A
muckraker seeks to expose
corruption of businesses or
government to the public. The term originates
from writers of the
Progressive
movement in America who wanted to expose corruption and
scandals in government and business. Muckrakers often wrote about
the wretchedness of urban life and poverty, and against the
established institutions of society, such as big business. They
were often accused of being
socialists or
communists.
In
British English usage the term
tends to have a more negative connotation, indicating a greater
sense of
prurience.
History
Muckrakers were a significant part of reform in the United States
in the 20th and 21st Centuries because of the freedom of the press
provided for by the First Amendment of the Constitution. They
played a significant role in the social justice movements for
reform, and the campaigns to clean up cities and states, by
constantly reporting and publicizing the dark corners of American
society in a sensationalist way.
Origin of the term
The period 1700-1802 saw an increase in the kind of reporting that
would come to be called "muckraking." By the 1900s, magazines such
as
Cosmopolitan,
The Independent, Munsey's
and
McClure's were already in
wide circulation and read avidly by the growing middle class.
The term "muckraker" was first used in a speech on April 14, 1906
by President Theodore Roosevelt: “In Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress
you may recall the description of the Man with the Muck-rake, the
man who could look no way but downward with the muck-rake in his
hands; Who was offered a celestial crown for his muck-rake, but who
would neither look up nor regard the crown he was offered, but
continued to rake to himself the filth of the floor.” This first
reference to "muckrakers" is believed to have been with the
William Randolph Hearst's
magazines and newspapers in mind, notable for their
yellow journalism.
Roosevelt saw benefits and disadvantages to muckraking activity. He
declared that although these men did good work when they scraped up
the ‘filth’ of America, "the man who did nothing else was certain
to become a force of evil.” On the other hand, he said, "I hail as
a benefactor…every writer or speaker, every man who, on the
platform, or in book, magazine, or newspaper, with merciless
severity makes such attack, provided always that he in turn
remembers that that attack is of use only if it absolutely
truthful”.
The term eventually came to be used to depict investigative
journalists who exposed the dark corners and all the corruption of
American public life, especially in corporate America.
As mentioned before, the Muckrakers were part of the social justice
movement during the Progressive era. During this time period, these
journalists, through their research and constant exposure of the
wrongdoing by officials in American public life, gave fuel to
protests that led to investigations and later on reform of not only
Corporate America but the American Government. The Muckrakers’
journalistic efforts helped reform and regulate Wall Street and
aspects of big businesses. The muckrakers also shed light on an
array of social issues, such as the issues with urban housing and
horrible living conditions in highly populated cities, medical
patents, child labor laws, child prostitution, and even women’s
rights.
Early 20th century muckraking
Lincoln Steffens published “Tweed
Days in St. Louis,” in which he profiled corrupt leaders in St.
Louis, in October, 1902, in McClure’s Magazine.
Ida Tarbell published
The Rise of
the Standard Oil Company in 1902, providing insight into the
manipulation of trusts. She followed that work with
The History of The
Standard Oil Company: the Oil War of 1872, which appeared
in
McClure's Magazine in
1908.
Upton Sinclair published
The Jungle in 1906, which revealed
conditions in the meat packing industry in the United States and
was a major factor in the establishment of the
Pure Food and Drug Act.
Ray Stannard Baker published
The Right to Work in McClure's magazine in 1903, about
coal mine conditions, an ongoing coal strike, and the situation of
non-striking workers (or scabs)
The Treason of the Senate:
Aldrich, the Head of it All, by
David Graham Phillips, published as a
series of articles in
Cosmopolitan magazine in
February, 1906, described corruption in the U.S. Senate.
The Great American Fraud by
Samuel Hopkins Adams revealed
fraudulent claims and endorsements of patent medicines in
America.
There were many other works by many other great Muckrakers, which
brought to light a variety of Issues in America which were
addressed during the Progressive era.
Second half of the 20th century
An example of a contemporary muckraking work is
Ralph Nader's
Unsafe at Any Speed (1965) which
led to reforms in automotive manufacturing in the United
States.
In the 1970s,
Bob Woodward and
Carl Bernstein — journalists for
The Washington Post — uncovered and
wrote about the U.S. Executive Branch corruption that came to be
known as the
Watergate
scandal.
Muckraking has been a factor in reform in countries besides the
United States. For instance, in 1979, the Chinese author
Liu Binyan created a sensation with his
muckraking report
People or
Monsters, about Chinese bureaucratic corruption.
Muckrakers and their works
Early Muckrakers
- Samuel Hopkins Adams
(1871–1958) — The Great American Fraud, exposed false
claims about patent medicines
- Ray Stannard Baker
(1870–1946) — of McClure's &
The American
Magazine
- Nellie Bly (1864 – 1922) Ten Days
in a Mad-House
- Cecil Chesterton (1879-1918) -
of The New Witness and the
1912 Marconi scandal in Britain
- Claud Cockburn (1904-1981) -
In Time of Trouble
(1956), A Discord of
Trumpets
- Burton J. Hendrick (1870–1949) — "The Story of Life
Insurance" May - November 1906 McClure's
- Helen Hunt Jackson
(1831–1885) — A Century of Dishonor, U.S. policy regarding
American Indians
- Frances Kellor (1873-1952) —
Studied chronic unemployment in her book Out of Work
(1904)
- Thomas W.
Lawson (1857-1924)
Frenzied Finance (1906) on Amalgamated Copper stock
scandal
- Henry Demarest Lloyd
(1847-1903) - Wealth Against Commonwealth, exposed the
corruption within the Standard Oil Company
- Jessica Mitford (1917–1996) —
author of The American Way of Death (US Funeral Industry)
and Making of a Muckraker (collection on various topics
including writing schools and prisons)
- Frank Norris (1870 -1902)
The Octopus
- Fremont Older (1856 - 1935) San
Francisco corruption and the case of Tom
Mooney
- Westbrook Pegler (1894–1969) —
exposed crime in labor unions in 1940s
- Jacob Riis (1849-1914) - How the
Other Half Lives, the slums
- Charles Edward Russell
(1860–1941) — investigated Beef Trust, Georgia's prison
- George Seldes (1890–1995) —
Freedom of the Press (1935) and Lords of the
Press (1938), blacklisted during the 1950s period of
McCarthyism.
- Upton Sinclair (1878–1968) —
The Jungle (1906), U.S.
meat-packing industry, and the books in the "Dead Hand" series that
critique the institutions (journalism, education, etc.) that could
but did not prevent these abuses.
- John Spargo, (1876–1966) — American
reformer and author, The
Bitter Cry of Children (child labor)
- William Thomas Stead -
crusaded against child prostitution in Victorian England with
The Maiden
Tribute of Modern Babylon in the Pall Mall Gazette
- Lincoln Steffens (1866 – 1936)
The Shame of the Cities
(1904)
- I.F. Stone
(1907–1989) — McCarthyism and Vietnam War, published newsletter, I.F.
Stone's Weekly
- Kasey Swift (1904-1999) - Weekly
editor of Atlanta Journal Constitution, wrote Keys to
the City (non-fiction book about influence of political bosses
on Atlanta politics). Early Civil Rights advocate.
- Ida M. Tarbell (1857 – 1944) exposé, The History of the
Standard Oil Company
- John Kenneth Turner —
(1879-1948) author of Barbarous Mexico (1910), an account
of the exploitative debt peonage system used in Mexico under
Porfirio Díaz.
Contemporary muckrakers
- Andrew Breitbart — Exposed
corruption at Acorn and the NEA. He is a journalist, commentator,
and co-author of Hollywood, Interrupted: Insanity Chic in
Babylon.
- Ben Bagdikian — journalist and
major American Media Critic, also the dean emeritus of the
University of California at Berkeley's Graduate School of
Journalism; author of The Media Monopoly and The New
Media Monopoly
- Wayne Barrett — investigative
journalist, senior editor of the Village Voice; wrote on mystique and
misdeeds in Rudy Giuliani's conduct as
mayor of New York City, Grand Illusion: The Untold Story of
Rudy Giuliani and 9/11 (2006)
- Richard Behar — investigative
journalist, two-time winner of the 'Jack
Anderson Award'. Anderson himself once praised Behar as "one of
the most dogged of our watchdogs"
- Wayne
Dolcefino - investigative news reporter for KTRK-TV
channel 13
in Houston
- Barbara Ehrenreich —
journalist and author - Nickel and
Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America
- Stuart Goldman- investigative
reporter, critic, syndicated columnist.
- Juan Gonzalez —
investigative reporter, columnist in New York Daily News
- Amy Goodman — broadcast journalist,
host of Pacifica Radio Network's
program Democracy Now!
- John Howard Griffin
(1920–1980) — white journalist who disguised himself as a black man
to write about racial injustice in the south
- Seymour Hersh —
My Lai
massacre
, Israeli
nuclear weapons program, Henry
Kissinger, the Kennedys, 2003 invasion of Iraq, Abu
Ghraib
abuses
- Malcolm Johnson — exposed
organized crime on the New York waterfront
- Kemal
Kılıçdaroğlu — Turkish social democrat uncovering the big
corruption scandals of the Justice and Development
Party .
- Jonathan Kwitny (1941–1998) —
wrote numerous investigative articles for the The Wall Street Journal
- Joshua Micah Marshall -
writer and journalist, operates the muckraking blog TPM Muckraker, responsible for helping to
break the 2006-2007 US Attorney firing scandal, the Duke Cunningham corruption case and
others.
- Stephen Mayne —
shareholder-activist and founder of crikey.com.au
- Mark Crispin Miller —
professor and writer; has written on 2000 and 2004 contested
elections
- Michael Moore — documentary filmmaker, director of
Roger & Me, Bowling for Columbine,
Fahrenheit 911, and
Sicko
- Ralph Nader — consumer rights
advocate; Unsafe at Any Speed (1965), exposed unsafe
automobile manufacturing
- Allan Nairn — Dili Massacre, US backing of Haitian death squad FRAPH
- Jack Newfield — muckraking
columnist; wrote for New York
Post
- Greg Palast — politics and elections
issues, Exxon Valdez,
corporate crime, corruption
- John Pilger — award-winning war
correspondent, film maker and author
- Anna Politkovskaya — Murdered
Russian journalist critical of the Kremlin
- Jeffrey Robinson - author of
The Laundrymen - Inside money laundering, the world's third
largest business
- Jeremy Scahill - author of
Blackwater: The Rise of the World's Most Powerful Mercenary
Army, contributor to Democracy
Now!
- Eric Schlosser — author of
Fast Food Nation, an
exposé of fast food in American culture
- Morgan Spurlock — American
Filmmaker; exposed through example the dangers of McDonalds in his documentary Super Size Me
- Maia Szalavitz - Author of
Help at Any Cost: How the Troubled-Teen Industry Cons Parents and
Hurts Kids, an expose of abuse in the unregulated troubled
teen industry and controversy surrounding the methods and
philosophy behind tough love behavior modification.
- Studs Terkel — Legendary Chicago
writer, journalist, DJ, and historian
- Dr. Hunter S. Thompson (1937–2005) — American
journalist and author credited with the invention of gonzo journalism
- Günter Wallraff - German
journalist who famously makes extensive use of undercover journalism
- Gary Webb (1955–2004) — investigated
Contra-crack
cocaine connection, published as Dark Alliance
(1999)
- Gary Weiss — exposed the Mob on Wall
Street, described by Barron's
Magazine as "an old-time gumshoe, with a soupçon of
little-guy champion Jimmy Breslin and a dash of 1950s bad-boy comic
Lenny Bruce"
- Nathan Winograd -- exposes
issues in U.S. animal shelters in Redemption (2007)
- Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein — breakthrough journalists for
The Washington Post on
the Watergate scandal; authors of
All the President's
Men, non-fiction account of the scandal
See also
Notes
- pg. 49. Regier, C.C. The Era of the Muckrakers. University of
North Carolina press; 1932, 1957.
- pg. 62. American Epoch, IBID
- Brinkley, Alan. "Chapter 21: Rise of Progressivism". Edited by
Barrosse, Emily (in United States English). American History, A
Survey (Twelfth Edition ed.). Los Angeles, CA: McGraw Hill. p.
566-567. ISBN 978-0-07-325718-1.
- Regier, Cornelius C. The era of the muckrakers. P. Smith
publishers. Gloucester, Mass.1957 [c1932
- The Muckrakers. Edited by Arthur and Lila Weinberg. University
of Illinois Press 2001
- pg. 13 Aileen Gallagher, The Muckrakers, American journalism
during the age of reform. The Rosen Publishing Group, INC.
2006
- pg. 13 Aileen Gallagher, The Muckrakers, American journalism
during the age of reform. The Rosen Publishing Group, INC.
2006
- Edited by Arthur and Lila Weinberg. The Muckrakers. University
of Illinois press, urbana Chicago, 2001 [1961]
r