- French Blue redirects here. For the colour, see
Blue.
The
Hope Diamond is a large, , deep-blue diamond, housed in the Smithsonian
Natural History Museum
in Washington, D.C.
The Hope Diamond is blue to the naked eye
because of trace amounts of
boron within its
crystal structure, but it exhibits red
phosphorescence under
ultraviolet light. It is classified as a
Type IIb diamond, and is famous for
supposedly being
cursed. It is currently unset
for the first time since it has been on display.
Physical properties
An examination in December 1988 by the
Gemological Institute of
America's Gem Trade Lab (GIA-GTL) showed the diamond to weigh
45.52 carats (9.104 g) and described it as "fancy dark
grayish-blue." A re-examination in 1996 slightly rephrased that
description as "fancy deep grayish-blue." The stone exhibits an
unusually intense and strongly-colored type of luminescence: after
exposure to long-wave ultraviolet light, the diamond produces a
brilliant red phosphorescence ('glow-in-the-dark' effect) that
persists for some time after the light source has been switched
off. The clarity was determined to be VS1, with whitish graining
present. The cut was described as being "cushion antique brilliant
with a faceted girdle and extra facets on the pavilion." The
dimensions in terms of length, width, and depth are 25.60mm ×
21.78mm × 12.00mm (1in × 7/8in × 15/32in).
Color
In popular literature, many superlatives have been used to describe
the Hope Diamond as a "superfine deep blue", often comparing it to
the color of a fine sapphire "blue of the most beautiful blue
sapphire" (Deulafait). Other references include Mawe (1823), Ball
(1835), Bruton (1978), Tolansky (1962). However, these descriptions
are somewhat exaggerated.
As colored diamond expert Stephen Hofer points out, blue diamonds
similar to the Hope can be shown by
colorimetric measurements to be grayer (lower in
saturation) than blue
sapphires. In 1996 The Gemological Institute of America's Gem Trade
Lab (GIA-GTL) examined the diamond and using their proprietary
scale, graded it
fancy deep grayish blue. Visually, the
gray modifier (mask) is so dark (indigo) that it produces an "inky"
effect appearing almost blackish-blue in
incandescent light. Current photographs
of the Hope Diamond utilize high-intensity light sources that tend
to maximize the brilliance of gemstones.
History
Legend
According to specious later accounts, the original form of the Hope
Diamond was stolen from an eye of a sculpted idol of the
Hindu goddess
Sita, the wife
of
Rama, the Sixth
Avatar
of
Vishnu. However, much like the "curse of
Tutankhamun", this general type of
"legend" was the invention of Western authors during the Victorian
era, and the specific legends about the Hope Diamond's "cursed
origin" were invented in the early 20th century to add mystique to
the stone and increase its sales appeal; see
The "Curse" section below.
The Tavernier Blue
Tavernier's original sketch of "The Tavernier Blue".
The first
known precursor to the Hope Diamond was the Tavernier Blue diamond, a crudely cut
triangular shaped stone of 115 carats (22.44 g) named for the French
merchant-traveler Jean-Baptiste
Tavernier who brought it to Europe. His book, the
Six Voyages (Le Six Voyages de...), contains sketches of
several large diamonds he sold to Louis XIV in 1669; while the blue
diamond is shown among these, Tavernier makes no direct statements
about when and where he obtained the stone.
The historian Richard
Kurin builds a plausible case for 1653 as the year of acquisition,
and an origin from the Kollur mine in
Guntur
district Andhra Pradesh
(then a part of the Golconda kingdom), India
. But
the most that can be said with certainty is that Tavernier obtained
the blue diamond during one of his five voyages to India between
the years 1640 and 1667.
Early in
the year 1669, Tavernier sold this blue diamond along with
approximately one thousand other diamonds to King Louis XIV of France
for 220,000
livres, the equivalent of 147 kilograms of pure gold. In a
newly published historical novel, The French Blue,
gemologist/historian Richard W. Wise proposes a new theory. He
contends that the patent of nobility granted Tavernier by Louis XIV
was a part of the payment for the Tavernier Blue. During that
period Colbert, The king's Finance Minister regularly sold offices
and noble titles for cash. An outright patent of nobility,
according to Wise was worth approximately 500,000 livres making a
total of 720,000 livres, a price much closer to the true value of
the gem. There has been some controversy regarding the actual
weight of the stone; Morel believes that the 112 3/16 carats stated
in Tavernier's invoice would be in old French carats, thus 115.28
metric carats.
The French Blue

The cubic zirconia replica of the
Tavernier Blue diamond created by Scott Sucher
In 1678, Louis XIV commissioned the
court
jeweller, Sieur Pitau, to recut the
Tavernier Blue, resulting in a 67 1/8 carat (13.4 g) stone which
royal inventories thereafter listed as the
Blue Diamond of
the Crown (
diamant bleu de la Couronne de France
,), but later English-speaking historians have simply called it the
French Blue. The king had the stone set on a
cravat-pin.
In 1749,
King Louis XV had the
French Blue set into a more elaborate jewelled pendant for the
Order of the Golden
Fleece, but this fell into disuse after his death.
Marie Antoinette is commonly cited as a
victim of the diamond's "curse", but she never wore the Golden
Fleece pendant, which was reserved for the use of the king. During
the reign of her husband,
King Louis
XVI, she used many of the
French
Crown Jewels for her own personal adornment by having the
individual gems placed into new settings and combinations, but the
French Blue remained in this pendant except for a brief exception
in 1787, when the stone was removed for scientific study by
Mathurin Jacques Brisson
and returned to its setting soon after.
In September 1792, while Louis XVI and his family were confined in
the
Palais des Tuileries during
the early stages of the
French
Revolution, a group of thieves broke into the Garde-Meuble
(Royal Storehouse) and stole most of the Crown Jewels. While many
jewels were later recovered, including other pieces of the Order of
the Golden Fleece, the French Blue was not among them and it
disappeared from history.
Disappearance
The Hope Diamond was long believed to have been cut from the French
Blue, but this remained unconfirmed until a three-dimensional lead
model of the latter was recently rediscovered in the archives of
the French Natural History Museum in Paris. Previously, the
dimensions of the French Blue had been known only from two drawings
made in 1749 and 1789; although the model slightly differed from
the drawings in some details, these details were identical to
features of the Hope Diamond, allowing
CAD
technology to digitally reconstruct the French Blue around the
recut stone.
Historians
Germain Bapst and Bernard Morel suggested that one robber, Cadet
Guillot, took the French Blue, the Côte-de-Bretagne spinel, and
several other jewels to Le
Havre
and then to London
, where the
French Blue was cut into two pieces. Morel adds that in
1796, Guillot attempted to resell the Côte-de-Bretagne in France
but was forced to relinquish it to a fellow thief,
Lancry de la Loyelle, who put Guillot
into
debtors' prison.
Conversely, the historian Richard Kurin speculates that the "theft"
of the French Crown Jewels was in fact engineered by the
revolutionary leader
George Danton as
part of a plan to bribe the opposing military commander,
Duke Karl Wilhelm
of Brunswick. When under attack by
Napoleon in 1805, Karl Wilhelm may have had the
French Blue recut to disguise its identity; in this form, the stone
could have come to England in 1806, when his family fled there to
join his daughter
Caroline of
Brunswick. Although Caroline was the wife of the
Prince Regent George (later
George IV of the United
Kingdom), she lived apart from her husband, and financial
straits sometimes forced her to quietly sell her own jewels to
support her household.
Caroline's nephew,
Duke
Karl Friedrich, was later known to possess a blue diamond which
was widely thought to be another piece of the French Blue. However,
this smaller diamond's present whereabouts are unknown, and the
recent CAD reconstruction of the French Blue fits too tightly
around the Hope Diamond to allow for the existence of such a sister
stone.
George IV
A blue diamond with the same shape, size, and color as the Hope
Diamond was recorded in the possession of the London diamond
merchant
Daniel Eliason in September
1812, the earliest point when the history of the Hope Diamond can
be definitively fixed. It is often pointed out that this date was
almost exactly 20 years after the theft of the French Blue, just as
the
statute of limitations
for the crime had expired.
Eliason's
diamond may have been acquired by King George IV of the
United
Kingdom
; there is no record of the ownership in the
Royal
Archives
at Windsor,
but some secondary evidence exists in the form of contemporary
writings and artwork, and George IV tended to commingle the state
property of the Crown Jewels with family heirlooms and his own
personal property. After his death in 1830, it has been
alleged that some of this mixed collection was stolen by his
mistress,
Lady Conyngham,
and some of his remaining personal items were discreetly liquidated
to cover the many debts he had left behind him. In either case, the
blue diamond was not retained by the British royal family.
The Hope family
In 1839, the Hope Diamond appeared in a published catalog of the
gem collection of Henry Philip Hope, of the prominent Anglo-Dutch
banking family. The stone was set in a fairly simple
medallion surrounded by many smaller white
diamonds, which he sometimes lent to Louisa Beresford, the widow of
his brother Thomas Hope, for society
balls. Henry Philip Hope died in 1839, the same
year as the publication of his collection catalog. His three
nephews, the sons of his brother Thomas, fought in court for ten
years over his inheritance, and ultimately the collection was split
up.
The oldest nephew, Henry Thomas Hope, received eight of the most
valuable gems including the Hope Diamond. It was put on display in
the
Great Exhibition of London in
1851 and
Paris Exhibition
Universelle in 1855, but was usually kept in a bank vault. In
1861, his only child, Henrietta, married
Henry
Pelham-Clinton,
Earl of Lincoln.
When Hope died on December 4, 1862, his wife Anne Adele inherited
the gem, but feared that the profligate lifestyle of her son-in-law
(now the 6th Duke of Newcastle) might cause him to sell the Hope
properties.
Upon Adele's death in 1884, the entire Hope estate, including the
Hope diamond, was entailed to Henrietta's younger son, Henry
Francis, on the condition that he change his surname when he
reached legal majority. As
Lord Henry
Francis Hope Pelham-Clinton Hope, this grandson received his
legacy in 1887. However, Francis had only a
life interest to his inheritance, meaning he
could not sell any part of it without court permission.
On November 27, 1894, Lord Francis married his mistress, American
actress May Yohe. She later claimed she had worn the diamond at
social gatherings (and had an exact replica made for her
performances), but he claimed otherwise. Lord Francis lived beyond
his means, and it eventually caught up with him. In 1896, his
bankruptcy was discharged, but, as he
could not sell the Hope Diamond until he had the court's
permission, his wife supported them.
In 1901, he was free
to sell the Hope Diamond, but May ran off with Putnam Strong, son of former New York City
mayor William
L. Strong. Francis
divorced her in 1902.
Lord Francis sold the diamond for £29,000 to Adolph Weil, a London
jewel merchant. Weil later sold the stone to U.S. diamond dealer
Simon Frankel, who took it to New York. There, it was evaluated to
be worth $141,032 (equal to £28,206 at the time). In 1908, Frankel
sold the diamond for $400,000 to a Salomon or Selim Habib,
reportedly in behalf of Sultan
Abdul
Hamid of Turkey; however, on June 24, 1909, the stone was
included in an auction of Habib's assets to settle his own debts,
and the auction catalog explicitly stated that the Hope Diamond was
one of only two gems in the collection which had never been owned
by the Sultan. The Parisian jewel merchant Simon Rosenau bought the
Hope Diamond for 400,000 francs and resold it in 1910 to
Pierre Cartier for 550,000
francs.
Cartier, McLean, and Winston
Pierre Cartier first offered the Hope Diamond to U.S.
socialite Evalyn
Walsh McLean in 1910. She initially rejected the stone in the
Hope family's old setting, but she found the stone much more
appealing when Cartier reset it in a more modern style and told
elaborate stories about its supposed "cursed" origins. The new
setting was the current platinum framework surrounded by a row of
sixteen alternating Old Mine Cut and pear-shaped Old Mine Cut
diamonds, . Eventually, McLean bought the new necklace and
afterwards wore it at every social occasion she organized. When she
died in 1947, she willed the diamond to her grandchildren, though
her property would be in the hands of
trustees until the eldest had reached 25 years of
age, which would have meant at least 20 years in the future.
However,
the trustees gained permission to sell her jewels to settle her
debts, and in 1949 sold them to New York
diamond merchant Harry
Winston.
Over the
next decade, Winston exhibited McLean's necklace in his "Court of
Jewels," a tour of jewels around the United States, as well as
various charity balls and the August
1958 Canadian
National Exhibition
. At some point, he also had the Hope
Diamond's bottom
facet slightly recut to
increase its brilliance.
On November 10, 1958, he donated it to the
Smithsonian
Institution
, where it became Specimen #217868, sending it
through U.S.
Mail in a plain brown
paper bag. Winston never believed in any of the tales about the
curse and died of a heart attack at the age of 82 on December 28,
1978.
The Smithsonian Institution

Spectators gazing at the Hope Diamond,
seen from the rear in its case at the National Gem Collection of
the Smithsonian Institution.
For its
first four decades in the National
Museum of Natural History
, the Hope Diamond lay in its necklace inside a
glass-fronted safe as part of the gems and jewelry gallery, except
for a few brief excursions: a 1962 exhibition in the Louvre
; the 1965
Rand Easter Show in Johannesburg,
South Africa; and two visits back to Harry Winston's premises in
New York City for a 50th anniversary celebration in 1988 and some
minor cleaning and restoration in 1996.
When the Smithsonian's gallery was renovated in 1997, the necklace
was moved onto a rotating pedestal inside a cylinder made of thick
bulletproof glass in its own display room, adjacent to the main
exhibit of the National Gem Collection in the Janet Annenberg
Hooker Hall of Geology, Gems, and Minerals. The Hope Diamond is the
most popular jewel on display.
On February 9, 2005, the Smithsonian Institution published the
findings of its year-long computer-aided geometry research on the
gem and officially acknowledged the Hope Diamond is part of the
stolen French Blue crown jewel.
On August
19 2009, the Smithsonian Institution
announced that the Hope Diamond is to get a
temporary new setting to celebrate a half-century at the National
Museum of Natural History
. Starting in September, the 45.52 carat
diamond will be exhibited as a stand-alone gem with no
setting.
The Hope has been removed from its setting for cleaning from time
to time, but this is the first time it will be on public view by
itself.
Previously it has been shown in a platinum setting, surrounded by
16 white pear-shaped and cushion-cut diamonds, suspended from a
chain containing forty-five diamonds. The Hope will return to this
original setting in late 2010.
The Musée nationale d'Histoire naturelle (MNHN) in Paris
On
November 2008, the Muséum
national d'Histoire naturelle
published a bilingual French/English press release
about the discovery of a unique and previously unknown lead cast of
the French Blue diamond in the MNHN gemmological collections in
Paris, and the resulting investigation by an international group of
researchers. Compared to the previously available drawings,
the model showed numerous unsuspected facets and corrected the
actual thickness of the stone, leading to CAD analysis and the
creation of the first numeric reconstruction of the French Blue
including a virtual snapshot video.
The emblem of the Golden Fleece of Louis XV was numerically
reconstructed around the French Blue, including the "Côte de
Bretagne" spinel of , the "Bazu" diamond of , 3 oriental topazes
(yellow sapphires), five 4- brillants and nearly 300 smaller
diamonds. Special care was taken to reconstruct the major gemstones
from CAD analysis and knowledge of historical gemsetting
techniques.
As part of the investigation, the "Tavernier Blue" diamond was also
reconstructed from the original French edition of Tavernier's
Voyages (rather than the later London edition that somewhat
distorted and modified Tavernier's original figures), and the
Smithsonian Institution provided
ray-tracing and
optical spectroscopic data about the
Hope diamond.
The lead cast of the French Blue had been given to the museum in
1850 by Charles Archard, a prominent jeweler in Paris at that time.
The model was accompanied by a label stating that the stone was in
the possession of "Mr. Hoppe of London".
The MNHN in Paris commissioned the first exact
cubic zirconia replicas of Tavernier and
French Blue diamonds from lapidary Scott Sucher. These replicas
have been completed and are currently on view together with the
French Crown jewels and the
Great Sapphire of Louis XIV, a
fantastic Moghol-cut sapphire of .
The "Curse"
The Hope Diamond in the National Gem Collection with its
setting.
The Hope Diamond in its present state at the National Gem
Collection without its setting.
An early account of the Hope Diamond's "cursed origins" was a
fanciful and anonymously written newspaper article in
The Times on June 25, 1909. However, an
article entitled "Hope Diamond Has Brought Trouble To All Who Have
Owned It" had appeared in the
Washington Post on January
19, 1908.
A few months later, this was compounded by
The New York Times on November 17,
1909, which wrongly reported that the diamond's former owner, Selim
Habib, had drowned in a shipwreck near Singapore; in fact, it was a
different person with the same name, not the owner of the diamond.
The jeweler
Pierre Cartier
further embroidered the lurid tales to intrigue Evalyn Walsh McLean
into buying the Hope Diamond in 1911.
One likely source of inspiration was
Wilkie Collins' 1868 novel
The Moonstone, which created a coherent
narrative from vague and largely disregarded legends which had been
attached to other diamonds such as the
Koh-i-Nur and the
Orloff
diamond.
According to these stories, Tavernier stole the diamond from a
Hindu temple where it had been set as one of
two matching eyes of an idol, and the temple priests then laid a
curse on whomever might possess the missing stone. Largely because
the other blue diamond "eye" never surfaced, historians dismissed
the fantastical story. Furthermore, the legend claimed that
Tavernier died of fever soon after and that his body was torn apart
by wolves, but the historical record shows that he actually lived
to the age of 84.
The Hope Diamond was also blamed for the unhappy fates of other
historical figures vaguely linked to its ownership, such as the
falls of Madame
Athenais de
Montespan and French finance minister
Nicolas Fouquet during the reign of
Louis XIV of France; the beheadings of
Louis XVI and
Marie Antoinette and the rape and
mutilation of the
Princesse de Lamballe
during the
French Revolution; and
the forced abdication of Turkish Sultan
Abdul Hamid who had supposedly killed various
members of his court for the stone (despite the annotation in
Habib's auction catalog).
Even the jewelers who may have handled the Hope Diamond were not
spared from its reputed malice: The insanity and suicide of Jacques
Colot, who supposedly bought it from Eliason, and the financial
ruin of the jeweler Simon Frankel, who bought it from the Hope
family, were linked to the stone. But although he is documented as
a French diamond dealer of the correct era, Colot has no recorded
connection with the stone, and Frankel's misfortunes were in the
midst of economic straits that also ruined many of his peers.
The legend further includes the deaths of numerous other characters
who had been previously unknown: Diamond cutter Wilhelm Fals,
killed by his son Hendrik, who stole it and later committed
suicide; Francois Beaulieu, who received the stone from Hendrik but
starved to death after selling it to Daniel Eliason; a Russian
prince named Kanitowski, who lent it to French actress Lorens Ladue
and promptly shot her dead on the stage, and was himself stabbed to
death by revolutionaries; Simon Montharides, hurled over a
precipice with his family. However, the existence of only a few of
these characters has been verified historically, leading
researchers to conclude that most of these persons are
fictitious.
The actress May Yohe made many attempts to capitalize on her
identity as the former wife of the last Hope to own the diamond,
and sometimes blamed the Hope for her misfortunes. In July 1902,
months after Lord Francis divorced her, she told police in
Australia that her lover, Putnam Strong, had
abandoned her and taken her jewels. Incredibly, the couple
reconciled, married later that year, but divorced in 1910. On her
third marriage by 1920, she persuaded film producer George Kleine
to back a 15-episode serial
The Hope Diamond Mystery,
which added fictitious characters to the tale. It was not
successful. In 1921, she hired Henry Leyford Gates to help her
write
The Mystery of the Hope Diamond, in which she
starred as Lady Francis Hope. The film added more characters,
including a fictionalized Tavernier, and added
Marat among the diamond's "victims". She
also wore her copy of the Hope, trying to generate more publicity
to further her career.
Lord Francis Hope married Olive Muriel Thompson in 1904. They had
three children before she died suddenly in 1912, a tragedy that has
been attributed to The Curse.
Evalyn Walsh McLean added her own narrative to the story behind the
blue jewel, including that one of the owners was
Catherine the Great. McLean would bring
the Diamond out for friends to try on, including
Warren G. Harding and
Florence Harding. McLean often strapped the
Hope to her pet dog's collar while in residence at Friendship, in
northwest Washington
D.C.. There are also stories that she would frequently misplace
it at parties, and then make a children's game out of finding the
Hope.
However, since the diamond was put in the care of the Smithsonian
Institution, there have been no unusual incidents related to
it.
A new mounting
The stone is to be temporarily reset in a newly designed necklace,
created by the Harry Winston firm. Three designs for the new
setting, all white diamonds and white metal, were created and the
public was allowed to vote on them via the internet. The winning
necklace will debut sometime in 2010. The Hope has been displayed
as a loose gem since late summer of 2009 (see above image).
See also
References
Further reading
- François Farges, Scott Sucher, Herbert Horovitz and Jean-Marc
Fourcault (September 2008), Revue de Gemmologie, vol. 165,
pp. 17–24 (in French) (English version to be published in 2009
in Gems & Gemology)
- Marian Fowler, Hope: Adventures of a Diamond,
Ballantine (March, 2002), hardcover, ISBN 0-345-44486-8.
- Stephen C. Hofer, Collecting and Classifying Coloured
Diamonds, Ashland Press 1998, ISBN 0-9659410-1-9
- Janet Hubbard-Brown, The Curse of the Hope Diamond (History
Mystery), Harpercollins Children's Books (October, 1991),
trade paperback, ISBN 0-380-76222-6.
- Richard Kurin, Hope Diamond: The Legendary History of a
Cursed Gem, New York: HarperCollins Publishers &
Smithsonian Press, 2006. hardcover, ISBN 0060873515.
- Susanne Steinem Patch, Blue Mystery : The Story of the Hope
Diamond, Random House (April, 1999), trade paperback, ISBN
0-8109-2797-7; hardcover ISBN 0-517-63610-7.
- Edwin Streeter, The Great Diamonds of the World,
George Bell & Sons, (Jan, 1898), hardcover, no ISBN known.
- Richard W. Wise, Secrets Of The Gem Trade, The
Connoisseur's Guide To Precious Gemstones, Brunswick House
Press (2003) ISBN 0-9728223-8-0
- Richard W. Wise, The French Blue, Brunswick House
Press, (2010) ISBN978-0-9728223-6-7