The
Iraq War, also known as the Occupation of
Iraq, The Second Gulf War or
Operation Iraqi Freedom, is an ongoing military campaign which began on March 20,
2003, with the invasion of
Iraq by a multinational
force led by troops from the United States
and the United Kingdom
.
Prior to the war, the governments of the United States and the
United Kingdom claimed that Iraq's alleged possession of
weapons of mass
destruction (WMD) posed a threat to their security and that of
their coalition/regional allies. In 2002, the U.N. Security Council
passed
Resolution 1441 which called
for Iraq to completely cooperate with U.N. weapon inspectors to
verify that Iraq was not in possession of weapons of mass
destruction and long-range missiles.
Weapons inspectors found no evidence of WMD, but could not
verify the accuracy of Iraq's weapon declarations.
U.S. Senate Intelligence Community (June 2008): "Two
Bipartisan Reports Detail Administration Misstatements on Prewar
Iraq Intelligence, and Inappropriate Intelligence Activities by
Pentagon Policy Office".
There is a fundamental difference between relying on
incorrect intelligence and deliberately painting a picture to the
American people that you know is not fully accurate.
- Senator John D. (Jay) Rockefeller IV At the time
Hans Blix, the lead weapons inspector, advised the
UN Security Council that while
Iraq was cooperating in terms of access, Iraq's declarations with
regards to WMD still could not be verified. In his remarks to the
UN Security Council on 14.2.2003 Hans Blix said on cooperation that
"In my 27 January update to the Council, I said that it seemed from
our experience that Iraq had decided in principle to provide
cooperation on process, most importantly prompt access to all sites
and assistance to UNMOVIC in the establishment of the necessary
infrastructure. This impression remains and we note that access to
sites has so far been without problems." On time remaining until
the confirmation of disarmament he said "the period of disarmament
through inspection could still be short if immediate, active and
unconditional cooperation with UNMOVIC and IAEA were to be
forthcoming." United Nations Security Council:
4707th meeting. Friday, 14 February
2003, 10 a.m., New York, New York, USA.
After investigation following the invasion, the US-led
Iraq Survey Group concluded that Iraq had
ended its nuclear, chemical, and biological programs in 1991 and
had no active programs at the time of the invasion, but that they
intended to resume production if the
Iraq
sanctions were lifted. Although some degraded remnants of
misplaced or abandoned
chemical
weapons from before 1991 were found, they were not the weapons
which had been the pretext for the invasion. Some US officials also
accused
Iraqi President Saddam Hussein of harboring and supporting
al-Qaeda, but no evidence of an operation
connection was ever found.
Other
reasons for the
invasion included Iraq's financial support for the families of
Palestinian suicide bombers, Iraqi government
human rights abuses,
and an effort to spread
democracy to the
country.
The invasion of Iraq led to an
occupation and the
eventual capture of President Hussein, who was later
executed by the new
Iraqi government. Violence against
coalition forces and among various
sectarian groups soon led to the
Iraqi insurgency, strife between many
Sunni and
Shia
Iraqi groups, and al-Qaeda
operations
in Iraq.
In June
2008, US Department
of Defense
officials claimed security and economic indicators
began to show signs of improvement in what they hailed as
significant and fragile gains. Iraq was fifth on the 2008
Failed States Index, and sixth
on the 2009 list.
Member nations of the Coalition withdrew their forces as public
opinion favoring troop withdrawals increased and as Iraqi forces
began to take responsibility for security. In late 2008, the US and
Iraqi governments approved a
Status of Forces
Agreement effective through January 1, 2012. The Iraqi
Parliament also ratified a Strategic Framework Agreement with the
U.S., aimed at ensuring cooperation in constitutional rights,
threat deterrence, education, energy development, and other
areas.
In late February 2009,
US President
Barack Obama announced a new 18-month
withdrawal window for "combat forces", with approximately 50,000
troops remaining in the country "to advise and train
Iraqi security forces and to provide
intelligence and surveillance". General
Ray
Odierno, the top US military commander in Iraq, said he
believes all US troops will be out of the country by the end of
2011, while British forces ended combat operations on April 30,
2009. Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki has said he supports the
accelerated pullout of US forces.
2001–2003: Iraq disarmament crisis and pre-war
intelligence
According to documents provided by former
US Treasury Secretary Paul O'Neill,
George W. Bush,
ten days after taking office in January 2001, instructed his aides
to look for a way to overthrow the Iraqi regime.
A secret memo entitled
"Plan for post-Saddam Iraq" was discussed in January and February
2001, and a Pentagon
document
dated March 5, 2001, and entitled "Foreign Suitors for Iraqi
Oilfield contracts", included a map of potential areas for petroleum exploration.
UN weapons inspections resume
The issue of
Iraq's disarmament
reached a crisis in 2002-2003, when
US
President George W. Bush demanded a complete end to alleged
Iraqi
production of weapons of mass destruction and full compliance
with UN Resolutions requiring UN weapons inspectors unfettered
access to suspected weapons production facilities. The
UN had prohibited
Iraq from developing or possessing such weapons after the
Gulf War and required Iraq to permit inspections
confirming compliance. During inspections in 1999, Iraq alleged
that UN inspectors included US intelligence agents that supplied
the US with a direct feed of conversations between Iraqi security
agencies as well as other information. This was confirmed by the
New York Times and the Wall Street Journal.
During 2002, Bush repeatedly warned of military action unless
inspections were allowed to progress unfettered. In accordance with
UN
Security Council Resolution 1441 Iraq reluctantly agreed to
new inspections in late 2002. The weapons inspections did not
uncover any WMD in Iraq but they were at the time of the invasion
still incomplete. Shortly before the invasion
Hans Blix, the lead weapons inspector, advised the
UN Security Council that Iraq
was cooperating with inspections and that the confirmation of
disarmament through inspections could be achieved in a short period
of time if Iraq remained cooperative.
Alleged weapons of mass destruction
In the initial stages of the
war on
terror, the
Central
Intelligence Agency (CIA), under
George
Tenet, was rising to prominence as the lead agency in the
Afghanistan war. But when Tenet
insisted in his personal meetings with President Bush that there
was no connection between al-Qaeda and Iraq, Vice-President
Dick Cheney and Secretary of Defense
Donald Rumsfeld initiated a secret
program to re-examine the evidence and marginalize the CIA and
Tenet. A major part of this program was a Pentagon unit known as
the
Office of Special Plans
(OSP), which was created by Deputy Secretary of Defense
Paul Wolfowitz and headed by
Douglas Feith. It was created to supply senior
Bush administration officials with raw intelligence pertaining to
Iraq, unvetted by intelligence analysts, and circumventing
traditional intelligence gathering operations by the CIA. The
questionable intelligence acquired by the OSP was "
stovepiped" to Cheney and presented to the
public.
In some cases, Cheney’s office would leak the intelligence to news
correspondents, who would in turn cover it in such outlets such as
The New York Times.
Cheney would subsequently appear on the Sunday political television
talk shows to discuss the intelligence, referencing
The New
York Times as the source to give it credence.
Prior to the
Gulf War, in 1990, Iraq had
stockpiled of
yellowcake uranium at the Tuwaitha nuclear complex about south
of Baghdad.
In late February 2002, the CIA sent former
Ambassador Joseph Wilson to
investigate reports that
Iraq was attempting to purchase additional yellowcake from Niger
.
Wilson returned and informed the CIA that reports of yellowcake
sales to Iraq were "unequivocally wrong." The Bush administration,
however, continued to allege Iraq's attempts to obtain additional
yellowcake were a justification for military action, most
prominently in the January, 2003
State of the Union address when President
Bush said that Iraq had sought uranium, citing
British intelligence sources.
In response, Wilson wrote a critical
New York Times op-ed
piece in June 2003 stating that he had personally investigated
claims of yellowcake purchases and believed them to be fraudulent.
After Wilson's op-ed, Wilson's wife was publicly identified as an
undercover CIA analyst
Valerie Plame
in a
column. This led to a
Justice Department investigation into the
source of the leak.
On May 1, 2005 the "
Downing Street
memo" was published in
The
Sunday Times. It contained an overview of a secret July
23, 2002 meeting among
British
government,
Ministry of Defence,
and
British intelligence
figures who discussed the build-up to the Iraq war — including
direct references to classified U.S. policy of the time. The memo
stated, "Bush wanted to remove Saddam, through military action,
justified by the conjunction of
terrorism
and WMD. But the intelligence and facts were being fixed around the
policy."
On September 18, 2002, George Tenet briefed Bush that Iraq did not
have weapons of mass destruction. Bush dismissed this top-secret
intelligence from Hussein's inner circle which was approved by two
senior CIA officers, but it turned out to be completely accurate.
The information was never shared with Congress or even CIA agents
examining whether Saddam had such weapons. The CIA had contacted
Iraq's foreign minister,
Naji Sabri, who
was being paid by the French as an agent. Sabri informed them that
Saddam had ambitions for a nuclear program but that it was not
active, and that no biological weapons were being produced or
stockpiled, although research was underway.
In September 2002, the Bush administration, the CIA and the DIA
said attempts by Iraq to acquire high-strength
aluminum tubes, which were prohibited
under the UN monitoring program, pointed to a clandestine effort to
make enriched uranium for nuclear bombs. This analysis was opposed
by the
United States
Department of Energy (DOE) and
INR which was
significant because of DOE's expertise in gas centrifuges and
nuclear weapons programs. The DOE and INR argued that such tubes
were poorly suited for centrifuges. An effort by the DOE to change
Colin Powell's comments before his UN
appearance was rebuffed by the administration.
Indeed, Powell, in his address to the
UN Security Council just prior to the
war, made reference to the aluminum tubes. But a report released by
the
Institute for
Science and International Security in 2002 reported that it was
highly unlikely that the tubes could be used to enrich uranium.
Powell later admitted he had presented an inaccurate case to the
United Nations on Iraqi weapons, and the intelligence he was
relying on was, in some cases, "deliberately misleading." Shortly
after the
United States
presidential election, 2008, and the election of rival
Democratic party nominee
Barack Obama, president Bush admitted that
"[my] biggest regret of all the presidency has to have been the
intelligence failure in Iraq".
Preparations for war
During 2002 the amount of ordinance used by British and American
aircraft patrolling the no-fly zones of Iraq increased compared to
the previous years and by August had become a "become a full air
offensive".
Tommy Franks, the allied
commander later stated that the bombing was designed to "degrade"
the Iraqi air defence system prior to an invasion.
In October 2002, a few days before the
U.S. Senate voted on the
Joint Resolution to Authorize the Use of United States Armed Forces
Against Iraq, about 75 senators were told in
closed session that Iraq had the means of
attacking the eastern seaboard of the U.S. with biological or
chemical weapons delivered by
unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs.) On
February 5, 2003,
Colin Powell
presented further evidence in his Iraqi WMD program presentation to
the
UN Security Council that
UAVs were ready to be launched against the US. At the time, there
was a vigorous dispute within the US military and intelligence
community as to whether CIA conclusions about Iraqi UAVs were
accurate.
Other intelligence agencies suggested that Iraq did not possess any
offensive UAV capability, saying the few they had were designed for
surveillance and intended for
reconnaissance. Despite this controversy, the
Senate voted to approve the Joint Resolution with the support of
large bipartisan majorities on October 11, 2002 providing the Bush
administration with a
legal basis for the US
invasion under
US law.
The resolution granted the authorization by the
Constitution of the United
States and the
United States
Congress for the President to command the
military to fight anti-United States violence.
Citing the
Iraq Liberation
Act of 1998, the resolution reiterated that it should be the
policy of the United States to remove the Hussein regime and
promote a democratic replacement.
Chief UN weapons inspector
Hans Blix
remarked in January 2003 that "Iraq appears not to have come to a
genuine acceptance – not even today – of the disarmament, which was
demanded of it and which it needs to carry out to win the
confidence of the world and to live in peace." Among other things
he noted that of chemical agent were unaccounted for, information
on Iraq's VX nerve agent program was missing, and that "no
convincing evidence" was presented for the destruction of of
anthrax that had been declared.
On February 3, 2003 secretary of State Colin Powell appeared before
the UN to present American evidence that Iraq was hiding
unconventional weapons. The French government also believed that
Saddam had stockpiles of
anthrax and
botulism toxin, and
the ability to produce VX. But in March, Blix said progress had
been made in inspections, but no evidence of WMDs had been
found.
In early 2003, the US, British, and Spanish governments proposed
the so-called "eighteenth resolution" to give Iraq a deadline for
compliance with previous resolutions enforced by the threat of
military action. This proposed resolution was subsequently
withdrawn due to lack of support on the UN Security Council.
In
particular, North Atlantic Treaty
Organization
(NATO) members France, Germany
, Canada
and non-NATO
member Russia
were opposed
to military intervention in Iraq, due to the high level of risk to
the international community's security and defended disarmament
through diplomacy.
A meeting between George W.
Bush and British
Prime Minister Tony Blair took place on January 31, 2003 in the
White
House
. The
secret memo of this meeting purportedly showed that the Bush
administration had already decided on the invasion of Iraq at that
point. Bush was allegedly floating the idea of painting a
U-2 spyplane in UN colors and letting it fly
low over Iraq to provoke Iraqi forces into shooting it down,
thereby providing a pretext for the US and Britain's
subsequent invasion.
Bush and Blair made a
secret deal to carry out the invasion regardless of whether weapons
of mass destruction were discovered by UN weapons inspectors, in
direct contradiction with statements Blair made to the British House
of Commons
afterwards that the Iraqi regime would be given a
final chance to disarm. In the memo, Bush is paraphrased as
saying:
Bush said to Blair that he "thought it unlikely that there would be
internecine warfare between the different religious and ethnic
groups" in Iraq after the war.
Opposition to invasion
On January 20, 2003,
French Foreign Minister
Dominique de Villepin declared
"we believe that military intervention would be the worst
solution." Meanwhile
anti-war groups across the
world organised public protests. According to French academic
Dominique Reynié, between
January 3 and April 12, 2003, 36 million people across the globe
took part in almost 3,000 protests against war in Iraq, the
demonstrations on February 15, 2003 being the largest and most
prolific.
In February 2003, the U.S. Army's top general,
Eric Shinseki, told the Senate Armed Services
Committee that it would take "several hundred thousand soldiers" to
secure Iraq. Two days later,
US
Defense Secretary Donald
Rumsfeld said the post-war troop commitment would be less than
the number of troops required to win the war and, "the idea that it
would take several hundred thousand U.S. forces is far from the
mark." Deputy Defense Secretary
Paul
Wolfowitz said Shineski's estimate was "way off the mark,"
because other countries would take part in an occupying
force.
In March 2003, Hans Blix reported that, "No evidence of proscribed
activities have so far been found," in Iraq, saying that progress
was made in inspections which would continue. He estimated the time
remaining for disarmament being verified through inspections to be
"months". But the U.S. government announced that "diplomacy has
failed" and that it would proceed with a coalition of allied
countries, named the "
coalition
of the willing", to rid Iraq of its alleged weapons of mass
destruction.
The U.S. government abruptly advised U.N.
weapons inspectors to immediately leave Baghdad
.
There were also serious
legal questions
surrounding the launching of the war against Iraq and the
Bush Doctrine of
preemptive war. On September 16, 2004
Kofi Annan, the Secretary General of the
United Nations, said of the invasion, "I have indicated it was not
in conformity with the
UN Charter. From
our point of view, from the Charter point of view, it was
illegal."
In November 2008
Lord Bingham, the
former British
Law Lord,
described the war a serious violation of
international law, and accused Britain and
the US of acting like a "world
vigilante".
He also criticized the post-invasion record of Britain as "an
occupying power in Iraq". Regarding the treatment of Iraqi
detainees in
Abu
Ghraib, Bingham said: "Particularly disturbing to proponents of
the rule of law is the cynical lack of concern for international
legality among some top officials in the
Bush administration."
2003: Invasion

Map of the invasion routes and major
operations/battles of the Iraq War as of 2007
The first
Central
Intelligence Agency invasion team entered Iraq on July 10,
2002. This team was composed of members of the CIA's
Special Activities Division and
was later joined by members of the US military's elite
Joint Special Operations
Command (JSOC). Together, they prepared for the invasion of
conventional forces. These efforts consisted of persuading the
commanders of several Iraqi
military
divisions to surrender rather than oppose the invasion, and to
identify all of the initial leadership targets during very high
risk reconnaissance missions.
Most importantly, their efforts organized the
Kurdish Peshmerga to become
the northern front of the invasion.
Together this force defeated Ansar al-Islam in Iraqi Kurdistan
prior to the invasion and then defeated the
Iraqi army in the north. The
battle against Ansar al-Islam led to the death of a substantial
number of militants and the uncovering of a chemical weapons
facility at
Sargat.
At 5:34 AM Baghdad time on March 20, 2003 (9:34 p.m., March 19 EST)
the military invasion of Iraq began. The
2003 invasion of Iraq, led by
US army General
Tommy
Franks, began under the codename "Operation Iraqi Liberation",
later renamed "Operation Iraqi Freedom", the UK codename
Operation Telic, and the Australian codename
Operation Falconer. Coalition
forces also cooperated with Kurdish Peshmerga forces in the north.
Approximately forty other governments, the "
coalition of the willing,"
participated by providing troops, equipment, services, security,
and special forces.
The stated objectives of the invasion were; end the Hussein regime;
eliminate whatever weapons of mass destruction could be found;
eliminate whatever
Islamist militants could
be found; obtain intelligence on militant networks; distribute
humanitarian aid; secure Iraq’s
petroleum infrastructure; and assist in
creating a representative but compliant government as a model for
other
Middle East nations.
The invasion was a quick and decisive operation encountering major
resistance, though not what the US, British and other forces
expected. The Iraqi regime had prepared to fight both a
conventional and irregular war at the same time, conceding
territory when faced with superior conventional forces, largely
armored, but launching smaller scale attacks in the rear using
fighters dressed in civilian and paramilitary clothes. This
achieved some temporary successes and created unexpected challenges
for the invading forces, especially the US military.
In the
north, OIF-1 used the largest special operations force since the
successful attack on the Taliban government
of Afghanistan
just over a year earlier. The Iraqi army was
quickly overwhelmed in each engagement it faced with US forces,
with the elite
Fedayeen Saddam
putting up strong, sometimes suicidal, resistance before melting
away into the civilian population.
On April 9 Baghdad fell, ending President Hussein's 24-year rule.
US forces seized the deserted
Ba'ath
Party ministries and stage-managed the tearing down of a huge
iron statue of Hussein, photos and video of which became symbolic
of the event, although later controversial. In November 2008, Iraqi
protesters staged a similar stomping on and burning of an effigy of
George W. Bush. The abrupt fall of Baghdad was accompanied by a
widespread outpouring of gratitude toward the invaders, but also
massive civil disorder, including the
looting of public and government buildings and
drastically increased crime.
According
to the
Pentagon
, (of total)
of ordnance was looted, providing a significant source of
ammunition for the Iraqi
insurgency. The invasion phase concluded when Tikrit
, Hussein's
home town, fell with little resistance to the US Marines of Task
Force Tripoli and on April 15 the coalition declared the
invasion effectively over.
In the invasion phase of the war (March 19-April 30), 9,200 Iraqi
combatants were killed along with 7,299
civilians, primarily by US air and
ground forces. Coalition forces reported the death in combat of 139
U.S. military personnel and 33 UK military personnel. This worked
out at almost 100 dead Iraqis for every dead coalition
soldier.
Coalition Provisional Authority and Iraq Survey Group
Shortly
after the invasion, the multinational coalition created the
Coalition Provisional
Authority (CPA) سلطة Ø§Ù„Ø§Ø¦ØªÙ„Ø§Ù Ø§Ù„Ù…ÙˆØØ¯Ø©, based in the Green Zone
, as a transitional government of Iraq
until the establishment of a democratic government. Citing
United
Nations Security Council Resolution 1483 (May 22, 2003) and the
laws of war, the CPA vested itself with
executive,
legislative, and
judicial authority over the Iraqi government from
the period of the CPA's inception on April 21, 2003, until its
dissolution on June 28, 2004.
The CPA was originally headed by
Jay
Garner, a former U.S. military officer, but his appointment
lasted only until May 11, 2003 when President Bush appointed
L. Paul
Bremer. Bremer served until the CPA's dissolution in July
2004.
Another group created by the
multinational force in Iraq
post-invasion was the 1,400-member international
Iraq Survey Group who conducted a
fact-finding mission to find
Iraqi weapons of mass
destruction programmes. In 2004 the ISG's
Duelfer Report stated that Iraq did not have
a viable WMD program.
Post-invasion phase
On May 1,
2003, President Bush staged a dramatic visit to the aircraft carrier USS
Abraham Lincoln
operating a few miles west of San Diego,
California
. The visit climaxed at sunset with Bush's
now well-known "
Mission
Accomplished" speech. In this nationally televised speech,
delivered before the
sailors and
airmen on the
flight deck,
Bush effectively declared victory due to the defeat of Iraq's
conventional forces. However, former President Hussein remained at
large and significant pockets of resistance remained.
After President Bush's speech, coalition forces noticed a gradually
increasing flurry of attacks on its troops in various regions,
especially in the "
Sunni Triangle".
The initial Iraqi insurgents were supplied by hundreds of weapons
caches created prior to the invasion by the Iraqi army and
Republican Guard.
Initially, Iraqi resistance (described by the coalition as
"Anti-Iraqi Forces") largely stemmed from
fedayeen and Hussein/
Ba'ath
Party loyalists, but soon religious radicals and Iraqis angered
by the occupation contributed to the insurgency.
The three provinces
with the highest number of attacks were Baghdad
, Al Anbar
, and Salah Ad Din
. Those three provinces account for 35% of
the population, but are responsible for 73% of U.S. military deaths
(as of December 5, 2006), and an even higher percentage of recent
U.S. military deaths (about 80%.)
Insurgents use
guerrilla tactics
including: mortars, missiles,
suicide
attacks,
snipers,
improvised explosive devices
(IEDs), car bombs, small arms fire (usually with
assault rifles), and RPGs (
rocket propelled grenades), as well
as sabotage against the
petroleum, water,
and electrical infrastructure.
Post-invasion
Iraq coalition efforts commenced after the fall of the Hussein
regime. The coalition nations, together with the United Nations,
began to work to establish a stable, compliant
democratic state capable of defending itself from
non-coalition forces, as well as overcoming internal
divisions.
Meanwhile, coalition military forces
launched several operations around the Tigris
River
peninsula and in the Sunni Triangle. A series of similar
operations were launched throughout the summer in the Sunni
Triangle. Toward the end of 2003, the intensity and pace of
insurgent attacks began to increase. A sharp surge in guerrilla
attacks ushered in an insurgent effort that was termed the
"
Ramadan
Offensive", as it coincided with the beginning of the Muslim
holy month of
Ramadan.
To counter this offensive, coalition forces begin to use air power
and artillery again for the first time since the end of the
invasion by striking suspected ambush sites and mortar launching
positions. Surveillance of major routes, patrols, and raids on
suspected insurgents were stepped up.
In addition, two
villages, including Hussein's birthplace of al-Auja
and the small town of Abu
Hishma were surrounded by barbed wire and carefully
monitored.
However, the failure to restore basic services to pre-war levels,
where over a decade of
sanctions, US
and UK bombing,
corruption, and
decaying infrastructure had left major cities barely functioning,
contributed to local anger at the IPA government.
Hunting down the Hussein regime
[In the summer of 2003, the multinational forces focused on
hunting down the
remaining leaders of the former regime. On July 22, a raid by
the US
101st Airborne
Division and soldiers from
Task Force
20 killed Hussein's sons (
Uday and
Qusay) along with one of his
grandsons. In all, over 300 top leaders of the former regime were
killed or captured, as well as numerous lesser functionaries and
military personnel.
Most
significantly, Saddam Hussein himself was captured on December 13,
2003 on a farm near Tikrit
in Operation Red Dawn. The operation
was conducted by the
United States
Army's
4th
Infantry Division and members of
Task
Force 121. Intelligence on Saddam’s whereabouts came from his
family members and former bodyguards.
With the capture of Hussein and a drop in the number of insurgent
attacks, some concluded the multinational forces were prevailing in
the fight against the insurgency. The provisional government began
training the new Iraqi security forces intended to police the
country, and the United States promised over $20 billion in
reconstruction money in the form of credit against Iraq's future
oil revenues. Oil revenue was also used for rebuilding schools and
for work on the electrical and refining infrastructure.
Shortly after the capture of Hussein, elements left out of the
Coalition Provisional
Authority began to agitate for elections and the formation of
an
Iraqi Interim
Government. Most prominent among these was the
Shia cleric
Grand Ayatollah Ali
al-Sistani. The Coalition Provisional Authority opposed
allowing democratic elections at this time. The insurgents stepped
up their activities.
The two most turbulent centers were the area
around Fallujah
and the poor Shia sections of
cities from Baghdad (Sadr
City
) to Basra
in the
south.
2004: Iraqi Resistance expands
- See also: Military operations of the
Iraq War for a list of all Coalition operations for this
period, 2004 in Iraq, Iraqi coalition
counter-insurgency operations, History of Iraqi insurgency,
United States
occupation of Fallujah, Iraq Spring Fighting of
2004
The start of 2004 was marked by a relative lull in violence.
Insurgent forces reorganised during this time, studying the
multinational forces' tactics and planning a renewed offensive.
However, violence did increase during the
Iraq Spring Fighting of 2004
with foreign fighters from around the Middle East as well as
al-Qaeda in Iraq (an affiliated
al-Qaeda group), led by
Abu Musab al-Zarqawi helping to drive
the insurgency.
As the insurgency grew there was a distinct change in targeting
from the coalition forces towards the new Iraqi Security Forces, as
hundreds of Iraqi civilians and police were killed over the next
few months in a series of massive bombings. An organized Sunni
insurgency, with deep roots and both nationalist and Islamist
motivations, was becoming more powerful throughout Iraq. The Shia
Mahdi Army also began launching attacks
on coalition targets in an attempt to seize control from Iraqi
security forces. The southern and central portions of Iraq were
beginning to erupt in urban guerrilla combat as multinational
forces attempted to keep control and prepared for a
counteroffensive.
The most
serious fighting of the war so far began on March 31, 2004, when
Iraqi insurgents in Fallujah
ambushed a Blackwater
USA convoy led by four US private military contractors who
were providing security for food caterers Eurest Support Services. The
four armed contractors,
Scott
Helvenston, Jerko Zovko, Wesley Batalona, and Michael Teague,
were killed with grenades and small arms fire. Subsequently, their
bodies were dragged from their vehicles by local people, beaten,
set ablaze, and their burned corpses hung over a bridge crossing
the
Euphrates.
Photos of the event
were released to news agencies
worldwide, causing a great deal of indignation and moral outrage in the United States, and
prompting an unsuccessful "pacification" of the city: the First Battle
of Fallujah
in April 2004.
The
offensive was resumed in November 2004 in the bloodiest battle of
the war so far: the Second
Battle of Fallujah, described by the US military as "the
heaviest urban combat (that they had
been involved in) since the battle of Hue City
in Vietnam
." Intelligence briefings given prior to battle
reported that Coalition forces would encounter Chechnyan
, Filipino
, Saudi
, Iranian,
Italian
, and Syrian
combatants,
as well as native Iraqis.
During the assault, US forces used
white phosphorus as an
incendiary weapon against insurgent personnel, attracting
controversy. The 46-day battle resulted in a victory for the
coalition, with 95 US soldiers killed along with approximately
1,350 insurgents. Fallujah was totally devastated during the
fighting, though civilian casualties were low, as they had mostly
fled before the battle.
Another
major event of this year was the revelation of widespread prisoner abuse at Abu Ghraib
which received international media attention in
April 2004. First reports of the
Abu Ghraib prisoner abuse, as well
as graphic pictures showing US military personnel taunting and
abusing Iraqi prisoners, came to public attention from a
60 Minutes II news report
(April 28) and a
Seymour M.
Hersh article in the
The New Yorker (posted online on April
30.) Military correspondent
Thomas Ricks claimed that these
revelations dealt a blow to the moral justifications for the
occupation in the eyes of many people, especially Iraqis, and was a
turning point in the war.
2005: Elections and transitional government
On January 31, Iraqis
elected the
Iraqi Transitional Government
in order to draft a permanent constitution. Although some violence
and a widespread Sunni
boycott marred the
event, most of the eligible Kurd and Shia populace participated. On
February 4,
Paul Wolfowitz announced
that 15,000 US troops whose tours of duty had been extended in
order to provide election security would be pulled out of Iraq by
the next month. February to April proved to be relatively peaceful
months compared to the carnage of November and January, with
insurgent attacks averaging 30 a day from the prior average of
70.
Hopes for a quick end to the insurgency and a withdrawal of US
troops were dashed in May, Iraq's bloodiest month since the
invasion. Suicide bombers, believed to be mainly disheartened Iraqi
Sunni Arabs, Syrians and Saudis, tore through Iraq. Their targets
were often Shia gatherings or civilian concentrations of Shias. As
a result, over 700 Iraqi civilians died in that month, as well as
79 US soldiers.
The
summer of 2005 saw fighting around Baghdad and at Tall Afar
in northwestern Iraq as US forces tried to seal off
the Syrian border. This led to fighting in the autumn in the
small towns of the
Euphrates valley
between the capital and that border.
A referendum was held in October 15 in which the new
Iraqi constitution was
ratified. An
Iraqi national assembly was
elected in
December, with participation from the Sunnis as well as the
Kurds and Shia.
Insurgent attacks increased in 2005 with 34,131 recorded incidents,
compared to a total 26,496 for the previous year.
2006: Civil war and permanent Iraqi government

Nouri al-Maliki meets with George
W.
The beginning of 2006 was marked by government creation talks,
growing sectarian violence, and continuous anti-coalition attacks.
Sectarian
violence expanded to a new level of intensity following the
al-Askari
Mosque bombing
in the Iraqi city of Samarra, on February 22,
2006. The explosion at the mosque, one of the holiest sites
in Shi'a Islam, is believed to have been caused by a bomb planted
by al-Qaeda.
Although no injuries occurred in the blast, the mosque was severely
damaged and the bombing resulted in violence over the following
days. Over 100 dead bodies with bullet holes were found on February
23, and at least 165 people are thought to have been killed. In the
aftermath of this attack the US military calculated that the
average homicide rate in Baghdad tripled from 11 to 33 deaths per
day. In 2006 the UN described the environment in Iraq as a "civil
war-like situation."
The current government of Iraq took office on May 20, 2006
following approval by the
members
of the
Iraqi National
Assembly. This followed the
general election in
December 2005. The government succeeded the Iraqi Transitional
Government which had continued in office in a
caretaker capacity until the formation
of the permanent government.
On November 23, the deadliest attack since the beginning of the
conflict occurred. Suspected Sunni Arab militants used suicide car
bombs and mortar rounds on the capital's Shia Sadr City slum to
kill at least 215 people and wound 257. This attack was retaliated
by Shia militias who fired mortar rounds at various Sunni
neighborhoods and organizations.
Iraq Study Group report and Hussein's execution
The
Iraq Study Group Report
was released on December 6, 2006. Iraq Study Group, made up of
people from both of the major US parties, was led by former
US Secretary of State James Baker and former
Democratic congressman
Lee Hamilton. It concluded that "the situation
in Iraq is grave and deteriorating" and "U.S. forces seem to be
caught in a mission that has no foreseeable end."
The report's 79
recommendations include increasing diplomatic measures with
Iran
and Syria
and
intensifying efforts to train Iraqi troops. On December 18,
a Pentagon report found that insurgent attacks were averaging about
960 a week, the highest since the reports had begun in 2005.
Coalition forces formally transferred control of a province to the
Iraqi government, the first since the war. Military prosecutors
charged eight US Marines with the murders of 24 Iraqi civilians in
Haditha in November 2005, 10 of them women
and children. Four officers were also charged with
dereliction of duty in relation to the
event.
Saddam Hussein was hanged on December 30, 2006 after being found
guilty of
crimes against
humanity by an Iraqi court after a year-long trial.
2007: US troop surge
In a January 10, 2007 televised address to the US public, Bush
proposed 21,500 more troops for Iraq, a job programme for Iraqis,
more reconstruction proposals, and $1.2 billion for these
programmes. On January 23, 2007 in the
2007 State of the Union
Address, Bush announced "deploying reinforcements of more than
20,000 additional soldiers and Marines to Iraq."

A U.S.
Soldier from the Nemesis troop, 3rd Squadron, 2nd Stryker
Cavalry Regiment clear a house after one of their Stryker vehicles
gets hit by an improvised explosive device, October 18, 2007,
Baghdad, Iraq.(U.S.
On February 10, 2007
David Petraeus
was made commander of
Multi-National Force - Iraq
(MNF-I), the four-star post that oversees all coalition forces in
country, replacing General
George Casey. In his new position,
Petraeus oversaw all coalition forces in Iraq and employed them in
the new
"Surge"
strategy outlined by the Bush administration. 2007 also saw a
sharp increase in insurgent
chlorine bombings.
On May 10, 2007, 144 Iraqi Parliamentary lawmakers signed onto a
legislative petition calling on the United States to set a
timetable for withdrawal. On June 3, 2007, the Iraqi Parliament
voted 85 to 59 to require the Iraqi government to consult with
Parliament before requesting additional extensions of the UN
Security Council Mandate for Coalition operations in Iraq. Despite
this, the mandate was renewed on December 18, 2007 without the
approval of the Iraqi parliament.
Pressures
on US troops were compounded by the continuing withdrawal of
British forces from the Basra Governorate
. In early 2007,
British Prime Minister
Blair announced that following
Operation Sinbad British troops would begin
to withdraw from Basra, handing security over to the Iraqis.
This announcement was confirmed in the autumn by Prime Minister
Gordon Brown, Blair's successor, who
again outlined a withdrawal plan for the remaining UK forces with a
complete withdrawal date sometime in late 2008. In July Danish
Prime Minister
Anders Fogh
Rasmussen also announced the withdrawal of 441 Danish troops
from Iraq, leaving only a unit of nine soldiers manning four
observational helicopters.
Planned troop reduction
In a speech made to Congress on September 10, 2007, Petraeus
"envisioned the withdrawal of roughly 30,000 U.S. troops by next
summer, beginning with a Marine contingent [in September]." On
September 14, Bush backed a limited withdrawal of troops from
Iraq.
Bush said 5,700 personnel would be home by Christmas 2007, and
expected thousands more to return by July 2008. The plan would take
troop numbers back to their level before the surge at the beginning
of 2007. Controversy arose when former Secretary of State
Colin Powell announced before the surge took
place that there would have to be a draw down of troops by
mid-2007.
Effects of the surge on security
By March 2008, violence in Iraq was reported curtailed by 40-80%,
according to a Pentagon report. Independent reports raised
questions about those assessments. An Iraqi military spokesman
claimed that civilian deaths since the start of the troop surge
plan were 265 in Baghdad, down from 1,440 in the four previous
weeks. The
New York Times
counted more than 450 Iraqi civilians killed during the same 28-day
period, based on initial daily reports from
Iraqi Interior Ministry and hospital
officials.
Historically, the daily counts tallied by the
NYT have
underestimated the total death toll by 50% or more when compared to
studies by the United Nations, which rely upon figures from the
Iraqi Health Ministry and
morgue figures.
The rate of US combat deaths in Baghdad nearly doubled to 3.14/day
in the first seven weeks of the "surge" in security activity,
compared to previous period. Across the rest of Iraq it reduced
slightly.
On August 14, 2007 the
deadliest
single attack of the whole war occurred.
Nearly 800 civilians
were killed by a series of co-ordinated suicide bomb attacks on the
northern Iraqi settlement of Qahtaniya
. More than 100 homes and shops were
destroyed in the blasts. US officials blamed al-Qaeda. The targeted
villagers belonged to the non-Muslim
Yazidi
ethnic minority. The attack may have represented the latest in a
feud that erupted earlier that year when members of the Yazidi
community stoned to death a teenage girl called
Du’a Khalil Aswad accused of
dating a Sunni Arab man and converting to
Islam. The killing of the girl was recorded on
camera-mobiles and the video was uploaded onto the internet
On
September 13, 2007 Abdul Sattar
Abu Risha was killed in a bomb attack in the city of Ramadi
. He
was an important US ally because he led the "
Anbar Awakening", an alliance of Sunni Arab
tribes that opposed al-Qaeda. The latter organisation claimed
responsibility for the attack. A statement posted on the Internet
by the shadowy
Islamic State of
Iraq called Abu Risha "one of the dogs of Bush" and described
Thursday's killing as a "heroic operation that took over a month to
prepare".
There was a reported trend of decreasing US troop deaths after May
2007, and violence against coalition troops had fallen to the
"lowest levels since the first year of the American invasion".
These, and several other positive developments, were attributed to
the surge by many analysts.
Data from the Pentagon and other US agencies such as the
Government Accountability
Office (GAO) found that daily attacks against civilians in Iraq
remained “
about the same†since February. The GAO also
stated that there was no discernible trend in sectarian violence.
However, this report ran counter to reports to Congress, which
showed a general downward trend in civilian deaths and
ethno-sectarian violence since December 2006. By late 2007, as the
U.S. troop surge began to wind down, violence in Iraq had begun to
decrease from its 2006 highs.
Reports from the ground dispute that the surge had a significant
effect on security in Iraq.
While life in Baghdad
improved in 2007-08, the main reason this was that
the battle for Baghdad in 2006-07 between the Shia and the Sunni populations was
won by the Shia, who as of September 2008 controlled three-quarters
of the capital. These demographic changes appeared
permanent; Sunni families who try to get their houses back faced
assassination. Thus the war against the US occupation by the Sunni
community, who had been favoured under Saddam Hussein, had largely
ended. The Sunni have been largely defeated, not so much by the US
army as by the Shia-led Iraqi government and the Shia
militias.
Entire neighborhoods in Baghdad were ethnically cleansed by Shia
and Sunni militias and
sectarian
violence has broken out in every Iraqi city where there is a
mixed population. This assessment is supported by a study of
satellite imagery tracking the amount of light emitted by Baghdad
neighborhoods at night. The interpretation of the data was that
violence had declined in Baghdad due to
ethnic cleansing and that intercommunal
violence had reached a climax as the surge was beginning. John
Agnew, an authority on ethnic conflict and leader of the project
stated "
The surge really seems to have been a case of closing
the stable door after the horse has bolted."
Investigative reporter
Bob Woodward
cites US government sources according to which the US "surge" was
not the primary reason for the drop in violence in 2007-2008.
Instead, according to that view, the reduction of violence was due
to newer covert techniques by US military and intelligence
officials to find, target and kill insurgents, including working
closely with former insurgents.
In the
Shia region near Basra
, British
forces turned over security for the region to Iraqi Security
Forces. Basra is the ninth province of Iraq's 18 provinces
to be returned to local security forces' control since the
beginning of the occupation.
Political developments

Official Iraq-benchmark of the
Congress 2007
More than half of the members of Iraq's parliament rejected the
continuing occupation of their country for the first time. 144 of
the 275 lawmakers signed onto a legislative petition that would
require the Iraqi government to seek approval from Parliament
before it requests an extension of the U.N. mandate for foreign
forces to be in Iraq, which expires at the end of 2008. It also
calls for a timetable for troop withdrawal and a freeze on the size
of foreign forces. The U.N. Security Council mandate for U.S.-led
forces in Iraq will terminate "if requested by the government of
Iraq." Under Iraqi law, the speaker must present a resolution
called for by a majority of lawmakers. 59% of those polled in the
U.S. support a timetable for withdrawal.
In mid-2007, the Coalition began a controversial program to recruit
Iraqi Sunnis (often former insurgents) for the formation of
"Guardian" militias. These Guardian militias are intended to
support and secure various Sunni neighborhoods against the
Islamists.
Tensions with Iran
In 2007,
tensions increased greatly between Iran
and
Iraqi
Kurdistan
due to the
latter's giving sanctuary to the militant Kurdish secessionist
group Party for a
Free Life in Kurdistan (PEJAK.) According to reports, Iran had
been shelling PEJAK positions in Iraqi Kurdistan since August
16. These tensions further increased with an alleged border
incursion on August 23 by Iranian troops who attacked several
Kurdish villages killing an unknown number of civilians and
militants.
Coalition forces also
began to
target alleged Iranian
Quds force
operatives in Iraq, either
arresting or killing
suspected members. The Bush administration and coalition
leaders began to publicly state that Iran was supplying weapons,
particularly
EFP
devices, to Iraqi insurgents and militias although to date have
failed to provide any proof for these allegations. Further
sanctions on Iranian organizations were also announced by the Bush
administration in the Autumn of 2007. On November 21, 2007
Lieutenant General
James Dubik, who is
in charge of training Iraqi security forces, praised Iran for its
"contribution to the reduction of violence" in Iraq by upholding
its pledge to stop the flow of weapons, explosives and training of
extremists in Iraq.
Tensions with Turkey
Border
incursions by PKK militants based in Iraqi
Kurdistan have continued to harass Turkish forces, with casualties
on both sides increasing tensions between Turkey, a NATO
member, and
Iraqi Kurdistan.
In the
fall of 2007, the Turkish military stated their right to cross the
Iraqi Kurdistan border in "hot pursuit" of PKK militants and began
shelling Kurdish villages in Iraq and attacking PKK bases in the
Mount
Cudi
region with aircraft.The Turkish parliament
approved a resolution permitting the military to pursue the PKK in
Iraqi Kurdistan. In November, Turkish gunships attacked parts of
northern Iraq in the first such attack by Turkish aircraft since
the border tensions escalated. Another series of attacks in
mid-December hit PKK targets in the Qandil, Zap, Avashin and Hakurk
regions. The latest series of attacks involved at least 50 aircraft
and artillery and Kurdish officials reported one civilian killed
and two wounded.
Additionally, weapons that were given to Iraqi security forces by
the US military are being recovered by authorities in Turkey after
being used in that state.
Private security firm controversy
On September 17, 2007, the Iraqi government announced that it was
revoking the license of the US security firm
Blackwater USA over the firm's involvement in
the killing of eight civilians, including a woman and an infant, in
a firefight that followed a car bomb explosion near a State
Department motorcade. Additional investigations of
alleged arms
smuggling involving the firm was also under way. Blackwater is
currently one of the most high-profile firms operating in Iraq,
with around 1,000 employees as well as a fleet of helicopters in
the country. Whether the group may be legally prosecuted is still
a
matter of debate.
2008: Iraqi forces arm
Throughout 2008, U.S. officials and independent think tanks began
to point to improvements in the security situation, as measured by
key statistics. According to the
US Defense Department, in December
2008 the "overall level of violence" in the country had dropped 80%
since before
the surge
began in January 2007, and the country's murder rate had dropped to
pre-war levels. They also pointed out that the casualty figure for
U.S. forces in 2008 was 314 against a figure of 904 in 2007.
According to the
Brookings
Institution, Iraqi civilian fatalities numbered 490 in November
2008 as against 3,500 in January 2007, whereas attacks against the
coalition numbered somewhere between 200 and 300 per week in the
latter half of 2008, as opposed to a peak of nearly 1,600 in summer
2007. The number of Iraqi security forces killed was under 100 per
month in the second half of 2008, from a high of 200 to 300 in
summer 2007.
Meanwhile, the proficiency of the Iraqi military increased as it
launched a spring offensive against Shia militias which Prime
Minister
Nouri al-Maliki had
previously been criticized for allowing to operate.
This began with a
March operation against the
Mehdi Army in Basra, which led to
fighting in Shia areas up and down the country, especially in the
Sadr
City
district of Baghdad. By October, the
British officer in charge of Basra said that since the operation
the town had become "secure" and had a murder rate comparable to
Manchester
in England. The U.S. military also said
there had been a decrease of about a quarter in the quantity of
Iranian-made explosives found in Iraq in 2008, possibly indicating
a change in Iranian policy. Progress in Sunni areas continued after
members of
the Awakening
movement were transferred from U.S. military to Iraqi control.
In May,
the Iraqi army - backed by coalition support - launched an
offensive in Mosul
, the last
major Iraqi stronghold of al-Qaeda. Despite detaining
thousands of individuals, the offensive failed to lead to major
long-term security improvements in Mosul. At the end of the year,
the city remained a major flashpoint.
.gif/200px-Turkey_South_(3d).gif)
3D Map of Southern Turkey and Northern
Iraq
the regional dimension, the ongoing conflict between Turkey and
PKK intensified on February 21, when Turkey
launched a
ground attack into the Quandeel Mountains of Northern Iraq. In
the nine day long operation, around 10,000 Turkish troops advanced
up to 25 km into Northern Iraq. This was the first substantial
ground incursion by Turkish forces since 1995. Shortly after the
incursion began, both the Iraqi cabinet and the Kurdistan regional
government condemned Turkey's actions and called for the immediate
withdrawal of Turkish troops from the region. Turkish troops
withdrew on February 29.
The fate of the Kurds and the future of the
ethnically-diverse city of Kirkuk
remained a
contentious issue in Iraqi politics.
U.S. military officials met these trends with cautious optimism as
they approached what they described as the "transition" embodied in
the
U.S.-Iraq
Status of Forces Agreement which was negotiated throughout
2008. The commander of the coalition, U.S. General
Raymond T. Odierno, noted that "in military terms,
transitions are the most dangerous time" in December 2008.
Spring offensives on Shia militias
At the end of March, the Iraqi Army, with Coalition air support,
launched an offensive, dubbed "Charge of the Knights", in Basra to
secure the area from militias. This was the first major operation
where the Iraqi Army did not have direct combat support from
conventional coalition ground troops. The offensive was opposed by
the
Mahdi Army, one of the militias,
which controlled much of the region.
Fighting quickly
spread to other parts of Iraq: including Sadr City
, Al Kut, Al Hillah
and others. During the fighting Iraqi forces
met stiff resistance from militiamen in Basra to the point that the
Iraqi military offensive slowed to a crawl, with the high attrition
rates finally forcing the Sadrists to the negotiating table.
Following talks with Brig. Gen.
Qassem
Suleimani, commander of the
Qods
brigades of Iran's
Revolutionary Guard Corps, and the
intercession of the
Iranian
government, on March 31, 2008, al-Sadr ordered his followers to
ceasefire. The militiamen kept their weapons.
By May 12, 2008, Basra "residents overwhelmingly reported a
substantial improvement in their everyday lives" according to
The New York Times.
"Government forces have now taken over Islamic militants’
headquarters and halted the death squads and 'vice enforcers’ who
attacked women, Christians, musicians, alcohol sellers and anyone
suspected of collaborating with Westerners", according to the
report; however, when asked how long it would take for lawlessness
to resume if the Iraqi army left, one resident replied, "one
day".
In late April roadside bombings continued to rise from a low in
January of 114 to over 250, surpassing the May 2007 high.
In early May, the Iraqi government called on the residents of Sadr
City to flee after more than 40 days of fighting, which left
between 500-1,000 people dead. Due to the nearly constant violence,
there are ongoing shortages of food, water, and other
supplies.
Congressional testimony
Speaking before the U.S. Congress on April 8, 2008, General
David Petraeus urged delaying troop
withdrawals, saying, "I’ve repeatedly noted that we haven’t turned
any corners, we haven’t seen any lights at the end of the tunnel,"
referencing the comments of then President Bush and former
Vietnam-era General
William
Westmoreland. When asked by Senator
Evan
Bayh if reasonable people could disagree on the way forward,
Petraeus responded, "I don’t know if I would go that far." When
asked twice again about that point, Petraeus said, "We fight for
the right of people to have other opinions."
Upon questioning by then Senate committee chair
Joe Biden, Ambassador Crocker admitted that
Al-Qaeda in Iraq was less important than
the Al-Qaeda organization led by
Osama
bin Laden along the Afghan-Pakistani border. Lawmakers from
both parties complained that U.S. taxpayers are carrying Iraq's
burden as it earns billions of dollars in oil revenues. Democrats
plan to push legislation this spring that would force the Iraqi
government to spend its own surplus to rebuild.
Iraqi security forces rearm
Iraq became one of the top current purchasers of U.S. military
equipment with their army trading its
AK-47
assault rifles for the U.S.
M-16 and
M-4 rifles, among other equipment. This
year alone, Iraq accounts for more than $12.5 billion of the $34
billion US weapon sales to foreign countries (not including the
potential F-16 fighter planes.)
Iraq sought 36
F-16’s, the most sophisticated
weapons system Iraq has attempted to purchase. The Pentagon
notified Congress that it had approved the sale of 24 American
attack helicopters to Iraq, valued at as much as $2.4 billion.
Including the helicopters, Iraq announced plans to purchase at
least $10 billion in U.S. tanks and armored vehicles, transport
planes and other battlefield equipment and services. Over the
summer, the Defense Department announced that the Iraqi government
wanted to order more than 400 armored vehicles and other equipment
worth up to $3 billion, and six C-130J transport planes, worth up
to $1.5 billion.
Status of forces agreement
The
U.S.-Iraq
Status of Forces Agreement is a SOFA approved by the Iraqi
government in late 2008 between Iraq and the United States. It
establishes that U.S. combat forces will withdraw from Iraqi cities
by June 30, 2009, and that all U.S. forces will be completely out
of Iraq by December 31, 2011. The pact is subject to possible
negotiations which could delay withdrawal and a referendum
scheduled for mid-2009 in Iraq which may require all U.S. forces to
completely leave by the middle of 2010. The pact requires criminal
charges for holding prisoners over 24 hours, and requires a warrant
for searches of homes and buildings that are not related to
combat.
U.S. contractors working for U.S. forces will be subject to Iraqi
criminal law, while contractors working for the State Department
and other U.S. agencies may retain their immunity. "The immunity
question, the largest question being talked about, is not addressed
in the ... agreement," said Alan Chvotkin, who works on behalf of
contractors, including Moyock, N.C.-based Blackwater Worldwide.
Chvotkin said he believed Blackwater's guards still have immunity
under Decree 17 issued by L. Paul Bremer. Blackwater currently has
no license to work in Iraq. If U.S. forces commit still undecided
"major premeditated felonies" while off-duty and off-base, they
will be subject to the still undecided procedures laid out by a
joint U.S.-Iraq committee if the U.S. certifies the forces were
off-duty.
On the other hand, Iraq has primary legal jurisdiction
over off-duty soldiers and civilians who commit "major and
premeditated crimes" outside of U.S. installations. These major
crimes will need to be defined by a joint committee and the United
States retains the right to determine whether or not its personnel
were on- or off-duty. Iraq also maintains primary legal
jurisdiction over contractors (and their employees) that have
contracts with the United States.
Arms Control Center: How Comfortable is
the U.S.-Iraq SOFA?
Committees assigned to deal with U.S.-led combat
operations and jurisdiction over U.S. military personnel are among
those that have not met even as Iraq moves toward sovereignty, U.S.
Army Gen. Ray Odierno told reporters.
Los Angeles Times: In Iraq,
transfer-of-power committees have yet to take shape
On November 16, 2008, Iraq's Cabinet approved the agreement. On
November 27, 2008, the Iraqi Parliament ratified the agreement. On
December 4, 2008, Iraq's presidential council approved the security
pact. Some Americans have discussed "loopholes" and some Iraqis
have said they believe parts of the pact remain a "mystery". U.S.
Secretary of Defense Robert Gates has predicted that after 2011 he
would expect to see "perhaps several tens of thousands of American
troops" as part of a residual force in Iraq.
Several groups of Iraqis protested the passing of the SOFA accord
as prolonging and legitimizing the occupation. Tens of thousands of
Iraqis burned an
effigy of
George W. Bush in a
central
Baghdad square
where U.S.
troops five years previously organized a tearing down of a statue
of Saddam Hussein. Some Iraqis expressed skeptical optimism
that the U.S. would completely end its presence by 2011.
Feelings are mixed as Iraqis ponder U.S. security
agreement On December 4, 2008, Iraq's presidential council
approved the security pact. U.S. Secretary of Defense
Robert Gates has predicted that after 2011 he
would expect to see "perhaps several tens of thousands of American
troops" as part of a residual force in Iraq.
A representative of Grand Ayatollah Ali Husseini al-Sistani's
expressed concern with the ratified version of the pact and noted
that the government of Iraq has no authority to control the
transfer of occupier forces into and out of Iraq, no control of
shipments, and that the pact grants the occupiers immunity from
prosecution in Iraqi courts. He said that Iraqi rule in the country
is not complete while the occupiers are present, but that
ultimately the Iraqi people would judge the pact in a referendum.
Thousands of Iraqi have gathered weekly after Friday prayers and
shouted anti-US and anti-Israeli slogans protesting the security
pact between Baghdad and Washington. A protester said that despite
the approval of the Interim Security pact, the Iraqi people would
break it in a referendum next year.
2009: Coalition exit from Urban areas
Transfer of Green Zone
On
January 1, 2009, the United States handed control of the Green Zone
and Saddam Hussein's presidential palace to the
Iraqi government in a ceremonial move described by the country's
prime minister as a restoration of Iraq's sovereignty. Iraqi
Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki said he would propose January 1 be
declared national "Sovereignty Day". "This palace is the symbol of
Iraqi sovereignty and by restoring it, a real message is directed
to all Iraqi people that Iraqi sovereignty has returned to its
natural status," al-Maliki said.
The U.S. military attributed a decline in reported civilians deaths
to several factors including the U.S.-led "troop surge", the growth
of U.S.-funded
Awakening Councils,
and Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr's call for his militia to abide
by a cease fire.
Provincial elections
On January 31, 2009, Iraq held provincial elections. Provincial
candidates and those close to them faced some political
assassinations and attempted assassinations, and there was also
some other violence related to the election. Iraqi voter turnout
failed to meet the original expectations which were set and was the
lowest on record in Iraq, but U.S. Ambassador Ryan Crocker
characterized the turnout as "large". Of those who turned out to
vote, some groups complained of disenfranchisement and fraud. After
the post-election curfew was lifted, some groups made threats about
what would happen if they were unhappy with the results.
Exit strategy announcement
On
February 27, 2009, United
States
President Barack Obama gave a speech at Marine Corps
Base Camp Lejeune
in the U.S. state of
North
Carolina
announcing
that the U.S. combat mission in Iraq would end by August 31,
2010. A "transitional force" of up to 50,000 troops tasked
with training the
Iraqi Security
Forces, conducting
counterterrorism operations, and providing
general support may remain until the end of 2011, the president
added. Obama declared that this strategy for withdrawal was in line
with the American goal of "a full transition to Iraqi
responsibility" for the sovereign nation of Iraq. He congratulated
the Iraqi people and government for their "proud resilience" in not
"giving into the forces of disunion", but cautioned that Iraqis
would have to remain vigilant against "those...who will insist that
Iraq’s differences cannot be reconciled without more killing" even
after the U.S. drawdown in 2010 and withdrawal in 2011.
The day before Obama's speech,
Prime Minister of Iraq Nuri al-Maliki said at a press conference
that the
government of Iraq had
"no worries" over the impending departure of U.S. forces and
expressed confidence in the ability of the Iraqi Security Forces
and police to maintain order without American military
support.
Sixth year anniversary protests
On April 9, 2009, the sixth anniversary of Baghdad's fall to
coalition forces, tens of thousands of Iraqis thronged Baghdad to
mark the sixth anniversary of the city's fall and to demand the
immediate departure of coalition forces. The crowds of Iraqis
stretched from the giant Sadr City slum in northeast Baghdad to the
square around 5 km (3 miles) away, where protesters burned an
effigy featuring the face of former U.S. President George W. Bush,
who ordered the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq, and also the face of
Saddam. Shi'ites were brutally persecuted under Saddam's rule.
There were also Sunni Muslims in the crowd. Police said many
Sunnis, including prominent leaders such as a founding sheikh from
the
Sons of Iraq, took part.
British troops end combat operations
On April
30, 2009, the United
Kingdom
formally ended combat operations. Prime Minister Gordon
Brown characterized the operation in Iraq as a "success story"
because of UK troops' efforts. Britain handed control of Basra to
the United States Armed Forces.
U.S. withdraw from urban areas and decrease in violence
The withdrawal of U.S. forces began at the end of June, with 38
bases to be handed over to Iraqi forces. On June 29, 2009, U.S.
forces withdrew from Baghdad. On November 30, 2009, Iraqi
Interior Ministry officials
reported that the the civilian death toll in Iraq fell to its
lowest level in November since the 2003 invasion.
Combatants
Casualty estimates

Wounded US personnel flown from Iraq
to Ramstein, Germany for medical treatment.
For coalition death totals see the infobox at the top right. See
also
Casualties of the Iraq
War, which has casualty numbers for coalition nations,
contractors, non-Iraqi civilians, journalists, media helpers, aid
workers, wounded, etc.. The main article also gives explanations
for the wide variation in estimates and counts, and shows many ways
in which undercounting occurs. Casualty figures, especially Iraqi
ones, are highly disputed. This section gives a brief
overview.
U.S. General
Tommy Franks reportedly
estimated soon after the invasion that there had been 30,000 Iraqi
casualties as of April 9, 2003. After this initial estimate he made
no further public estimates.
In December 2005 President Bush said there were 30,000 Iraqi dead.
White House spokesman Scott McClellan later said it was "not an
official government estimate", and was based on media
reports.
There have been several attempts by the media, coalition
governments and others to estimate the Iraqi casualties:
- USA Today count (July 17, 2009): 4,328
members of the U.S. military. The AP count is one fewer than the
Defense Department's tally, last updated Friday at 10 a.m.
EDT.
The British military has reported 176 deaths; Italy, 33; Ukraine,
18; Poland, 21; Bulgaria, 13; Spain, 11; Denmark, seven; El
Salvador, five; Slovakia, four; Latvia and Georgia, three each;
Estonia, Netherlands, Thailand, Romania, two each; and Australia,
Hungary, Kazakhstan, South Korea, one death each.
- Iraqi Health
Ministry casualty survey: in January 2008 the Iraqi health minister, Dr Salih
Mahdi Motlab Al-Hasanawi, reported the results of the "Iraq Family
Health Survey" of 9,345 households across Iraq which was carried
out in 2006 and 2007. It estimated 151,000 violence-related Iraqi
deaths (95% uncertainty range, 104,000 to 223,000) from March 2003
through June 2006. Employees of the Iraqi Health Ministry carried
out the survey for the World
Health Organization. The results were published in the New England Journal of
Medicine.
- Iraq's Health
Minister Ali al-Shemari said in
November 2006 that since the March 2003 invasion between
100,000-150,000 Iraqis have been killed. Al-Shemari said on
Thursday, Nov. 9, that he based his figure on an estimate of 100
bodies per day brought to morgues and hospitals.
- The United Nations found that
34,452 violent civilian deaths were reported by morgues, hospitals,
and municipal authorities across Iraq in 2006.
- The Iraqi ministries of
Health, Defence and Interior said that 14,298 civilians, 1,348
police, and 627 soldiers were killed in 2006. The Iraqi government
does not count deaths classed as "criminal", nor those from
kidnappings, nor wounded persons who die later as the result of
attacks. However "a figure of 3,700 civilian deaths in October
2006, the latest tally given by the UN based on data from the
Health Ministry and the Baghdad morgue, was branded exaggerated by
the Iraqi Government."
- The Iraq Body Count
project (IBC) has documented 91,856 - 100,278 violent,
non-combatant civilian deaths since the beginning of the war as of
May 6, 2009. However, the IBC has been criticized for counting only
a small percentage of the number of actual deaths because they only
include deaths reported by specific media agencies. IBC Director
John Sloboda admits, "We've always said our work is an undercount,
you can't possibly expect that a media-based analysis will get all
the deaths."
- The 2006
Lancet survey of casualties of the Iraq War estimated 654,965
Iraqi deaths (range of 392,979-942,636) from March 2003 to the end
of June 2006. That total number of deaths (all Iraqis) includes all
excess deaths due to increased lawlessness, degraded
infrastructure, poorer healthcare, etc, and includes civilians,
military deaths and insurgent deaths. 601,027 were violent deaths
(31% attributed to Coalition, 24% to others, 46% unknown.) A copy
of a death certificate was available for a high proportion of the
reported deaths (92 per cent of surveyed households produced one.)
The causes of violent deaths were gunshot (56%), car bomb (13%),
other explosion/ordnance (14%), air strike (13%), accident (2%),
unknown (2%.) The survey results have been criticized as
"ridiculous" and "extreme and improbable" by various critics such
as the Iraqi government and Iraq
Body Count project. However, in a letter to The Age, published
Oct. 21, 2006, 27 epidemiologists and health professionals defended
the methods of the study, writing that the study's "methodology is
sound and its conclusions should be taken seriously."
- An Opinion
Research Business survey conducted August 12-19, 2007 estimated
1,220,580 violent deaths due to the Iraq War (range of 733,158 to
1,446,063.) Out of a national sample of 1,499 Iraqi adults, 22% had
one or more members of their household killed due to the Iraq War
(poll accuracy +/-2.4%.) ORB reported that 48% died from a gunshot
wound, 20% from car bombs, 9% from aerial bombardment, 6% as a
result of an accident and 6% from another blast/ordnance. It is the
highest estimate given so far of civilian deaths in Iraq and is
consistent with the Lancet study. On
January 28, 2008, ORB published an update based on additional work
carried out in rural areas of Iraq. Some 600 additional interviews
were undertaken and as a result of this the death estimate was
revised to 1,033,000 with a given range of 946,000 to
1,120,000.
Criticisms and costs

A local memorial in North Carolina in
December 2007; US casualty count can be seen in the
background.
The U.S.
rationale for the
Iraq War has faced heavy criticism from an array of popular and
official sources both inside and outside the United States, with
many US citizens finding many parallels with the
Vietnam War. According to the
Center for Public Integrity,
President Bush's administration made a total of 935 false
statements between 2001 and 2003 about Iraq's alleged threat to the
United States. Both proponents and
opponents of the invasion have
also criticized the prosecution of the war effort along a number of
other lines. Most significantly, critics have assailed the US and
its allies for not devoting enough troops to the mission, not
adequately planning for
post-invasion Iraq,
and for permitting and perpetrating widespread human rights abuses.
As the war has progressed, critics have also railed against the
high human and financial costs.
The
court-martial of
Ehren Watada, the first US officer to refuse to
serve in Iraq, ended in a
mistrial because
the
Judge Advocate
General's Corps would not consider the question of whether
orders could be illegal. A federal district court judge ruled that
Watada cannot face
double jeopardy
on three of his five charges, but abstained from ruling on whether
the two remaining charges of
conduct unbecoming
an officer may still go forward.
Another criticism of the initial intelligence leading up to the
Iraq war comes from a former CIA officer who described the Office
of Special Plans as a group of
ideologues
who were dangerous for US national security and a threat to world
peace, and that the group lied and manipulated intelligence to
further its agenda of removing President Hussein. Subsequently, in
2008, the nonpartisan Center for Public Integrity has enumerated a
total of 935 false statements made by George Bush and six other top
members of his administration in what it termed a "carefully
launched campaign of misinformation" during the two year period
following 9-11, in order to rally support for the invasion of
Iraq.
The
financial cost of the
war has been more than £4.5 billion ($9 billion) to the UK, and
over $845 billion to the U.S., with the total cost to the U.S.
economy estimated at $3 trillion.
Criticisms include:
After President Barack Obama was inaugurated in 2009 some anti-war
protestors decided to stop protesting even though the war was still
going on, some of them decided to stop because they felt they
should give the new President time to establish his administration,
and others stopped because they were convinced that the new
President will end the war.
A CNN report noted that the U.S. led interim government, the
Coalition Provisional
Authority lasting until 2004 in Iraq had lost $8,800,000,000 in
the
Development Fund for
Iraq. An inspector general's report mentioned that "'Severe
inefficiencies and poor management' by the Coalition Provisional
Authority would leave no guarantee that the money was properly
used," said Stuart W. Bowen Jr., director of the
Office
of the Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction. "The
CPA did not establish or implement sufficient managerial, financial
and contractual controls to ensure that funds were used in a
transparent manner."
Humanitarian crises
In December 2007, the Iraqi government reported that there were 5
million
orphans in Iraq - nearly half of the
country's children. Iraq's health has deteriorated to a level not
seen since the 1950s, said Joseph Chamie, former director of the
U.N. Population Division and an Iraq specialist. "They were at the
forefront", he said, referring to health care just before the 1991
Persian Gulf War. "Now they're looking more and more like a country
in
sub-Saharan Africa."
Malnutrition rates have risen from 19% before
the US-led invasion to a national average of 28% four years later.
Some 60-70% of Iraqi children are suffering from psychological
problems. 68% of Iraqis have no access to safe drinking water. A
cholera outbreak in
northern Iraq is thought to be the result of poor waterquality. As
many as half of Iraqi doctors have left the country since
2003.

An Iraqi girl from the Janabi Village
waits in line with her father to be examined by an Iraqi doctor,
Yusufiyah, Iraq, March 02, 2008.
The Medical Operation was conducted by U.S.
Soldiers from Charlie Company, 3rd Battalion, 187th Infantry
Regiment, 101st Airborne Division and the Sons of Iraq (Abna
al-Iraq).
Army photo by Spc Luke Thornberry)
Human rights abuses
Throughout the entire Iraq war there have been
human rights abuses on all sides of the
conflict.
Iraqi government
- The use of torture by Iraqi security forces.
Coalition forces and private contractors
- Controversy over whether disproportionate force was used,
during the assaults by
Coalition and (mostly Shia and Kurdish) Iraqi government forces on
the Sunni insurgent stronghold of Fallujah in 2004.
- Planting weapons on noncombatant, unarmed Iraqis by three US
Marines after killing them. According to a report by The Nation, other similar acts have been
witnessed by US soldiers. Members of Iraq Veterans Against the War
tell similar stories.
Insurgent groups

Car bombings are a frequently used
tactic by insurgents in Iraq.
- Killing over 12,000 Iraqis from January 2005 to June 2006,
according to Iraqi Interior Minister Bayan
Jabr, giving the first official count for the victims of
bombings, ambushes and other deadly attacks. The insurgents have
also conducted numerous suicide
attacks on the Iraqi civilian population, mostly targeting the
majority Shia community. An October 2005 report from Human Rights Watch examines the range of
civilian attacks and their purported justification.
- Attacks against civilians including children through bombing of
market places and other locations reachable by car bombs.
- Attacks on diplomats and diplomatic facilities including; the
bombing of the U.N. headquarters in Baghdad in August 2003 killing
the top U.N. representative in Iraq and 21 other UN staff members;
beheading several diplomats: two Algerian diplomatic envoys Ali
Belaroussi and Azzedine Belkadi, Egyptian diplomatic envoy
al-Sherif, and four Russian diplomats.
- The February 2006 bombing of the al-Askari Mosque, destroying
one of the holiest Shiite shrines, killing over 165 worshipers and
igniting sectarian strife and
reprisal killings.
- The publicised killing of several contractors; Eugene Armstrong, Jack Hensley, Kenneth
Bigley, Ivaylo Kepov and Georgi Lazov (Bulgarian truck
drivers.) Other non-military personnel murdered include: translator
Kim Sun-il, Shosei
Koda, Fabrizio Quattrocchi
(Italian), charity worker Margaret
Hassan, reconstruction engineer Nick
Berg, photographer Salvatore Santoro (Italian) and supply
worker Seif Adnan Kanaan (Iraqi.)
Four private armed contractors, Scott Helvenston, Jerko Zovko,
Wesley Batalona and Michael Teague, were killed with grenades and
small arms fire, their bodies dragged from their vehicles, beaten
and set ablaze. Their burned corpses were then dragged through the
streets before being hung over a bridge crossing the
Euphrates.
- Attacks against coalition convoys and bases.
Public opinion on the war
International opinion
According to a January 2007
BBC World
Service poll of more than 26,000 people in 25 countries, 73% of
the global population disapproves of the US handling of the Iraq
War. A September 2007 poll conducted by the BBC found that 2/3rds
of the world's population believed the US should withdraw its
forces from Iraq. According to an April 2004 USA Today/CNN/Gallup
Poll, only a third of the Iraqi people believed that "the
American-led occupation of their country is doing more good than
harm, and a solid majority support an immediate military pullout
even though they fear that could put them in greater
danger."Majorities in the UK and Canada believe the war in Iraq is
"unjustified" and - in the UK - are critical of their government's
support of US policies in Iraq.
According to polls conducted by The Arab American Institute,
four years after the invasion of Iraq, 83% of Egyptians had a
negative view of the US role in Iraq; 68% of Saudi Arabians had a
negative view; 96% of the Jordanian population had a negative view;
70% of the UAE and 76% of the Lebanese
population also described their view as
negative. The Pew Global Attitudes Project reports
that in 2006 majorities in the Netherlands
, Germany, Jordan, France, Lebanon, China, Spain,
Indonesia
, Turkey, Pakistan
, and Morocco
believed the world was safer before the Iraq War
and the toppling of Hussein. Pluralities in the US and India
believe the world is safer without Hussein.
Iraqi opinion
The US government has long maintained its involvement there is with
the support of the Iraqi people, but in 2005 when asked directly,
82–87% of the Iraqi populace was opposed to the US occupation and
wanted US troops to leave. 47% of Iraqis supported attacking US
troops. Another poll conducted on September 27, 2006, found that
seven out of ten Iraqis want US-led forces to withdraw from Iraq
within one year. Overall, 78% of those polled said they believed
that the presence of US forces is "provoking more conflict than
it's preventing." 53% of those polled believed the Iraqi government
would be strengthened if US forces left Iraq (versus 23% who
believed it would be weakened), and 71% wanted this to happen in 1
year or less. All of these positions were more prevalent amongst
Sunni and Shia respondents than among Kurds. 61% of respondents
said that they approve of attacks on US-led forces, although 94%
still had an unfavorable opinion of al-Qaeda.
A March 7, 2007 survey of more than 2,000 Iraqis found that 78% of
the population opposed the presence of Coalition forces in Iraq,
that 69% believed the presence of U.S. forces is making things
worse, and that 51% of the population considered attacks on
coalition forces acceptable, up from 17% in 2004 and 35% in 2006.
In addition:
- 64% described their family's economic situation as being
somewhat or very bad, up from 30% in 2005.
- 88% described the availability of electricity as being either
somewhat or very bad, up from 65% in 2004.
- 69% described the availability of clean water as somewhat or
very bad, up from 48% in 2004.
- 88% described the availability of fuel for cooking and driving
as being somewhat or very bad.
- 58% described reconstruction efforts in the area in which they
live as either somewhat or very ineffective, and 9% described them
as being totally nonexistent.
A 2007 survey for the first time asked ordinary Iraqis their view
on the highly contentious draft oil law. According to the poll, 76
percent of Iraqis feel inadequately informed about the contents of
the proposed law. Nonetheless, 63 percent responded that they would
prefer Iraqi state-owned companies – and not foreign corporations –
to develop Iraq’s extensive oil fields.
Relation to the US Global War on Terrorism
Former President Bush consistently referred to the Iraq war as "the
central front in the
War on
Terror", and argued that if the US pulls out of Iraq,
"terrorists will follow us here." While other proponents of the war
have regularly echoed this assertion, as the conflict has dragged
on, members of the US Congress, the US public, and even US troops
have begun to question the connection between Iraq and the fight
against anti-US terrorism. In particular, a consensus has developed
among intelligence experts that the Iraq war has increased
terrorism.
Counterterrorism expert
Rohan Gunaratna frequently refers to
the invasion of Iraq as a "fatal mistake." London's conservative
International
Institute for Strategic Studies concluded in 2004 that the
occupation of Iraq had become "a potent global recruitment pretext"
for
jihadists and that the invasion
"galvanised" al-Qaeda and "perversely inspired insurgent violence"
there. The US
National
Intelligence Council concluded in a January 2005 report that
the war in Iraq had become a breeding ground for a new generation
of terrorists;
David B. Low, the national intelligence officer for
transnational threats, indicated that the report concluded that the
war in Iraq provided terrorists with "a training ground, a
recruitment ground, the opportunity for enhancing technical
skills... There is even, under the best scenario, over time, the
likelihood that some of the jihadists who are not killed there
will, in a sense, go home, wherever home is, and will therefore
disperse to various other countries." The Council's chairman
Robert L. Hutchings said, "At the moment, Iraq is
a magnet for international terrorist activity." And the 2006
National Intelligence
Estimate, which outlined the considered judgment of all 16 US
intelligence agencies, held that "The Iraq conflict has become the
'cause celebre' for jihadists, breeding a deep resentment of US
involvement in the
Muslim world and
cultivating supporters for the global jihadist movement."
See also
Demographic images of Iraq
Image:Iraq 2003 occupation.png|The various occupation zones in
Iraq.Image:Iraq Provinces Handed Over To Iraqi Security.png|Iraq
governorates or
muhafazat that have been handed over to
Iraqi security control.
References
External media
- Books
- News
- Electronic Iraq: Daily news and analysis from Iraq
with a special focus on the Iraqi experience of war.
- News from
Iraq: Aggregated news on the war, including politics and
economics.
- Iraq: Transition of Power: CNN Special Report:
Three years later, debate rages.
- Iraq war stories, a Guardian and Observer
archive in words and pictures documenting the human and political
cost, The Guardian, Tuesday 14 April 2009.
- Economics
- Analysis
- Maps of Iraq
- Road to War
- Bibliography
- Iraqi sources
- "Iraq Diaries," Iraqis writing about their
experiences of war at ElectronicIraq.net.
- Opinions and polls
- Combat operations related
- Judiciary