Huntington's disease,
chorea, or
disorder (
HD), is an incurable
neurodegenerative genetic disorder that affects muscle
coordination and some
cognitive functions,
typically becoming noticeable in middle age. It is the most common
genetic cause of abnormal involuntary writhing movements called
chorea. It is much more common in
people of Western Europe descent than in those from Asia or Africa.
The disease is caused by a
dominant mutation on either of the two copies of a specific
gene, located on chromosome 4. Any child of an
affected parent has a 50% risk of inheriting the disease. In rare
situations where both parents have an affected gene, or either
parent has two affected copies, this risk is greatly increased.
Physical symptoms of Huntington's disease can begin at any age from
infancy to old age, but usually begin between 35 and 44 years of
age. On rare occasions, when symptoms begin before about 20 years
of age, they progress faster and vary slightly, and the disease is
classified as
juvenile,
akinetic-rigid or
Westphal
variant HD.
The
Huntingtin gene normally provides the
genetic code for a protein that is also
called "huntingtin". The mutation of the Huntingtin gene codes for
a different form of the protein, whose presence results in gradual
damage to specific areas of the brain. The exact way this happens
is not fully understood.
Genetic
testing, which has been possible since the discovery of the
mutation, can be performed before the onset of symptoms in the
relatives of an affected individual, as an antenatal test, and also
on test-tube embryos, raising ethical debates.
Genetic counseling has developed to
inform and aid individuals considering genetic testing and has
become a model for other
genetically dominant diseases.
The exact way HD affects an individual varies and can differ even
between members of the same family, but the symptoms progress
predictably for most individuals. The earliest symptoms are a
general lack of coordination and an unsteady gait. As the disease
advances, uncoordinated, jerky body movements become more apparent,
along with a decline in mental abilities and behavioral and
psychiatric problems. Physical abilities
are gradually impeded until coordinated movement becomes very
difficult, and mental abilities generally decline into
dementia. Although the disorder itself is not
fatal, complications such as
pneumonia,
heart disease, and physical injury
from falls reduce life expectancy to around twenty years after
symptoms begin. There is no cure for HD, and full-time care is
often required in the later stages of the disease, but there are
emerging treatments to relieve some of its symptoms.
Self-help support organizations, first
founded in the 1960s and increasing in number, have been working to
increase public awareness, to provide support for individuals and
their families, and to promote research. These organizations were
instrumental in finding the gene in 1993. Since that time there
have been important discoveries every few years and understanding
of the disease is improving. Current research directions include
determining the exact mechanism of the disease, improving
animal models to expedite research, clinical
trials of pharmaceuticals to treat symptoms or slow the progression
of the disease, and studying procedures such as
stem cell therapy with the goal of
repairing damage caused by the disease.
Signs and symptoms
Symptoms of Huntington's disease commonly become noticeable between
the ages of 35 and 44 years, but they can begin at any age
from infancy, often when affected individuals have already had
children. In the early stages, there are subtle changes in
personality,
cognition, or physical
skills. The physical symptoms are usually the first to be noticed,
as cognitive and
psychiatric symptoms are
generally not severe enough to be recognized on their own at the
earlier stages. Almost everyone with Huntington's disease
eventually exhibits similar physical symptoms, but the onset,
progression and extent of cognitive and psychiatric symptoms vary
significantly between individuals.
The most characteristic initial physical symptoms are jerky,
random, and uncontrollable movements called
chorea. Chorea may be initially exhibited
as general restlessness, small unintentionally initiated or
uncompleted motions, lack of coordination, or slowed
saccadic eye movements. These minor motor
abnormalities usually precede more obvious signs of motor
dysfunction by at least three years. The clear appearance of
symptoms such as rigidity, writhing motions or
abnormal posturing appear as the disorder
progresses. These are signs that the system in the brain that is
responsible for movement is affected.
Psychomotor functions become increasingly
impaired, such that any action that requires muscle control is
affected. Common consequences are physical instability, abnormal
facial expression, and difficulties chewing,
swallowing and
speaking.
Eating difficulties commonly cause weight loss and may lead to
malnutrition.
Sleep disturbances are
also associated symptoms. Juvenile HD differs from these symptoms
in that it generally progresses faster and chorea is exhibited
briefly, if at all, with rigidity being the dominant symptom.
Seizures are also a common symptom of this
form of HD.
Reported prevalences of behavioral and psychiatric
symptoms in Huntington's disease
| Irritability |
38–73% |
| Apathy |
34–76% |
| Anxiety |
34–61% |
| Depressed mood |
33–69% |
| Obsessive and compulsive |
10–52% |
| Psychotic |
3–11% |
Cognitive abilities are impaired progressively. Especially affected
are
executive functions which
include planning, cognitive flexibility,
abstract thinking, rule acquisition,
initiating appropriate actions and inhibiting inappropriate
actions. As the disease progresses,
memory
deficits tend to appear. Reported impairments range from
short-term memory deficits to
long-term memory difficulties, including
deficits in
episodic (memory of
one's life),
procedural (memory of
the body of how to perform an activity) and
working memory. Cognitive problems tend to
worsen over time, ultimately leading to
dementia. This pattern of deficits has been called
a "
subcortical
dementia" syndrome to separate it from the typical effects of
"
cortical dementia" such
as
Alzheimer's disease.
Reported
neuropsychiatric
manifestations are
anxiety,
depression, a reduced display of
emotions (
blunted affect),
egocentrism,
aggression, and
compulsive behavior, the latter of which
can cause or worsen
addictions, including
alcoholism,
gambling, and
hypersexuality. Difficulties in recognizing
other people's negative expressions have also been observed.
Prevalence of these symptoms is also
highly variable between studies, with estimated rates for lifetime
prevalence of
psychiatric disorders
between 33% and 76%. For many sufferers and their families these
symptoms are among the most distressing aspects of the disease,
often affecting daily functioning and constituting reason for
institutionalisation. Suicidal
thoughts and suicide attempts are more common than in the general
population.
Mutant huntingtin is expressed throughout the body and associated
with abnormalities in peripheral tissues that directly caused by
such expression outside the brain. These abnormalities include
muscle atrophy,
cardiac failure,
impaired glucose tolerance,
weight loss,
osteoporosis and
testicular atrophy.
Genetics
All humans have the
Huntingtin gene
(
HTT), which provides the genetic code to produce the
protein huntingtin (HTT). Part of this gene is a
repeated section called a
trinucleotide repeat, which
varies in length between individuals and may change length between
generations. When the length of this repeated section reaches a
certain threshold, it produces an altered form of the protein,
called mutant huntingtin protein (mHTT). The differing functions of
these proteins are the cause of pathological changes which in turn
cause the disease symptoms. The Huntington's disease mutation is
genetically dominant, because either of a person's HTT genes being
mutated causes the disease. It is not inherited according to
gender, but the length of the repeated section of the gene, and
hence its severity, can be influenced by the gender of the affected
parent.
Genetic mutation
HD is one of several
trinucleotide repeat disorders
which are caused by the length of a repeated section of a gene
exceeding a normal range. The
HTT gene is located on the
short arm of
chromosome 4 at 4p16.3.
HTT
contains a sequence of three
DNA
bases—cytosine-adenine-guanine (
CAG)—repeated multiple times (i.e. ...CAGCAGCAG...),
known as a trinucleotide repeat. CAG is the
genetic code for the
amino acid glutamine, so
a series of them results in the production of a chain of glutamine
known as a
polyglutamine tract
(or polyQ tract), and the repeated part of the gene, the
PolyQ
region.
Classification of the trinucleotide repeat, and resulting
disease status, depends on the number of CAG repeats
| Repeat count |
Classification |
Disease status |
| <28></28> |
Normal |
Unaffected |
| 28–35 |
Intermediate |
Unaffected |
| 36–40 |
Reduced Penetrance |
+/- Affected |
| >40 |
Full Penetrance |
Affected |
Generally, people have fewer than 36 repeated glutamines in the
polyQ region which results in production of the
cytoplasmic protein Huntingtin. However, a
sequence of 36 or more glutamines results in the production of a
protein which has different characteristics. This altered form,
called mHTT (mutant HTT), increases the decay rate of certain types
of
neuron. Regions of the brain
have differing amounts and reliance on these type of neurons, and
are affected accordingly. Generally, the number of CAG repeats is
related to how much this process is affected, and accounts for
about 60% of the variation of the age of the onset of symptoms. The
remaining variation is attributed to environment and other genes
that modify the mechanism of HD. 36–40 repeats result in a
reduced-
penetrance form of the disease,
with a much later onset and slower progression of symptoms. In some
cases the onset may be so late that symptoms are never noticed.
With very large repeat counts, HD has full penetrance and can occur
under the age of 20, when it is then referred to as juvenile HD,
akinetic-rigid, or Westphal variant HD. This accounts for about 7%
of HD carriers.
Inheritance
Huntington's disease has
autosomal
dominant inheritance, meaning that an affected individual
typically inherits a copy of the gene with an expanded
trinucleotide repeat (the mutant
allele) from
an affected parent. In this type of inheritance pattern, each
offspring of an affected individual has a 50% risk of inheriting
the mutant allele and therefore being affected with the disorder
(see figure). This probability is sex-independent.
Trinucleotide CAG repeats over 28 are unstable during
replication and this instability increases
with the number of repeats present. This usually leads to new
expansions as generations pass (
dynamic
mutations) instead of reproducing an exact copy of the
trinucleotide repeat. This causes the number of repeats to change
in successive generations, such that an unaffected parent with an
"intermediate" number of repeats (28–35), or "reduced penetrance"
(36–40), may pass on a copy of the gene with an increase in the
number of repeats that produces fully penetrant HD. Such increases
in the number of repeats (and hence earlier
age of onset and severity of disease) in
successive generations is known as genetic
anticipation. Instability is greater
in
spermatogenesis than
oogenesis, so maternally inherited alleles are
usually of a similar repeat length, whereas paternally inherited
ones have a higher chance of increasing in length and can exhibit
the
anticipation phenomenon.
It is rare for Huntington's disease to be caused by a
new mutation, where neither parent have
over 36 CAG repeats.
Individuals with
both genes affected are
rare, except in large
consanguineous
families. For some time HD was thought to be the only disease for
which this did not affect the symptoms and progression of the
disease, but it has since been found that it can affect the
phenotype and the rate of progression.
Offspring of an individual who has two affected genes will inherit
one of them and therefore definitely inherit the disease. Offspring
where both parents have one affected gene have a 75% risk of
inheriting HD, including a 25% risk of inheriting two affected
genes. Identical
twins, who have inherited the
same affected gene, typically have differing ages of onset and
symptoms.
Mechanism
The HTT protein interacts with over 100 other proteins, and appears
to have multiple biological functions. The behavior of mutated mHTT
protein is not completely understood, but it is toxic to certain
types of cells, particularly in the brain. Damage mainly occurs in
the
striatum, but as the disease
progresses, other areas of the brain are also significantly
affected. As the damage accumulates, symptoms associated with the
functions of these brain areas appear. Planning and modulating
movement are the main functions of the striatum, and difficulties
with these are initial symptoms.
HTT function
HTT is
expressed in all mammalian
cells. The highest concentrations are found in the brain and
testes, with moderate amounts in the
liver,
heart, and
lungs. The function of HTT in humans is unclear. It
interacts with proteins which are involved in
transcription,
cell signaling and intracellular
transporting. In
animals
genetically
modified to exhibit HD, several functions of HTT have been
found. In these animals, HTT is important for embryonic
development, as its absence is related to embryonic death. It also
acts as an
anti-apoptotic agent preventing
programmed cell death and
controls the production of
brain-derived neurotrophic
factor, a protein which protects neurons and regulates their
creation during
neurogenesis. HTT also
facilitates
vesicular transport and
synaptic transmission and controls neuronal
gene transcription. If HTT
expression is increased,
brain cell survival is improved and the effects
of mHTT are reduced, whereas when HTT expression is reduced, the
resulting characteristics are more typical of the presence of mHTT.
In humans the disruption of the normal gene does not cause the
disease. It is currently concluded that the disease is not caused
by
inadequate production of HTT,
but by a gain of toxic function of mHTT.
Cellular changes due to mHTT
[[Image:Neuron with mHTT inclusion zoomed.jpg|thumb|left|alt=Closer
view of neuron having a large central core with several tendrils
branching out some of which branche again, the core of the contains
an orange blob about a quarter of its diameter|A microscope image
of a neuron with inclusion (stained orange) caused by HD, image
width 250
µm]]
There are multiple cellular changes through which the toxic
function of mHTT may manifest and produce the HD pathology. During
the biological process of
posttranslational
modification of mHTT, cleavage of the protein can leave behind
shorter fragments constituted of parts of the polyglutamine
expansion. These fragments can then
misfold and coalesce, in a process called
protein aggregation, to form
inclusion bodies within cells. Inclusion
bodies have been found in both the
cell
nucleus and
cytoplasm. Inclusion
bodies in cells of the brain are one of the earliest pathological
changes, and some experiments have found that they can be
toxic for the cell, but other experiments have
shown that they may form as part of the body's defense mechanism
and help protect cells.
Several pathways by which mHTT may cause cell death have been
identified. These include: effects on
chaperone proteins, which help fold
proteins and remove misfolded ones; interactions with
caspases, which play a role in the
process of removing cells; the
toxic effects of glutamate on nerve cells;
impairment of energy production within cells; and effects on the
expression of genes. The cytotoxic effects of mHTT are strongly
enhanced by interactions with a protein called
Rhes, which
is expressed mainly in the striatum. Rhes was found to induce
sumoylation of mHTT, which causes the
protein clumps to disaggregate—studies in cell culture showed that
the clumps were much less toxic than the disaggregated form.
Macroscopic changes due to mHTT
HD affects specific areas of the brain. The most prominent early
effects are in a part of the
basal
ganglia called the
striatum, which is
composed of the
caudate nucleus and
putamen. Other areas affected include the
substantia nigra, layers 3, 5 and 6
of the
cerebral cortex, the
hippocampus,
purkinje
cells in the
cerebellum,
lateral tuberal nuclei of the
hypothalamus and parts of the
thalamus. These areas are affected according to
their structure and the types of neurons they contain, reducing in
size as they lose cells. Striatal spiny neurons are the most
vulnerable, particularly ones with
projections towards the external
globus pallidus, with
interneurons and spiny cells projecting to the
internal pallidum being less affected. HD also causes an
abnormal increase in
astrocytes.
The basal ganglia—the part of the brain most prominently affected
by HD—play a key role in movement and behavior control. Their
functions are not fully understood, but current theories propose
that they are part of the cognitive
executive system and the motor circuit.
The basal ganglia ordinarily inhibit a large number of circuits
that generate specific movements. To initiate a particular
movement, the cerebral cortex sends a signal to the basal ganglia
that causes the inhibition to be released. Damage to the basal
ganglia can cause the release or reinstatement of the inhibitions
to be erratic and uncontrolled, which results in an awkward start
to motion or motions to be unintentionally initiated, or a motion
to be halted before, or beyond, its intended completion. The
accumulating damage to this area causes the characteristic erratic
movements associated with HD.
Diagnosis
Medical diagnosis of the onset of
HD can be made following the appearance of physical symptoms
specific to the disease. Genetic testing can be used to confirm a
physical diagnosis if there is no family history of HD. Even before
the onset of symptoms, genetic testing can confirm if an individual
or
embryo carries an expanded copy of the
HTT gene that causes the disease.
Genetic counseling is available to
provide advice and guidance throughout the testing procedure, and
on the implications of a confirmed diagnosis. These implications
include the impact on an individual's psychology, career, family
planning decisions, relatives and relationships. Despite the
availability of pre-symptomatic testing, only 5% of those at risk
of inheriting HD choose to do so.
Clinical
A
physical examination,
sometimes combined with a
psychological examination, can
determine whether the onset of the disease has begun. Excessive
unintentional movements of any part of the body are often the
reason for seeking medical consultation. If these are abrupt and
have random timing and distribution, they suggest a diagnosis of
HD. Cognitive or psychiatric symptoms are rarely the first
diagnosed; they are usually only recognized in hindsight or when
they develop further. How far the disease has progressed can be
measured using the
unified Huntington's disease rating
scale which provides an overall rating system based on motor,
behavioral, cognitive, and functional assessments.
Medical imaging, such as
computerized tomography (CT) and
magnetic resonance
imaging (MRI), only shows visible
cerebral atrophy in the advanced stages of
the disease.
Functional
neuroimaging techniques such as
fMRI and
PET can show changes in brain
activity before the onset of physical symptoms.
Genetic
Because HD is dominant, there is a strong motivation for
individuals who are at risk of inheriting it to seek a diagnosis.
The genetic test for HD consists of a
blood test which counts the numbers of CAG
repeats in each of the
HTT alleles. A positive result is
not considered a diagnosis, since it may be obtained decades before
the symptoms begin. However, a negative test means that the
individual does not carry the expanded copy of the gene and will
not develop HD.
A
pre-symptomatic test is
a life-changing event and a very personal decision. The main reason
given for choosing testing for HD is to aid in career and family
decisions. Over 95% of individuals at risk of inheriting HD do not
proceed with testing, mostly because there is no treatment. A key
issue is the anxiety an individual experiences about not knowing
whether they will eventually develop HD, compared to the impact of
a positive result. Irrespective of the result, stress levels have
been found to be lower two years after being tested, but the risk
of suicide is increased after a positive test result. Individuals
found to have not inherited the disorder may experience
survivor guilt with regard to family members
who are affected. Other factors taken into account when considering
testing include the possibility of discrimination and the
implications of a positive result, which usually means a parent has
an affected gene and that the individual's siblings will be at risk
of inheriting it.
Genetic
counseling in HD can provide information, advice and support
for initial decision-making, and then, if chosen, throughout all
stages of the testing process. Counseling and guidelines on the use
of genetic testing for HD have become models for other genetic
disorders, such as autosomal dominant cerebellar
ataxias.
Presymptomatic
testing for HD has also influenced testing for other illnesses
with genetic variants such as
polycystic kidney disease, familiar
Alzheimer's disease and
breast cancer.
Embryonic
Embryos produced using
in vitro fertilisation may be
genetically tested for HD using
preimplantation genetic
diagnosis. This information can then be used to ensure embryos
with affected
HTT genes are not implanted, and therefore
any offspring will not inherit the disease. It is also possible to
obtain a
prenatal diagnosis for
an embryo or
fetus in the womb.
Differential diagnosis
Although HD accounts for ninety percent of the cases of chorea
caused by genetic disorders, and an observational diagnosis for
someone with typical symptoms and a
family history of the disease is usually
correct, a genetic test is required to rule out other disorders.
Most of these other disorders are collectively labelled HD-like
(HDL). The causes of most of these HDL diseases are unknown, but
those with known causes are due to mutations in the
prion protein gene (HDL1), the
junctophilin 3 gene (HDL2), a recessively inherited
HTT gene (HDL3 — only found in one family and poorly
understood), and the gene encoding the
TATA box-binding protein (HDL4/
SCA17).
Management
There is no cure for HD, but there are treatments available to
reduce the severity of some of its symptoms. For many of these
treatments, comprehensive clinical trials to confirm their
effectiveness in treating symptoms of HD specifically are
incomplete. As the disease progresses and a persons ability to tend
to their own needs reduces, carefully managed
multidisciplinary caregiving becomes increasingly necessary.
Tetrabenazine was developed
specifically to reduce the severity of chorea in HD, it was
approved in 2008 for this use in the US. Other drugs that help to
reduce chorea include
neuroleptics and
benzodiazepines. Compounds such as
amantadine or
remacemide are still under investigation but have
shown preliminary positive results.
Hypokinesia and rigidity can be treated with
antiparkinsonian drugs, and
myoclonic hyperkinesia can be treated with
valproic acid.
Psychiatric symptoms can be treated with medications similar to
those used in the general population.
Selective serotonin
reuptake inhibitors and
mirtazapine
have been recommended for depression, while
atypical antipsychotic drugs are
recommended for psychosis and behavioural problems.
Weight loss and eating difficulties due to
dysphagia and other muscle discoordination are
common, making nutrition management increasingly important as the
disease advances.
Thickening agents
can be added to liquids as thicker fluids are easier and safer to
swallow. Reminding the patient to eat slowly and to take smaller
pieces of food into the mouth may also be of use to prevent
choking. If eating becomes too hazardous or uncomfortable, the
option of using a
percutaneous endoscopic
gastrostomy is available. This is a feeding tube, permanently
attached through the
abdomen into the
stomach, which reduces the risk of
aspirating food and provides better
nutritional management.
Although there have been relatively few studies of exercises and
therapies that help
rehabilitate cognitive
symptoms of HD, there is some evidence for the usefulness of
physical therapy and
speech therapy. However, more rigorous
studies are needed for health authorities to endorse them. A
multidisciplinary approach may be important to limit disability.
The families of individuals, who have inherited or are at risk of
inheriting HD, have generations of experience of HD which may be
outdated and lack knowledge of recent breakthroughs and
improvements in genetic testing, family planning choices, care
management, and other considerations.
Genetic counseling benefits these
individuals by updating their knowledge, dispelling any myths they
may have and helping them consider their future options and
plans.
Prognosis
The length of the trinucleotide repeat accounts for 60% of the
variation in the age of onset and the rate of progression of
symptoms. A longer repeat results in an earlier age of onset and a
faster progression of symptoms. For example, individuals with a
trinucleotide repeat greater than sixty repeats often develop the
disease before twenty years of age, and those with less than forty
repeats may not develop noticeable symptoms. The remaining
variation is due to environmental factors and other genes that
influence the mechanism of the disease.
Life expectancy in HD is generally around 20 years following
the onset of visible symptoms. The pathology of Huntington’s
disease is not fatal, but complications caused by the disease's
symptoms become increasingly hazardous. The largest risk is
pneumonia, which is the cause of death of
one-third of those with HD. As the ability to synchronise movements
deteriorates, difficulty clearing the lungs and an increased risk
of
aspirating food or drink both increase
the risk of contracting pneumonia. The second greatest risk is
heart disease, which causes almost a
quarter of fatalities of those with HD.
Suicide is the next greatest cause of fatalities,
with 7.3% of those with HD taking their own lives and up to 27%
attempting to do so. It is unclear to what extent suicidal thoughts
are influenced by psychiatric symptoms, as they may be considered
to be an understandable response to avoid the later stages of the
disease or help retain a sense of control of an individual's life.
Other associated risks include choking,
physical
injury from falls, and malnutrition.
Epidemiology
The late onset of Huntington's disease means it does not usually
affect reproduction. The
prevalence is
similar for men and women, but varies greatly geographically as a
result of ethnicity, local migration and past immigration patterns.
The rate of occurrence is highest in peoples of Western European
descent, averaging around seventy per million people, but is lower
in the rest of the world, e.g. one per million people of Asian and
African descent. Additionally, some localized areas have a much
higher prevalence than their regional average.
One of the highest
prevalences is in the isolated populations of the Lake Maracaibo
region of Venezuela
, where HD affects up to seven thousand per million
people. Other areas of high localization have been
found in Tasmania
and specific
regions of Scotland
, Wales
and Sweden
.
Increased prevalence in some cases occurs due to a local
founder effect, a historical migration of
carriers into an area of
geographic
isolation. Some of these carriers have been traced back
hundreds of years using
genealogical
studies. Genetic
haplotypes can also give
clues for the geographic variations of prevalence.
Until the the discovery of a genetic test, statistics could only
include clinical diagnosis based on physical symptoms and a family
history of HD, excluding those who died of other causes before
diagnosis. These cases can now be included in statistics and as the
test becomes more widely available, estimates of the prevalence and
incidence of the disorder are likely to increase.
History
Before the 19th century, some HD sufferers may have been thought to
be possessed by spirits or persecuted as
witches, and were
shunned
or
exiled by society. Others were more
accepting; for example, the community of the family studied by
George Huntington openly
accommodated those who exhibited symptoms of HD.
The first definite mention of HD was in a letter by
Charles Oscar Waters, published in the
first edition of
Robley Dunglison's
Practice of Medicine in 1842. Waters described 'a form of
chorea, vulgarly called magrums', including accurate descriptions
of the chorea, its progression, and the strong heredity of the
disease. In 1846
Charles
Gorman observed how higher prevalence seemed to occur in
localized regions.
Independently of Gorman and Waters, both
students of Dunglison at Jefferson Medical College
, Johan Christian
Lund also produced an early description in 1860.
He
specifically noted that in Setesdalen
, a secluded area in Norway
, there was a
high prevalence of dementia associated with a pattern of jerking
movement disorders that ran in families.
The first thorough description of the disease was by
George Huntington in 1872. Examining the
combined medical history of several generations of a family
exhibiting similar symptoms, he realized their conditions must be
linked; he presented his detailed and accurate definition of the
disease as his first paper. Unknowingly, Huntington described the
exact pattern of inheritance of autosomal dominant disease years
before the discovery of Mendelian genetics. "Of its hereditary
nature. When either or both the parents have shown manifestations
of the disease..., one or more of the offspring almost invariably
suffer from the disease... But if by any chance these children go
through life without it, the thread is broken and the grandchildren
and great-grandchildren of the original shakers may rest assured
that they are free from the disease.". Sir
William Osler was interested in the disorder
and chorea in general, and was impressed with Huntington's paper,
stating that "
In the history of medicine, there are few
instances in which a disease has been more accurately, more
graphically or more briefly described." Osler's continued
interest in HD, combined with his influence in the field of
medicine, helped to rapidly spread awareness and knowledge of the
disorder throughout the medical community. Great interest was shown
by scientists in Europe, including
Louis Théophile Joseph
Landouzy,
Désiré-Magloire
Bourneville,
Camillo Golgi, and
Joseph Jules Dejerine, and
until the end of the century, much of the research into HD was
European in origin. By the end of the 19th century, research and
reports on HD had been published in many countries and the disease
was recognized as a worldwide condition.
During the rediscovery of
Mendelian inheritance at the turn of
the 20th century, HD was used tentatively as an example of
autosomal dominant inheritance. The strong inheritance pattern
prompted several researchers to attempt to trace and connect family
members of previous studies, one of whom was
Smith Ely Jelliffe.
Jelliffe collected
information from across New York State
and published several articles regarding the
genealogy of HD in New
England
. Jelliffe's research roused the interest of
his college friend,
Charles
Davenport, who made major contributions to the understanding of
the disease in 1911, proving that it was indeed autosomal dominant
and proceeding to document several of its inheritance
variabilities, such as the age of onset. He also described the
range of psychiatric and physical symptoms, providing much of the
framework for following research. Jelliffe's work was expanded upon
in 1932 by
P. R. Vessie, who
traced about a thousand people with HD back to two brothers who
left England
in 1630,
bound for Boston
.
Research
into the disorder continued steadily through the 20th century,
reaching a major breakthrough in 1983 when the US–Venezuela
Huntington's
Disease Collaborative Research Project discovered the
approximate location of a causal gene. This was the result
of an extensive study begun in 1979, focusing on the populations of
two isolated Venezuelan villages, Barranquitas and Lagunetas, where
there was an unusually high prevalence of the disease. Among other
innovations, the project developed DNA marking methods which were
an important step in making the
Human Genome Project possible. In 1993
the research group isolated the precise causal gene at 4p16.3,
making this the first
autosomal disease
locus found using genetic
linkage analysis. In the same time frame,
key discoveries concerning the mechanisms of the disorder were
being made, including the findings by
Anita Harding's research group on the effects
of the gene's length.
Modelling the disease in various types of animals, such as the
transgenic mouse developed in 1996,
enabled larger scale experiments. As these animals
metabolisms are faster and their lifespans much
shorter than a humans, results from experiments are received sooner
and research can be performed more quickly. The 1997 discovery that
mHTT fragments
misfold led to the
discovery of the
nuclear inclusions
they cause. These advancements and discoveries have led to
increasingly extensive research into the proteins involved with the
disease, potential drug treatments, care methods, and the gene
itself.
Society and culture
Ethics
Huntington's disease, particularly the application of the genetic
test for the disease, has raised several ethical issues. The issues
for genetic testing include defining how mature an individual
should be before being considered eligible for testing, ensuring
the confidentiality of results, and whether companies should be
allowed to use test results for decisions on employment, life
insurance or other financial matters. There was controversy when
Charles Davenport proposed in 1910
that
compulsory
sterilization and
immigration
control be used for people with certain diseases, including HD, as
part of the
eugenics movement.
In vitro fertilization has some
issues regarding its use of embryos. Some HD research has ethical
issues due to its use of
animal
testing and
embryonic stem
cells.
The development of an accurate diagnostic test for Huntington's
disease has caused social, legal, and ethical concerns over access
to and use of a person's results.Many guidelines and testing
procedures have strict procedures for disclosure and
confidentiality to allow individuals to decide when and how to
receive their results and also to whom the results are made
available.
Financial
institutions and businesses are faced with the question of
whether to use genetic test results when assessing an individual,
such as for life insurance or employment. Some countries'
organizations, such as the United Kingdom's insurance companies,
have agreed not to use this information. As with other untreatable
genetic conditions with a later onset, it is ethically questionable
to perform pre-symptomatic testing on a child or adolescent as
there would be no medical benefit for that individual. There is
consensus for only testing individuals who are considered
cognitively mature, although there is a counter-argument that
parents have a right to make the decision on their child's behalf.
With the lack of an effective treatment, testing a person under
legal age who is not judged to be
competent is considered unethical in most
cases.
Prenatal genetic testing or
preimplantation
genetic diagnosis to ensure a child is not born with a given
disease has some ethical concerns. For example, prenatal testing
raises the issue of selective abortion, a choice considered
unacceptable by some. Using preimplantation testing for HD requires
twice as many embryos to be used for in vitro fertilisation, as
half of them will be positive for HD. For a dominant disease there
are also difficulties in situations in which a parent does not want
to know his or her own diagnosis, as this would require parts of
the process to be kept secret from the parent.
Support organizations
In 1968, after experiencing HD in his wife's family, Dr. Milton
Wexler was inspired to start the
Hereditary Disease Foundation
(HDF), with the aim of curing genetic illnesses by coordinating and
supporting research. The foundation and Dr. Wexler's daughter,
Nancy S. Wexler, were key parts of the research team in Venezuela
which discovered the HD gene. As of 2009, Nancy Wexler is the
foundation's president. At roughly the same time as the HDF formed,
Marjorie Guthrie helped to found
the Committee to Combat Huntington's Disease (now the
Huntington's Disease
Society of America), after her husband
Woody Guthrie died from complications of HD.
Since then, support and research organizations have formed in many
countries around the world and have helped to increase public
awareness of HD. A number of these collaborate in umbrella
organizations, like the International Huntington Association and
the EuroHD network. Many support organizations hold an annual HD
awareness event, some of which have been endorsed by their
respective governments. For example, June 6 is designated "National
Huntington's Disease Awareness Day" by the US senate.
Research directions
Research into the mechanism of HD has focused on identifying the
functioning of HTT, how mHTT differs or interferes with it, and the
brain pathology that the disease produces. Most research is
conducted in animals. Appropriate animal models are critical for
understanding the fundamental mechanisms causing the disease and
for supporting the early stages of
drug
development. Mice and monkeys, chemically induced to exhibit
HD-like symptoms were initially used, but they did not mimic the
progressive features of the disease. Since the Huntingtin gene was
identified,
transgenic animals
(mice,
Drosophila
fruit flies, and more
recently monkeys) exhibiting HD-like syndromes can be generated by
inserting a CAG repeat expansion into the gene.
Nematode worms also provide a valuable model when
the gene is expressed.
Genetically engineered
intracellular
antibody fragments called
intrabodies
have been shown to prevent mortality during the development stages
of
Drosophila models. Their mechanism of action was an
inhibition of mHTT aggregation. As HD has been conclusively linked
to a single gene,
gene silencing is
potentially possible and by using
gene
knockdown in mouse models, researchers have shown that when the
influence of mHTT is reduced, symptoms improve.
Stem cell therapy is the replacement of
damaged neurons by transplantation of
stem
cells into affected regions of the brain. Experiments have
yielded some positive results using this technique in animal models
and preliminary human
clinical
trials.
Numerous drugs have been reported to produce benefits in animals,
including
creatine,
coenzyme Q10 and the antibiotic
minocycline. Some of these have then been tested
by humans in clinical trials, and as of 2009 several are at
different stages of these trials.
References
External links