Organ theft is the practice of stealing people's
organs via surgery while they are under the influence of drugs, or
once the person is dead, when the organs can be illicitly removed
and then used for further purposes such as transplants or sold on
the
black market.
Emergence of Organ Theft
The international
organ theft have
become a multi-national dollar business throughout the world where
organs are being harvested without informed consent from both live
and dead individuals. Organ theft is mainly prevalent in developing
countries due to low government enforcements and human right
policies.
Evidence for the phenomenon
The practice is occasionally advanced as a theory into mysterious
disappearances or murders, and is then advanced by sensationalist
news reports, followed by word-of-mouth promotion as an
urban legend.
Its semicredible basis, in fact, is the extreme difficulty with
which organs can be preserved postmortem (usually requiring a
braindead but still functionally alive
patient), and the long waiting lists for available organs. There
has never been sufficient evidence, however, to suggest that the
practice has ever occurred on an organized basis.
This has not prevented its repeated depiction in horror movies and
fiction novels.
Organ theft events
It has been confirmed that the organs of a number of prisoners in
China were taken for transplant after their executions (though
ostensibly with their forced permission) on a for-profit basis,
often to foreign nationals. The Chinese authoritarian justice
system is alleged to work very quickly for those sentenced to
death, not allowing significant time for appeals. This has led to
allegations that the entire justice system has been corrupted by a
government approved system of organ theft. Among those making this
claim are
Harry Wu and the
Laogai Research Foundation. Until
2006, the Chinese government did not have a specific law in place
outlawing the acquisition of organs without express consent.
However, even with this new statute, other conflicting statutes
remain, including that which allows State prisons to use prisoners
in whatever way it deems beneficial to the State.
In July 2006, former Canadian Secretary of State
David Kilgour, and Human Rights Lawyer
David Matas, published a report
concluding that "...large numbers of
Falun
Gong practitioners are victims of systematic organ harvesting,
whilst still alive..."
In
The Hunt: Me and
War criminals,
Carla Del
Ponte claims that
Kosovo
Albanians smuggled human organs of kidnapped Serbs after the
Kosovo war ended in 1999.
Organ sale
Although illegal in most countries, the sale of organs is common.
Accurate statistics are hard to come by, but in March 2007, one
estimate was that 5 to 10% of the world's kidney transplants
involved compensation. Although many reports that this trade has
involved coercion or kidnapping (thus becoming organ theft) have
turned out to be just rumors, some cases have involved theft, for
example the
2008 kidney ring
run by doctor Amit Kumar in India.
Another example is from Brazil, where a woman had a routine ovarian
cyst surgery but later realized that one of her kidneys had
disappeared during her operation. This had occured without her
knowledge when she realized after she went for a checkup at a
different location than the hospital that she had her surgery. The
hospital refused to provide her with any information or
justification for her organ theft that had taken place during her
surgery. These types of routine acts of theft are done for organ
trafficking that can be later sold to the highest bid.
See also
References
Further reading
- Marie-Monique Robin,
Voleurs d'yeux (1995 Albert
Londres award)
- Joel Bast, How Claims Spread: Cross-National Diffusion of
Social Problems, chapter: The Diffusion of Organ Theft
Narratives
- Michael Parmly, Principal Deputy
Assistant Secretary of State Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and
Labor Hearing Before the Subcommittee on International
Operations and Human Rights Washington, DC June 27, 2001
- Police Hunt for Doctor in Kidney-Snatching Ring
CNN, January 29 2008
- BBC News - Sellafield organ removal inquiry
18/04/2007
- The Epoch Times - New Witness Confirms Existence of
Chinese Concentration Camp, Says Organs Removed from Live
Victims
- CNN.com Law Center - UCLA
suspends its
Willed Body Program 09/03/2004
- Illegal Organ Trafficking Poses A Global
Problem by The Huffington Post, July 24 2009