John Kenneth "Ken" Galbraith,
OC (October 15, 1908– April 29, 2006) was a
Canadian-American economist. He was a
Keynesian and an
institutionalist, a leading
proponent of 20th-century
American
liberalism and
progressivism. His books
on economic topics were bestsellers from the 1950s through the
1970s and he filled the role of
public intellectual in this period on
matters of economics.
Galbraith was a prolific author who produced four dozen books and
over a thousand articles on various subjects. Among his most famous
works was a popular trilogy on economics,
American Capitalism (1952),
The Affluent Society
(1958), and
The New
Industrial State (1967).
He taught at Harvard University
for many years. Galbraith was active in
politics, serving in the administrations of
Franklin D. Roosevelt,
Harry S. Truman,
John F.
Kennedy and
Lyndon B. Johnson; and among other roles served as
United States
Ambassador to India under Kennedy.
He was one of the few honorees who received the
Presidential Medal of Freedom
twice. He received one in 1946 from President Truman and another in
2000 from President
Bill Clinton. He
was also awarded the
Order of Canada
in 1997 and, in 2001, the
Padma
Vibhushan, India's second highest civilian award, for his
contributions to strengthening ties between India and the United
States.
Life
Early life and teaching
Galbraith
was born to Canadians of Scottish
descent,
Archibald "Archie" Galbraith and Sarah Catherine Kendall, in
Iona Station,
Ontario
, Canada
, and was
raised in Dunwich Township,
Ontario. He had three siblings: Alice, Catherine and
Archibald William (Bill). His early school years were spent at a
one room school on Willy's Sideroad, which is still standing. The
family farm is on Thomson Line. He went to school at Dutton High
School. His father was a farmer and school teacher; his mother, a
political activist. By the time he was a teenager, he had adopted
the name Ken, and later disliked being called John. Both his
parents were supporters of the
United Farmers of Ontario in the
1920s.
After initially studying agriculture,
Galbraith graduated from the University of Toronto
's Ontario
Agricultural College (then affiliated with Toronto, now the
University of
Guelph
) with a B.Sc
degree in 1931, and then received an M.Sc (1933) and Ph.D in Agricultural Economics (1934)
from the University of California,
Berkeley
. In 1934, he also became a tutor at Harvard
University
. In 1937, he became a
United States citizen, at a time
when the USA did not contemplate dual citizenship and Canada did
not yet have a Citizenship Act, Canadians then being "British
Subjects." By the 1980s and '90s respectively, the USA and Canada
acknowledged that their citizens who had taken out citizenship in
the others' countries were recognized as having also retained their
original citizenship and Professor Galbraith died as he had been
born - a Canadian, though he had previously already been amply
honoured as a Canadian as well as American.
In the same year, he
took a year-long fellowship at Cambridge University
, England
, where he
became influenced by John Maynard
Keynes, then traveled in Europe for several months in 1938,
attending an international economic conference and developing his
ideas. Galbraith was a very tall man, growing to a reported
height of 6'9" [206 cm].
Galbraith taught intermittently at Harvard in the period 1934 to
1939.
From
1939 to 1940, he taught at Princeton University
. From 1943 until 1948, he served as editor
of
Fortune magazine. In
1949, he was appointed professor of economics at Harvard.
World War II and Price Administration
During
World War II, Galbraith, charged
with keeping inflation from crippling the war effort, served as
deputy head of the
Office
of Price Administration. Because wartime production needs
mandated large budget deficits and an accommodative monetary
policy, the outbreak of inflation and a runaway wage-price spiral
was seen as a very real possibility. In 1942, Roosevelt issued a
General Maximum Price Regulation, followed a year later by a "Hold
the Line Order" which froze prices and gave the OPE power to keep
prices in check. The OPA itself - through its Consumer Division -
mobilized the public on behalf of these guidelines, reducing the
likelihood of "cheating" by those who would seek higher wages or
prices. The result was that wages and prices were kept in check,
and the U.S. enjoyed rapid growth and price stability through the
war.
Although little appreciated at the time, the actual power Galbraith
wielded in this position was so great that he joked later that the
rest of his career had been downhill. Indeed, congressional and
business backlash against the OPA meant that Galbraith would be
forced out in 1943, eventually replaced by advertising executive
Samuel Bowles.
At the end of the war, Galbraith was asked to be one of the leaders
of the
Strategic Bombing
Surveys of both Europe and Japan.
He also became an
adviser to post-war administrations in Germany
and Japan
.
Political posts under Kennedy
his time as an adviser to President
John
F. Kennedy, Galbraith was appointed as
United States Ambassador to
India from 1961 to 1963. His rapport with President Kennedy was
such that he regularly bypassed the State Department and sent his
diplomatic cables directly to the President. In India, he became an
intimate of Prime Minister
Jawaharlal
Nehru, and extensively advised the Indian government on
economic matters; he harshly criticised
Louis Mountbatten, the last Viceroy of
British rule, for Mountbatten's passive role in the
Partition of India in 1947 and the bloody
partition of the Punjab and Bengal.
While in India, he helped establish one of
the first computer science departments, at the Indian Institute of
Technology in Kanpur
, Uttar Pradesh
. Even after leaving office, Galbraith
remained a friend and supporter of India and hosted a lunch for
Indian students at Harvard every year on graduation day.
Because of his recommendation,
First Lady of the United
States Jacqueline Bouvier
Kennedy undertook her
diplomatic
missions in India and Pakistan.
Family
Galbraith married
Catherine Merriam
Atwater on September 17, 1937, whom he met while she was a
Radcliffe student.
They resided in Cambridge,
Massachusetts
, and had a summer home in Newfane,
Vermont
. They had four sons: J. Alan Galbraith is a
partner in the prominent Washington D.C. law firm
Williams & Connolly; Douglas
Galbraith died in childhood of leukemia;
Peter W. Galbraith has been a US diplomat who
served as Ambassador to Croatia and is a widely published
commentator on American foreign policy, particularly in the Balkans
and the Middle East;
James K.
Galbraith is a prominent progressive
economist at the University of Texas at Austin
Lyndon B.
Johnson School of Public
Affairs
. The Galbraiths also have ten grandchildren.
[12651]
Later life and recognition
In 1972 he served as president of the
American Economic Association.
The
Journal of Post Keynesian Economics benefited from
Galbraith's support, and he served as the chairman of its board
from its beginning. In 1985, the
American Humanist Association
named him the Humanist of the Year. In 1997 he was made an Officer
of the
Order of Canada and in 2000
he was awarded his second U. S.
Presidential Medal of Freedom.
He was
also awarded an honorary doctorate from Memorial
University of Newfoundland
at the fall convocation of 1999. He was also
awarded in 2000 with the Leontief Prize for his outstanding
contribution to economic theory by the
Global Development
and Environment Institute. The library in his home town
Dutton, Ontario was renamed
the John Kenneth Galbraith Reference Library in honor of his
attachment to the library and his contributions to the new
building.
On April
29, 2006, Galbraith died in Cambridge, Massachusetts
of natural causes, after a two-week stay in a
hospital.
Honors
Honorary Degrees
John Kenneth Galbraith received 50
Honorary Degrees from institutions around
the world:
- Bard College
in Annandale-on-Hudson, New York
(LL.D) in
1958
- University of Toronto
in Toronto, Ontario
(LL.D) in
1961
- University of Guelph
in Guelph, Ontario
in 1965
- University of Saskatchewan
in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
(LL.D) on May 20,
1965
- Boston College
in Boston, Massachusetts
(LL.D) in
1967
- HWS University in Geneva, New
York
(LL.D) in
1967
- University of Western Ontario
in London, Ontario
(LL.D) on 31 May
1968
- Tufts University
in Boston, Massachusetts
(DHL) in
1968
- Albion College
in Albion,
Michigan
(D.Litt) in
1968
- Knox College
in Galesburg, Illinois
in 1970
- Michigan State University
in East Lansing, Michigan
(LL.D) in Fall
1971
- York University
in Toronto, Ontario
(LL.D) Spring
1976
- Rutgers University
in New Brunswick, New Jersey
(LL.D) in
1979
- Grinnell
College in Grinnell,
Iowa
(LL.D) in
1983
- Smith College
in Northampton, Massachusetts
(LL.D) in
1989
- London School of Economics
in London, England
(D.Sc) on 28 June
1999
- Memorial
University of Newfoundland
in St. John's, Newfoundland
(D.Litt) Fall
1999
Works
Although he was a president of the American Economic Association,
Galbraith was considered an
iconoclast by
many economists. This is because he rejected the technical analyses
and mathematical models of
neoclassical economics as being
divorced from reality. Rather, following
Thorstein Veblen, he believed that economic
activity could not be distilled into inviolable laws, but rather
was a complex product of the cultural and political milieu in which
it occurs. In particular, he believed that important factors such
as advertising, the separation between corporate ownership and
management,
oligopoly, and the influence
of government and military spending had been largely neglected by
most economists because they are not amenable to axiomatic
descriptions. In this sense, he worked as much in
political economy as in classical
economics.
His work included several best selling works throughout the fifties
and sixties. After his retirement, he remained in the public
consciousness by continuing to write new books and revise his old
works as well as presenting a major series on economics for
BBC television in 1977 "
The Age of Uncertainty". While some
considered his views anachronistic during the pro-market,
small-government, anti-regulation and low-tax orthodoxies which
came to prominence in the 1980s, the downfall of those ideas'
popularity with the late 2000s economic crisis has awakened
interest in his theories once again.
In addition to his books, he wrote hundreds of essays and a number
of novels. Among his novels,
A
Tenured Professor achieved particular critical
acclaim.
Economics books
Galbraith was an important figure in 20th century
institutional economics, and
provides perhaps the exemplar institutionalist perspective on
Economic Power.
In
American Capitalism: The
Concept of Countervailing Power, published in 1952,
Galbraith outlined how the American economy in the future would be
managed by a triumvirate of big business, big labor, and an
activist government. Galbraith termed the reaction of lobby groups
and unions "countervailing power." He contrasted this arrangement
with the previous pre-depression era where big business had
relatively free rein over the economy.
His 1954 bestseller
The Great
Crash, 1929 describes the famous Wall Street melt down of
stock prices and how markets progressively become decoupled from
reality in a speculative boom. The book is also a platform for
Galbraith's keen insights, and humour, into human behaviour when
wealth is threatened. It has never been out of print.
In his most famous work,
The
Affluent Society (1958), which also became a bestseller,
Galbraith outlined his view that to become successful, post-World
War II America should make large investments in items such as
highways and education using funds from general taxation.
Galbraith also critiqued the assumption that continually increasing
material production is a sign of economic and societal health.
Because of this Galbraith is sometimes considered one of the first
post-materialists. In this book, he
coined and popularized the phrase "
conventional wisdom". Galbraith worked
on the book while in Switzerland, and had originally titled it
Why The Poor Are Poor but changed it to
The Affluent
Society at his wife's suggestion.
The Affluent
Society contributed (likely to a significant degree, given
that Galbraith had the ear of President Kennedy ) to the "
war on poverty," the government spending
policy first brought on by the administrations of Kennedy and
Johnson.
In
The New Industrial
State (1967), Galbraith argues that very few industries in
the United States fit the model of
perfect competition. In The New
Industrial State Galbraith expanded his analysis of the role of
power in economic life. A central concept of the book is the
revised sequence. The conventional wisdom in economic thought
portrays economic life as a set of competitive markets governed
ultimately by the decisions of sovereign consumers. In this
original sequence, the control of the production process flows from
consumers of commodities to the organizations that produce those
commodities. In the revised sequence, this flow is reversed and
businesses exercise control over consumers by advertising and
related salesmanship activities.
The revised sequence concept applies only to the industrial system
- that is, the manufacturing core of the economy in which each
industry contains only a handful of very powerful corporations. It
does not apply to the market system in the Galbraithian dual
economy. In the market system, composed of the vast majority of
business organizations, price competition remains the dominant form
of social control. In the industrial system, however, composed of
the 1,000 or so largest corporations, competitive price theory
obscures the relation to the price system of these large and
powerful corporations. In Galbraith's view, the principal function
of market relations in this industrial system is not to constrain
the power of the corporate behemoths but to serve as an instrument
for the implementation of their power. Moreover, the power of these
corporations extends into commercial culture and politics, allowing
them to exercise considerable influence upon popular social
attitudes and value judgments. That this power is exercised in the
shortsighted interest of expanding commodity production and the
status of the few is both inconsistent with democracy and a barrier
to achieving the quality of life which the new industrial state
with its affluence could provide.
The New Industrial State not only provided Galbraith with another
best-selling book, it also extended once again the currency of
Institutionalist economic thought. The book also filled a very
pressing need in the late 1960s. The conventional theory of
monopoly power in economic life maintains that the monopolist will
attempt to restrict supply in order to maintain price above its
competitive level. The social cost of this monopoly power is a
decrease in both allocative efficiency and the equity of income
distribution. This conventional economic analysis of the role of
monopoly power did not adequately address popular concern about the
large corporation in the late 1960s. The growing concern focused on
the role of the corporation in politics, the damage done to the
natural environment by an unmitigated commitment to economic
growth, and the perversion of advertising and other pecuniary
aspects of culture. The New Industrial State gave a plausible
explanation of the power structure involved in generating these
problems and thus found a very receptive audience among the rising
American counterculture and political activists.
A third related work was
Economics and the Public Purpose
(1973), in which he expanded on these themes by discussing, among
other issues, the subservient role of women in the unrewarded
management of ever-greater consumption, and the role of the
technostructure in the large firm in
influencing perceptions of sound economic policy aims.
In
A Short
History of Financial Euphoria (1994), he traces
speculative bubbles through several centuries, and argues that they
are inherent in the economic system because of "mass psychology"
and the "vested interest in error that accompanies speculative
euphoria." Also, financial memory is "notoriously short": what
currently seems to be a "new financial instrument" is inevitably
nothing of the sort. Galbraith cautions: "The world of finance
hails the invention of the wheel over and over again, often in a
slightly more unstable version." Crucial to his analysis is the
assertion that the common factor in boom and bust is the creation
of debt to finance speculation, which "becomes dangerously out of
scale in relation to the underlying means of payment".
Galbraith cherished
The New Industrial State and
The
Affluent Society as his two best. Economist and friend of
Galbraith
Michael Sharpe visited
Galbraith in 2004, on which occasion Galbraith gifted him with a
copy of what would be Galbraith's last book,
The Economics of
Innocent Fraud. Galbraith confided in Sharpe that "[t]his is
my best book", an assertion Galbraith delivered "a little
mischievously."
Some of Galbraith's Ideas
Galbraith's main ideas focused around the influence of the
market power of large corporations. He believed
that this market power weakened the widely-accepted principle of
consumer sovereignty, allowing corporations to be price makers,
rather than price takers, allowing corporations with the strongest
market power to increase the production of their goods beyond an
efficient amount. He further believed that market power played a
major role in inflation and argued that corporations and trade
unions could only increase prices to the extent that their market
power allowed them to. He argued that in situations of excessive
market power, price controls effectively controlled inflation, but
cautioned against using them in markets that were basically
efficient such as agricultural goods and housing. He noted that
price controls were much easier to enforce in industries with
relatively few buyers and sellers. Galbraith's view of market power
was not entirely negative; he also noted that the power of US firms
played a part in the success of the US economy.
In
The Affluent Society Galbraith asserts that classical
economic theory was true for the eras before the present, which
were times of "poverty"; now, however, we have moved from an age of
poverty to an age of "affluence," and for such an age, a completely
new economic theory is needed. Galbraith's main argument is that as
society becomes relatively more affluent, so private business must
"create" consumer wants through advertising, and while this
generates artificial affluence through the production of commercial
goods and services, the public sector becomes neglected. He points
out that while many Americans were able to purchase luxury items,
their parks were polluted and their children attended poorly
maintained schools. He argues that markets alone will underprovide
(or fail to provide at all) for many public goods, whereas private
goods are typically 'overprovided' due to the process of
advertising creating an artificial demand above the individual's
basic needs. This emphasis on the power of advertising and
consequent overconsumption may have anticipated the drop in savings
rates in the USA and elsewhere in the developing world.
Galbraith proposed curbing the consumption of certain products
through greater use of consumption taxes, arguing that this could
be more efficient than other forms of taxation, such as labour or
land taxes. Galbraith's major proposal was a program he called
"investment in men" — a large-scale publicly-funded education
program aimed at empowering ordinary citizens. Galbraith wished to
entrust citizens with the future of the American republic.
Volume 20, issue 4 of the
Review of
Political Economy was dedicated to John Kenneth Galbraith's
ideas.
Criticism of Galbraith's Work
Galbraith's work, in general, and
The Affluent Society, in
particular, have drawn sharp criticism from free-market supporters
at the time of its publication.
Monetarist
Milton Friedman in "Friedman on
Galbraith, and on curing the British disease" views Galbraith as a
20th century version of the early 19th century Tory radical of Great Britain
. He asserts that Galbraith believes in the
superiority of aristocracy and in its paternalistic authority, that
consumers should not be allowed choice and that all should be
determined by those with "higher minds":
Many reformers – Galbraith is not alone in this – have
as their basic objection to a free market that it frustrates them
in achieving their reforms, because it enables people to have what
they want, not what the reformers want.
Hence every reformer has a strong tendency to be averse
to a free market.
Richard Parker, in his
biography
John Kenneth Galbraith: His Life, His Economics, His
Politics, characterizes Galbraith as more complex. Galbraith's
primary purpose in
Capitalism: The Concept of Countervailing
Power (1952) was, ironically, to show that
big business was now necessary to the American
economy to maintain the
technological progress that drives
economic growth. However, Galbraith
saw the necessity of "countervailing power," not only including
government regulation and
oversight, but also collective bargaining, and the suasion that
large retailers and distributors could bring to bear on large
producers and suppliers. In
The New Industrial State
(1967), Galbraith argued that the dominant American corporations
had created a
technostructure that
closely controlled both
consumer
demand and
market growth through
advertising and
marketing. While Galbraith defended government
intervention, Parker notes that he also believed that government
and big business worked together to maintain stability.
Paul Krugman, the influential, Nobel
Prize–winning Princeton University
professor and New
York Times op-ed columnist, has
denigrated Galbraith's stature as an economist. In
Peddling Prosperity: Economic Sense and Nonsense in an Age of
Diminished Expectations, he calls Galbraith a "policy
entrepreneur" – an economist who writes solely for the public, as
opposed to one who writes for other professors, and who therefore
makes unwarranted diagnoses and offers over-simplistic answers to
complex economic problems. He asserts that Galbraith was never
taken seriously by fellow academics, who viewed him as more of a
"media personality". For example, Krugman believes that Galbraith's
work
The New Industrial State is not considered to be
"real economic theory", and that
Economics in Perspective
is "remarkably ill-informed". However, acknowledging the alleged
damage caused by the
George
W. Bush
administration, Krugman now says of his polemics in the 1990s,
“I was wrong obviously. If I’d understood where politics would be
now, it would have been quite different.”
Describing the reception of Galbraith's lectures by students at
Harvard,
Thomas Sowell coined the term
"the Galbraith Effect":
“On the first day of class, Professor Galbraith gave a
brilliant opening lecture, after which the students gave him a
standing ovation. Galbraith kept on giving brilliant opening
lectures the whole semester. But, instead of standing ovations,
there were now dwindling numbers of students and some of them got
up and walked out in the middle of his lectures. Galbraith never
got beyond the glittering generalities that marked his first
lecture. After a while, the students got tired of not getting any
real substance.”
Memoirs
The Scotch (published in the UK under two alternative
titles as
Made to Last and
The Non-potable Scotch: A
Memoir of the Clansmen in Canada) (illustrated by Samuel H.
Bryant),
Galbraith's account of his boyhood environment in Elgin County in
southern Ontario
, was written in 1963. His description of the
people he grew up among is amusing, but hardly charitable.
Galbraith's 1981 memoir,
A Life in Our Times stimulated
discussion of his thought, his life and times after his retirement
from academic life. In 2004, the publication of an authorised
biography,
John Kenneth Galbraith: His Life, His Politics, His
Economics by friend and fellow progressive economist
Richard Parker, renewed interest
in his career and ideas.
Bibliography
- Modern
Competition and Business Policy, 1938.
- A Theory of Price
Control, 1952.
- American
Capitalism: The Concept of Countervailing Power,
1952.
- The Great Crash,
1929, 1954.
- Economics
and the Art of Controversy, 1955.
- The Affluent
Society, 1958.
- Perspectives on
conservation, 1958. (Editor)
- The Liberal Hour,
1960
- Economic
Development in Perspective, 1962.
- The Scotch, 1963
- The McLandress
Dimension, 1963 (pseudonym Mark Epernay)
- Economic
Development, 1964.
- The New Industrial
State, 1967.
- Beginner's
Guide to American Studies, 1967.
- How to get out of
Vietnam, 1967.
- The Triumph (a novel),
1968.
- Ambassador's
Journal, 1969.
- How to control the
military, 1969.
- Indian Painting (with
Mohinder Singh Randhawa), 1969.
- Who needs
democrats, and what it takes to be needed, 1970.
- American Left and
Some British Comparisons, 1971.
- Economics, Peace
and Laughter, 1972.
- Power and the
Useful Economist, 1973, AER
- Economics and
the Public Purpose, 1973
- A China Passage,
1973.
- John
Kenneth Galbraith introduces India, 1974. (Editor)
- Money:
Whence It Came, Where It Went, 1975.
- Socialism
in rich countries and poor, 1975.
-
The Economic effects of the Federal public works expenditures,
1933-38, (with G. Johnson) 1975.
- The Age of
Uncertainty (also a BBC 13 part television series),
1977.
- The Galbraith
Reader, 1977.
- Almost
Everyone's Guide to Economics, 1978. (With Nicole
Salinger.)
- Annals of an
Abiding Liberal, 1979.
- The Nature of Mass
Poverty, 1979.
- A Life in Our
Times, 1981.
- The Voice of the
Poor, 1983.
- The Anatomy of
Power, 1983.
- Essays from the
Poor to the Rich, 1983.
- Reaganomics: Meaning, Means
and Ends, (with Paul McCracken) 1983.
- A View from the
Stands, 1986.
- Economics in
Perspective: A Critical History, 1987.
- Capitalism, Communism and
Coexistence (with Stanislav Menshikov), 1988.
-
Unconventional Wisdom: Essays on Economics in Honour of John
Kenneth Galbraith, 1989. (Editor)
- A Tenured
Professor, 1990.
- A History of
Economics: The Past as the Present, 1991.
- The Culture of
Contentment, 1992.
- Recollections
of the New Deal: When People Mattered, 1992. (Editor)
- A Journey
Through Economic Time, 1994.
- The World
Economy Since the Wars: A Personal View, 1994.
- A Short
History of Financial Euphoria, 1994.
- The Good
Society: the humane agenda, 1996.
- Letters to Kennedy,
1998.
- The socially
concerned today, 1998.
- Name-Dropping:
From F.D.R. On, 1999.
- The Essential
Galbraith, 2001.
- The Economics of
Innocent Fraud, 2004.
- John Kenneth
Galbraith and the future of economics, 2005.
See also
References
Footnotes
External links