The
Canadian Alliance (in French Alliance
canadienne), formally the Canadian Reform
Conservative Alliance (or in French Alliance
réformiste-conservatrice canadienne), was a Canadian
conservative political party that existed from
2000 to 2003. The party was the successor to the
Reform Party of Canada and inherited
its position as the
Official Opposition in the
House of Commons and held
it throughout its existence. The party supported policies that were
both
fiscally and
socially conservative, seeking reduced
government spending on social programs and reductions in
taxation.
The Alliance was created out of the
United Alternative initiative launched by
the
Reform Party and several
provincial Tory parties as a vehicle to merge with the
Progressive
Conservative Party of Canada. The federal PC Party under
Joe Clark rebuffed the initiative to
"unite the right". In December 2003, the Canadian Alliance and the
Progressive Conservative parties voted to disband and merge into
the
Conservative Party of
Canada.
Background
The Canadian Alliance's origins were in the
Reform Party of Canada, which was
founded in 1987 as a
populist party
supporting
Western Canadian
interests. However, soon after its formation it moved sharply
to the right and became a populist conservative (largely
socially conservative) party.
Initially, the Reform Party was motivated by the need for
democratic reforms and by profound Western Canadian discontent with
the Progressive Conservative government of
Brian Mulroney. Led by its founder
Preston Manning, the Reform Party rapidly
gained momentum in western Canada and sought to expand its base in
the east. Manning, son of longtime
Alberta Premier Ernest Manning, gained support partly from
the same political constituency as his father's old party, the
Social Credit Party of
Canada.
With the
collapse of a fragile Tory coalition composed of westerners,
Ontarians
and Quebec
nationalists, the Reform Party's fortunes rose. It first entered
Parliament in 1989 when Deborah Grey
won a by-election in an Edmonton
-area
riding. The party achieved major success in the
1993 federal election, when
it succeeded in replacing the Progressive Conservative Party as the
leading right-wing party in Canada. Its platform and policies
emphasized,
inter alia, the rights and responsibilities of
the individual, Senate and other democratic reforms, and smaller
more fiscally responsible government. However, the party came under
constant attack of being extremist and intolerant due to a number
of statements by Reform MPs which were considered to be
racist,
homophobic, and
sexist remarks. In the
1997 election, the Reform
Party made only minor gains, but did manage to become Canada's
official opposition. The party still failed to present a true
challenge to the
Liberal
government, since its agenda was seen as too extreme for the liking
of central and eastern Canada. Reform actually won a seat in
Ontario in 1993, but lost it in 1997.
Demand for unity by the right, encouraged Manning to promote a new
movement, the "
United
Alternative", to create a small-"c" conservative alternative to
the Liberals. Manning blamed "conservative" vote splitting for
keeping the Liberals in power, although some polls showed that the
Liberals were the second choice of many PC voters (especially in
Ontario). Manning's efforts created a strong debate in the Reform
party, and he would even write a letter to the effect that he
didn't want to lead Reform anymore, but would only lead the new
party. Manning would win a leadership review with over 75%, and
opposition died down.
In 2000, following the second of the two United Alternative
conventions, the party voted to dissolve in favour of a new party:
the "Canadian Conservative Reform Alliance", a declaration of
policy and a new constitution. The new party's platform was a
mixture of the PC and Reform platforms. However, it was largely
seen as merely a renamed and enlarged Reform Party. Former Reform
members dominated the new party, and the Reform caucus in the
Commons essentially became the Alliance caucus (with a few
exceptions). Former
PM
Brian Mulroney called the party
"Reform in pantyhose", and some opponents referred to the party as
the "Reform Alliance" to enforce this perception.
Media covering the convention quickly pointed out that if one added
the word "Party" to the end of the party's name, the resulting
initials were "CCRAP" (humorously pronounced "see-
crap" or just "crap") even though it, like the
Bloc Québécois, didn't actually
have the word
party in its name. When it became clear
after a few days that the joke was not going to subside, the
party's official name was quickly changed to the
Canadian
Reform Conservative Alliance, but was almost always called
simply "the Canadian Alliance" or "the Alliance". However, the
"CCRAP" nickname was still used by its opponents. Grey, the deputy
leader of Reform, was chosen as the new party's interim leader,
becoming the first female Leader of the Opposition in Canadian
history.
The federal Progressive Conservatives under
Joe Clark refused to participate in these talks,
but there was strong support from many provincial Tories,
especially in Ontario and Alberta.
Subsequently, at the new party's first
leadership convention, Manning
was defeated in favour of the younger, more charismatic Stockwell Day, longtime treasurer (finance
minister) of Alberta
. One
Progressive Conservative senator,
Gerry St. Germain, joined the new party in
October 2000, becoming the Alliance's only member of the
Senate.
In the fall of 2000, the Liberals called a
snap election that caught
the Alliance off-guard. Nonetheless, the party went into the
election with great hopes, campaigning on tax cuts, an end to the
federal gun registration program, and their vision of "family
values". Day was expected to have greater appeal to Ontario voters.
At one point, the Alliance was at 30.5% in the polls, and some
thought they could win the election, or at least knock the Liberals
down to a
minority government.
However, the Liberals responded by accusing the Alliance of having
a "hidden agenda" (introduce
two-tier health care, threatening
gay rights and
abortion rights) which the party denied.
Though disappointed with the election results in Ontario, it
increased its presence to 66 MPs, including two MPs from Ontario.
Nationally, the party increased its popular vote to 25%. The
Alliance remained the Official Opposition in the House of Commons.
The Liberals increased their large majority mostly at the expense
of the NDP, and the Tories under Joe Clark lost many seats and
remained in fifth place, but Clark was elected in
Calgary Centre in the middle of Alliance
country, so the overall political landscape was not significantly
changed.
However, the Alliance failure to win more than the two seats in
Ontario, along with residual resentments from the Alliance
leadership contest and questions about Day's competence, led to
caucus infighting. In the spring of 2001, eleven MPs who either
voluntarily resigned or were expelled from the party formed the
"Independent Alliance Caucus". The group was led by
Chuck Strahl and included Grey. Day offered the
dissidents an amnesty at the end of the summer, but seven of them,
including Grey and Stahl, turned it down and formed their own
parliamentary grouping, the
Democratic Representative
Caucus. The DRC formed a coalition with Clark's Tories in the
House, which was widely seen as an attempt by Clark to reunite the
Canadian right on his terms. The split forced Day to call a new
leadership convention, and, in April 2002,
Stephen Harper defeated Day at the subsequent
Canadian Alliance
leadership election.
Once Harper assumed the leadership, most of the rebellious MPs
rejoined the Alliance party. Two MPs did not rejoin, however:
Inky Mark chose to remain outside of
caucus, and eventually joined the Tories, and the scandal-plagued
Jim Pankiw was rejected when he applied
for readmission to the Alliance caucus.
Provincial wings
During its short history, the Canadian Alliance never seriously
entertained the prospect of forming provincial wings, or forging
formal links with existing provincial parties.
The vast majority of
CA supporters in most provinces supported, and continued to support
their provincial Progressive Conservative parties, while most
supporters in Saskatchewan
remained loyal to the Saskatchewan Party.
However,
an attempt to form a provincial party with clear, if unofficial
links with the CA was made in Alberta
, where the
Alberta Alliance was formed in
2002. Under the leadership of Reform/CA activist
Randy Thorsteinson, the new party never
sought a formal link with the CA, and had it done so the overture
would likely have been rebuffed since many Albertan CA members
continued to support the
Alberta Progressive
Conservatives. However, the Alberta Alliance copied the colours
of the CA and many of its logos bear a striking resemblance to
those of the federal party. The Alberta Alliance continued to grow
following the federal party's merger, and the provincial party
fielded a full slate of candidates for the
2004 provincial election, on
November 22, 2004, and won one seat in the Legislature.
Conservative Party of Canada
On October 15, 2003, the Canadian Alliance and the Progressive
Conservative Party (under its new leader
Peter MacKay) announced that they would merge
to form a new party, called the
Conservative Party of Canada.
The union was ratified on December 5, 2003, with 96% support of the
membership of the Canadian Alliance, and on December 6, 90.04%
support of elected delegates in the PC Party. On December 8, the
party was officially registered with
Elections Canada, and on March 20, 2004,
former Alliance leader Stephen Harper was elected as leader of the
party. The new party was dubbed "the Alliance Conservatives" by
critics who considered the new party a "
hostile takeover" of the old Progressive
Conservatives by the newer Alliance.
The new Conservative Party would form the government on February 6,
2006.
Party leaders
Federal election results 2000
| Election |
# of candidates |
# of seats won |
# of total votes |
% of popular vote |
| 2000 |
298 |
66 |
3,276,929 |
25.49% |
See also