Cut is a British
advertising
campaign launched in 2009 by the charitable organisation Women's Aid to promote
awareness of domestic
violence. The campaign was created by
advertising agency Grey London, and centres around a 120-second
commercial starring
Keira Knightley.
Supporting the commercial are poster and online components.
Cut was directed by
Joe Wright
and produced by Dominic Delaney. Post-production work was handled
by Big Buoy and Prime Focus. The campaign drew a significant amount
of media attention, especially after advertising approval body
Clearcast prohibited the spot from
appearing on even post-
watershed television, due to several
particularly violent scenes. The title of the piece refers to the
filmmaking practice of
cutting.
Sequence
Cut opens with a young actress, played by
Keira Knightley, leaving the
set after a day's work. The actress drives
home, wiping off her make-up in the car. When she arrives at her
apartment, she calls to her boyfriend before finding a shattered
mirror and a trail of blood across the floor into the kitchen. When
she turns around, she sees her boyfriend's knuckles are bloodied
and offers him a towel. He snaps it out of her hand. He then asks
about the scenes with the
leading man
and whether her scenes with him "felt real". He cuts off her reply
by throwing the towel back in her face and, when she tries to
protest, strikes her to the ground and proceeds to yank her hair
and kick her several times in the chest. The camera
zooms out to reveal that the room is an otherwise
empty set. The
strapline "Isn't it time
someone called
Cut" appears,
followed by the statistic that two women die as a result of
domestic abuse each week, and a request for a donation of £2 a
month.
Background and production
Since the appointment of advertising agency
Grey London to handle the marketing of
Women's Aid in 2005, they
had worked on a number of publicity campaigns for the
feminist charitable organisation. In 2006, their
Valentine's Day campaign, with a budget of just £500,
reached an estimated 52% of adults within the United Kingdom and
generated editorial coverage worth an estimated
€613,000. Comprising spots in
print,
posters, and
radio, the campaign received wide
critical acclaim, including an Aerial Award,, a Euro Effie Award,,
and an IPA Effectiveness Award. The following year marked the
launch of the
ACT campaign.
ACT centred around a
series of images taken by British photographer
Rankin, of a number of female British
celebrities, including
Anna Friel and
Honor Blackman.
Cosmetics were applied to the celebrities to give
them the appearance of having been
beaten. Noel Bussey of
Campaign magazine said of the
series:
"Many agencies pull out their best work when it's for
charity, but rarely is it this effective, so well shot or so close
to the brief." Women's Aid went to win the 2007 Campaigning
Team of the Year award at the Charity Times Gala Awards in London
for the work surrounding the
ACT campaign.
Keira Knightley had worked with director
Joe
Wright on a number of projects prior to
Cut, including
the feature films
Pride & Prejudice
and
Atonement, and a 2008
television commercial for
Chanel perfume. The
pair volunteered their time for
Cut at no charge, and
convinced a team of around fifty others to do so as well. The
assembled team included
BAFTA-nominated
make-up artist Ivana Primorac and
cinematographer Seamus McGarvey, whose work with Wright on
Atonement earned him an
Academy
Award nomination. Filming took place in January 2009, and the
piece was intended to begin airing on April 2.
Release and reception
It was intended that
Cut begin broadcasting simultaneously
on post-
watershed television
and during trailers for
15-rated films in
cinemas from April 2, 2009. However, when the commercial was sent
for approval by
Clearcast, the advertising
authority refused permission for
Cut to appear on British
television either before or after the watershed. Clearcast advised
that the final scene of
Cut, in which Knightley's
character is being kicked repeatedly by her boyfriend, was too
violent and likely to cause offense, and therefore demanded that
the scene be removed from the piece before it could be televised.
Women's Aid refused to make the modifications, instead electing to
eschew television and concentrate on the cinema, online, and print
aspects of the campaign.
Cut made its debut at cinemas on
April 6. Media space was donated by the cinema advertising
companies
Pearl & Dean,
Digital Cinema Media, and
Admedia. The ad also appeared online, both
at a dedicated
microsite and on
video sharing website
YouTube. This online component was backed up with a
series of print advertisements created by Grey London
creative director Nils Leonard.
The campaign was received well by the public. Within six days the
film had over half a million
hit
online, swiftly rising to over a million. Of those who viewed
Cut, only two wrote to complain to the Advertising
Standards Authority. Clearcast's decision to block the piece from
appearing on television was widely lambasted. Reactions by the
media to the ad itself were mixed.
Yasmin Alibhai-Brown of
The Independent supported the piece,
saying: "I know seeing her heroine Keira Knightley being knocked
about by her lover will shake and wake my daughter up to this
crime. Nothing I can say will have the same impact." However,
Kira Cochrane of
The Guardian was more critical, saying:
"[O]nce the initial horror had passed, I was left wondering about
the point of the ad. [...] [T]here's something about a celebrity
being used to represent a domestic violence victim that makes me
feel slightly queasy." Irrespective of these differing opinions,
Cut has proven to be a financial and critical success.
During the period in which the campaign ran in cinemas and print,
metrics reported a 33% increase in awareness of the charity, and
Women's Aid received a 50% rise in people looking to make a
donation. The campaign was also shortlisted for a Cyber Lion at the
Cannes
Lions International Advertising Festival, considered one of the
most prestigious awards in the advertising industry.
References
- " Keira Knightley beaten by jealous lover in
hard-hitting domestic abuse TV campaign", The Daily Mail,
April 2, 2009. Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- "http://www.campaignlive.co.uk/news/search/519922// Hotline:
Grey London appointed to handle Women's Aid's account]",
Campaign, September 30, 2005.
Retrieved September 8, 2009.
- " IPA Effectiveness Awards 2006: Bronze Awards",
Campaign, November 3, 2006.
Retrieved September 8, 2009.
- " Grey EMEA Lands Hat-Trick at EACA Euro Effies",
PR
Newswire, September 27, 2007. Retrieved September 8,
2009.
- Darby, Ian; " Grey duo Smith and Butler scoop Aerial",
Campaign, March 26, 2006. Retrieved
September 8, 2009.
- Williams, Eliza; " Celebrities Beaten Up for Women's Aid",
Creative Review, February 1, 2007. Retrieved September 8,
2009.
- Boycott, Rosie; " Hitting back: the brutal face of domestic
violence", The Daily Mail, February 2, 2007.
Retrieved September 8, 2009.
- Bussey, Noel; " Pick of the week - Grey/Women's Aid",
Campaign, February 2, 2007.
Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- " Women's Aid Federation of England Report and
Financial Statements", Charity Commission for England and
Wales, March 31, 2008. Retrieved September 8, 2009.
- Shields, Rachel; " 'Too violent' Knightley advert banned from TV",
The
Independent, April 26, 2009. Retrieved September 9,
2009.
- Schmidt, Veronica; " Keira Knightley beaten up by boyfriend in domestic
violence advert", The Times, April 2, 2009. Retrieved September
9, 2009.
- Bussey, Noel; " Keira Knightley takes a beating in new Women's Aid
ad", Campaign, April 2, 2009. Retrieved
September 9, 2009.
- Williams, Eliza; " Keira Knightley stars in Women's Aid ad",
Creative Review, April 2, 2009. Retrieved September 9,
2009.
- " Knightley in violent charity ad", BBC News, April 2, 2009.
Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- Alarcon, Cameron; " Womens Aid teams up with Keira Knightley",
Marketing
Week, April 2, 2009. Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- " Outdoor Lions Entries: Cut",
Cannes
Lions International Advertising Festival Authority, 2009.
Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- " Cyber Lions Shortlist: Cut", Cannes Lions
International Advertising Festival Authority, 2009.
Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- Johnston, Ian; " Cuts demanded in Keira Knightley's anti-domestic
violence advert", The Telegraph, April 27, 2009.
Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- Moore, Jane; " Why TV must show the ugly truth of Keira's ad",
The Sun, May 27, 2009. Retrieved
September 9, 2009.
- "It seems pathetic. It is really important to raise awareness
about domestic violence, and TV gets into people’s homes" - Sandra
Horely, chief executive of the charitable women's shelter
organisation "Refuge" (taken from " Keira's violent ad censored", The New
Zealand Herald, April 28, 2009. Retrieved September 9,
2009.)
- " Friend defends Knightley's abuse ad",
Daily
Express, May 8, 2009. Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- Alibhai-Brown, Yasmin; " Let's hear it for our luvvies when they do such
good", The Independent, April 6, 2009.
Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- Cochrane, Kira; " Battered, Hollywood-style", The Guardian, April 3,
2009. Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- " Does shock advertising still work?",
Campaign, April 27, 2009. Retrieved
September 9, 2009.
- Howard, Theresa; " Fewer ads entered at Cannes Lions as fewer people
attend", USA
Today, June 21, 2009. Retrieved September 12, 2009.
- " Bark Copenhagen Nominated for Prestigious Cannes
Lions Advertising Award", Marketwire, June 22, 2009. Retrieved
September 12, 2009.
- Agarwal, Sapna; " Indian entries, registrations to Cannes Lions see a
drop", Business Standard, June 19, 2009.
Retrieved September 12, 2009.
- Herzog, Boaz; " Nike Will Receive Honor at Cannes Lions Advertising
Festival.", The Oregonian, February 12, 2003.
Retrieved September 12, 2009 (via Highbeam.com).
External links