Reactions by the UN and national representatives
The top UN official in Lebanon said "Hezbollahâs action escalates
the already tense situation along the
Blue Line and is an act of very
dangerous proportions," in a statement.
Kofi
Annan demanded
Hezbollah free the two
captured Israeli soldiers. He has sent a three man party to the
Middle East to urge countries to show restraint.
Jan Egeland, a top United Nations humanitarian
official, said that Israeli response is in violation of
international law. He was equally critical of Hezbollah and Hamas
for abducting Israeli soldiers. He also said that those who had
seized Israeli soldiers and fired rockets into Israel from southern
Lebanon bore their share of the blame. Egeland also criticized
Hezbollah for using the civilian population as cover, telling the
BBC, "I also clearly see that Hezbollah is trying to blend into the
civilian population in too many places and they bear also a heavy
responsibility for this. They do not seem to care that they really
inflict a lot of suffering on their own population."UN Secretary
General Kofi Annan: "What is most urgently needed is an immediate
cessation of hostilities for three vital reasons: âŠ"
- On 17 July UN Secretary General Kofi Annan and UK Prime
Minister Tony Blair called for an international force to be sent to
Lebanon to stop the attacks on Israel by Hezbollah. Mr Blair was quoted as saying that the
force could "stop the bombardment coming over into Israel and
therefore gives Israel a reason to stop its attacks on
Hezbollah".
- On 19 July, Kofi Annan went on to condemn Israel's use of force
saying that "I condemn without reservations the attack in southern
Lebanon, and demand that Israeli troops be released
immediately."
- On 20
July UN Secretary General Kofi Annan
demanded both sides stop all violence immediately, condemning
Hezbollah for sparking the conflict but
also attacking Israel
for its
"excessive use of force".
According to United Nations Secretary General Kofi Annan: "What is
most urgently needed is an immediate cessation of hostilities for
three vital reasons: first, prevent further loss of innocent life
and the infliction of further suffering; second, to allow full
humanitarian access to those in need; the third, give diplomacy the
chance to work out a practical package of actions that would
provide a lasting solution to the current crisis."
- On 26 July US blocks UN from condemning Israel, The United
States blocked the UN Security Council from issuing a statement
that would have condemned Israel's bombing of a UN post on the
Lebanon border that killed four military observers overnight
Tuesday.
- On 29 July Under-Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs and
Emergency Relief Coordinator Jan Egeland
appealed for a seventy-two hour truce to allow for humanitarian
relief of the civilian population in Lebanon. This was later
disputed by the Israeli's as they said all relief efforts were
already ongoing.
- On 30
July following the bombing of Qana
by IAF the
Secretary General condemned the attack and urged the UN Security
Council to also condemn it. Immediately prior to the attack
a second IAF bombing had taken place on a UN post on 29 July and a
crowd in Beirut had also attacked UN officials in outrage for the
Qana incident. Annan said:
"We must condemn this action in the strongest possible
terms, and I appeal to you [the Security Council] to do
likewise..
The tragic events in Qana remind us that, ten years ago
over 100 people who had taken refuge in this same village suffered
a similar fate.
We must deliver the region from this seemingly endless
cycle of violence"
Middle East
On 27
July, the US-backed government of Afghanistan, together with
Iran
and Tajikistan
denounced Israel's attacks against Lebanon.
"We feel sad about the death of dozens of civilians in Lebanon and
ask for solving the crisis through diplomatic channels," stated
Afghan President
Hamid Karzai.
President Mubarak of Egypt and King
Abdullah II of Jordan criticized Hezbollah's actions as harmful, as
it may have "the region being dragged into âadventurism' that does
not serve Arab interests." Foreign minister
Aboul Gheit stated "Targeting civilians
under the pretext of fighting terrorism is unacceptable and
unjustified. Israeli practices violate international law. We
condemn any military action that targets civilians. We consider it
a terrorist act, regardless of who the civilians are or its
source." Hosni Mubarak, the Egyptian president, condemned the
Israeli military aggression in Lebanon but also indirectly
criticised Hezbollah for harming Arab interests.
Egyptian Foreign Minister Aboul Gheit said, "A cease-fire is
imperative and we have to keep working to reach that objective. It
is imperative. We have to bring it to an end as soon as possible.
Thank you."
Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, was made a number of comments on
the violence. He was criticised for saying on a 9 July broadcast
for Al Arabiya satellite TV station:
"Definitely Iran has influence on
Shi'ites.
Shi'ites are 65 percent of the Iraqis
.
.
.
Most of the Shi'ites are loyal to Iran, and not to
the countries they are living in"
Following this in a newspaper interview with Egypt's Al-Gomhuriyya
daily on 26 July, the Egyptian President said:
"Those who urge Egypt to go to war to defend Lebanon or
Hizbullah are not aware that the time of exterior adventures is
over..
This was possible at a time when the Egyptian
population was only 24 million , but it is not possible now with 75
million citizens in need of development, services, job
opportunities and residential projects."
The next day an interview with
TIME
magazine was published where the President is quoted as saying
that Israeli conduct in Lebanon: "went way too far" and has
"triggered an increasing rage within the Arabs, Moslems and
worldwide." The President is also reported to have told TIME:
"Military operations will not solve Israel's problems
with Hizbullah.
An immediate cease-fire is the utmost
priority.
Cessation of hostilities would create the environment
conducive to addressing such problems in a candid
manner.
The bloodshed and the heavy toll of Israel's operations
must be brought to an end."
Foreign ministry spokesman
Hamid-Reza
Asefi condemned Israel's response stating, "The Zionist regime
is desperate because of the resistance put up by regional Muslim
nations and is now resorting to blind tactics against the innocent
people of Lebanon with full US backing."
Iran also adds that an
Israeli
attack against Syria
would be
considered an attack against the entire Muslim world and it would bring about a "fierce
response." Iranian President
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, quoted by the
Iranian News Agency,
said "The Zionists think that they are victims of Hitler, but they
act like Hitler and behave worse than Genghis Khan."
Ahmadinejad stated on 27 July that:
Not only has the occupying regime [Israel] attacked and
destroyed Lebanon under the support of certain countries, it has
victimized several hundred women and children while thousands of
people have been displaced escaping Israeli
bombardment.
During a visit to Beirut on 2 August Iranian Foreign Minister
Manouchehr Mottaki referring to
the 'Rome convention' of late July said:
"We consider those, who helped in preventing the Rome
convention from condemning and stopping the attack, as partners to
the Zionist entity in its savage crimes committed against innocent
women and children in Lebanon."
In a speech during an emergency meeting of Muslim leaders in
Malaysia, Ahmadinejad also called for an immediate cease-fire to
end the fighting between Israel and the Iranian-backed group
Hezbollah.
On 14 July Iraqi Parliament Speaker Mahmoud Al-Mashhadani condemned
Israeli attacks on Lebanon and called on the UN Security Council
and international community to act, warning against the outcome for
the region. Mahmoud Al-Mashhadani reportedly indicated that the
"attacks reflected Israel's disrespect of the international
community and international agreements."
Hoshyar Zebari, Iraqi Foreign
Minister in the US-backed government, also represented Iraq at a
closed session meeting in Cairo with
Arab
League Foreign Ministers on 15 July. The meeting was convened
to discuss the possibility of a resolution on the conflict.
Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki is reported to have condemned
Israel during the conflict saying "We call on the world to take
quick stands to stop the Israeli aggression" and "[Israel's]
excessive use of force is to be condemned".
A statement from the
Jordanian
Government said "Jordan stands against whoever exposes the
Palestinian people and their cause, Lebanon and its sovereignty to
unexpected dangers. Israel's use of force against unarmed civilians
and the outcome in terms of the human loss and destruction of civil
institutions." Jordan has also denounced Hezbollah's actions
believing them to be harmful to Arab interests in the region.
Prime Minister Sheikh
Nasser Al-Mohammed Al-Ahmed
Al-Sabah condemned what it cited as "Israeli aggression on the
Lebanese people" and expressed solidarity with Lebanon. Sheikh
Nasser made his statement after receiving Lebanese Member of
Parliament and Head of Future Block
Saad Rafiq Al-Hariri.
Palestinian Authority chairman
Mahmoud Abbas described Israel's
incursion as the start of an escalation to a large-scale Middle
East war. He urged World Powers "to stop this serious
deterioration".
A Saudi official quoted by the Saudi Press Agency on 13 July was
critical of Hezbollah guerrillas - without naming them - of
"uncalculated adventures" that precipitated the latest Middle East
crisis. "A difference should be drawn between legitimate resistance
and rash adventures carried out by elements inside the state and
those behind them without consultation or coordination with Arab
countries. ... The Kingdom sees that it is time for those elements
alone to shoulder the full responsibility for this irresponsible
behavior and that the burden of ending the crisis they have created
falls on them alone."
Vice
President Farouk al-Sharaa says
that Israel is responsible for the conflict, due to the Israeli
occupation of the West
Bank
.The Syrian Baath Party has also expressed
its solidarity and support with Hezbollah. Syria's military has
been put on high alert. Syria's president
Bashar Assad has also released a statement
saying "The occupying enemy hasn't forgotten the humiliating defeat
and its submissive exit from south Lebanon under the strikes bold
resistance," "Syria, which stood by its brother (Lebanon) and
sacrificed martyrs to defend Lebanon's freedom as we did for
Syria's sovereignty, remains as always adamant in standing by our
Arab people who's fighting in Lebanon and Palestine, and by the
bold national resistance who struck the enemy. All threats voiced
by powers in the world who support the enemy won't deter us from
continuing to support our brothers," "because we believe that
falling for the sake of heaven (martyrdom) is the only way to
freedom and victory. We have to make all effort in training to save
every drop of blood when the hour comes. The fighting continues so
long our land is occupied and our rights are denied. Victory will
be achieved God willing." "the Israeli enemy continues its
extermination war against our proud peoples in Lebanon and
Palestine. Our brothers in Lebanon are being subjected to
aggression by the Israeli war machine from the air, the sea and the
ground," "The aggression, killing and destruction committed by the
Israelis in Lebanon are part of an operation that was planned and
organized by the large forces dominating the international
community."
The ruling party,
General
People's Congress strongly condemned the actions of which it
considered to be aggressions against the Palestinians and the
Lebanese and called for the international community to intervene.
Other political parties have also condemned the Israelis, and
announced their support for the Palestinian and Lebanese people âin
their fight for their right of survival and defeating occupier.â
They also called for the closing of Israeli embassies in Arab
countries.
Asia
Foreign minister
Li Zhaoxing urged all
parties concerned to keep restraint to avoid further deterioration
of the situation, expressing his close attention to and deep
concern over the conflict. After a Chinese
U.N.
observer was killed when a U.N. observation post in Lebanon was
bombed by Israeli aircraft, China called for an Israeli apology and
demanded that Israel stop bombing U.N. positions. China asked the
U.N. Security Council to strongly condemn
the Israeli bombing and the permanent representative of China in
U.N. implied that U.S. resistance in allowing such condemnation
would affect China's position in the
nuclear program of Iran
The
Security Bureau
reminds Hong Kong residents in Lebanon and Israel to keep abreast
of latest developments and pay attention to personal safety.
[319683]
The Ministry of External Affairs expressed concern over the growing
tensions in Lebanon and urged all parties to end the violence in
favor of peaceful negotiation. "We are seriously concerned about
the escalating tension in West Asia as a result of developments on
the Israel-Lebanese border since yesterday which have the potential
to inflame the region further and widen the conflict," the
statement issued said. On 27 July 2006 India made a statement
condemning Israelâs âdisproportionate and excessive use of forceâ
in Lebanon but simultaneously criticized Hezbollah for kidnapping
two Israeli soldiers. Junior Foreign Minister Anand Sharma in a
statement to Parliament demanded an immediate cessation to
hostilities, saying Lebanon had become a âvictim by default.â
President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono stated
that "Indonesia
has repeatedly called on Israel to stop its
military action ... the United
Nations has to take action to prevent the conflict from
escalating", earlier Foreign
Minister Hassan Wirajuda said
"We condemn the military actions that have killed many innocent
civilians".. Indonesia also warned the United States that
supporting Israel in the conflict may lead to a rise in Islamic
fundamentalism, making it more difficult for
Muslim states to fight radical Islam. Indonesian
foreign minister
Hassan Wirajuda
expressed fears that even moderate muslims may become
radical.
Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi urged restraint and
stated âI understand the anger of the Israelis, but I hope you will
not seek an eye for an eye and keep in mind the importance of
peace.â
On 31 July, Japan condemned the Israeli air strike in Qana and
called for a cease-fire.Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi said "I
think it is truly deplorable that innocent people are falling
victim day after day."
Chief Cabinet secretary Shinzo Abe said, "It is extremely
regrettable that this kind of incident occurred amid international
calls on Israel to exercise self-restraint. We call on the parties
concerned to make a cease-fire, while seeking sincere and utmost
efforts by all countries concerned to resolve the problem in order
to prevent civilian casualties and not to further worsen the
situation."
[319684]
Kazakh officials have called upon the
UN Security Council to adopt
a consolidated resolution on the escalation of conflict in Lebanon.
"Kazakhstan calls the conflicting parties to an immediate ceasefire
and considers it necessary that the UN Security Council adopt a
consolidated resolution on the escalation of conflict in Lebanon,"
stated
Ilyas Omarov, press secretary of
the Kazakh foreign ministry. "We deeply regret about the continuing
escalation of the conflict causing sufferings of the peaceful
population of Lebanon, Palestine, and Israel. Kazakhstan believes
that military actions should not cause casualties among peaceful
population or demolition of social infrastructure, as well as a
humanitarian crisis," he stated. "A decision of Israel to suspend
the air strikes for 48 hours must become a first step on the way to
cessation of military actions in the region."
Dato' Seri Syed Hamid Albar, the minister of foreign
affairs for Malaysia, condemned "the unlawful airstrikes by Israel"
and "the irresponsible use of force by Israel on Lebanon" causing
"hardship and suffering to [Lebanon's] people". Malaysia urged
Israel to "cease all military action" and "call[ed] upon the
international community to intervene". On 20 July, the foreign
minister told the press that Malaysia was considering plan to
deploy peacekeepers to Lebanon.
During an emergency meeting of Muslim leaders by the
Organisation of the
Islamic Conference on 3 July, chairman Dato' Seri
Abdullah Ahmad Badawi called for the
convening of the
United
Nations General Assembly in 'emergency special session', under
the terms of the "
Uniting for
Peace" resolution, if the Security Council failed to act
immediately in the crisis. Also present at the conference were the
heads of states and foreign ministers of 18 member states including
Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.On 5 August, Malaysia
rejected plans for a dialogue with Israel to resolve the crisis on
grounds of no diplomatic ties between the two nations.
The foreign ministry has expressed outrage over "Israeli aggression
against Lebanon and Palestine." "This attack is a flagrant
violation of Lebanese sovereignty and contravenes the norms and
principles of the UN charter. The aerial bombardment of Beirut
airport and the naval blockade of Lebanese waters announced by the
Israeli government represents a dangerous escalation. We have also
watched with deep concern the Israeli attacks on Gaza that have
resulted in enormous losses in life and property." The statement
also said that "the latest Israeli aggression against Palestinian
territories and Lebanon have undermined hopes and efforts for peace
in the region. The situation demands restraint and a return to
diplomacy and negotiations."
On 16 July Pakistan condemned the violence being committed by
Israel against Lebanon and urged that attacks resulting in loss of
life and property must be stopped immediately. Prime Minister
Shaukat Aziz expressed these views
while talking to his Lebanese counterpart
Fouad Siniora on Sunday. "Pakistan appeals to
the world community, the permanent members of the Security Council,
the UN and other international bodies to intervene,â Mr Aziz said,
adding that Pakistan stood by the people of Lebanon and respected
their sovereignty and territorial integrity.
President Arroyo had urged stranded OFWs to
leave Lebanon at once.
Several lawmakers have voiced supported for a ceasefire between
Hezbollah and Israeli forces, indicating a condemnation to
Israel.
Tajikistan
denounced Israel's attacks on Lebanon on 27 July, together with
Iran
and Afghanistan
. "We are seriously concerned about the
deteriorating security conditions in the Middle East," stated Tajik
President
Emomali Rahmonov,
"particularly more so due to Israel's attack against Lebanon that
has claimed the lives of hundreds of innocent civilians so far."
Rakhmonov added, "We hereby ask for an immediate end to those
attacks, and the solving of the dispute through negotiations." He
emphasized, "According to latest reports, most of the victims of
Israeli attacks are the Lebanese children, youngsters, women, and
elderly folks."
The Foreign Ministry of Vietnam condemned Israel's air strike on
Qana. Vietnamese Foreign Ministry Spokesman Le Dung further stated
that "Vietnam calls upon all related sides to cease fire
immediately and to demonstrate restraint to avoid causing harm to
civilians."
Europe
Foreign
minister Vardan Oskanyan issued a
statement that "Armenia is extremely concerned about the military
actions in Lebanon
and their
escalation, as well as the great loss of civilian life."
"Armenia condemns any violence whether it be abduction or use of
force," he underscored. "We particularly denounce the use of such
disproportionate force intended solely to collectively punish
civilians and damage infrastructure.
This kind of reaction
by Israel
is
particularly difficult to understand given the fact that the
Lebanese government has clearly distanced itself from the abduction
incident. We hope that there will be restraint in the region
and also hope there will be an immediate ceasefire so that the
issues can be addressed by peaceful means."
Ursula Plassnik, Austrian foreign
minister, called for an immediate end to hostilities in Lebanon.
"The [use of] blind force must stop," Plassnik said. "I appeal
seriously to the Israeli army and Hezbollah to stop their attacks
and no longer oppose diplomatic efforts" to end the conflict, she
said.
Minister
of foreign affairs Karel de Gucht and
Prime Minister Guy Verhofstadt said
that Israel
has the
right to defend itself, but has now responded with excessive
violence. Verhofstadt also called for the release of the
captured Israeli soldiers. The Belgian-Lebanese leader of the
Arab European League,
Dyab Abou Jahjah, expressed his will to go
to Lebanon to fight against Israel.
Former High Representative
Paddy
Ashdown said that "It is not Hezbullah's position that is
weakening now. It is Israel's. Its stated war aim was to destroy
Hezbullah. It is not clear why, having failed to do this by
occupying Lebanon, it thought it could achieve it by bombing," he
warned.
Bulgaria has voiced its concern over the growing tension in the
Near East region in the last few days, Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Spokesman Dimitar Tsanchev said in a press-release: "We condemn the
kidnap of the two Israeli soldiers. We consider that the Shiite
Lebanese organization Hisbullah should release them immediately and
cease the shooting against Israeli territory, the press-release
says. We bitterly condemn the bombing of the Israeli Army on
Lebanon, which result in the death of tens of innocent Lebanese
citizens. Israel should refrain from such actions and from breaking
the borders of Lebanon," the release further said.
The
Danish foreign minister Per Stig
MĂžller said that the Lebanese
government has to take responsibility to prevent
further terror attacks from Hezbollah in
southern Lebanon. Israel
has the
right to act in self defense, but is also obligated to not use too
strong measures.
Finland, which currently holds the European Union's rotating
presidency, has issued the following statement: "The European Union
is greatly concerned about the disproportionate use of force by
Israel in Lebanon in response to attacks by Hezbollah on Israel.
The presidency deplores the loss of civilian lives and the
destruction of civilian infrastructure. The imposition of an air
and sea blockade on Lebanon cannot be justified."
Finnish foreign minister
Erkki
Tuomioja, representing the EU in Israel, criticised Israeli
"precision attacks" for hitting "everyone except Hezbollah" after
the killing of four UN peacekeepers (including one Finnish) in
southern Lebanon.
[319685] "Israel could be destroying Lebanon while
leaving the guerrilla group Hizbullah intact", stated
Tuomioja on 11 August
Foreign
minister Philippe
Douste-Blazy said the Israeli offensive on Lebanon is a
"disproportionate act of war with negative consequences" which
could "plunge Lebanon back into the worst years of the war with the
flight of thousands of Lebanese who ... were in the process of
rebuilding their country.â
âI am very concerned about the latest
developments on the Israel-Lebanon border⊠I condemn the rocket
strikes this (Wednesday) morning on the town of Qiryat
Shemona
. I also condemn the kidnapping of two
Israeli soldiers and I ask for their immediate and unconditional
release⊠I call on all parties to show restraint and not engage in
a cycle of violence in which civilian populations would be the
first victims.â
Jacques Chirac,
president of France â a country which
maintained close links with Lebanon since the days of the
League of Nations mandate â
castigated the Israeli offensive into Lebanon on 14 July.
Chancellor
Angela Merkel says "We call on the
powers in the region to seek to bring about a de-escalation of the
situation. We cannot confuse cause and effect. The starting point
is the capture of the Israeli soldiers. It is important that the
government in Lebanon, which is on a peaceful path, should be
strengthened, but it must be made clear that the capture [of the
soldiers] cannot be tolerated. The attacks did not start from the
Israeli side, but from Hezbollah's side." Sunday, German
Development Minister
Heidemarie Wieczorek-Zeul voiced
criticism against Israel's attacks on civilian infrastructure in
Lebanon, calling it "completely unacceptable."
Spokesman
Evangelos Antonaros
urged Hezbollah to release the captured Israeli soldiers. "Greece
expresses its serious concern and is intensely troubled," the
spokesman said. "It is vital, to stop the (situation) worsening,
Hezbollah must immediately release the soldiers taken hostage. At
the same time, Greece calls on the government of Israel to avoid
the use of excessive and pointless force which cannot provide a
solution to the problem."
A demonstration took place on the 25 July, near the
embassy of the United
States, with slogans such as "Down USA, down Israel".
The Italian foreign minister
Massimo
D'Alema said "We have the impression that the (Israeli)
reaction is out of proportion and dangerous for the consequences it
could have, I think that this, apart from some nuances, is the way
the whole international community sees the situation." He then
added, "We are working for moves by the EU and the G8 in the next
few hours to stop the spiral of violence," making reference to the
G8 meeting planned for the weekend in St. Petersburg. He also
condemned Hezbollah's assault on Israeli soldiers as
"unacceptable," adding that Rome had asked for the release of the
soldiers being held hostage.
On 16 July there were reports that Italy was attempting to broker
an agreement between Israel and Lebanon. The Israelis would agree
to a cease-fire immediately on two conditions:
- The return of the two soldiers captured on 12 July.
- The Army/Government of Lebanon would have to ensure that
Hezbollah would pull back to the Litani
River.
Minister for
Foreign Affairs Dermot Ahern said
"It is now in the interests of everyone in the region that all
parties act urgently on the repeated calls to exercise restraint.
They must cooperate with the diplomatic efforts to resolve the
crisis without further death and suffering. The Israeli Government
has a particular and immediate responsibility in this
regard."
On 26
July, Mr Dermot Ahern told RTĂ
News that
the Irish officer acting as liaison between the UN and the Israeli
defence forces had warned them six times (before the airstrike that
killed four UN observers) that their shelling was too close to UN
positions. Mr Ahern continued that the deaths were the
result either of an incredible accident or of deliberate targeting.
The concerns were passed onto the
Israeli Ambassador to the
Republic of Ireland Daniel Megiddo.
Following the Israeli air strike on Qana, on 30 July,The
Taoiseach,
Bertie
Ahern said "This event strongly underlines the clear message
the Government has been giving out which is that an immediate
ceasefire on all sides is urgently necessary. Military actions are
only making a solution more difficult."
A
shipment of bombs that attempted to land in Republic of
Ireland
from Texas to Tel Aviv were denied use of Irish
airspace and airfields on 29 July by the Irish Government.
The weapons were part of a series of agreed arms shipments between
the United States Government and Israel.
The plane diverted to
Prestwick
Airport
in Scotland. .
On 2 August, The
Oireachtas Committee for
Foreign Affairs unanimously agreed a motion condemning the
bloodshed in the Middle East and calling for an immediate ceasefire
and the provision of humanitarian relief for those affected.
The
Dutch
foreign
minister Bernard Bot has expressed
"understanding for Israel's reaction" but said "it would be hard to
support Israel in case there will be many civilian
casualties". Moreover Israel should try everything it can to
minimize civilian casualties.
The Norwegian foreign minister
Jonas Gahr StĂžre called Israel's
reaction "totally unacceptable" and referred to it as "a dangerous
escalation," while also condemning Hezbollah's attack on the
Israeli soldiers and the kidnapping of the two Israeli
soldiers.
Jonas Gahr StĂžre stated again
on 30 July 2006, "The Israeli attack on the Lebanese village of
Qana is a a clear-cut violation of international law.".
However, he also stated, "
Hezbollah has
through its fighting taken the whole Lebanese population as
hostage, which is totally unacceptable. The civilian population is
targeted and the situation in southern Lebanon is unsafe both in
safety and humanitarily. I support UN Emergency Relief Coordinator
Jan Egeland's demand of an 72-hour
ceasefire and the creation of a supply line to send first aid
supplies to Southern Lebanon".
On 13 July, the Romanian Foreign Affairs Ministry (MAE) voiced
concern over the crisis. The ministry called on the parties
involved to show calm and refrain from any actions that might
further deteriorate the situation and might lead to new victims and
inflict material damages. The MAE also stated that Hezbollah should
free the two captured Israeli soldiers immediately and
unconditionally and stop the attacks on Israel.
On 19 July, Romanian President
Traian BÄsescu said in a press
conference that "we are starting to face a
humanitarian crisis" and urged
UN Security Council to quickly
adopt a solution to put an end to the insecurity in the area. "We
recognize Israelâs right to security but it has generated a
humanitarian crisis", "Both parties must protect civilians", and
"The incapacity of the international community to enforce the UN
resolution led to a humanitarian
disaster" BÄsescu said. Also present, Foreign Affairs Minister
RÄzvan Ungureanu said
that "it is absolutely necessary that hostilities cease".
Russia sharply criticized Israel over its onslaught against
Lebanon, sparked when Hezbollah militants captured two Israeli
soldiers. The Russian Foreign Ministry
Sergei Lavrov said Israel's actions have gone
"far beyond the boundaries of an anti-terrorist operation" and
repeating calls for an immediate cease-fire.
Foreign minister said "this is a disproportionate response to what
has happened and if both sides are going to drive each other into a
tight corner then I think that all this will develop in a very
dramatic and tragic way." He added: "We firmly reaffirm support for
Lebanon's sovereignty and territorial integrity."
Russian Defense Minister
Sergei Ivanov
called on both sides to quickly calm the situation and said
Hezbollah should stop using "terrorist methods."
Russian President
Vladimir Putin has
urged both sides to halt their military actions. "This should
become the starting point for resolving all other problems," Putin
said. "We will urge all the sides involved in the conflict to stop
bloodshed immediately."
Putin also called on Israel to show restraint, and a Russian
newsagency said "Putin believes that Israel pursues other aims in
the Middle East, except for the return of hostages."
At a briefing after the first day of the G8 summit Putin said that
"We condemn any terrorist attacks, including kidnappings, but there
is the impression that Israel is pursuing other, broader aims other
than returning the abducted servicemen." He also said that he
thought there were still ways to resolve the conflict that had not
been used and he urged every effort to be made.
Spain's Prime Minister
JosĂ© Luis RodrĂguez
Zapatero issued a statement saying that "From my point of view,
Israel is wrong. One thing is self defense, and the other is to
launch a counter offensive consisting on a general attack in
Lebanon and Gaza that is just going to further escalate violence in
the area" . The Spanish Government asked also Israel to act with
moderation and in proportion to these events given the need to
avoid a spreading of violence, which would put the stability of the
region in danger and would have as its principal victim, once
again, the civilian population. Spain also called on Hezbollah to
release the two Israeli soldiers.
On Saturday, 22 July 2006:
12:10 p.m.: The prime ministers of
Spain and Turkey appealed to world leaders and international bodies
to help stop hostilities in the Middle East, saying the violence
threatened to drag the entire region into a "chaotic
deadlock."
In a joint declaration, Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey
and Spain's Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero offered to contribute to
efforts toward a cease-fire.
Turkey's Erdogan spoke with Bush by phone earlier in
the day.[319686]
The minister of foreign affairs
Jan
Eliasson said on 13 July (translated) "The military offensive
of Israel is an extremely dangerous escalation of the situation in
the region". He condemned the attack of Hezbollah, but said that
the line of proportionality in the reaction had been crossed. "I am
deeply critical that the civilian population is being
affected."
On 30 July,
Jan Eliasson said
"It
is time to end this madness. The UN Security Council must
accept its responsibility and immediately adopt a resolution to
bring an end to hostilities." (
[319687])
On 13 July, the
Swiss
Department of Foreign Affairs condemned Israel's
"disproportionate" military actions in Lebanon and stated that
"Israel's reply should remain strictly proportional and not
threaten a non-hostile neighboring state." It also condemned "the
Hezbollah attacks against settlements in Northern Israel, which
also violate international humanitarian law". The department
expressed concerns of a regional conflict being ignited and called
on all parties to de-escalate the situation.
On 27 July, the
Swiss Federal
Council held a special meeting to discuss the crisis. The
Council announced that it deplored the human tragedy of the
conflict and that it would reinforce its humanitarian aid measures;
it also allocated CHF 5 million in emergency aid for the
ICRC. The government's failure to reiterate the foreign
department's criticism of Israel and its decision not to cancel the
Swiss cooperation with the Israeli armaments industry were
considered by the press to be a rebuke to outspoken Socialist
foreign minister
Micheline
Calmy-Rey by the Council's center-right majority.
Turkey foreign minister
Abdullah
GĂŒl urges for all sides in the Middle East to agree to a
ceasefire quickly in order to prevent a further escalation from
occurring. "I invite everyone to a ceasefire quickly. If a
ceasefire is delayed, I see the risk of an escalation and the
complete destruction of the opportunity for co-existence," GĂŒl told
reporters.
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip ErdoÄan recently
issued a statement in which he expressed his concerns about the
goals of Israel and questioned whether it is "the complete invasion
of Palestine", and pointed out "If that is indeed the case,
certainly there will be repercussions from the entire humanity. The
children of Palestine are as valuable as those of Israel." ErdoÄan
criticized the Israeli counterattacks, stating that "While the
kidnapping in Palestine was both negative and wrong, a tenfold use
of excessive force is even more so. No reason can justify bombing
civilians and laying waste to cities in a merciless manner."
ErdoÄan also mentioned that he got a phone call from Fuad Sinyora,
the Prime Minister of Lebanon, where Sinyora explained to him that
"they were being wrongfully accused of a crime they did not commit"
and asked him to intervene in behalf of a cease-fire. "We are going
to contribute in every way we can," ErdoÄan said in his
statement.
The government of the UK was hesitant in calling for an âimmediateâ
stop to the fighting, and British Foreign Secretary
Margaret Beckett said that âa call to the
end the violenceâ must form an element of a âlong-term peace plan.â
An envoy for the EU said that Britain would "pay a heavy political
price" if it continued to oppose the call for an immediate
cease-fire.
On 25 July, a poll was published in
The
Guardian indicating that only 22% of Britons believed Israel's
response to the Hezbollah incursion was proportionate. The poll
also showed a majority (63% of those surveyed) believe Prime
Minister Blair is keeping Britain too close to the United
States.
Prime Minister
Tony Blair personally
urged for a calm mediation between both sides. "I entirely
understand the desire, and indeed need, for Israel to defend itself
properly and I also understand the plight of Lebanon and the
Lebanese government, not to say the many Palestinians that suffer
as well," he said. "The only way we are going to get this situation
resolved is if we support the UN mission, get some calm into the
situation and then as soon as possible... get back in to the road
map towards a two-state solution that offers the only chance for
stability and peace in the future." Blair also underscored the
tragedy that the crisis has brought to the region. "What is
happening is absolutely tragic for all the people involved, but the
only solution is that the international community empowers the
moderates on both sides to come to a solution." On 16 July, Prime
Minister Blair blamed Iran and Syria for the flare-up in the Middle
East.
On 22
July Kim Howells, Foreign
Office
minister with
responsibility for the Middle East, criticised Israel's bombardment
of Lebanon while on a visit to Beirut. He said "The
destruction of the infrastructure, the death of so many children
and so many people. These have not been surgical strikes. And it's
very difficult, I think, to understand the kind of military tactics
that have been used. You know, if they're chasing Hezbollah, then
go for Hezbollah. You don't go for the entire Lebanese
nation."
On 25 July
Menzies Campbell,
leader of the
Liberal Democrats,
wrote to Blair demanding the suspension of all future arms exports
to Israel including the removal of 'special licences'. His letter
followed the publication of a report detailing British arms sales
to Israel by four Government departments. Campbell stated in his
letter; "In light of disproportionate military action by Israel in
Lebanon and Gaza the UK government must suspend any further arms
exports to Israel."
On 27
July British Foreign Secretary Margaret
Beckett protested to the government of the United States via US
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice about its use of Prestwick
Airport
, Scotland to transport bombs to Israel. The
laser guided munitions were allegedly transported using two
chartered Airbus A310 cargo planes.
On 28 July, former British Foreign Secretary and current Leader of
the House of Commons
Jack
Straw called the Israeli response "disproportionate"
On 29 July former British Foreign Secretary and current Leader of
the House of Commons
Jack
Straw warned that Israel's military action "could further
destabilise the already fragile Lebanese nation", while noting that
"Israel has clear rights to defend itself proportionately". He
added that he grieved equally "for all those innocent Israeli
civilians killed in the conflict" and the "10 times as many
innocent Lebanese, men women and children, killed by Israeli
fire".
On 30 July the British Ambassador to the UN, Emyr Jones Parry,
urged the Security Council to call for an immediate end to
hostilities and work for a political resolution of the
crisis.
On 30
July anti-war protestors at Scotland's Prestwick Airport
managed to have a chartered plane laden with bombs
on route from Texas to Tel Aviv diverted to RAF
Mildenhall
in Suffolk, England. The bombs are part of a
series of agreed arms shipments between the United States
Government and Israel and were diverted originally from Irish
airspace as the Irish Government refused to allow the aircraft
permission to land. The transport of weapons to Israel via British
airspace has caused embarrassment for the British Government
although the shipments are to continue.
On 14 July, resigning Secretary of State Cardinal
Angelo Sodano said that "the Holy See condemns
both the terroristic attacks of one side and the military reprisals
of the other. Indeed, the right to defense of one State does not
exempt it from respect of the norms of international law,
especially as regards the protection of civilian populations.In
particular, the Holy See deplores now the attack on Lebanon, a free
and sovereign nation, and assures its closeness to those
populations, who already have suffered so much to defend their
independence."
These statements have drawn some criticism, both inside and outside
the Vatican, for what is seen as a pro-Arab and anti-Israeli bias
on Sodano's part. It is believed that earlier incidents of a
similar nature have contributed to the current Pope accepting
Sodano's resignation on 22 June 2006, although Sodano will remain
in office until 15 September.Following declarations from the
Pope himself have expressed equal concern for
the suffering of people on both Lebanon and Israel, and a constant
request for a ceasefire.
On 16 July, during the weekly Angelus prayer, Pope
Benedict XVI expressed strong concern for the
escalation of military action and the numerous civilian casualties.
He admitted that the conflict had been originated by "objective
violations of right and justice", but stated that "neither
terroristic acts nor reprisals are justifiable, especially when
they have tragic consequences on the civilian population", and said
that the path of war does not lead to positive results. After
mentioning that the Israeli city of Haifa had been heavily struck,
the Pope prayed for peace and concord.
During an exchange with the press on 19 July, the Pope commented:
"I fully agree with the G8 statement." The G8 asked that Israel act
with restraint but laid the blame for the conflict on
Hezbollah.
On 23 July, the Pope proclaimed a special day of prayer and penance
for peace. He renewed his appeal to the combatants, asking that
they cease fire, allow the sending of humanitarian aid, and begin
negotiations with the help of the international community. Then the
Pope reaffirmed "the right of the Lebanese to the integrity and
sovereignty of their country, the right of Israelis to live in
peace in their state, and the right of Palestinians to have a free
and sovereign country." He also expressed solidarity for civilian
populations who suffer because of a conflict in which they are
"mere victims", both the Israelis forced to live in shelters and
the Lebanese who see their country destroyed and have to seek
refuge elsewhere.
On 30 July, the Pope deplored the "increasingly tragic" situation
in the Middle East and how "in the hearts of many, hatred and will
of vengeance seem to grow". He said that "these facts show how it
is not possible to reestablish justice [...] using the instrument
of violence". The Pope exclaimed that those responsible should
immediately cease hostilities, "in the name of God". Then he asked
governments and international institutions to make every effort to
that end, and asked people of good will to continue sending relief
aid and praying God for peace.
Americas
The foreign ministry issued a statement saying that the Brazilian
government was "dismayed" at the deaths of four Brazilians of
Lebanese origin, including two children. Brazil condemned both
sides escalating into a bigger conflict. And urged South Lebanon to
recognize Israel's boundaries, and right of a country.
Additionally, Brazil called for dialogue between the parties so
that a cease-fire can be achieved and kidnapped Israeli soldiers
can be released.
At the outset of the conflict, Prime Minister
Stephen Harper said âIsrael has the right to
defend itself,â adding âI think Israel's response under the
circumstances has been measured.â Regarding resolution to the
conflict he stated âIt's essential that Hezbollah and Hamas release
their Israeli prisoners and any countries in that area that have
influence on these organizations should encourage an end to
violence and recognize and encourage the recognition of Israel's
right to exist.âHarper's
characterisation of Israel's response as "measured" created
controversy in Canada. On 17 July 2006, Harper appeared to moderate
these remarks, noting that the situation had deteriorated since his
initial comments, but that it was difficult for Israel to fight
"non-governmental forces" when they are embedded in the civilian
population. Harper added that "the attack [on Israel] is the cause
of this immediate conflict," and that "Israel must show restraint
as part of the solution but it is essential that the attacks
against Israel would stop and it is essential that Israeli soldiers
be returned to Israel."
Opinions on the conflict are mixed in Canada, as is reflected by
the editorial content of the nation's media. Some outlets, such as
the
Toronto Star, have criticized
Israel's response to Hezbollah's actions as disproportionate, while
right-wing publications such as the
National Post, have come out in support of the
scope of Israel's military action and the position the Canadian
government has taken, and have criticized those who have called the
evacuation of Canadians in the region too slow. Commentators in
other outlets (for example, the
Globe and
Mail and the
CBC) have represented a
variety of views. Canada has a large Lebanese community. About
30,000 Canadians, mainly of Lebanese descent, were in Lebanon at
the time hostilities broke out, and the Canadian government has
been making efforts to evacuate those who wish to leave in an
operation that has been criticized for being slow and inefficient.
On 17
July, a group of protesters, primarily expatriate Lebanese,
gathered in front of the Israeli consulate in Montreal
and protested the continued bombing in
Lebanon. Further protests took place on 22 July in
localities across Canada.
A poll of Canadians published in the 25 July edition of the
National Post shows that support among Canadians (bar Quebec) is
greatly on the side of Israel; with 64% stating that "Israel's
action was either somewhat or completely justified". In all
provinces except Quebec support was greater than 50%, with British
Columbia, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, Alberta and Ontario having the
highest support for Israel (in that order). When asked which side
of the conflict should make a major compromise in order to have a
ceasefire, 63% of Canadians said it was "those who kidnapped the
Israeli soldiers."
In recent days, Harper and his former
Foreign Affairs
Minister,
Peter MacKay (now
Minister of Defence), have reiterated their support for Israel's
position, while urging restraint and calling for a ceasefire.
Speaking of the situation in both Lebanon and Gaza on 18 July,
Harper told reporters, "We all want to encourage not just a
ceasefire, but a resolution. And a resolution will only be achieved
when everyone gets to the table and everyone admits that
recognition of each other," Mr. Harper said, referring to the
refusal of Hezbollah and Hamas to recognize Israel's right to
exist. Harper laid the blame for the civilian deaths on both sides
at the feet of Hezbollah. "Hezbollah's objective is violence,"
Harper asserted, "Hezbollah believes that through violence it can
create, it can bring about the destruction of Israel. Violence will
not bring about the destruction of Israel ... and inevitably the
result of the violence will be the deaths primarily of innocent
people."
Prime Minister Stephen Harper said he does not favour sending
Canadian troops to southern Lebanon as part of a multinational
peacekeeping force, adding that countries in the area should be
responsible for resolving the conflict.
On 6
August 2006, Bloc Québécois
leader Gilles Duceppe was accused of
supporting Hezbollah by Israel
's ambassador
to Canada, Alan Baker after
Duceppe participated in a march in Montreal
protesting the war in Lebanon
.
"The New York Times reported Saturday that the U.S. agreed to speed
delivery of satellite and laser-guided bombs [to Israel], at
Israel's request." The shipment was not publicly announced..
In addition, the United States has thus far rejected what it
considers to be meaningless calls for a cease-fire
[319688]. "The Bush administration has openly
rejected calls for a ceasefire. The New York Times reports that
U.S. and Israeli officials have agreed the bombings will continue
for another week." "On Tuesday [18 July 2006] Secretary of State
Condoleezza Rice rejected an
immediate ceasefire and said one could only occur once certain
conditions are met."
John Bolton, the U.S.
Ambassador to the United Nations, rejected the call for
a ceasefire.
[He said]: "The notion that you just declare a
ceasefire and act as if that is going to solve the problem, I think
is simplistic.â
US unilateral opposition in the UN Security Council:
On Saturday [15 July 2006] the United Nations Security
Council again rejected pleas from Lebanon that it call for an
immediate cease-fire between Israel and Lebanon.
The Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported the U.S. was the
sole member of the 15-nation UN body to oppose any council action
at all at this time.
In sharp contrast to public policy, however, 65% of Americans say
"the U.S. [should] stay out of the situation" between Israel and
Hezbollah.
The United States government has blamed Hezbollah and Syria for the
crisis.
President
George W. Bush said âI want the world to address the
root cause of the problem, and the root cause of the problem is
Hezbollah.â
Assistant
Secretary of State for Near Eastern Affairs David Welch condemns what he calls a âdangerous
escalationâ and calls for the release of the Israeli soldiers.
United States
Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist
said, âWe must hold the governments of Syria and Iran accountable
for their continued support to Hezbollah.
So long as these
governments are failing to live up to their responsibilities, no
one should question the right of the government of Israel to act in
self-defense against terrorists operating from Lebanon.â Frist also
said that the Lebanese
government should uphold its responsibility under a
United Nations resolution
to make sure its territory isnât being used for Hezbollah or other
groups. President Bush remarked that Israel
has the
right to defend itself. âThe soldiers need to be returned,â
he said. âItâs really sad where people are willing to take innocent
life in order to stop that progress (for peace). As a matter of
fact, itâs pathetic.â He also said, âThe democracy of Lebanon is an
important part of laying a foundation of peace in that region,â and
âThe concern is that any activities by Israel to protect herself
will weaken the (
Siniora)
government.âThe President also rejected Lebanon's calls for a
cease-fire in escalating Mideast violence on Friday, saying only
that Israel should try to limit civilian casualties as it steps up
attacks on its neighbor. âThe president is not going to make
military decisions for Israel,â said White House spokesman
Tony Snow.. Bush also told UK PM
Tony Blair that âWeâre not blaming Israel and
weâre not blaming the Lebanese governmentâ in a conversation that
was intended to be private, but was picked up by the
G8 television network.
On 15 July President Bush called upon Syria to exert its influence
over Hezbollah militants to get them to âlay down their armsâ. US
President George W. Bush rejected calls for a ceasefire stating
only that Israel should try to limit civilian casualties as it
steps up attacks on its neighbor.
On 15
July the United States sent a security team to Beirut
in an effort
to begin planning the evacuation of American citizens from Lebanon
to Cyprus
.
The U.S.
is believed to be using the facilities at the British Sovereign Base Areas on Cyprus
, which
includes RAF
Akrotiri
.
On 17 July, President Bush and Prime Minister Blair were caught
having a candid conversation at the G8 conference when their
comments were broadcast by a live microphone. "What about Kofi
Annan?" Bush asked. "I don't like the sequence of it. His attitude
is basically cease-fire and everything else happens." "I think the
thing that is really difficult is you can't stop this unless you
get this international presence agreed," Blair responded. Bush
reasserted his view that the impetus needed to be placed on
Hezbollah to end the conflict. "What they need to do is get Syria
to get Hezbollah to stop doing this shit, and it's over," Bush told
Blair.
US Ambassador to the UN
John Bolton
said there was no moral equivalence between the civilian casualties
from the Israeli raids in Lebanon and those killed in Israel from
"malicious terrorist acts". Asked to comment on the deaths in an
Israeli air strike of eight Canadian citizens in southern Lebanon
Sunday, he said: "it is a matter of great concern to us ...that
these civilian deaths are occurring. It's a tragedy." "I think it
would be a mistake to ascribe moral equivalence to civilians who
die as the direct result of malicious terrorist acts," he added,
while defending as "self-defense" Israel's military action, which
has had "the tragic and unfortunate consequence of civilian
deaths".
[President Bush:] Everybody abhors the
loss of innocent life.
On the other hand, what we recognize is that the root
cause of the problem is Hezbollah.
And that problem must be addressed.
And it can be addressed internationally by making it
clear to Syria that they've got to stop their support to
Hezbollah.
Syria's trying to get back into Lebanon, it looks like
to me.
.
.
.
Sometimes it requires tragic situations to help bring
clarity in the international community.
And it is now clear for all to see that there are
terrorist elements who want to destroy our democratic friends and
allies, and the world must work to prevent them from doing
so.
As the campaign in Lebanon began, on 14 July, the US Congress was
notified of a potential sale of $210 million worth of jet fuel to
Israel. The Defense Security Cooperation Agency noted that the sale
of the
JP-8 fuel, should it be completed, will
"enable Israel to maintain the operational capability of its
aircraft inventory." and "The jet fuel will be consumed while the
aircraft is in use to keep peace and security in the region." It
was reported on 24 July that the United States was in the process
of providing Israel with "bunker buster" bombs, which would
allegedly be used to target the leader of Lebanon's Hezbollah
guerrilla group and destroy its trenches.
Al-Manar TV reported
on 26 July that the shipment arrived in Israel via Gulf States
including Qatar
and Saudi Arabia
on 25 July.
United States President
George W.
Bush supports the Israeli action and
on 13 July said Israel has a right to defend itself. At the G8
Summit, President Bush said "the root of the problem is Hezbollah"
and that the U.S. is "never going to tell a nation how to defend
herself." Canadian Prime Minister
Stephen
Harper expressed his support for Israel's actions, calling the
Israeli response "measured". According to
Reuters and the
New York
Times, the Bush administration authorized the expedited
processing and shipment of precision-guided bombs (already allotted
for sale in 2005) to Israel to support the Israeli campaign, but
did not announce the increased haste publicly.
On 25 July Hassan Nasrallah, Hezbollah's secretary general, said
the Israeli onslaught was an attempt by the US and Israel to
"impose a new Middle East" in which Lebanon would be under US
hegemony.
[319689]
On 30
July immediately following the IAF bombing of Qana
in which a
large number of fatalies took place Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice reportedly stated:
"We [the United States Government] want a
ceasefire as soon as possible, I would have wanted a ceasefire
yesterday if possible, but the parties have to agree to a ceasefire
and there have to be certain conditions in
place...
Any ceasefire has to have circumstances that are going
to be acceptable to the parties."
Rice's
comments came after an earlier television address by the Lebanese
Prime Minister in which he indicated that the meetings scheduled
with Rice that day were cancelled due to the events at
Qana
.
Senate and Congress
On 18 July the
US Senate passed
S.Res. 534 98-0 by unanimous Consent, "Condemning Hezbollah and
Hamas and their state sponsors and supporting Israel's exercise of
its right to self-defense". Resolution 534 calls for the release of
Israeli soldiers who are being held captive by Hezbollah or Hamas;
condemns the governments of Iran and Syria for their continued
support for Hezbollah and Hamas; urges all sides to protect
innocent civilian life andinfrastructure; and strongly supports the
use of all diplomatic means available to freethe captured Israeli
soldiers. However, Senator
Chuck Hagel
eventually came to demand that the U.S. impose a ceasefire.
On 20 July 2006, the
US House of
Representatives passed resolution 921 supporting Israelâs right
to defend itself and condemning attacks against the State of
Israel. The final vote was 410 to 8 in favour of the
resolution.
On 30 July Congress sent a letter to the EU's Head of Foreign
Policy
Javier Solana, asking that the
EU add Hezbollah to its list of illegal terrorist organisations.
The letter, signed by 210 members of Congress.
"We were dismayed to hear your 19 July assertion that
the EU lacked 'sufficient data' to add Hizbullah to its terrorist
list."
Members of Congress had already called on the EU, via a 2005
resolution, to add Hezbollah to the list. The EU declined all
requests.
Foreign DiplomatsOn 12 July 2006, during a CNN
interview, Lebanese Ambassador to the U.S.
Farid Abboud made some controversial comments
that created a stir in Lebanon, forcing the government to recall
Ambassador Farid Abboudto Beruit.
Ali Rodriguez, Foreign Minister of
Venezuela, condemned Israel activities in Lebanon.On 3 August,
Venezuelan president
Hugo ChĂĄvez
declared he has withdrawn his country's ambassador from Israel to
show his indignation over the military offensive in Lebanon. . He
called the Israeli attacks in Lebanon "
genocide". He also spoke after returning from an
international tour that included Iran. While there, Chavez called
the Israeli offensive in Lebanon a "fascist outrage."
"The Israeli elite repeatedly criticize Hitler's actions against
the Jews, and indeed Hitler's actions must be criticized, not just
against the Jews but against the world," Chavez said during his
visit to Iran, adding: "It's also fascism what Israel is doing to
the Palestinian people ... terrorism and fascism."
In an interview with Qatar-based Al Jazeera television, Chavez also
slammed U.S. backing for Israel, describing Washington as a
"Dracula always searching for oil and blood". "The Israeli
offensive against the Palestinians and Lebanon is an aggression
that we feel targets us also. It is an unjustified aggression that
is being carried out in the style of (Adolf) Hitler, in a Fascist
fashion," he said, referring to the leader of Nazi Germany. "They
(Israelis) are doing what Hitler did against the Jews. They are
killing innocent children and whole families," he said in the
remarks dubbed in Arabic.
9 August, it was known that Venezuela is likely to sever ties with
Israel in protest at its war against Lebanon, according to
statements by President Hugo ChĂĄvez. "They have also recalled their
ambassador and our next step will most likely be to break off
diplomatic relations. I have no interest in maintaining diplomatic
relations, or offices, or businesses, or anything with a state like
Israel.".
Oceania
Prime Minister
John Howard has stated
that he is "appalled at the loss of life on both sides". However,
he blamed the conflict on Hezbollah's breaches of UN resolutions
and international law.
Africa
Foreign minister
Aziz Pahad said that the
South African Government was "greatly concerned" about the
increasing violence between Israel, Palestine and Lebanon, fearing
that it would lead to a "catastrophe and a possible regional war"
in the Middle East.
Reactions by international organizations
Amnesty International
A press release by Amnesty International on 13 July condemns
attacks by both Israel and Hezbollah as "a blatant breach of
international humanitarian law and amount to war crimes." A
briefing presented facts "strongly suggesting" that Israel's
"extensive destruction" and "widespread attacks against public
civilian infrastructure" was "deliberate and an integral part of
the military strategy, rather than
collateral damage". This behaviour
suggested "a policy of punishing both the Lebanese government and
the civilian population" in an effort to turn them against
Hezbollah. The report also states that Israel to preserve the
principle of proportionality, even if the
destroyed objects could serve a dual purpose. It called for an
independent and impartial inquiry appointed by UN, to investigate
alleged war crimes by both Hezbollah and Israel.
The Arab League has called Hezbollah's attacks on Israel
"unexpected, inappropriate, and irresponsible acts," in the words
of Saudi Arabia's foreign minister, Prince
Saud Al-Faisal. The Arab League says they
have âfears of widening of tension and possible Israeli strike
against Syria,â âItâs up to the resistance â both the Lebanese and
the Palestinian â to decide what they are doing and why are they
fighting.â
Following
a meeting of Arab League foreign ministers in Cairo
on 16 July,
Secretary-General Amr Moussa declared
that "The Middle East process is dead" and that "The only way to
revive the peace process is to take it back to theSecurity
Council".
Association of Southeast Asian Nations
At its Annual Ministerial Meeting in Kuala Lumpur, ASEAN delegates
condemn the violence and destruction in the Middle East. They urge
all parties to practice utmost constrain in avoiding civilian
casualties.
Finland, which held the European Union's rotating presidency,
issued the following statement: "The European Union is greatly
concerned about the disproportionate use of force by Israel in
Lebanon in response to attacks by Hezbollah on Israel. The
presidency deplores the loss of civilian lives and the destruction
of civilian infrastructure. The imposition of an air and sea
blockade on Lebanon cannot be justified."
On 28 July 2006 a senior EU delegation threw its support behind the
Lebanese Prime Minister
Fuad Siniora's
7-point plan. The Finnish Foreign Minister
Erkki Tuomioja, representing the
EU presidency, said Siniora's plan was a "good
basis to reach an agreement", and that he was "struck by the unity
of the Lebanese government".
On 8 August 2006 the European Union issued a memo in which it
outlined its response to the conflict.
Human Rights Watch
A press release by Human Rights Watch issued on 3 August accuses
Israeli forces of "hav[ing] systematically failed to distinguish
between combatants and civilians in their military campaign against
Hezbollah in Lebanon". In a 50-page report, the human rights
organization analyzed almost two dozen cases of Israeli air and
artillery attacks on civilian homes and vehicles. âThe pattern of
attacks shows the Israeli militaryâs disturbing disregard for the
lives of Lebanese civilians,â said Kenneth Roth, executive director
of Human Rights Watch. âOur research shows that Israelâs claim that
Hezbollah fighters are hiding among civilians does not explain, let
alone justify, Israelâs indiscriminate warfare.â
The "Indiscriminate Bombing in Lebanon [is] a War Crime"
International Red Cross
The International Committee of the Red Cross stated that they have
"serious questions" regarding the actions of Israeli forces in
Lebanon. ICRC director of operations Pierre Kraehenbuehl stated at
a press conference in Geneva that "The high number of civilian
casualties and the extent of damage to essential public
infrastructure raise serious questions regarding respect for the
principle of proportionality in the conduct of hostilities." The
ICRC is responsible for protecting the
Geneva Conventions, which discuss the
rules of war. The IRCR stated that these rules not only apply to
Israel, but also to Hezbollah militants
According to
Democracy Now!, "The International Committee
of the Red Cross also criticized Israel for killing so many
civilians and for destroying much of Lebanonâs public
infrastructure."
Non-Aligned Movement
The Non-Aligned Movement has condemned what they claim to be
disproportionate Israeli attacks on Gaza and Lebanon and called for
an international force to be deployed to prevent the violence from
spiralling into a regional conflict.
[319690] [319691] [319692]
The Organization of Islamic Conference has called for the convening
of the
United Nations
General Assembly in 'emergency special session', under the
terms of the "
Uniting for Peace"
resolution, if the Security Council fails to act immediately in the
crisis.
[319693]
Reactions by communities and citizens
On the 22 July 2006, between 10,000 and 20,000 Sydney residents,
mostly of Lebanese & Arab heritage, flocked onto George Street
in the city's
CBD.There
was a huge police presence, including riot police, mounted police,
dog squads and helicopters. Arab communities have not mobilised in
this scale for years in this rally organised by 30 community
organisations and the Stop The War Coalition. Similar protests were
also held in other major cities across Australia. In Melbourne,
there were 10,000, in Brisbane 500 and in Canberra 300. Slide show
here of rallies

Lebanese protest in Sydney, 22 July
2006
On the 19
July, about 2000 members of Sydney's Jewish community held peace
vigil and service at the Sydney Great Synagogue
.
On the 29
July, between 200 and 400 protestors in support of Lebanon and
Palestinians marched in Perth, Western Australia
. The rally had been organised by the Perth
Peace Group and Socialist Alliance with the aim of a peaceful
protest. After marching through the Central Business District
(CBD), the rally moved to the Sheraton hotel where John Howard was
giving a a keynote address to the
Western Australia Liberals state
conference. As Howard exited the building protesters gathered in
numbers, and chanted "Shame" and "We want peace," with some
protestors surging towards his car. Light scuffles broke out,
followed by two arrests.
A follow-up rally was held in solidarity
outside of the East Perth
police watch house, protesters dispersed shortly
afterwards.
An
anti-Israeli protest of 70 people was held in the Azerbaijani
town of Nardaran
. The protestors burnt flags of Israel and
the United States, chanting slogans condemning Israel. Local
resident Haji Alikram Aliyev declared of the government, "They do
not fear Allah but Jews. We cannot keep silence in this case or
else it will be betrayal," he said. "Azerbaijani parliament should
follow the Turkish parliament and abolish the Israel-Azerbaijan
friendship commission."
There has
also been a demonstration in Brussels
against Israel's military actions.
The families of the kidnapped Israelis met with European Union
parliament members in Brussels to appeal for help in obtaining a
sign of life from their loved ones. Thousands rallied in Brussels
for Israel and demanding the release of the abducted soldiers.
[319694]
There are
programed (and one already have happened) two demonstration in
SĂŁo
Paulo
against Israel.
In
Montreal
, Canadians protested against Israel and against
Canadian Prime Minister Stephen
Harper near the Israeli consulate, while supporters of Israel
praised Harper.
In
Montreal, 22 July 2006, an estimated 1,000 protesters marched along
west Sainte-Catherine Street
then south on Jeanne-Mance before rallying outside
ComplÚxe Léo-Parizeau on boulevard René-Lévesque.
Politicians participating included
Maria
Mourani and
Francine Lalonde of
the
Bloc Québécois.
La Presse
gave the story front page coverage.
Montreal, 30 July 2006, an estimated 3,000 protesters gathered in
Dorchester Square outside the Israeli Consulate at boulevard
René-Lévesque and rue Peel.Demonstrators marched north on Peel,
east on Sainte-Catherine, north on Mansfield, west on de Maisoneuve
then south on Peel, returning to the starting point.
What had been planned
as a vigil became a much larger event with the news of the Qana
attack the
day before. Emotions were quite raw, and while the
demonstration was peaceful, some protesters openly supported
Hezbollah.

Protest in Montreal, Canada 6 August
2006
Montreal, 6 August 2006 an estimated 15,000 protesters assembled at
Parc Lafontaine at 13h00. At 14h00 they marched north on rue de la
Roche, west on avenue du Mont Royal, south on rue Saint-Denis and
finally west on boulevard René-Lévesque. March halted outside the
federal government building, ComplÚxe Léo-Parizeau at approximately
16h00. Politicians participating in the protest included
Gilles Duceppe, leader of
Bloc Québécois,
André Boisclair, leader of
Parti Québécois, Liberal MP
Denis Coderre and Quebec
Green Party chief
Scott McKay. A group of
Neturei Karta Orthodox Jews, came from New
York City to attend the protest. Protest was peaceful, police
presence was almost exclusively for traffic control.
Despite the protests, a poll of Canadians published in the 25 July
edition of the
National Post
shows that support among Canadians (bar Quebec) is greatly on the
side of Israel; with 64% stating that "Israel's action was either
somewhat or completely justified". In all provinces except Quebec
support was greater than 50%, with British Columbia, Saskatchewan,
Manitoba, Alberta and Ontario having the highest support for Israel
(in that order). When asked which side of the conflict should make
a major compromise in order to have a ceasefire, 63% of Canadians
said it was "those who kidnapped the Israeli soldiers."
A Strategic Counsel poll for
CTV and
The Globe and Mail, published 1
August 2006, showed that the Harper government's open support of
Israel is opposed by 45% of the Canadian public, while 32% support
it.
Again
in Quebec
opposition
was strongest, 63% being opposed to the government's position,
while 17% support it. On the question of Canadian
neutrality, 77% of Canadians stated Canada should remain neutral,
16% stated Canada should support Israel and 1% stated Canada should
support Hezbollah.
On 21
July 2006, a pro-Israel demonstration was
held on the central square of Copenhagen
, with the theme "Secure borders for
everybody". A
Gallup poll on 5
August, showed an overwhelming Danish support for the Israeli side
of the conflict, with 48% saying they had most sympathy for Israel
while the "Shia Muslim militia" only found support by 7%
On 28 July it was reported that around 1,000 demonstrators gathered
in Cairo to protest. Waving copies of the Qur'an chanted the crowd
was heard to chant: "O Sunni, O Shia, let's fight the Jews," and
"the Jews and the Americans are killing our brothers in Lebanon."
The protest had been organised by the
Muslim Brotherhood.
On 20
August around 2,800 people rallied in the Finnish capital of
Helsinki
to show their support for Israel.
An anti-American/anti-Israel/anti-capitalist rally took place in
Berlin.
[319695]
A
pro-Israel rally took place in Dusseldorf
.[319696][319697]
Approximately 150 people gathered at Austurvöllur square outside
the
AlĂŸingi to protest against Israeli
action in Lebanon on 13 July.
While the
overall attitude of Indian citizenry regarding the 2006
Israel-Lebanon conflict has been noncommital, there is a growing
circle of Indian bloggers and opinion page writers who express
support for Israel
on this
issue. They compare Israel's response with the Indian
Government's response to the
11 July 2006 Mumbai train
bombings and feel that the reaction has been too soft. Many
wish for the same level response as Israel's retaliation towards
Hezbollah.. In particular, an Indian blogger writes:
"The unanimity, determination and the promptness
involved in their arriving at the decision to root out Hizbollah
... deserves accolades!! [It is the] sharpest of contrasts to the
callousness of Indian polity."
The post attracted pages of responses, including many comparing
Indian politicians unfavorably to Israelis. Similarly,
editorialists in The
Pioneer,
one of India's newspapers, argued that Delhi should follow Israel's
example and attack Pakistan to show that it "cannot escape blame
for its surrogates' actions", alluding to accusations made by the
Indian Government and media of Pakistan's involvement in
Terrorism in Kashmir.
Hindu Unity, a prominent but
controversial
Hindu Nationalist
website, has displayed a poster and a caption that advertises
support for Israel in the 2006 Israel-Lebanon conflict
[319698] and
aggressively encourages Indians to do the same.
On 16
July Thousands of protesters have rallied in Jakarta
to condemn the Israeli attacks on the Palestinian
territories and Lebanon. On 28 July thousands of
demonstrators gathered in several cities with banners portraying
Israeli Prime Minister
Ehud Olmert and
American President
George W. Bush as "the real terrorists". During a
protest outside the US embassy in Jakarta a speaker stated:
"It's ironic that America shouts about peace and
democracy, and then supports Israel when it kills innocent
Muslims.
How can they stop terrorism against the west if they
always make Muslims angry?"
Thousands of Iraqis demonstrated in Baghdad on 14 July, praising
the leader of Hezbollah and denouncing Israel and the United States
for attacks against Lebanon. Some protesters said they were ready
to fight the Israelis.
On 26
July, volunteers willing to fight alongside Hezbollah in Lebanon
were recruited at a Shiite party headquarters in Basra
. The
party's Secretary General Yousif al Mousawi said about 200 people
signed up within two hours. One recruit was quoted as saying: "We
cannot stand by and watch our Hezbollah brothers fight alone.. If
we are to die in Lebanon, then we will go to heaven. It is our duty
as Muslims to fight."
On 4 August 200,000+ Iraqi Shiites filled the streets of the Shiite
dominated Sadr City following calls to attend a rally in support of
Hezbollah's resistance. The calls were made by cleric
Muqtada al-Sadr. The crowd reportedly
chanted: "Death to Israel, death to America!!"
On 18
July, thousands of Iranians poured into the streets of Tehran
and staged
a mass rally to condemn the attacks by Israel on Gaza and
Lebanon.
On 31 July, a
TrĂłcaire organised peace
rally took place outside the United States embassy in Dublin. The
rally attended by hundreds of people, including Lebanese citizens,
demanded an end to the present conflict.
On 31
July, the Irish
Film Institute
canceled the sponsorship provided by the Embassy of
Israel in Ireland for 'Walk on Water', one of the films being
screened at the Dublin Gay and Lesbian Film Festival, due to the
current Israeli activities in the Lebanon.
On 12
July 2006, just a few hours following the Israeli attack on Lebanon
started, about 100-200 people in Tel Aviv
protested in front of the Israeli Ministry of Defense
against the attack. On 16 July, about 1,000 people demonstrated
in Tel
Aviv
against the war. On 22 July 2,500 people,
including both Jews and Arabs, gathered in Tel Aviv to demonstrate
against the war. A demonstration was also held in Haifa on the same
date but was called off after air raid sirens sounded. On 28 July,
a "die-in" demonstration, with red paint being put on
demonstrators' shirts and demonstrators lying on the ground to
dramatise their point of view, took place in Tel Aviv.
On Saturday 5 August, nearly 10,000 (according to organizers)
people demonstrated in Tel Aviv against the war in Lebanon.
Participating organisations included
Gush
Shalom, the Women's Coalition for Peace,
Ta'ayush,
Anarchists Against the Wall,
Yesh Gvul, the
Israeli
Palestinian Bereaved Families for Peace, and political parties
Hadash,
Balad and the
United Arab List.
A poll taken 28 July by the Dahuf Institute for the newspaper
Yedioth Ahronoth found
that seven in ten (71%) supported using more military force in
Lebanon. Asked what Israelâs next step should be, 48 percent said
fight until Hezbollah is destroyed, 30 percent said drive the
militia away from the border, and 21 percent said to negotiate with
Hezbollah.
On 31
August, mass rally of tens of thousands of people in Rabin Square
called for the release of the three kidnapped IDF
soldiers.[319699]
Various demonstrations were also held in Jordan, most were in front
of the UN headquarters, embassies, and other influential
organizations.
The day after Hezbollah's 12 July attack on Israel, Sheik Hamid
al-Ali issued an informal statement titled "The Sharia position on
what is going on." In it, the Kuwaiti based cleric condemned the
imperial ambitions of Iran regarding Hezbollah's cross border
raid.
[319700]
Also on the National Flag grounds in Kuwait City hundreds gathered
to express support to Hezbollah.
A large
group of over 2,000 gathered in front of a mosque near the Petronas
Twin Towers
in Kuala
Lumpur
right after Friday
prayer. The group later marched to several embassies to
demand international community to intervene in the conflict and
condemn Israeli aggression.
A larger group also assembled in Kota Bahru
to condemn the attack.
The Netherlands
5,000
people demonstrated in Amsterdam
against the Israeli military actions in
Lebanon.[319701]
On
Saturday 22 July, two hundred people demonstrated in Aotea Square
in Auckland
. One protester lowered the
American flag and began waving a
Palestinian flag. Police were prevented
from arresting him after protestors intervened.
Over the weekend 4-7 August there were
mobilisations across New Zealand calling for an end to Israeli
aggression.
In
Auckland
around 300 people braved pouring rain to hold a
lively march and rally to call for an end to US and Israeli
imperialism in the Middle East.
Demonstrators staged a
die-in at the US
consulate before burning US and Israeli flags.
In
Auckland
a protest was held outside a Ponsonby mosque
demanding the deportation of Palestinian and Lebanese
immigrants.
In
Wellington
a few hundred protestors marched down Lambton Quay to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs
and Trade as part of a Wellington Palestine Group protest to demand
that the government not allow Israel to reopen its embassy in New
Zealand until such time as Israel has ceased from the war,
demolished the security fence, withdrawn from territory and help
Palestinian refugees [319702].
In
Dunedin
an emergency demonstration against the war
attracted 250-300 people who marched on the Octagon via Labour MP
Pete Hodgson's office and called on the
government not to resume any military joint-training exercises with
the USA (something Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters was trying desperately to
secure on his latest trip to Washington DC).
The
National
Distribution Union who represent packing and distribution
workers in New Zealand has condemned the Israeli air strike on a
Lebanese fruit-packing warehouse that killed 33 farm workers. A
group called 'Aotearoa
Jews for
Justice' says they stand "in solidarity with the Lebanese and
Palestinian people suffering at the hands of the Israeli
army."
Amnesty
International held vigils for peace in six major New Zealand
cities on the night of Monday 7 August calling for an end to all
violence.
Abdullah bin Jabreen, one of Saudi Arabia's leading
Wahhabi sheiks, issued a strongly worded
fatwa declaring it unlawful to support, join or
pray for
Shiite Hezbollah.
[319703]
On 22
July 1,500 people marched in Stockholm
against the Israeli bombings in Lebanon.
Demonstrations were also held in Gothenburg
, Malmö
, and many
other Swedish cities on the same day.
On 22
July, approximately 1,500 people demonstrated in Oslo
in front
of the Norwegian Parliament, in protest against Israeli military
actions in Lebanon. The demonstration then proceeded to the
Israeli embassy.
The same repeated on 5 August, with about 1,000 people taking part
in the demonstration.
Thousands of protesters have thronged the streets of central
Damascus to protest against Israel and support Hezbollah.
Tens of
thousands of people gathered in Turkey's southeastern Diyarbakır
Province
on 16 July to protest against the Israeli offensive
in the Gaza Strip and against the Israeli attacks on
Lebanon.
On 22 July, between 7,000 (according to the police) and 20,000
(according to organisers) people demonstrated in London in protest
against the Israeli military actions in Lebanon. Demonstrations
also took place in 10 other cities across the United Kingdom,
including between 1,000 and 2,000 in Manchester.
A pro-Israel
rally was
held a day later. That weekend, an anti-Israel protest was
held at a Davis Cup tennis match between Great Britain and Israel in
Eastbourne
.
Smaller demonstrations and vigils have also been taking place.
For
example, a vigil was held in Parliament Square
on 18 July. Another protest was held in front of
Downing
Street
on 28 July, organised by the Stop the War Coalition and the
CND. Worker-Communist Party of Iran
organised a 3-day picket against the war in front of Israeli
Embassy in London from 26 July to 28 July.
[319704]
30 July
protestors at Scotland's Prestwick Airport
managed to have a chartered plane laden with bombs
on route from Texas to Tel Aviv diverted to RAF
Mildenhall
in Suffolk, England due to their protests. The
bombs are part of a series of agreed arms shipments between the
United States Government and Israel and were diverted originally
from Irish airspace as the Irish Government refused to allow the
aircraft permission to land. The transport of weapons to Israel via
British airspace has caused embarrassment for the British
Government although the shipments are to continue.
More than
a thousand demonstrated outside of the United
Nations headquarters
to support Israel and denounce Hezbollah.
Senator
Hillary Clinton and New York
Mayor
Michael Bloomberg attended
to show support. "We are here to show solidarity and support for
Israel," said Clinton. "We will stand with Israel, because Israel
is standing for American values as well as Israeli ones."
She
condemned Hamas, Hezbollah, Syria
, and
Iran
. [319705] Meanwhile, 10,000 Arab Americans demonstrated against Israel's
actions in Dearborn,
Michigan
.
In
Atlanta
, about 5,000 came to support Israel's defense and
military efforts and denounce Hezbollah, Hamas, and
al-Qaeda. Among them were US Congressman
David Scott, and Georgia Governor
Sonny Perdue.
In
Seattle,
Washington
, 2,000 gathered to support America's
"sister-nation" (Israel) waving American and Israeli flags,
denouncing the "unprovoked actions of Hezbollah and Hamas," and
asserting Israel's "right to protect and defend herself...
The international community must not be silent or shelter
terrorists." Among the supporters were Congressman
Dave Reichert, his political opponent
Darcy Burner, Michael Spektor of
AIPAC, Presbyterian Reverend Leland Seese, Jr. (a
long-time critic of Israel, prior), and some local rabbis. Congress
Reichert received a standing ovation after saying "no other nation
has given land for peace -- we now need to stand with Israel in its
fight against terror and for freedom... Like Ronald Reagan, I'd
like to see peace in Israel during our time."
In Los Angeles, 5,000 "Arabs and progressives", according to an
activist, marched through downtown L.A. to protest against Israel
and the U.S. and for the Palestinians and Lebanon. Speakers outside
the federal building included the participants from the
A.N.S.W.E.R. Committee, National Council of Arab
Americans, Muslim American Society, Council on American
Islamic Relations, Jim Lafferty of the National Lawyers Guild, Bill Paparian
the Green Party Candidate for Congress, Project Islamic Hope,
KPFK
90.7 FM, Yael Koran of Women in Black, Shakeel Syed of the Islamic
Shura Council of Southern California, Mahmud Ahmad of Al-Awda
Palestine Right to Return Coalition, Kim Baglieri of the Alliance
for Just and Lasting Peace in the Philippines, Phyllis Kim of
Korean Americans for Peace, Carlos Alvarez of the Party for Socialism and
Liberation and Bernie Moto of the FMLN. The rally was
also against the
Iraq War.
On 12 August 2006, thousands (according to the
New York
Times) (organizers say 30,000), of mostly Muslims "rallied
near the White House on Saturday to protest what they described as
Israeli aggression in Lebanon and the United States' unwavering
support for Israel." Speakers included former
Attorney General (and legal defender of
Saddam Hussein)
Ramsey Clark, Muslim American Society Freedom
Foundation, Partnership for Civil Justice, A.N.S.W.E.R. Coalition,
National Council of Arab Americans, Osama Siblani Publisher at Arab
American News, and Dr. Clovis Maksoud the former ambassador from
the
Arab League to the U.N,
American-Arab
Anti-Discrimination Committee. This was the largest rally
against Israeli aggression in America since the Gaza and Lebanon
conflicts began. The protest was one of several held around the
country. When a woman started to burn an Israeli flag at one such
rally in San Francisco, police rushed toward her and then other
demonstrators joined the fracas, resulting in one arrest. A counter
protest of a few hundred people was organized by San Francisco
Voice for Israel in San Francisco.
In Los Angeles, 6,000 to 10,000 (some sources say 6,000-8,000, many
say 10,000) demonstrated in support of Israel and against
Hezbollah, waving Israeli and American flags.
The pro-Israel rally
included Hollywood actor and California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, Los Angeles
Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa,
Councilman Jack Weiss, Congressman
Howard Berman (D), County Supervisor
Zev Yaroslavsky, Wiesenthal
Institute
Head Rabbi Marvin Hier,
Israeli General Consul Ehud Danoch,
candidate for Calif. State Assembly Steven
Sion (R), various rabbis and heads of Christian
churches. A counter-rally of Arab Muslims waving Palestinian
and Lebanese flags was on the opposite side of the street and
numbered about 100. Large police forces guarded the area and
streets and prevented Arab Hizbullah/Hamas supporters from entering
the demonstration.
[319706] The governor stated at the rally, "All of
California stands by Israel in its just struggle against extremist
Islamic terror organizations who oppose all peace arrangements."
The speakers at the rally harshly condemned Hizbullah, Hamas, Iran
and Syria, and stressed Israel's right to self-defense.
Later, at
a conference with ten rabbis from various
parts of California
including David Wolpe,
Governor Schwarzenegger said he attended the rally in part because
he had never heard an Israeli leader call for the destruction of an
Arab or Muslim nation, which he could not say the same about Arab
and Muslim leaders of countries.
A
demonstration of about 1,000 in San
Francisco
in support of Israel was attended by Senator Dianne Feinstein, and Arab-American writer
Nonie Darwish. (Pictures of the
rally, banners, and excerpts of the speech can be read
here.) Feinstein stated "Hezbollah, Damascus, Tehran
could end this now with the release all of Israeli soldiers and by
stopping the rocket attacks on Israeli communities," and said the
groups have a greater agenda. Darwish received a loud applause
after stating: "What is disproportionate is the indifferent
reaction of the international community whenever Israel is attacked
by terrorists!"
Todd Chretien and
Marsha Feinland of the smaller
Green Party and
Peace and Freedom Party who were
running against Feinstein had a small group of supporters opposing
the pro-Israel rally.
In
Baltimore,
Maryland
, over 700 people arrived in Baltimore's Holocaust Memorial to show solidarity with
Israel. Governor Robert Ehrlich,
Mayor
Martin O'Malley, and
Congressman Ben Cardin
were a few of the politicians who spoke. (See
here for pictures from the Baltimore rally.)
July 2006
Seattle Jewish Federation shooting - Naveed Afzal Haq (a
Pakistani American) walked into the Jewish Federation of Greater
Seattle building and shouted "I'm a Muslim American; I'm angry at
Israel" before shooting six women, killing one
[319707].
- 19
July 2006, Delaware
Senator Joe Biden (D) said
in an interview on Larry King
Live that the conflict "may be a real opportunity to
change the dynamic of the region... This is the first time
that everyone's on the same page.
"Not only are the Hezbollah holding Israeli soldiers hostage, but
they're holding Lebanon hostage. Half the Lebanese people are angry
at Hezbollah. The whole Sunni world understands this is a major
gambit by Iran.
"France and the European countries are united in this effort. And
so, if we're smart, we have an opportunity to use this as a very
serious uniting effort to close down Syria and put inordinate
pressure on Hezbollah."KING: Is Hezbollah the prime villain?BIDEN:
Absolutely, positively, unequivocally...
- ABC News/Washington Post Poll. Aug. 3-6, 2006.
N=1,002 adults in the US. MoE ± 3 (for all adults). 46% said Israel
and Hezbollah are both responsible for the conflict in Lebanon, 39%
said Hezbollah is most to blame, while only 7% said Israel is; 6%
were unsure, and 1% felt otherwise. The same poll found that 58%
blamed Hezbollah for the civilian casualties in Lebanon for
locating its fighters and rocket launchers in civilian areas, while
21% blame Israel for bombing Hezbollah targets those areas; 10%
both, 9% unsure, and 2% felt neither were to blame.
- A worldwide online poll conducted by Bill O'Reilly and sponsored by
MSNDirect.com in August 2006 found that of the
over 50,000 voters (majority American), 96% say that Israel should
not negotiate with Hezbollah or their demands. Only 4 percent said
yes.
Nicole Kidman along with 84 other
Hollywood elites signed their names on what read:
- We the undersigned are pained and devastated by the
civilian casualties in Israel and Lebanon caused by terrorist
actions initiated by terrorist organisations such as Hezbollah and
Hamas.
- If we do not succeed in stopping terrorism around the
world, chaos will rule and innocent people will continue to
die.
- We need to support democratic societies and stop terrorism
at all costs.
Other film gurus that signed included actors:
Michael Douglas,
Dennis Hopper,
Sylvester Stallone,
Bruce Willis,
Danny
DeVito,
Don Johnson,
James Woods,
Kelly
Preston,
Patricia Heaton and
William Hurt; and directors:
Ridley Scott,
Tony
Scott,
Michael Mann,
Dick Donner and
Sam Raimi; as well as star
tennis player
Serena Williams and
media tycoon
Rupert Murdoch.
Supporters of the ad included chairman and owner of
Paramount Pictures,
Sumner Redstone, and billionaire mogul,
Haim Saban.
- American actor-writer-producer Bill
Maher, despite heavily criticizing President Bush in the interview, said on 28
August 2006 on Larry King
Live: Absolutely and the proof of that is that they ask
Israel to maintain a level of restraint when they're attacked that
no other country would ever be asked to uphold.
I mean can you imagine if there was a terrorist organization that
took over the country on our northern border, which would be
Canada, and they started shelling us in our northern cities and
Minnesota and Bangor, Maine was being shelled, what do you think
George Bush would do?
I think he would nuke them before breakfast. And, look, you know I
don't like George Bush but he is the best president we've ever had
on Israel because for some reason he gets that.
...the media always likes the underdog or what they perceive as the
underdog, not that they're really the underdog at this point. Did
you see those pictures of Hezbollah handing out cash?
...So, you know, I feel really bad for Lebanon. I'm sorry you got
your country all bombed up. But, you know, when you let a terrorist
organization take over your country that's what's going to happen.
I'll tell you two Arab countries that never get bombed, Egypt and
Jordan, because they made a peace treaty with Israel. Try it.
According to an
NBC/
Wall Street Journal poll, when asked
whether they approve or disapprove of the job that George W. Bush
is doing in handling the military conflict between Israel and the
Lebanese group Hezbollah, 45% of Americans approve, 39%disapprove,
an 16% are not sure. When asked to think about the events of the
past week in the Middle East, 54% of Americans answered that their
sympathies are more with Israel, 11% answered more with Arab
nations, 11% both, 11% neither, and 13% not sure.
[319708]
In August
2006, University
of Chicago
political scientist John Mearsheimer accused Israel of using
the kidnapping of its soldiers by Hezbollah as an excuse to attack Lebanon and start
the 2006 Lebanon War.
Mearsheimer stated that "Israel had been planning to strike at
Hezbollah for months. Key Israelis had briefed the administration
about their intentions." When asked if there was any "hard
evidence" to support his statements, Mearsheimer cited the "public
record" and "Israeli civilian strategists," then repeated the
allegation that Israel was seeking "a cover for launching this
offensive."
Thousands
came together in the capital city, Sana'a
, on 19
July to protest the Israeli attacks against the Palestinians and
Lebanese. The demonstration was organized by the ruling and
opposition political parties.
Reactions by special interest groups
American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC)
On 18 July the
US Senate passed
S.Res. 534 98-0 by unanimous Consent, "Condemning Hezbollah and
Hamas and their state sponsors and supporting Israel's exercise of
its right to self-defense". Resolution 534 calls for the release of
Israeli soldiers who are being held captive by Hezbollah or Hamas;
condemns the governments of Iran and Syria for their continued
support for Hezbollah and Hamas; urges all sides to protect
innocent civilian life and infrastructure; and strongly supports
the use of all diplomatic means available to free the captured
Israeli soldiers. On 20 July 2006, the
US House of
Representatives passed resolution 921 supporting Israelâs right
to defend itself and condemning attacks against the State of
Israel. The final vote was 410 to 8 in favour of the
resolution.
Following the House passing Resolution 921 and the previous passage
of Senate Resolution 534 the lobbying body
American Israel Public Affairs Committee issued a
press release praising the results and asserted:
"Recent polls indicate that U.S. support for Israel is
at an all-time high and the resolutions are a reflection of the
American people's desire to stand by Israel in this time of
crisis."
On 30 July Congress sent a letter to the EU's Head of Foreign
Policy
Javier Solana, asking that the
EU add Hezbollah to its list of illegal terrorist organisations.
The letter, signed by 210 members of Congress.
"We were dismayed to hear your 19 July assertion that
the EU lacked 'sufficient data' to add Hizbullah to its terrorist
list."
Members of Congress had already called on the EU, via a 2005
resolution, to add Hezbollah to the list. American Israel Public
Affairs Committee (AIPAC) issued a statement Friday following the
signing of the letter in Congress, saying that:
"If the European Union is serious about its support for
international measures calling for Hizbullah's disarmament,
designating Hizbullah a terrorist organization is a necessary step
in that process."
The EU declined the requests.
AIPAC also had a role in defending the Israeli war effort to the
American public. A 27 July memo issued by AIPAC titled "Beirut
Largely Unscathed as Israel Targets Hezbollah Strongholds,"
advanced the idea that through "surgical strike" bombing the damage
reported in other media was exaggerated. AIPAC asserted that
following IDF bombing of the southern districts of Beirut,
"an overwhelming majority of the city remains
untouched."
On 2 August AIPAC asserted in a press release titled "The Bekka
(sic) Valley: A Terrorist Epicenter," that the Bekaa valley area
under bombardment by the IDF at that time was home to a number of
anti-Israel factions. AIPACs middle east analyst,
Josh Block was quoted in the press release as
saying:
"[It's] similar to a university setting, terrorists
from every corner of the international community have come together
in the Bekaa Valley training camps to learn how to conduct lethal
operations and utilize various types of weapons."
AIPAC then went on to list the groups it believed were operating
from the region which included the
Red
Army Faction,
Red Brigade, and the
Japanese Red Army. One commentator
remarked:
"Much of the material cited by AIPAC to back up the
press release is of dubious veracity, and the information that
links these terrorist groups to the Bekaa Valley region is years or
even decades old...
AIPAC's goal, it seems to me, is to demonstrate that
Israel's campaign in Lebanon is targeting an international,
globally-linked terrorist alliance that threatens not only the
Jewish state, but the West in general."
Christians United for Israel (CUFI)
There
were also calls of support from a second Zionist focused lobby
grouping headed by John Hagee the founder
and senior pastor of the 18,000-member evangelical Cornerstone
Church in San
Antonio
, Texas
.
Hagee, author of "Jerusalem Countdown: A Warning to the World", had
engaged in meetings with various congress members and launched a
Christian pro-Israel lobby which he said would rival AIPAC. The
five-month-old, 3,000 strong pro-Israel evangelical group
Christians United for Israel
(CUFI) attended a "Washington/Israel summit" during the week
beginning 17 July in an effort to lobby for greater congressional
and senate support for Israel, and the Israeli war effort. Hagee
was also reportedly setting up an "Israel Rapid Response" network
of e-mails, faxes and phone calls to mobilize voters. Over the
years, Hagee has reportedly donated $8.5 million US to support
Israeli hospitals and orphanages and has helped 12,000 Russian Jews
move to Israel.
References
- [1]
- Iran, Afghanistan and Tajikistan Condemn Attacks Against
Lebanon, Payvand's Iran News
- Arab World Divided Over Hezbollah - 19 July 2006 - The New
York Sun
- World divided over Mideast conflict - Al
Jazeera -15 July 2006
- Military: Slay plot foiled in Lebanon - The
Boston Globe -11 July 2006
- Egypt rules out intervention in Lebanon -
The Daily Star -27 July 2006
- Egypt's Mubarak: "No Light at the End of the
Tunnel" - TIME -27 July 2006
- Mubarak: US response to war too little, too late -
YNeynews.com -29 July 2006
- Arab Countries Denounce Hezbollah Actions,
United Press International
- Kuwait-Lebanon-Condemnation, Kuwait News
Agency
- Chinese FM Talks With Lebanese PM On Middle East
Situation Via Phone, People's Daily Online
- U.N. Observers' Calls Unheeded, Yahoo!
News
- æć ±ćłææ°è - ćźçæć°ä»„è»ç©șè„ČèĄšç€șéé©[07:24]
- LD Lebanon Reactions, Kuwait News Agency
- Yudhoyono urges Israel to stop military strikes
- The Jakarta post - 14 July 2006
- May produce thousands of bin Ladens - Verdens Gang - 4
August 2006
- Kazakhstan Calls UN Security Council To Adopt Consolidated
Resolution On Lebanon, Gazeta. Kz
- Pak Condemns Israeli Aggression Against Lebanon,
Palestine, International News Network
- Yerevan Condemns Any Violence in Near East,
PanArmenian. Net
- Armenia Extremely Concerned About Military Actions
In Lebanon, PanArmenian. Net
- Armenia Condemns Israeli Attack On Lebanon,
Armenialiberty.org, a division of Radio Free Europe
- Austrian Foreign Min: End Lebanon-Israel Conflict
Now, Easy Bourse
- Journal télévisé (19h30), La Une, 14 July 2006
- Betoging in Brussel tegen Israëlisch militair
optreden, Het Laatste Nieuws
- The Homeland is calling, Arab European
League, 13 July 2006
- Israel faces defeat, says former Bosnia high
representative, 29 July 2006
- Bulgaria concerned over growing tension in Near
East, 13 July 2006
- Danske politikere bekymret over krise i Libanon/Danish
politicians concerned about the Israel-Lebanon crisis
- Europe Looks To Mediate In Raging Middle East Conflict
- DW World - 16 July 2006
- Oireachtas Cttee condemns Mideast
bloodshed.
- PRESS RELEASE The Joint Committee on Foreign Affairs 2
August 2006
- Norway condemns Israeli attacks on Lebanon
- Norway condemns Israeli attack
- Romanian President press conference, Cotroceni Palace,
19 August 2006, 18:40 local (UTC+3), live at Realitatea TV
- [2]
- Putin Urges End To Military Action In Middle
East, RIA Novosti
-
http://www.tass.ru/eng/level2.html?NewsID=10628944&PageNum=0
- Israel bombardea el sur del LĂbano matando a 18
civiles, Informativos Telecinco
- Spain Urges Israel, Lebanon To Calm Border
Conflict, People's Daily Online
- Federal Department of Foreign Affairs Press
Release, 13 July 2006
- Federal Council Press Release, 27 July
2006
- Turkey Urges Ceasefire In Middle East,
Hemscott
- ErdoÄan: "İsrail'in derdi nedir?", CNN
Turk
- Blair Appeals For Mid East Calm, BBC News
- Vatican condemns Israel for attacks on Lebanon,
Yahoo News
- [3], CWNews.com
- The Wall Street Journal
- Cyprus News Agency: News in English,
06-07-17
- Defense Security Cooperation Agency news release 14 July 2006,
Transmittal No. 06-40, [4]
- Israel to get U.S. "bunker buster" bombs -
report, Reuters, 24 July 2006
- July 2006-voa6.cfm Bush: 'Israel Has Right to Defend
Itself'
- Ambassador Farid Abboud comments on
situation
- [5]Farid Abboud: Informational Site
- Venezuela Slams Israel For Offensive In
Lebanon, The Jerusalem Post
- >
-
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20060804/ap_on_re_la_am_ca/mideast_fighting_venezuela_1
- Hugo Chavez Compares U.S. to 'Dracula,' Israel to
'Hitler'
-
http://www.itv.com/news/world_ddd5b3eccbe0db5e2fa2210578cf3004.html
- South Africa Can Help In Middle East, IOL
- Israel / Lebanon: End attacks against civilians
immediately
- EU response to the conflict in Lebanon
- Human Rights Watch: Israel Responsible for Qana Attack - Indiscriminate
Bombing in Lebanon a War Crime
- [6], Union of Councils for Jews in the Former Soviet
Union
- Rally of Protest Staged in Nardaran, Today.Az
- Rally in Protest Against Israeli Armed Intervention in
Lebanon Staged in Nardaran, Azerbaijan, Azeri Press Information
Agency
- Comunidade libanesa mobiliza SĂŁo Paulo, cmi
brasil
- Relatives of Montrealers killed in Lebanon condemn
'massacres'
- La Presse, Dimanche 23 Juillet, 2006, page A1 continued page
A4
- CBC News: Lebanese-Canadians decry Israel in
protests across Canada
- Protests target Harper
- CBC News: Attack in Lebanon sparks Montreal
demonstration
- Israeli attack enrages Montrealers
- CBC News: Montrealers, politicians march for
Mideast peace
- CTV News: Thousands in Montreal protest Lebanon
war
- Montreal Gazette: Protesters denounce Israeli
bombings
- CTV News, 1 August 2006: Most Cdns. want neutrality
in Mideast policy: poll
- Globe And Mail, 1 August 2006: Only 32% back PM on
Mideast
- Gallup: Massiv dansk opbakning til Israel -
dr.dk/Nyheder/Indland
- Muslims unite in anger over Lebanon | Israel and the
Middle East | Guardian Unlimited
- Finland: Thousands rally for Israel
- Pro-Palestinian Protests at Austurvöllur - The ReykjavĂk
Grapevine Online
- Israel's War and India: Aftershocks
- Israel's War and India: Aftershocks - Carnegie
Endowment for International Peace
- Indonesians Protest In Solidarity, Al
Jazeera
- Muslims unite in anger over Lebanon, The Guardian
- Winnipeg Free Press
- Middle East: War Has Only Just Begun, Iran's House
Speaker Tells Anti-Israel Rally, AKI - Adnkronos
international
- "Protest at US embassy over conflict in Lebanon." (1 August
2006). The Irish Times p5.
- NEWS
RELEASE - IFI STATEMENT - 31/7/2006
- Left-wing rally: Negotiate with Hamas, Hizbullah,
Ynetnews
- Anti-war Tel Aviv rally draws Jewish, Israeli Arab
crowd, Haaretz
- The silent minority, The Guardian
- World Public Opinion
- Thousands protest Israeli attacks on Gaza,
Lebanon, New Straits Times
- Arrests at anti-Israel protest march in
Auckland, New Zealand Herald
- Oroligt efter demonstration i Stockholm
(swedish), Dagens Nyheter
-
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/6FB97C57-3ABE-41B0-8FEC-B7AC9111C90F.htm
- Today'S Zaman
- Demonstrators Rally At U.N. As Mideast Firestorm
Rages, NY1 News
- Dearborn Antiwar Protest: 10,000 Unite for
Lebanon, Detroit Free Press
- Hillary stands up for Israel, The Australian -
Defence
- Politicians, others support Israel at rally in
Atlanta, Jerusalem Post
- 2,000 rally for Israel
- Antiwar March in L.A. Draws Hundreds - Los Angeles
Times
- Aug. 12 demonstration
- Dueling Middle East war protests in San
Francisco
- 'A Real Defining Moment' - Los Angeles
Times
- StandWithUs.com - Demonstrations Around the United
States, Canada, & the UK for ISRAEL, StandWithUs.com
- Scottish Friends of Israel, Scottish Friends of
Israel
- Responses to a rally for Israel are split Sen.
Feinstein says nation 'fighting for its very existence',
SFGate.com
- Supporters of Israel rally in city, Baltimore
Sun
- Transcript - Senator Biden on Larry King
Live
- Israel/Palestinians
- FOXNews.com - Bill O'Reilly
- CNN LARRY KING LIVE - Interview with Bill
Maher
- Dana Milbank: Pronouncing Blame on the Israel Lobby,
Mearsheimer and Walt speak at a forum at invitation of the
Council on
American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), Washington Post,
29 August 2006
- Thousands in Yemen, Sudan protest Israeli
attacks, Swissinfo