An
extinct language is a
language which no longer has any speakers. Extinct
languages may be contrasted with
dead
languages: no longer spoken as a main language.
Language loss
Normally the transition from a dead to an extinct language occurs
when a language undergoes
language
death while being directly replaced by a different one. For
example,
Native
American languages were replaced by
English,
French,
Portuguese, or
Spanish as a result of colonization. The
Coptic language, replaced by
Arabic in its native Egypt, was once
thought to be extinct.
Language extinction may also occur when a language evolves into a
new language or family of languages. An example of this was
Old English, a forerunner of
Modern English.
By contrast to an extinct language which no longer has any
speakers, a dead language may remain in use for
scientific,
legal, or
ecclesiastical functions.
Old Church Slavonic,
Avestan,
Coptic,
Biblical
Hebrew,
Ge'ez and
Latin are among the many dead languages used as
sacred languages.
Alternatively, a language is said to be extinct if, although it is
known to have been spoken by people in the past, modern scholarship
cannot reconstruct it to the point that it is possible to write in
it or translate into it with confidence (say, a simple dialogue or
a short tale written in a modern language); whereas a language is
referred to as dead, but not extinct, if it is sufficiently known
at present to permit such routine use, even though it has no modern
speakers. By these definitions
Proto-Indo-European (of which
only conjectural reconstructions of lexicon and grammar exist) is
an extinct language, and
Classical
Latin and
Old Tupi are dead, but not
extinct languages.
A language that has living native speakers is called a
modern language.
Ethnologue records 6,912 living languages
known.
Hebrew is an example of a nearly
extinct spoken language (by the first definition above) that became
a
lingua franca and a
liturgical language that has been
revived to become a living spoken
language. There are other attempts at language revival.
For
example, young school children use Sanskrit
in revived language in Mathoor village
(India) In general, the success of these attempts
has been subject to debate, as it is not clear they will ever
become the common native language of a community of
speakers.
It is believed that 90% of the circa 7000 languages currently
spoken in the world will have become extinct by 2050, as the
world's language system, after evolving for centuries, has reached
a crisis and is dramatically restructuring.
Globalization, development, and language extinction
As economic and cultural
globalization
and development continue to push forward, growing numbers of
languages will become endangered and eventually, extinct. With
increasing economic integration on national and regional scales,
people find it easier to communicate and conduct business in the
dominant languages of world commerce: English, Chinese, and
Spanish. Malone, Elizabeth. "Language and Linguistics: Endangered
Language." National Science Foundation. 28 Jul 2008. National
Science Foundation, Web. 23 Oct 2009.
/www.nsf.gov/news/special_reports/linguistics/endangered.jsp>.
In their study of contact-induced language change, American
linguists Sarah Grey Thomason and
Terrence Kaufman state that in situations
of cultural pressure (where populations must speak a dominant
language), three linguistic outcomes may occur: first - and most
commonly - a subordinate population may shift abruptly to the
dominant language, leaving the native language to a sudden
linguistic death. Second, the more gradual process of
language death may occur over several
generations. The third and most rare outcome is for the pressured
group to maintain as much of its native language as possible, while
borrowing elements of the dominant language's grammar (replacing
all, or portions of, the grammar of the original language).
Institutions such as the education system, as well as (often
global) forms of media such as the Internet, television, and print
media play a significant role in the process of language loss.
Educating children in English in favor of their local, native
languages is one way in which the practical effects of Thomason and
Kaufman's theory on contact-induced language change can be
observed.
Cultural anthropologist
Wade Davis points
to the dangers of "
modernization"
(often cited as reason for economic development) and globalization
as threats to indigenous cultures and languages throughout the
world. He argues that just as the biosphere is being eroded by
these forces, so too is the "ethnosphere" - the cultural web of
life.Davis, Wade. ""On endangered cultures"." TED Talks. Monterey,
CA. Feb 2003. Lecture. 22 Oct 2009.
/www.ted.com/talks/wade_davis_on_endangered_cultures.html>
Implications of language extinction
Estimates of future language loss range from half of more than 6000
currently spoken languages being lost in the next 200
years"Linguistic Expert Warns of Language Extinction." Science
Daily 4 Mar 2007: n. pag. Web. 23 Oct 2009.
/www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/02/070218140348.htm>., to
90% by the year 2050. Wade Davis states that languages - as not
simply bodies of vocabulary or sets of grammatical rules, but "old
growth forests of the mind" - for the many and unique cultures of
the world reflect different ways of being, thinking, and
knowing.
As Davis puts it, language extinction effectively reduces the
"entire range of the human imagination... to a more narrow modality
of thought", and thus privileges the ways of knowing in dominant
(and overwhelmingly Western) languages such as English.
Foucauldian ideas of power and knowledge, as
both inseparable and symbiotic, are implicated in the
universalizing of Western knowledge as truth, and the rendering of
other forms as less valid or false: mere superstition, folklore, or
mythology. In the case of language extinction, those "voices" which
are deemed to be inferior or secondary by colonizing, globalizing,
or developing forces are literally silenced.
Davis also illustrates that languages are lost not because cultures
are
destined to fade away (as proponents of environmental
or cultural
determinism or
Social Darwinism may contend), but rather
that they are "driven out of existence by identifiable forces that
are beyond their capacity to adapt to"; he further remonstrates
that "genocide, the physical extinction of a people is universally
condemned, but ethnocide, the destruction of peoples' way of life
is not only
not condemned, it's universally - in many
quarters - celebrated as part of a development strategy."
Recently extinct languages
With last known speaker and/or date of death.
- Adai:
(late 19th century)
- Akkala Sami: Marja Sergina
(2003)
- entire Alsean family
- Alsea: John Albert
(1942)
- Yaquina: (1884)
- Apalachee: (early 18th
century)
- Arwi: (Early 19th
Century)
- Aruá: (1877)
- Atakapa: (early 20th
century)
- Atsugewi: (1988)
- Beothuk: Shanawdithit (a.k.a. "Nancy April") (1829)
- entire Catawban
family:
- Catawba: before
1960
- Woccon
- Cayuse: (ca. 1930s)
- Chemakum: (ca. 1940s)
- Chicomuceltec: (late 20th
century)
- Chimariko: (ca. 1930s)
- Chitimacha:
Benjamin Paul (1934) & Delphine Ducloux (1940)
- entire Chumashan
family: Barbareño language was last to become extinct.
- Barbareño: Mary Yee
(1965)
- Ineseño
- Island Chumash
- Obispeño
- Purisimeño
- Ventureño
- Coahuilteco: (18th
century)
- Cochimí (a Yuman-Cochimí language): (early
19th century)
- entire Comecrudan
family
- Comecrudo: recorded from
children (Andrade, Emiterio, Joaquin, & others) of last
speakers in 1886
- Garza: last
recorded in 1828
- Mamulique: last recorded in
1828
- entire Coosan family
- Hanis: Martha Johnson (1972)
- Miluk: Annie Miner Peterson
(1939)
- all Costanoan languages (which
make up a subfamily of the Utian
language family): (ca. 1940s)
- Karkin
- Mutsun
- Northern Costanoan:
- Ramaytush
- Chochenyo
- Tamyen
- Awaswas
- Rumsen: last recorded speaker
died 1939 in Monterey, California.
- Chalon
- Cotoname: last recorded from
Santos Cavázos and Emiterio in 1886
- Crimean Gothic: language
vanished by the 1800’s
- Cuman: (early 17th
century)
- Dalmatian: Tuone Udaina, (June 10, 1898)
- Esselen: report of few speakers
left in 1833, extinct before end 19th century
- Eyak (a Na-Dené language): Marie Smith Jones, January 21, 2008
- Gabrielino (an Uto-Aztecan language): elderly
speakers last recorded in 1933
- Galice-Applegate (an
Athabaskan language):
- Galice dialect: Hoxie Simmons (1963)
- Greenlandic Norse:
(by the late 15th century (16th century at the latest))
- Modern Gutnish (by the
18th century)
- Jassic (17th
century)
- Juaneño (an Uto-Aztecan language): last recorded
in 1934
- Kakadu : Big Bill Neidjie (July 2002)
- entire Kalapuyan
family:
- Central
Kalapuya:
- Ahantchuyuk, Luckimute, Mary's
River, and Lower McKenzie River dialects: last
speakers were about 6 persons who were all over 60 in 1937
- Santiam dialect: (ca. 1950s)
- Northern
Kalapuya:
- Tualatin dialect: Louis Kenoyer (1937)
- Yamhill dialect: Louisa Selky (1915)
- Yonkalla: last
recorded in 1937 from Laura Blackery Albertson who only partly
remembered it.
- Kamassian: (1989)
- Karankawa: (1858)
- Kathlamet (a Chinookan language): (ca. 1930s)
- Kitanemuk (an Uto-Aztecan language): Marcelino
Rivera, Isabella Gonzales, Refugia Duran (last recorded 1937)
- Kitsai (a Caddoan language): Kai Kai (ca. 1940)
- Kwalhioqua-Clatskanie (an
Athabaskan language): children
of the last speakers remembered a few words, recorded in 1935 &
1942
- Clatskanie dialect: father of Willie Andrew (ca.
1870)
- Kwalhioqua dialect: mother of Lizzie Johnson
(1910)
- Lower Chinook (a Chinookan language): (ca. 1930s)
- Mahican: last spoken in
Wisconsin (ca. 1930s)
- Manx: Ned Maddrell (December 1974) (but is being
revived as a second language)
- Mattole-Bear River
(an Athabaskan language):
- Bear River dialect: material from last elderly speaker
recorded (ca. 1929)
- Mattole dialect: material recorded (ca. 1930)
- Mbabaram: Albert Bennett
(1972)
- Miami-Illinois: (1989)
- Mochica: ca.
1950s
- Mohegan: Fidelia Fielding
(1908)
- Molala: Fred Yelkes (1958)
- Munichi: Victoria Huancho
Icahuate (late 1990s)
- Natchez: Watt Sam
& Nancy Raven (early 1930s)
- Negerhollands: Alice
Stevenson (1987)
- Nooksack: Sindick
Jimmy (1977)
- Northern Pomo:
(1994)
- Nottoway (an Iroquoian language): last recorded
before 1836
- Pentlatch (a Salishan language): Joe Nimnim
(1940)
- Pánobo (a Pano-Tacanan language): 1991
- Pochutec (Uto-Aztecan last documented 1917 by
Franz Boas
- Polabian (a Slavic language): (late 18th century)
- Salinan: (ca. 1960)
- entire Shastan family
- Konomihu
- New River Shasta
- Okwanuchu
- Shasta: 3 elderly
speakers in 1980, extinct by 1990
- Siuslaw: (ca.
1970s)
- Slovincian (a
Slavic language): (20th
century)
- Susquehannock: all last
speakers murdered in 1763
- Takelma: Molly Orton
(or Molly Orcutt) & Willie Simmons (both not fully fluent) last
recorded in 1934
- Tasmanian: (late
19th century)
- Tataviam (an Uto-Aztecan language): Juan José
Fustero who remembered only a few words of his grandparents'
language (recorded 1913)
- Teteté (a Tucanoan language)
- Tillamook (a
Salishan language): (1970)
- Tonkawa: 6 elderly
people in 1931
- Tsetsaut (an Athabaskan language): last fluent
speaker was elderly man recorded in 1894
- Tunica: Sesostrie Youchigant (ca. mid 20th
century)
- Ubykh: Tevfik Esenç (October 1992)
- Most dialects of Upper
Chinook (a Chinookan language) are
extinct, except for the Wasco-Wishram dialect. The Clackamas dialect became extinct in
the 1930s, other dialects have little documentation. (The Wasco-Wishram language is still
spoken by five elders.)
- Upper Umpqua: Wolverton
Orton, last recorded in 1942
- Vegliot Dalmatian:
Tuone Udaina (Italian: Antonio Udina)
(10 June 1898)
- Wappo
- Wiyot: Della Prince
(1962)
- Yana: Ishi (1916)
- Yola related to English
(mid-19th century)
Ryan Johnson Y.R.H
- Rubenstein James M.
Rubenstein|EIGHTH EDITION
See also
External links
References
- Lenore A. Grenoble, Lindsay J. Whaley, Saving Languages: An
Introduction to Language Revitalization, Cambridge University
Press (2006) p.18
- Dead language
- Ethnologue
- Times of India.
- Study by language researcher, David Graddol
- Research by Southwest University for Nationalities
College of Liberal Arts
- Thomason, Sarah Grey & Kaufman, Terrence. Language
contact, creolization, and genetic linguistics, University of
California Press (1991) p. 100.
- Timmons Roberts, J. & Hite, Amy. From Modernization to
Globalization: Perspectives on Development and Social Change,
Wiley-Blackwell (2000)
- Davis, Wade. The Wayfinders: Why Ancient Wisdom Matters in
the Modern World, House of Anansi Press (2009).
- Sharp, Joanne. Geographies of Postcolonialism, chapter
6: Can the Subaltern Speak?. SAGE Publications, 2008.
- Science: Last of the Kitsai. Time. 27
June 1932 (retrieved 6 Sept 2009)
- Culture: Language. The Confederated Tribes
of Warm Springs Reservation of Oregon. 2009 (retrieved 9 April
2009)
Bibliography
- Adelaar, Willem F. H.; & Muysken, Pieter C. (2004). The
languages of the Andes. Cambridge language surveys. Cambridge
University Press. ISBN 9780521362757.
- Brenzinger, Matthias (ed.) (1992) Language Death: Factual
and Theoretical Explorations with Special Reference to East
Africa. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter. ISBN
978-3-11-013404-9.
- Campbell, Lyle; & Mithun, Marianne (Eds.). (1979). The
languages of native America: Historical and comparative
assessment. Austin: University of Texas Press. ISBN
0292746245.
- Davis, Wade. (2009). The Wayfinders: Why Ancient Wisdom
Matters in the Modern World. House of Anansi Press. ISBN:
0887847668.
- Dorian, Nancy C. (1978). Fate of
morphological complexity in language death: Evidence from East
Sutherland Gaelic. Language, 54 (3),
590-609.
- Dorian, Nancy C. (1981). Language death: The life cycle of
a Scottish Gaelic dialect. Philadelphia: University of
Pennsylvania Press. ISBN 0812277856.
- Dressler, Wolfgand & Wodak-Leodolter, Ruth (eds.) (1977)
Language death (International Journal of the Sociology of
Language vol. 12). The Hague: Mouton.
- Gordon, Raymond G., Jr. (Ed.). (2005). Ethnologue:
Languages of the world (15th ed.). Dallas, TX: SIL
International. ISBN 1-55671-159-X. (Online version:
http://www.ethnologue.com).
- Harrison, K. David. (2007) When Languages Die: The Extinction
of the World's Languages and the Erosion of Human Knowledge. New
York and London: Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780195181920.
- Mithun, Marianne. (1999). The languages of Native North
America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN
0-521-23228-7 (hbk); ISBN 0-521-29875-X.
- Mohan, Peggy; & Zador, Paul. (1986). Discontinuity in a
life cycle: The death of Trinidad Bhojpuri. Language,
62 (2), 291-319.
- Sasse, Hans-Jürgen (1992) 'Theory of language death', in
Brenzinger (ed.) Language Death, pp. 7–30.
- Schilling-Estes, Natalie; & Wolfram, Walt. (1999).
Alternative models of dialect death: Dissipation vs. concentration.
Language, 75 (3), 486-521.
- Sebeok, Thomas A. (Ed.). (1973). Linguistics in North
America (parts 1 & 2). Current trends in linguistics (Vol.
10). The Hauge: Mouton. (Reprinted as Sebeok 1976).
- Sharp, Joanne. (2008). Chapter 6: Can the Subaltern
Speak?, in Geographies of Postcolonialism. Glasgow,
UK: SAGE Publications Ltd. ISBN: 9781412907798.
- Skutnabb-Kangas, Tove. (2000). Linguistic genocide in
education or worldwide diversity and human rights? Mahwah, New
Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. ISBN 0-8058-3468-0.
- Thomason, Sarah Grey & Kaufman, Terrence. (1991).
Language contact, creolization, and genetic linguistics.
University of California Press. ISBN 0520078934.
- Timmons Roberts, J. & Hite, Amy. (2000). From
Modernization to Globalization: Perspectives on Development and
Social Change. Wiley-Blackwell. ISBN: 9780631210979.