 |
4 |
- |
- |
- |
| 8th |
2 |
29 |
- |
22 |
- |
| 8th/9th |
- |
4 |
- |
5 |
- |
| 9th |
- |
53 |
13 |
113 |
5 |
| 9th/10th |
- |
1 |
4 |
- |
1 |
| 10th |
- |
17 |
124 |
108 |
38 |
| 10th/11th |
- |
3 |
8 |
3 |
4 |
| 11th |
- |
1 |
429 |
15 |
227 |
| 11th/12th |
- |
- |
33 |
- |
13 |
| 12th |
- |
- |
555 |
6 |
486 |
| 12th/13th |
- |
- |
26 |
- |
17 |
| 13th |
- |
- |
547 |
4 |
394 |
| 13th/14th |
- |
- |
28 |
- |
17 |
| 14th |
- |
- |
511 |
- |
308 |
| 14th/15th |
- |
- |
8 |
- |
2 |
| 15th |
- |
- |
241 |
- |
171 |
| 15th/16th |
- |
- |
4 |
- |
2 |
| 16th |
- |
- |
136 |
- |
194 |
Transmission
The task of copying manuscripts was generally done by
scribes who were trained professionals in the arts of
writing and bookmaking. Some manuscripts were also proofread, and
scholars closely examining a text can sometimes find the original
and corrections found in certain manuscripts. In the 6th century, a
special room devoted to the practice of manuscript writing and
illumination called the
scriptorium came into use, typically
inside medieval European monasteries. Sometimes a group of scribes
would make copies at the same time as one individual read from the
text.
Manuscript construction
An important issue with manuscripts is preservation.
The earliest New
Testament manuscripts were written on papyrus, made from a reed that grew abundantly in
the Egyptian
Nile Delta
. This tradition continued as late as the 8th
century. Papyrus eventually becomes brittle and deteriorates with
age. The dry climate of Egypt allowed some papyrus manuscripts to
be partially preserved, but, with the exception of P
77,
no New Testament papyrus manuscript is complete; many consist only
of a single fragmented page. However, beginning in the 4th century,
parchment (also called
vellum) began to be a common medium for New Testament
manuscripts. It wasn't until the 12th century that
paper (made from cotton or plant fibers0, which was
invented in 1st century China, began to gain popularity in biblical
manuscripts.
Of the 476 non-Christian manuscripts dated to the 2nd century, 97%
of the manuscripts are in the form of
scrolls; however, the 8 Christian manuscripts are
codices. In fact, most New Testament
manuscripts are codices. The adaptation of the codex form in
non-Christian text did not become dominant until the 4th and 5th
centuries, showing a preference for that form amonst early
Christians. The considerable length of some New Testament books
(such as the
Pauline epistles), and
the New Testament itself, was not suited to the limited space
available on a single scroll; in contrast a codex could be expanded
to hundreds of pages.
Script and other features
The handwriting found in New Testament manuscripts varies. One way
of classifying handwriting is by formality: book-hand vs. cursive.
More formal, literary Greek works were often written in a
distinctive style of even, capital letters called book-hand. Less
formal writing consisted of cursive letters which could be written
quickly. Another way of dividing handwriting is between
uncial (or majuscule) and
minuscule. The uncial letters were a
consistent height between the
baseline and the cap height, while the
minuscule letters had
ascenders and
descenders that moved past the baseline and cap
height. Generally speaking, the majuscules are earlier than the
minuscules, with a dividing line roughly in the 11th century.
The earliest manuscripts had hardly, if any, punctuation or
breathing marks. The manuscripts also lacked word spacing, so
words, sentences, and paragraphs would be a continuous string of
letters (
scriptio continua), often
with line breaks in the middle of words. Bookmaking was an
expensive endeavor, and one way to reduce the number of pages used
was to save space. Another method employed was to abbreviate
frequent words, such as the
nomina
sacra. Yet another method involved the
palimpsest, a manuscript which recycled an older
manuscript. Scholars using careful examination can sometimes
determine what was originally written on the material of a document
before it was erased to make way for a new text (for example
Codex Ephraemi Rescriptus
and the
Sinaitic
Palimpsest).
The original New Testament books did not have titles, section
headings, or
verse and
chapter divisions. These were developed over the years as
"helps for readers". The
Ammonian
Sections were an early system of division written in the margin
of many manuscripts. The
Eusebian
Canons was a series of tables that grouped parallel stories
among the gospels. After 400 were used κεφαλαια.
Manuscripts became more ornate over the centuries, which developed
into a rich
illuminated
manuscript tradition, including the famous Irish
Gospel Books, the
Book
of Kells and the
Book of
Durrow.
Cataloging
Desiderius Erasmus compiled the
first printed edition of the Greek New Testament in 1516, basing
his work on several manuscripts because he did not have a single
complete work and because each manuscript had small errors. In the
18th century,
Johann Jakob
Wettstein was one of the first biblical scholars to start
cataloging biblical manuscripts. He divided the manuscripts based
on the writing used (
uncial, minuscule) or
format (
lectionaries) and based on
content (
Gospels,
Pauline letters,
Acts +
General epistles, and
Revelation). He assigned the uncials
letters and minuscules and lectionaries numbers for each grouping
of content, which resulted in manuscripts being assigned the same
letter or number.
For manuscripts that contained the whole New Testament, such as
Codex Alexandrinus (A) and
Codex Ephraemi Rescriptus
(C), the letters corresponded across content groupings. However,
for a significant, early manuscript such as
Codex Vaticanus Graecus 1209
(B), which did not contain Revelation, the letter B was also
assigned to a later 10th century manuscript of Revelation, thus
creating confusion.
Constantin von Tischendorf found
one of the earliest, nearly complete copies of the Bible,
Codex Sinaiticus, over a century after
Wettstein's cataloging system was introduced. Because he felt the
manuscript was so important, Von Tischendorf assigned it the Hebrew
letter
aleph (א). Eventually enough uncials
were found that all the letters in the
Latin alphabet had been used, and scholars
moved on to first the
Greek alphabet,
and eventually started reusing characters by adding a
superscript. Confusion also existed in the
minuscules, where up to seven different manuscripts could have the
same number or a single manuscript of the complete New Testament
could have 4 different numbers to describe the different content
groupings.
Von Soden
Hermann, Freiherr von
Soden published a complex cataloging system for manuscripts in
1902-10. He grouped the manuscripts based on content, assigning
them a Greek prefix: δ for the complete New Testament, ε for the
Gospels, and α for the remaining parts. This grouping, however, was
flawed because some manuscripts grouped in δ did not contain
Revelation, and many manuscripts grouped in α contained either the
general epistles or the Pauline epistles, but not both. After the
Greek prefix, Von Soden assigned a numeral that roughly
corresponded to a date (for example δ1-δ49 were from before the
10th century, δ150-δ249 for the 11th century). This system proved
to be problematic when manuscripts were re-dated, or when more
manuscripts were discovered than the number of spaces allocated to
a certain century.
Gregory-Aland
Caspar René Gregory
published another cataloging system in 1908 in
Die griechischen
Handschriften des Neuen Testaments, which is the system still
in use today. Gregory divided the manuscripts into 4 groupings:
papyri, uncials, minuscules, and
lectionaries. This division is partially
arbitrary. The first grouping is based on the physical material
(
papyrus) used in the manuscripts. The
second two divisions are based on script: uncial and minuscule. The
last grouping is based on content: lectionary. Most of the papyrus
manuscripts and the lectionaries before the year 1000 are written
in uncial script. However, there is some consistency in that the
majority of the papyri are very early because parchment began to
replace papyrus in the 4th century (although the latest papyri
dates to the 8th century). Similarly, the majority of the uncials
date to before the 11th century, and the majority of the minuscules
to after.
Gregory assigned the papyri a prefix of
P, often
written in
blackletter script
(