Drexel Burnham Lambert was a
major Wall
Street
investment
banking firm, which first rose to prominence and then was
driven into bankruptcy in February 1990 by its involvement in
illegal activities in the junk bond
market, driven by Drexel employee Michael
Milken. At its height, it was the fifth-largest
investment bank in the United States
.
Early history
I.W.
"Tubby" Burnham, a 1931 graduate of the
Wharton School of the University of
Pennsylvania
, founded the firm in 1935 as Burnham and
Company, a small New York City
-based retail brokerage. Burnham started the
firm with $100,000 of capital, $96,000 of which was borrowed from
his grandfather and the founder of a Kentucky
distillery.
It became one of the more successful brokerages in the country,
eventually building its capital to $1 million. Burnham eventually
branched out into investment banking. However, the company's
ability to expand was limited by the structure of the investment
banking industry of that time. A strict unwritten set of rules
assured the dominance of a few large firms by controlling the order
in which their names appeared in advertisements for an
underwriting.
Burnham, as a "sub-major" firm, needed to
connect with a "major" or "special" firm in order to further
expand, and in 1967 found a willing partner in Drexel
Firestone, an ailing Philadelphia
-based firm with a rich history.
Drexel and Company had been founded in 1838 by
Francis Martin Drexel. His
son,
Anthony Joseph Drexel,
became a partner in the firm at age 21, in 1847.
The company made its
money in the opportunities created by gold discoveries in California
. The company was also involved in financial
deals with the federal government during the
U.S.-Mexican War and the
U.S. Civil
War. A. J. Drexel became the head of Drexel & Company when
his father died in 1863. He partnered with
J.P. Morgan and
created one of the largest banking companies in the world,
Drexel, Morgan & Co.
In 1940, several former Drexel partners and associates formed an
investment bank and assumed the rights to the "Drexel and Company"
name. The old Drexel, which chose to concentrate on commercial
banking after the
Glass-Steagall
Act regulated the separation of commercial and investment
banking, was completely absorbed into the
Morgan empire. The new Drexel grew
slowly, coasting on historic ties to the larger securities issuers.
By the early 1960s, it found itself short on capital. It merged
with Harriman, Ripley and Company in 1965, and renamed itself
Drexel Harriman Ripley. In the mid-1970s, it sold
a 25 percent stake to
Firestone Tire and Rubber
Company, renaming itself Drexel Firestone.
However, it was a mere shell of its former self; despite having
only two major clients by the dawn of the 1970s it was still
considered a major firm, and thus got a large chunk of the
syndicates formed to sell stocks and bonds. In 1973, a severe drop
in the stock market sent the firm reeling. Drexel management soon
realized that a prominent name was not nearly enough to survive,
and was very receptive to a merger offer from Burnham.
Even though Burnham dominated the merged firm, the more powerful
investment banks (whose informal blessing the new firm needed to
survive on Wall Street) insisted that the Drexel name come first as
a condition of joining the "major" bracket. Thus,
Drexel
Burnham and Company, headquartered in New York, was born
in 1973 with $44 million in capital.
In 1976, it merged with William D.
Witter, a small "research boutique" that
was the American arm of Belgian
-based
Groupe Bruxelles
Lambert. The firm was renamed
Drexel Burnham
Lambert, and incorporated that year after 41 years as a
limited partnership. The
enlarged firm was privately held; Lambert held a 26 percent stake
and received six seats on the board of directors. Most of the
remaining 74 percent was held by employees.
Business
Drexel's legacy as an advisor to both startup companies and
fallen angels remains an industry model
today. While Milken (a holdover from the old Drexel) got most of
the credit by almost single-handedly creating a junk bond market,
another key architect in this strategy was Fred Joseph. Shortly
after buying the old Drexel, Burnham found out that Joseph, chief
operating officer of
Shearson
Hamill, wanted to get back into the nuts and bolts of
investment banking and hired him as co-head of corporate finance.
Joseph,
the son of a Boston
taxicab driver, was a good fit for the firm's
culture. He promised Burnham that in 10 years, he would make
Drexel Burnham as powerful as
Goldman
Sachs.
Joseph's prophecy proved accurate.
The firm rose from the bottom of the pack
to compete with and even top the Wall Street
bulge bracket
firms. While Milken was clearly the most powerful man in the
firm (to the point that a business consultant warned Drexel that it
was a "one-product company"), it was Joseph who was named company
president in 1984 and CEO in 1985.
Drexel, however, was more aggressive in its business practices than
most. When it entered the
mergers and acquisitions field in
the early 1980s, it didn't shy away from backing
hostile takeovers—long a taboo among the
established firms. Its specialty was the "
highly confident letter," in which
it promised it could get the necessary financing for a hostile
takeover. Although it had no legal status, Drexel's reputation for
making markets for any bonds it underwrote was such that a "highly
confident letter" was as good as cash to many of the
corporate raiders of the 1980s. Among the
deals it financed during this time were
Boone Pickens' failed runs at
Gulf Oil and
Unocal,
Carl Icahn's bid for
Phillips 66,
Ted
Turner's buyout of
MGM/UA and
Kohlberg Kravis Roberts successful
bid for
RJR Nabisco.
Organizationally, the firm was considered the definition of a
meritocracy. Divisions received bonuses
based on their individual performance rather than the performance
of the firm as a whole.This often led to acrimony between
individual departments, who sometimes acted like independent
companies rather than small parts of a larger one. Also, several
employees formed limited partnerships that allowed them to invest
alongside Milken. These partnerships often made more money than the
firm itself did on a particular deal. For instance, many of the
partnerships ended up with more
warrants than the firm itself held in
particular deals.
The firm had its most profitable
fiscal
year in 1986, netting $545.5 million—at the time, the most
profitable year ever for a Wall Street firm. In 1987, Milken was
paid
executive compensation
of $550 million for the year.
Downfall
According to Dan Stone, a former Drexel executive, the firm's
aggressive culture led many Drexel employees to stray into
unethical, and sometimes illegal, conduct.
Milken himself viewed
the securities laws, rules and regulations with some degree of
contempt, and often condoned unethical and illegal behavior by his
colleagues at Drexel's operation in Beverly Hills
. However, he personally called Joseph, who
believed in following the rules to the letter, on several occasions
with ethical questions.
The firm was first rocked on
May 12, 1986,
when
Dennis Levine, a Drexel managing
director and investment banker, was charged with
insider trading. Levine had spent virtually
his entire career on Wall Street trading on inside information,
unknown to Drexel management when he was hired in 1985. Levine
pleaded guilty to four felonies, and implicated one of his recent
partners, super-
arbitrageur Ivan Boesky. Largely based on information Boesky
promised to provide about his dealings with Milken, the
Securities and Exchange
Commission initiated an investigation of Drexel on
November 17. Two days later,
Rudy Giuliani, the
United
States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, launched
his own investigation. Ominously, Milken refused to cooperate with
Drexel's own internal investigation, only speaking through his
attorneys.
For two years, Drexel steadfastly denied any wrongdoing, claiming
that the criminal and SEC cases were based almost entirely on the
statements of an admitted
felon looking to
reduce his sentence. However, it was not enough to keep the SEC
from suing Drexel in
September 1988
for insider trading, stock manipulation, defrauding its clients and
stock parking (buying stocks for the benefit of another). All of
the transactions involved Milken and his department. The most
intriguing charge was that Boesky paid Drexel $5.3 million in 1986
for Milken's share of profits from illegal trading. Earlier in the
year, Boesky characterized the payment as a consulting fee to
Drexel. Around the same year, Giuliani began seriously considering
indicting Drexel under the powerful
Racketeer
Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act. Drexel was
potentially liable under the doctrine of
respondent superior, which holds
that companies are responsible for an employee's crimes.
The threat of a RICO indictment unnerved many at Drexel. A RICO
indictment would have required the firm to put up a performance
bond of as much as $1 billion in lieu of having its assets frozen.
This provision was put in the law because
organized crime had a habit of absconding
with the funds of indicted companies, and the writers of RICO
wanted to make sure there was something to seize or forfeit in the
event of a guilty verdict. Unfortunately, most of Drexel's capital
was borrowed money, as is common with most Wall Street firms (in
Drexel's case, 96 percent—by far the most of any firm). This debt
would have to take second place to this performance bond.
Additionally, if the bond ever had to be paid, Drexel's
stockholders would have been all but wiped out. Due to this, banks
will not extend credit to a firm under a RICO indictment.
By this time, several Drexel executives—including Joseph—concluded
that Drexel could not survive a RICO indictment and would have to
seek a settlement with Giuliani. Senior Drexel executives became
particularly nervous after
Princeton Newport Partners, a
small investment partnership, was forced to close its doors in the
summer of 1988. Princeton Newport had been indicted under RICO, and
the prospect of having to post a huge performance bond forced its
shutdown well before the trial. Joseph said years later that he'd
been told that if Drexel were indicted under RICO, it would only
survive a month at most. Nonetheless, negotiations for a possible
plea agreement collapsed on
December 19
when Giuliani made several demands that were far too draconian even
for those who advocated a settlement. Giuliani demanded that Drexel
waive its
attorney-client
privilege, and also wanted the right to arbitrarily decide that
the firm had violated the terms of any plea agreement. He also
demanded that Milken leave the firm if the government ever indicted
him. Drexel's board unanimously rejected the terms. For a time, it
looked like Drexel was going to fight.
Only two days later, however, Drexel lawyers found out about a
limited partnership, MacPherson Partners, they previously hadn't
known about. This partnership had been involved in the issuing of
bonds for
Storer Broadcasting.
Several equity warrants were sold to one client who sold them back
to Milken's department. Milken then sold the warrants to MacPherson
Partners. The limited partners included several of Milken's
children, and more ominously, managers of
money funds. This partnership raised the specter
of self-dealing, and at worst, bribes to the money managers. At the
very least, this was a serious breach of Drexel's internal
regulations. Drexel immediately reported this partnership to
Giuliani, and its revelation seriously hurt Milken's credibility
with many at Drexel who believed in Milken's innocence—including
Joseph and most of the board.
With literally minutes to go before being indicted (according to at
least one source, the grand jury was actually in the process of
voting on the indictment), Drexel reached an agreement with the
government in which it pleaded
nolo
contendere (no contest) to six felonies—three counts of
stock parking and three counts of
stock manipulation. It also agreed to pay
a fine of $650 million—at the time, the largest fine ever levied
under the
Great Depression-era
securities laws. The government had dropped several of the demands
that had initially angered Drexel, but continued to insist that
Milken leave the firm if indicted—which he did shortly after his
own indictment in
March 1989. Most
sources say that Drexel pleaded guilty, but in truth, Drexel only
admitted that it was "not in a position to dispute the
allegations." Nonetheless, Drexel was now a convicted felon.
In April 1989, Drexel settled with the SEC, agreeing to stricter
safeguards on its oversight procedures. Later that month, the firm
eliminated 5,000 jobs by shuttering three departments—including the
retail brokerage operation. In essence, Drexel was jettisoning the
core of the old Burnham & Company. The retail accounts were
eventually sold to
Smith Barney.
Due to several deals that didn't work out, as well as an unexpected
crash of the junk bond market, 1989 was a difficult year for Drexel
even after it settled the criminal and SEC cases. Reports of an $86
million loss going into the fourth quarter resulted in the firm's
commercial paper rating being cut
in late November. This made it nearly impossible for Drexel to
reborrow its outstanding commercial paper, and it had to be repaid.
Rumors abounded that the banks could yank Drexel's
lines of credit at any time. Unfortunately,
Drexel had no corporate parent that could pump in cash, unlike most
American financial institutions. Groupe Bruxelles Lambert refused
to even consider making an equity investment until Joseph improved
the bottom line. The firm posted a $40 million loss for 1989—the
first operating loss in its 54-year history.
Drexel managed to survive into 1990 by transferring some of the
excess capital from its regulated broker/dealer subsidiary into the
Drexel holding company—only to be ordered to stop by the SEC in
February out of concerns about the broker's solvency. This sent
Joseph and other senior executives into a near-panic.
After the SEC, the
New York
Stock Exchange
, and the Federal
Reserve Bank of New York
cast doubts about a restructuring plan, Joseph
concluded that Drexel could not stay independent.
Unfortunately, concerns about possible liability to civil suits
scared off prospective buyers.
By
February 12, it was obvious Drexel
was headed for collapse. Its commercial paper rating was further
reduced that day. Joseph's last resort was a bailout by the
government. Unfortunately for Drexel, one of first hostile deals
came back to haunt it at this point. Unocal's investment bank at
the time of Pickens' raid on it was the establishment firm of
Dillon, Read—and its former chairman,
Nicholas F. Brady, was now
Secretary of the Treasury. Brady
had never forgiven Drexel for its role in the Unocal deal, and
would not even consider signing off on a bailout. Accordingly, he,
the SEC, the NYSE and the Fed strongly advised Joseph to file for
bankruptcy. Later the next day, Drexel officially filed for
Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. DBL
Trading, a subsidiary, was involved in the temporary
gold loan
default with the
Central Bank of Portugal at
that time.
Even before the firm's bankruptcy, Tubby Burnham spun off the
firm's funds management arm as Burnham Financial Group, which
currently operates as a diversified investment company. Burnham was
reportedly still arranging deals until his death at age 93. The
rest of Drexel emerged from bankruptcy in 1992 as
New
Street Capital, a small investment bank with only 20
employees (at its height, Drexel employed over 10,000 people).
In 1994,
New Street merged with Green Capital, a merchant bank owned by
Atlanta
financier Holcombe Green.
Criticism
By the late 1980s, public confidence in
leveraged buyouts had waned, and criticism
of the perceived engine of the takeover movement, the
junk bond, had increased. Innovative financial
instruments often generate skepticism, and few have generated more
controversy than high yield debt. Some argue that the debt
instrument itself, sometimes dubbed "turbo debt," was the
cornerstone of the 1980s "Decade of Greed." However, junk bonds
were actually used in less than 25% of acquisitions and
hostile takeover during that
period. Nevertheless, by 1990 default rates on high yield debt had
increased from 4% to 10%, further eroding confidence in this
financial instrument. Without Milken's cheerleading, the liquidity
of the junk bond market dried up. Drexel was forced to buy the
bonds of insolvent and failing companies, which depleted their
capital and would eventually bankrupt the company.
Survivors
A few other firms emerged from Drexel's collapse, besides Burnham
Financial.
Drexel Burnham Lambert Real Estate Associates II operates as a real
estate management firm.
Apollo
Management, the noted private equity firm, was also founded by
Drexel alumni led by
Leon Black. Fred
Joseph helped establish Morgan Joseph, a middle-market investment
bank. Although the firm carries his name, he is only co-head of
corporate finance. In 1993, the SEC barred him from serving as
president, chairman or CEO of a securities firm for life for
failing to properly supervise Milken. Morgan Joseph's CEO is John
Sorte, Joseph's successor as president and CEO of Drexel from 1990
to 1992.
Portfolio.com
and CNBC
recently
named Fred Joseph the seventh-worst CEO in American business
history stating that "his poor management left the company without
a crisis plan".
Famous Drexel alumni
- Abby Joseph Cohen, partner and
chief U.S. investment strategist at Goldman, Sachs & Co
- Marc Faber, formerly managing
director of Drexel's Hong Kong office, famous for the Gloom Boom
Doom investment report "Dr Doom"
- Michael Milken, former head of
the non-investment-grade bond department; almost single-handedly
created the market for "high-yield bonds" (also known as "junk bonds")
- Richard Sandor, Father of
Interest Rate Futures and Current Chairman of the Chicago Climate
Exchange
- Roderick M. Hills, former Chairman of U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission (SEC)
- Dennis Levine Chairman & CEO,
Adasar Group, Inc.
- Joel Greenblatt, founder of
Gotham Capital
- Joseph Cassano, founder of
AIG Financial Products
- Ken Moelis, former President and Head
of Investment Banking at UBS; founder of Moelis & Company
- Jeffrey Chanin, founder of Chanin
Capital Partners
- Todd Fisher, Senior Partner at
Kohlberg Kravis Roberts
& Co
- Terren Peizer, current CEO of
Hythiam Co
- Leon Black, leader of Apollo Management
- Gary Winnick, founder and former
chairman of Global Crossing
- Steve Feinberg, Cerberus Capital Management
- Mitch Julis, Canyon Capital Partners
- James Howard Hemsley,
Partner at Hamilton Bushard
- James Stephen Fossett
, American aviator, sailor and
adventurer
- Guy Adami, panelist on CNBC's Fast Money
- Richard B. Handler, current C.E.O. of Jefferies & Company
- Brett Clancy, current C.E.O. of
Japan Assets
- Bennett Goodman, co-founder of
GSO Capital now part of Blackstone
- Tripp Smith, co-founder of GSO
Capital now part of Blackstone
- Frederick H. Joseph, co-founder of Morgan Joseph
References