- For the bridge player,
see David
Berkowitz .
David Richard Berkowitz
(born Richard David Falco, June 1, 1953), also
known as Son of Sam and the .44 Caliber
Killer, is an American
serial killer and arsonist whose crimes terrorized New York City
from July 1976 until his arrest in August
1977.
Shortly after his arrest in August 1977, Berkowitz confessed to
killing six people and wounding seven others in the course of eight
shootings in New York between 1976 and 1977; he has been imprisoned
for these crimes since 1977. Berkowitz subsequently claimed that he
was commanded to kill by a
demon who
possessed his neighbor's dog.
Berkowitz later amended his confession to claim he was the shooter
in only two incidents, personally killing three people and wounding
a fourth. The other victims were killed, Berkowitz claimed, by
members of a violent
Satanic cult of which he was a member. Though he remains the
only person charged with or convicted of the shootings, some
law enforcement authorities
argue that Berkowitz's claims are credible: according to
John Hockenberry formerly of
MSNBC, many officials involved in the original "Son of
Sam" case suspected that more than one person was committing the
murders. Hockenberry also reported that the Son of Sam case was
reopened in 1996 and, , it was still considered open.
Early life
Berkowitz
was born Richard David Falco in Brooklyn, New
York
. His mother, Betty Broder, was married to
Anthony Falco, with whom she had a daughter before the couple
separated without legally
divorcing. After
this, she had an affair with the married Joseph Kleinman, who
fathered a son. Kleinman suggested she
abort the child, but she gave birth to a boy and
listed Falco as the father.
Before he was a week old, the baby was
adopted by hardware store owners Nathan and Pearl
Berkowitz, who reversed the order of his first and middle names in
addition to giving him their own surname.
John Vincent Sanders wrote that Berkowitz's childhood was "somewhat
troubled. Although of above-average intelligence, he lost interest
in learning at an early age and began an infatuation with petty
larceny and
pyromania." Berkowitz's adoptive mother died of
breast cancer when he was thirteen,
and his home life became strained in later years, particularly
because he disliked his adoptive father's second wife. He later
claimed his new step-sister was interested in
witchcraft, sparking an interest in the
occult he would later pursue more actively.
In 1969,
the 16-year-old Berkowitz attended the Woodstock
Festival
. He joined the
United States Army in 1971, and served on
active duty until his
honorable discharge in 1974.
He avoided
service in the Vietnam War, instead
serving in both the United States and South Korea
.
In 1974 Berkowitz located his birth mother, Betty Falco. After a
few visits, she disclosed the details of his illegitimate
conception and birth, which greatly
disturbed him. They fell out of contact, but Berkowitz did stay in
touch with his half-sister, Roslyn.
After leaving the Army, Berkowitz held several
blue collar jobs. At the time of his arrest, he
was employed by the
U.S.
Postal Service.
Cult claims
Berkowitz claims that he joined a
cult in the
spring of 1975. Initially, he said, the group was involved in
harmless activities, such as
séances and
fortune telling. Gradually, however,
Berkowitz claimed that the group introduced him to
drug use,
sadistic
pornography and violent crime. They began, he claims, by
killing dogs, mostly
German
Shepherds.
Over a dozen mutilated dog corpses were
discovered in Yonkers
, especially
near Untermeyer Park, which Berkowitz claimed was a frequent
meeting place for the cult.
Crimes begin
First attacks
Berkowitz claimed that his first attacks on women occurred in late
1975, when he attacked two women with a knife on
Christmas Eve. One alleged victim was never
identified, but the other victim, Michelle Forman, was injured
seriously enough to put her in the hospital.
Not long afterward,
Berkowitz moved to an apartment in Yonkers
.
Donna Lauria and Jody Valenti shooting
At about
1:10 a.m. on July 29, 1976, Mike and Rose Lauria returned to their
apartment in Pelham Bay
after dining out. Their daughter Donna,
18, and her friend Jody Valenti, 19, were sitting in Valenti's
Oldsmobile, parked outside the apartment,
discussing their evening at the Peachtree, a New Rochelle
discotheque. As
Valenti was about to leave, Mike Lauria agreed to his daughter's
suggestion that they walk the family's dog together. Before he went
inside to retrieve the poodle, Lauria noticed a man sleeping in a
yellow
compact car parked across the
street and about sixty feet behind his own car. Neighbors would
report to police that an unfamiliar yellow
compact car had been cruising the area for hours
before the shooting.
After her parents were inside, Donna Lauria opened the car door to
depart, noticing a man quickly approaching them. Startled and
angered by the man's sudden appearance, Lauria said, "Now what is
this…" From the paper sack he carried, the man produced a handgun
and, crouching as he aimed, fired three shots. Lauria was struck in
her chest by one bullet that killed her almost instantly, Valenti
took a bullet in her
thigh, and the third
missed both girls. The shooter turned and quickly walked
away.
Valenti, who survived her injuries, said she did not recognize the
killer. She described him as a white male in his 30s with a fair
complexion, standing about 5'9" and weighing about . His hair was
short, dark and curly in a "
mod
style." This description was echoed by Mike Lauria in his
description of the man who was sitting in the yellow compact car
parked behind Valenti and Lauria.
Detectives from the 8th Homicide precinct of the
New York Police Department had
little in the way of evidence. Most importantly, they were able to
determine that the handgun used was a
.44
caliber Charter Arms
Bulldog. A high-power, five-shot
revolver intended for use in close quarters, the
.44 Bulldog was identified because the unusual manufacturing
process of its barrel left distinctive marks on each slug.
Police followed two working
hypotheses in
the absence of further
evidence: that the
shooter was a spurned admirer of the popular Lauria or that the
shooting was a mistaken
assassination
attempt of the wrong person. The neighborhood had seen recent
mob activity, and police even hinted that Mike
Lauria, a member of the
Teamsters union,
might be involved in
organized
crime.
Berkowitz later claimed that he shot Lauria and Valenti, and that
several other cult members were involved in the crime, either by
surveillance of the victims, or by
acting as lookouts.
Carl Denaro and Rosemary Keenan shooting
In the
early morning of October 23, 1976, another shooting occurred, this
time in Queens
.
Carl Denaro, 25, and Rosemary Keenan, 38, were parked in a secluded
residential area in
Flushing,
Queens. Keenan was driving her own
Volkswagen Beetle, and Denaro was in the
passenger seat. At about 1:30 a.m., the car's windows seemed to
explode, and the duo dropped low in their seats as several bullets
struck the car. Denaro and Keenan did not realize someone was
shooting at them, even as Denaro was bleeding from a bullet wound
to his head. They panicked and Keenan drove to Peck's, a bar about
half a mile away. Keenan had only superficial injuries from the
broken glass, but Denaro eventually needed a metal plate to replace
a portion of his
skull. Neither victim had
seen whoever had made the attack.
Police determined that the slugs embedded in Keenan's car were .44
caliber bullets, but they were so damaged and deformed that they
thought it was unlikely that they could ever be linked to a
particular weapon. Denaro had shoulder-length hair, and police
would later speculate that the shooter had mistaken him for a girl.
Keenan's father was a 20-year veteran police detective of the
NYPD, spurring an in-depth investigation. As
with the Lauria-Valenti shooting, however, there seemed to be no
motive for the shooting, and police made little progress in the
case. Though many details of the Denaro-Keenan shooting were very
similar to the Lauria-Valenti case, police did not initially
suspect a connection, partly because the shootings occurred in
different boroughs of New York City and were investigated by
different local police agencies.
Berkowitz later claimed that, while he observed and helped plan the
crime, an unnamed female cult member actually shot Denaro. The
victims survived primarily, claimed Berkowitz, because the shooter
was unfamiliar with the powerful
recoil of a
.44 Bulldog.
Donna DeMasi and Joanne Lomino shooting
Late in the evening of November 26, 1976, Donna DeMasi, 16, and
Joanne Lomino, 18, had walked home from a movie, and were chatting
under a streetlight outside Lomino's home. A man approached to
within about ten feet of the girls. They later described him as
about 5'9", tall and slender, weighing perhaps with straight, dirty
blond hair and dark eyes. He wore a slim, knee-length coat
reminiscent of military surplus gear.
Startled but not frightened by his sudden appearance, DeMasi and
Lomino suspected the man was lost and asking directions. In a
high-pitched voice he said, "Can you tell me how to get," then he
produced a revolver. He shot each of the victims once, and as they
fell to the ground injured, he fired several more times, striking
the apartment building before running away. Having heard the
gunshots, a neighbor rushed from their apartment and saw the blonde
shooter rush by, gripping a pistol in his left hand.
DeMasi and Lomino were hospitalized with serious injuries: Lomino
was ultimately rendered a
paraplegic, but
DeMasi's wounds were less serious.
Based on the testimony of DeMasi, Lomino, and their neighbor,
police produced several
composite
sketches of the blonde shooter. Police also determined the gun
was a .44, but the slugs were so deformed that linking them to a
particular gun was all but ruled out.
Berkowitz later claimed that while he helped plan the DeMasi-Lomino
shooting, the actual perpetrator was cult member John Carr, and
that a Yonkers police officer, also a cult member, was involved in
the crime.
Christine Freund and John Diel shooting
The new year brought more shootings in Queens. In the early morning
of January 30, 1977, an engaged couple, Christine Freund, 26, and
John Diel, 30, were sitting in Diel's
Pontiac Firebird, preparing to drive to a
dance hall after having seen the motion picture
Rocky.
Three gunshots penetrated the car at about 12:40 a.m. In a panic,
Diel drove away for help. He suffered minor superficial injuries,
but Freund was shot twice. She died several hours later at the
hospital. Neither victim had seen their attacker(s).
Police determined the shooter had again used a .44
Bulldog. Police made the first public
acknowledgment that the Freund-Diel shooting was similar to the
earlier cases, and that the crimes might be connected: the earlier
victims had been struck with .44 caliber bullets, if not confirmed
Bulldog revolvers, and the shootings targeted young women with
long, dark hair and/or young couples parked in cars.
NYPD sergeant Richard Conlon stated that
police were "leaning towards a connection in all these cases."
Composite sketches of the black-haired Lauria-Valenti shooter and
the blonde Lomino-DeMasi shooter were released, and Conlon noted
that police were looking for multiple "suspects", not just
one.
Berkowitz later claimed that while "at least five" cult members
were at the scene of the Freund-Diel shooting, the actual shooter
was a cult associate nicknamed "
Manson II", who was brought in from outside
New York due to a special motive of which Berkowitz claimed to know
no details.
Virginia Voskerichian shooting
At about 7:30 p.m. on March 8, 1977,
Columbia University student Virginia
Voskerichian, 19, was walking home from school. She lived about a
block from where Christine Freund was shot. The Voskerichian
shooting differed from the other Son of Sam crimes in many
respects. All the other victims were couples, and were shot on
weekends in the late night or early morning.
There were no direct witnesses to the Voskerichian murder, which
happened on the victim's own street. In a desperate move to defend
herself, Voskerichian lifted her textbooks between herself and her
killer, only to have the makeshift shield penetrated, the bullet
striking her head and killing her.
Moments after the shooting, a neighborhood resident who had heard
the gunshots was rounding the corner onto Voskerichian's street. He
nearly collided with a person he described as a short, husky boy,
16 to 18 years old and clean-shaven, wearing a sweater and watch
cap, who was sprinting away from the crime scene. The neighbor said
the youth pulled the cap over his face and said, "Oh, Jesus!" as he
passed by, sprinting.
Other neighbors claimed to have seen the "teenager," and another
matching Berkowitz's description, loitering separately in the area
for about an hour before the shooting. In the following days, the
media repeated police claims that this "chubby teenager" was the
suspect in the shooting.
Berkowitz
later claimed that he was at the Voskerichian murder scene, but the
actual shooter was a "woman from Westchester
." Additionally, Berkowitz claimed the
Voskerichian shooting was partly designed to confuse police by
seeming to change the
modus operandi
established in earlier cult shootings.
Press and publicity
Press conference of March 10, 1977
In a March 10, 1977
press
conference, NYPD officials and
New York City Mayor Abraham Beame declared that the same .44
Bulldog revolver had fired the shots that killed Lauria and
Voskerichian. Official documents would later surface, however,
saying that while police strongly suspected the same .44 Bulldog
had been used in the shootings, the evidence was actually
inconclusive.
The same day, the Operation Omega
task
force made its public debut. Charged solely with investigating
the .44 Caliber shootings, the task force was led by Deputy
Inspector Timothy J. Dowd, composed of over 300 police officers.
Police speculated that the killer had a vendetta against women,
perhaps due to
chronic social
rejection, and also declared that the "chubby teenager" was
regarded as a witness, not a suspect in the Voskerichian shooting.
The police regarded the taller, black-haired male shooter in the
Lauria-Valenti case as the shooter in all the .44 Caliber
murders.
Publicity and political implications
The crimes earned considerable
mass media
publicity, with television, newspapers and radio publishing every
detail and speculation of the case.
Australian publisher
Rupert Murdoch had recently purchased the
New York Post, and the paper
offered perhaps the most sensational coverage of the crimes, as a
result vaulting from near-
bankruptcy into
profitability. Mayor Beame, meanwhile, helped funnel unprecedented
amounts of money to the NYPD to help solve the case.
Another shooting
Alexander Esau and Valentina Suriani shooting
In the
early morning of April 17, 1977, Alexander Esau, 20, and Valentina
Suriani, 18, were in the Bronx
, only a few
blocks from the scene of the Lauria-Valenti shooting. At
about 3:00 a.m., they were each shot twice and killed. Suriani died
at the scene, and Esau died in the hospital several hours later
without being able to describe his attacker(s).
In the days afterwards, police repeated their theory that only one
man was responsible for the .44 murders: the chubby teenager in the
Voskerichian case was still regarded as a witness, while the
dark-haired man who shot Lauria and Valenti was considered the
suspect.
Berkowitz later claimed that he was responsible for the
Esau-Suriani shootings.
Letters and profiling
Son of Sam letter
In the street near the Esau-Suriani shooting, a police officer
discovered a hand-written letter. Written mostly in block capital
letters with some lower-case letters, it was addressed to NYPD
Captain Joseph Borrelli.
In full, with misspellings intact, it read:
Though discovery of the letter was an open secret, the contents
were not made public. Only a few hints were leaked: police
speculated that the letter-writer might be familiar with
Scottish English. The phrase "me hoot, it
hurts, sonny boy" was taken as a Scots-accented version of "my
heart, it hurts, sonny boy"; and the police also
hypothesized that the shooter blamed a dark-haired nurse for his
father's death, due to the "too many heart attacks" phrase, and the
facts that Lauria was a medical technician and Valenti was studying
to be a
nurse. On July 28,
New York Daily
News columnist
Jimmy Breslin
alluded to the "wemon" quirk and referred to the shooter watching
the world from "his attic window."
Psychological profile and other police investigations
After consulting with several
psychiatrists, police released a
psychological profile of their suspect on
May 26, 1977. He was described as
neurotic
and probably suffering from
paranoid
schizophrenia and believed himself to be a victim of
demonic possession.
Police questioned the owners of 56 .44 Bulldog revolvers legally
registered in New York City, and
forensically tested each weapon, ruling
them out as the murder weapons. Among other unsuccessful ideas,
police created traps with undercover officers posed as lovers
parked in isolated areas, hoping to lure the shooter.
Breslin letter
On May 30, 1977, columnist
Jimmy
Breslin of the
New York
Daily News received a hand-written letter from someone who
claimed to be the .44 shooter.
The letter was postmarked early on May 30 in
Englewood,
New Jersey
. On the reverse of the envelope was
hand-printed a precisely-centered
quatrain:
Blood and Family/Darkness and Death/Absolute
Depravity/.44
The letter read:
Underneath the "Son of Sam" was a logo or sketch that combined
several symbols. The writer's question, "What will you have for
July 29?" was taken as an ominous threat: July 29 would be the
anniversary of the first .44 Caliber shooting.
Police and public response to the Breslin letter
Breslin notified police, who thought the letter was probably from
someone with knowledge of the shootings. Sophisticated in its
wording and presentation, especially when compared to the crudely
written first letter, police suspected the Breslin letter might
have been created in an art studio or similar professional location
by someone with expertise in
printing,
calligraphy,
graphic design or
architecture.
Based on the "Wicked King Wicker" reference, police arranged a
private screening of
The
Wicker Man, a 1970s
horror
film.
A week later, after consulting with police and agreeing to withhold
portions of the text, the
Daily News published the letter,
and Breslin urged the killer to turn himself over to authorities.
Reportedly, over 1.1 million copies of that day's paper were
sold.
The letter caused a panic in New York, and based on references in
the publicized portions of the letter, police received thousands of
tips, all of which proved baseless.
As all the shooting victims so far had long, dark hair, thousands
of women in New York cut or dyed their hair, and beauty supply
stores had trouble meeting the demand for blond wigs. Despite being
one of the hottest summers on record, people stayed indoors at
night, ignoring the longstanding tradition of spending sultry
evenings outdoors.
Shootings resume
Sal Lupo and Judy Placido shooting
On June 26, 1977, there was another shooting.
Sal Lupo, 20, and
Judy Placido, 17, had left the Elephas discotheque in the Bayside
section of Queens. The young couple was
sitting in their car at about 3:00 a.m. when Placido said, "This
Son of Sam is really scary — the way that guy comes out of nowhere.
You never know where he'll hit next." Moments later, three gunshots
blasted through the car.
Both were struck by slugs, but their injuries were relatively
minor, and both survived. Neither Lupo or Placido had seen their
attacker(s), but witnesses reported a tall, stocky, dark-haired man
sprinting from the area, and a blonde man with a mustache who drove
from the neighborhood in a
Chevy Nova
without turning on its headlights. Police speculated the
dark-haired man was the shooter, and that the blonder man had
observed the crime.
Berkowitz later claimed that cult member Michael Carr shot Lupo and
Placido. Additionally, Berkowitz claimed that cult members had long
wanted to shoot someone at the Elephas
disco,
thinking the site significant in light of their interest in the
work of noted 19th century occultist
Eliphas Levi.
Stacy Moskowitz and Robert Violante shooting
It was
near the one-year anniversary of the first .44 caliber shootings,
and police set up a sizable dragnet, focusing on past hunting grounds
of Queens
and The Bronx
. However, the next .44 shooting was in
Brooklyn
.
Early on July 31, 1977, Stacy Moskowitz and Robert Violante, both
20, were in Violante's car, which was parked under a streetlight
near a city park. They were kissing when a man approached to within
about three feet of the passenger side of Violante's car, fired
several gunshots into the car, striking both victims in the head,
before running into the park. Moskowitz died several hours later in
the hospital. Violante survived, though one of his eyes was
destroyed and he retained only very limited vision in the other
eye. With her short, curly blonde hair, Moskowitz was a departure
from the other female victims. Based on telephone calls to police
within seconds of the shooting, the crime occurred at 2:35
a.m.
The Moskowitz-Violante crime produced more witnesses than any of
the other Son of Sam murders, notably the only direct eyewitness
who was not an intended victim. During the shooting, Tommy Zaino,
19, was parked with his date in a car three car lengths ahead of
Violante's. Moments before the shooting, Zaino saw a peripheral
glimpse of the shooter's approach and happened to glance in his
rear view mirror just in time to see the crime occur. Due to the
bright street light and full moon, Zaino clearly saw the
perpetrator for several seconds, later describing him as 25 to 30
years old, of average height (5'7" to 5'9") with shaggy hair that
was dark blonde or light brown — "it looked like a
wig", Zaino said.
About a minute after the shooting, a woman seated next to her
boyfriend in his car on the other side of the city park saw a
"white male [who was wearing] a light-colored, cheap nylon wig"
sprint from the park and enter a "small, light-colored" auto, which
drove away quickly. "He looks like he just robbed a bank," said the
woman, who wrote what she could see of the car's
license plate: unable to determine the first
two characters, she was certain the others were either 4-GUR or
4-GVR.
Other witnesses included a woman who saw a light car speed away
from the park about 20 seconds after the gunshots, and at least two
witnesses who described a yellow
Volkswagen driving quickly from the neighborhood
with its headlights off. A neighborhood resident given the
pseudonym Mary Lyons heard the gunshots and
Violente's calls for help, and glancing from her apartment window,
she saw a man she later positively identified as Berkowitz, who was
walking casually
away from the crime scene as many others
were rushing
towards the scene to render aid.
Shortly after 2:35 a.m., a man given the
pseudonym Alan Masters was passing through an
intersection a few blocks from the park. Masters was nearly struck
by what he described as a yellow
Volkswagen Beetle that sped through the
intersection, against the red light and without headlights, with
the driver holding his door shut with his arm as he drove. Angered
and alarmed, Masters followed the Volkswagen at high speed for
several minutes before losing sight of the vehicle. Masters
described the driver as a white male in his late 20s or early 30s,
with a narrow face; dark, long, stringy hair; several days growth
of dark whiskers on his face; and wearing a blue jacket.
Upset,
Masters neglected to note the Volkswagen's license plate number,
but he thought it might have been a New Jersey
rather than a New York
plate. Violante encountered a very similar
man as he and Moskowitz were in the park shortly before the
shooting, describing him as a "grubby-looking
hippy" with whiskers, wiry hair over his forehead,
dark eyes, and wearing a
denim jacket.
Berkowitz
would later claim that the shooter in the Moskowitz-Violante case
was a friend of John Carr, who had arrived from North Dakota
for the occasion. Additionally, Berkowitz
would claim that after his
Ford
Galaxie, license plate 561 XLB, received a
parking ticket at 2:05 a.m. for being parked
too close to a
fire hydrant near the
city park, he tried to persuade two other cult members at the scene
to postpone or relocate the crime. Berkowitz claimed his suggestion
was overruled, and he was ordered to remain in the area to make
sure no police were nearby.
Police activities after the Moskowitz-Violente shooting
Police didn't learn of the Moskowitz-Violente shooting until about
2:50 a.m., and Dowd didn't think it was another Son of Sam shooting
until an officer at the scene reported that large-caliber shells
had been used.
About an hour after the shooting, police set up a series of
roadblocks, stopping hundreds of cars to question drivers and
inspect vehicles. Based on extended interviews of Masters and
others who described a Volkswagen speeding from the crime scene,
police now suspected that the shooter owned or drove such a
vehicle. In subsequent days, police determined there were over 900
Volkswagens in New York or New Jersey, and they made plans to track
down each of these cars and their owners.
Justice system
Suspicion and capture
The evening of the Moskowitz and Violante shooting, Cacilia Davis,
who lived near the crime scene, saw Berkowitz loitering in the
neighborhood and glaring menacingly at passersby for several hours
before removing a
parking ticket from
his yellow Ford Galaxie, which had been parked too close to a
fire hydrant. Two days after the
shooting, she contacted police.
Despite their claims to the contrary, police initially thought
Berkowitz a possible witness, rather than a suspect. Not until
August 9, 1977, seven days after Cacilia Davis informed police
about the man with the parking ticket, did
NYPD
Detective James Justis telephone Yonkers
police to ask them to schedule an interview with Berkowitz. The
Yonkers police dispatcher who first took Justis' call was Wheat
Carr, the daughter of Sam Carr and sister of Berkowitz's alleged
cult confederates John and Michael Carr.
Justis asked "the [Yonkers] police for some help tracking
[Berkowitz] down. Mike Novotny was a sergeant at the Yonkers Police
Department. According to Novotny, the Yonkers police had their own
suspicions about Berkowitz, in connection with other strange crimes
in Yonkers, crimes they saw referenced in one of the Son of Sam
letters. To the shock of the NYPD they told the New York City
detective that Berkowitz might just be the Son of Sam."
The next day, police investigated Berkowitz's car parked on the
street outside his Pine Street apartment in Yonkers. Police saw a
Commando Mark III rifle in the backseat. Searching the car, police
found a
duffel bag filled with
ammunition, maps of the crime scenes and a letter to Sgt. Dowd of
the Omega task force, threatening further murders. Police decided
to wait for Berkowitz to emerge from the apartment rather than risk
a violent encounter in the narrow apartment hallway.
Berkowitz emerged from the building shortly before 10:00 p.m.,
carrying a .44 Bulldog in a paper sack. Police arrested Berkowitz
as he was starting the car outside his apartment on Pine Street in
Yonkers on August 10, 1977. His first words upon arrest were
reported to be, "You got me. What took you so long?"
Police searched his apartment, and found it in disarray, with
Satanic
graffiti on the walls. They also
found a
diary wherein Berkowitz took credit
for dozens of
arsons throughout the New York
area (some sources allege that this number might be as high as
1,411).
After police had brought Berkowitz into custody, Mayor Beame came
out to the public and said, "The people of the City of New York can
rest easy because of the fact that the police have captured a man
whom they believe to be the Son of Sam."
Questioning
Police were worried that, if challenged in court, their initial
search of Berkowitz's vehicle might be ruled
unconstitutional. Police had no
search warrant, and their justification for
the search of Berkowitz's car might seem flimsy. They had searched
initially based on the
rifle visible in the
back seat, though possession of such a rifle was legal in New York
State, and required no special permit.
Berkowitz quickly confessed to the shootings, however, and
expressed an interest in
pleading
guilty in exchange for receiving
life imprisonment rather than facing the
death penalty. Berkowitz was
questioned for about 30 minutes in the early morning of August 11,
1977, and he quickly confessed to the "Son of Sam" killings.
During questioning, Berkowitz said that the "Sam" mentioned in the
first letter was Sam Carr, his former neighbor. Berkowitz claimed
that Carr's black
labrador
retriever, Harvey, was possessed by an ancient demon, and that
it issued irresistible commands that Berkowitz must kill people.
Berkowitz said he once tried to kill the dog, but was unsuccessful
due to
supernatural interference.
Sentencing
During his sentencing, Berkowitz repeatedly chanted "Stacy was a
whore" at a low yet audible volume. He was
referring, presumably, to Stacy Moskowitz, who died in the final
.44 caliber shooting. His behavior caused an uproar, and the
courtroom was adjourned. Berkowitz later claimed that his statement
was a response to Moskowitz's mother, who frequently opined that
Berkowitz should be executed.
On June 12, 1978, he was sentenced to six life sentences in prison
for the murders, making his maximum term 365 years.
He was first
imprisoned at the Attica Correctional Facility
. He was also given additional terms for
assault and attempted murder.
Berkowitz's life in prison
In 1979, there was an attempt on Berkowitz's life. He refused to
identify the person(s) who had attacked him with a knife, but
suggested that the act was directed by the cult he once belonged
to. He bears a permanent scar from the wound that took 52 stitches
to close.
In 1987, Berkowitz became a
born
again Christian in prison. According
to his personal testimony, his moment of
conversion occurred after reading
Psalm 34:6 from a
Gideon's Pocket Testament Bible given
to him by a fellow inmate. In the same testimony, he stated that
his obsession with and heavy involvement in the occult played a
major role in the Son of Sam murders.
In March 2002, Berkowitz sent a letter to
New York Governor George Pataki asking that his
parole hearing be canceled, stating: "In all honesty,
I believe that I deserve to be in prison for the rest of my life. I
have, with God's help, long ago come to terms with my situation and
I have accepted my punishment." In June 2004, he was denied a
second parole hearing after he stated that he did not want one. The
parole board saw that he had a good record in the prison programs,
but decided that the brutality of his crimes called for him to stay
imprisoned. In July 2006, the board once again denied parole on
similar grounds, with Berkowitz not in attendance at the hearing.
He is very involved in
prison
ministry and regularly
counsels
troubled inmates.
In June 2005, Berkowitz sued his former attorney, Hugo Harmatz,
claiming he had taken possession of Berkowitz's letters and other
personal belongings in order to publish a book of his own.
Berkowitz stated that he would only drop the lawsuit if the
attorney signed over all money he makes to the victims' families.
On October 25, 2006, Berkowitz and Harmatz
settled out of court, with Harmatz agreeing
to return the disputed items to Berkowitz's present attorney Mark
Jay Heller, and to donate part of his book profits to the New York
State Crime Victims Board.
Shortly before her death in 2006, Stacy Moskowitz's mother wrote
Berkowitz a letter saying she had forgiven him for his crimes.
Moskowitz
lived her final days in a Miami
co-op, surrounded by pictures of her daughters, whom
she talked about constantly. "...she said she did forgive
everyone," said her close friend and neighbor, Sharon Denaro. "She
needed to relieve herself of anger to be able to move forward with
her life. She would say things like, 'This kind of anger can make
you sick. Don't let anger eat you up'."
Berkowitz
is housed in Sullivan Correctional
Facility
in Fallsburg, New York
. His "official" website is maintained on his
behalf by a church group as he is not allowed access to a
computer. Berkowitz's next parole hearing is slated
for May 2010; he has been denied parole four times thus far.
Berkowitz plans to write a memoir, entitled
Son of Hope: The
Prison Journals of David Berkowitz, which will be published
through Morning Star Communications. Berkowitz himself will receive
no money from publication, and a portion of the proceeds will go to
the New York state crime victims board for distribution to the
victims of his crimes.
He is also corresponding with an advocate of murder victims and
working to stop the sales of memorabilia related to murderers
Laws
One major side effect of Berkowitz's murder spree were the
"
Son of Sam laws" enacted in several
states in the 1980s.
The first of these laws was enacted in New York state after rampant
speculation about publishers offering Berkowitz large sums of money
for his story. The new law, named for Berkowitz, authorized the
state to seize all money earned from such a deal from a criminal
for five years, with intentions to use the seized money to
compensate victims.
Later claims
Satanic cult claims
Within a few weeks of his arrest, Berkowitz was hinting that others
were involved in the .44 murders. In a letter to the
New York Post dated September 19, 1977,
Berkowitz repeated the possessed dog story, but closed out his
missive with the warning, "There are other Sons out there, God help
the world."
In later years, he has discussed the cult claims in greater detail,
but alleges that he cannot divulge all he knows without putting his
family at risk. The cult had roughly two dozen core members in New
York, the "twenty-two disciples of hell" mentioned in the Breslin
letter. The cult had ties across the U.S., claimed Berkowitz, and
was deeply involved in
drug smuggling
and other illegal activities. Berkowitz reportedly invited the
former
priest and
exorcist Malachi
Martin to visit him to discuss his past Satanic cult
involvement.
Hockenberry asserts that, even aside from the Satanic cult claims,
many officials doubted the single-shooter theory, writing, "[w]hat
most don't know about the Son of Sam case is that from the
beginning, not everyone bought the idea that Berkowitz acted alone.
The list of skeptics includes both the police who worked the case
and the prosecutor from Queens where five of the shootings took
place."
Son of Sam case reopened based on cult claims
Journalist Maury Terry began investigating the Son of Sam shootings
before Berkowitz was arrested. Doubtful of the single shooter
theory favored by police, Terry dug deeper into the case, noting a
number of unresolved questions and inconsistencies that he first
publicized in a March 1978 newspaper article.
Eventually interviewing Berkowitz several times, Terry uncovered
evidence that he argues strongly support the idea that a violent
offshoot of the
Process Church was
responsible for the Son of Sam murders and many other crimes. After
consulting with police and agreeing to withhold some names and
other details, Terry publicized his conclusions first in a series
of newspaper articles distributed by the
Gannett syndicate in 1979, and later in his book
The Ultimate Evil, which has been expanded several times
since its initial 1987 publication. Queens'
district attorney John Santucci, who
thought the case against Berkowitz was riddled with inconsistencies
and unresolved questions, was so impressed with Terry's research
that, "he agreed to reopen the Son of Sam case ... But to date
no-one else has ever been charged in connection with the
crimes."
Arlis Perry claims
In
October 1978 Berkowitz mailed a book about witchcraft and other occult subjects to police in
North
Dakota
. He had underlined several passages,
offering some marginal notes, including the phrase: "Arliss [sic]
Perry, Hunted, Stalked and Slain.
Followed to Calif. Stanford
University
."
Arlis Perry, a newlywed 19-year-old
North Dakota native, had been killed in a
chapel on the grounds of Stanford University on
October 12, 1974. Her murder remains unsolved. Berkowitz mentioned
the Perry murder in a few letters, suggesting that he heard details
of the crime from "Manson II", the culprit and a member of the
violent Satanic cult. In the
San Jose Mercury News, Jessie
Seyfer noted that "investigators interviewed him in prison and now
believe he has nothing of value to offer" regarding the Perry
case.
Real-life sons of Sam
Berkowitz claimed that brothers John and Michael Carr, the real
life sons of Yonkers resident Sam Carr, were members of the same
Satanic cult. John was the "John Wheaties, rapist and suffocator of
young girls" mentioned in the Breslin letter.
Both Carr brothers died within two years of Berkowitz's arrest.
John Carr
was discovered dead in February 1978 in his girlfriend's North Dakota
home; police initially viewed his death as
suspicious, but it was ultimately ruled a probable suicide. Michael Carr died in a single-car traffic
accident in October 1979, on Manhattan
's West Side
Highway.
Berkowitz claims that both Carr brothers were probably murdered by
Satanic cult members because their heavy drug use marked them as
untrustworthy and likely to become
informants.
Depictions
- The 1985 CBS film Out of the
Darkness, the first to deal with the Son of Sam killings,
was told from the point of view of Ed Zigo, one of the detectives
responsible for capturing Berkowitz by poring over parking tickets
given to an illegally parked car in Brooklyn near where Stacy
Moskowitz was murdered. Zigo was played by Martin Sheen, and Berkowitz was played by
Robert Trebor.
- The 1999 film Summer of
Sam, directed by Spike Lee,
depicts the tensions that develop in a Bronx neighborhood during
the shootings. Berkowitz was played by Michael Badalucco.
- The 2007 ESPN mini-series The Bronx is Burning features the
murders as a backdrop.
- Son of Sam is a 2008 Lionsgate film by Ulli
Lommel focusing on Berkowitz's satanic cult connection.
References
Further reading
- Breslin, Jimmy and Dick Schaap (1978). .44: a Novel.
Viking Press. ISBN 0-670-32432-9.
- Klausner, Lawrence D. (1980). Son of Sam: Based on the
Authorized Transcription of the Tapes, Official Documents and
Diaries of David Berkowitz. McGraw-Hill. ISBN 0070350272.
- Newfield, Jack and Paul DuBrul (1977). The abuse of power:
the permanent Government and the fall of New York. Viking
Press. ISBN 0-670-10204-0.
- Rowlett, Curt (2006). Labyrinth13: True Tales of the
Occult, Crime & Conspiracy. Chapter 10, "Son of Sam and
the Process Church of the Final Judgment: Exploring the Alleged
Connections". Lulu Press. ISBN 1-4116-6083-8.
- Terry, Maury (1987). The Ultimate Evil: An Investigation
into America's Most Dangerous Satanic Cult. Doubleday. ISBN
0-385-23452-X.
External links