A
parody ( ; also called
send-up
or
spoof), in contemporary usage, is a work
created to mock, comment on, or poke fun at an original work, its
subject, author, style, or some other target, by means of humorous,
satiric or
ironic
imitation. As the literary theorist
Linda
Hutcheon (2000: 7) puts it, "parody … is imitation, not always
at the expense of the parodied text." Another critic, Simon Dentith
(2000: 9), defines parody as "any cultural practice which provides
a relatively
polemical allusive imitation of
another cultural production or practice." Often, the most
satisfying element of a good parody is seeing others mistake it for
the genuine article.
Parody may be found in art or culture, including
literature,
music
(although "parody" in music has a rather wider meaning than for
other art forms), and
cinema. Parodies are
sometimes colloquially referred to as spoofs or lampoons.
Origins
According to
Aristotle (
Poetics, ii. 5),
Hegemon of Thasos was the inventor of a
kind of parody; by slightly altering the wording in well-known
poems he transformed the sublime into the ridiculous. In ancient
Greek literature, a
parodia was a narrative poem imitating the style and
prosody of
epic "but treating light,
satirical or mock-heroic subjects" (Denith, 10). Indeed, the
apparent Greek roots of the word are
para- (which can mean
beside,
counter, or
against) and
-ody (
song, as in an ode). Thus, the original
Greek word
parodia has sometimes been taken to mean
counter-song, an imitation that is set against the
original. The Oxford English Dictionary, for example, defines
parody as imitation "turned as to produce a ridiculous effect"
(quoted in Hutcheon, 32). Because
par- also has the
non-antagonistic meaning of
beside, "there is nothing in
parodia to necessitate the inclusion of a concept of
ridicule" (Hutcheon, 32).
Roman writers explained parody as an
imitation of one poet by another for humorous effect.
In French
Neoclassical literature,
parody was also a type of poem where one work imitates the
style of another for humorous effect.
Music
In
classical music,
parody
means a reworking of one kind of composition into another (e.g., a
motet into a keyboard work as
Girolamo Cavazzoni,
Antonio de Cabezón, and
Alonso Mudarra all did to
Josquin des Prez motets.) More commonly, a
parody mass (
missa parodia) or an
oratorio used extensive quotation from
other vocal works such as motets or
cantatas;
Victoria,
Palestrina,
Lassus, and other notable composers of the
16th century used this technique;
Bach also used existing cantatas for
his
Christmas Oratorio. In fact,
the musical use of the word parody is wider than its general use -
and while much
musical parody does have
humorous, even satirical intent, some simply recycles musical
ideas.
English term
The first usage of the word
parody in English cited in the
Oxford English
Dictionary is in
Ben Jonson, in
Every Man in His Humour in 1598: "A Parodie, a parodie! to
make it absurder than it was." The next notable citation comes from
John Dryden in 1693, who also appended
an explanation, suggesting that the word was in common use, it
means to make fun of or re-create what you doing.
Modernist and post-modernist parody
In the broader sense of Greek
parodia, parody can occur
when whole elements of one work are lifted out of their context and
reused, not necessarily to be ridiculed. Hutcheon argues that this
sense of parody has again become prevalent in the
twentieth century, as artists have sought
to connect with the past while registering differences brought by
modernity. Major modernist examples of
this recontextualizing parody include
James
Joyce's
Ulysses, which
incorporates elements of
Homer's
Odyssey in a
twentieth-century Irish context, and
T. S.
Eliot's
The Waste Land, which incorporates and
recontextualizes elements of a vast range of prior texts, including
Dante's
The
Inferno.
Blank parody, in which an artist takes the skeletal form of an art
work and places it in a new context without ridiculing it, is
common.
Pastiche is a closely related
genre, and parody can also occur when
characters or settings belonging to one work are used in a humorous
or ironic way in another, such as the transformation of minor
characters
Rosencrantz and
Guildenstern from
Shakespeare's
drama
Hamlet into the principal characters in
a comedic perspective on the same events in the play (and film)
Rosencrantz and
Guildenstern Are Dead.
In Flann
O'Brien's novel At
Swim-Two-Birds, for example, mad King Sweeney, Finn MacCool, a pookah, and an assortment of cowboys all assemble in an inn in Dublin
: the mixture
of mythic characters, characters from genre
fiction, and a quotidian setting combine for a humor that is not
directed at any of the characters or their authors. This
combination of established and identifiable characters in a new
setting is not the same as the post-modernist habit of using
historical characters in fiction out of context to provide a
metaphoric element.
Reputation
Sometimes the reputation of a parody outlasts the reputation of
what is being parodied. For example,
Don
Quixote, which mocks the traditional
knight errant tales, is much better known than
the novel that inspired it,
Amadis de
Gaula (although Amadis is mentioned in the book). Another
notable case is the
novel Shamela by
Henry
Fielding (1742), which was a parody of the gloomy
epistolary novel Pamela, or Virtue Rewarded (1740) by
Samuel Richardson. Many of
Lewis Carroll's parodies of Victorian
didactic verse for children, such as "
You Are Old, Father William",
are much better known than the (largely forgotten) originals.
Stella Gibbons's comic novel
Cold Comfort Farm has
eclipsed the pastoral novels of
Mary Webb
which largely inspired it.In more recent times, the television
sitcom
'Allo 'Allo! is perhaps better
known than the drama
Secret
Army of which it is a parody (although a full appreciation of
the humour largely depends on a knowledge of the earlier
work).
Some artists carve out careers by making parodies. One of the
best-known examples is that of
"Weird Al"
Yankovic. His career of parodying other musical acts and their
songs has outlasted many of the artists or bands he has parodied.
Although he is not required under law to get permission to parody,
as a personal rule, however, he does seek permission to parody a
person's song before recording it.
In the US legal system the point that in most cases a parody of a
work constitutes fair use was upheld in the case of
Rick Dees, who decided to use 29 seconds of the
music from the song
When Sonny Gets Blue to parody
Johnny Mathis' singing style even
after being refused permission. An appeals court upheld the trial
court's decision that this type of parody represents fair use.
Fisher v. Dees 794 F.2d
432 (9th Cir. 1986)
Film parodies
Some
genre theorists, following
Bakhtin, see parody as a natural development in the
life cycle of any
genre; this idea has proven
especially fruitful for genre film theorists. Such theorists note
that
Western movies, for example,
after the classic stage defined the conventions of the genre,
underwent a parody stage, in which those same conventions were
ridiculed and critiqued. Because audiences had seen these classic
Westerns, they had expectations for any new Westerns, and when
these expectations were inverted, the audience laughed.
Perhaps the earliest parody was the
1922
Mud and Sand, a Stan Laurel film that made fun of Rudolph
Valentino's movie
Blood and Sand. Laurel specialized in
parodies in the mid-20s, writing and acting in a number of them.
Some were send-ups of popular films, such as
Dr. Jekyl and Mr.
Hyde (
1920)--parodied in the comic
Dr.
Pyckle and Mr. Pride (
1926). Others were
spoofs of Broadway plays, such as
No, No, Nanette
(
1925), parodied as
Yes, Yes, Nanette
(1925). In
1940 Charlie Chaplin created a satirical comedy
about
Adolf Hitler:
The Great Dictator, which followed
the first-ever Hollywood parody of the Nazis, the
Three Stooges' short subject
You Nazty Spy! .
About 20 years later
Mel Brooks started
his career with a Hitler parody as well. After
The Producers (
1968)
Brooks became one of the most famous film parodists and did spoofs
on any kind of movie genre.
Blazing
Saddles (
1974) is one of his most
popular parodies, and
Spaceballs
(
1987) is still presumed to be the best
science fiction spoof ever.
The famous British comedy group
Monty
Python is also famous for its parodies, e.g. the
King Arthur spoof
Monty Python and the Holy
Grail (
1974) or the
Jesus satire
Life of
Brian (
1979). In the
1980s there came another team of parodists including
David Zucker,
Jim Abrahams and
Jerry
Zucker. Their most popular movies are the
Hot Shots! and the
Naked Gun movies.
Nowadays parodies have taken on whole movie genres at once. One
famous film parody is the
Scary
Movie franchise. Other notable genre parodies include
Not Another Teen Movie,
Date Movie,
Epic
Movie,
Meet the Spartans, and
Disaster Movie.
Self-parody
A subset of parody is
self-parody in which artists parody their
own work (as in
Ricky Gervais's
Extras) or notable
distinctions of their work (such as
Antonio Banderas's
Puss in Boots in
Shrek 2), or an artist or genre repeats
elements of earlier works to the point that originality is
lost.
Another notable example of this is episode 100 of "
Family Guy" in which the writer and producer,
Seth MacFarlane, spent the entirety
of the episode asking questions to other actors which always
received a negative response, such as:
and,
Copyright issues
Although a parody can be considered a
derivative work under
United States Copyright Law, it
can be protected from claims by the copyright owner of the original
work under the
fair use doctrine, which is
codified in
17 USC § 107.
The Supreme Court of
the United States
stated that parody "is the use of some elements of
a prior author's composition to create a new one that, at least in
part, comments on that author's works." That commentary
function provides some justification for use of the older work. See
Campbell
v. Acuff-Rose Music,
Inc.
In 2001, the
United
States Court of Appeals, 11th Circuit, in
Suntrust v. Houghton Mifflin, upheld
the right of
Alice Randall to publish
a parody of
Gone with the
Wind called
The Wind
Done Gone, which told the same story from the point of
view of
Scarlett O'Hara's slaves,
who were glad to be rid of her.
Under Canadian law, although there is protection for Fair Dealing,
there is no explicit protection for parody and satire. In
Canwest v. Horizon, the publisher of Vancouver
Sun launched a lawsuit against a group which had published a
pro-Palestinian parody of the paper. Alan Donaldson, the judge in
the case, ruled that parody is not a defense to a copyright
claim.
Social and political uses
Parody is a frequent ingredient in
satire and
is often used to make social and political points. Examples include
Swift's
A Modest Proposal, which satirizes English
neglect of Ireland by parodying emotionally disengaged political
tracts, and, in contemporary culture,
The
Daily Show and
The Colbert
Report, which parody a news broadcast and a talk show,
respectively, to satirize political and social trends and events.
Some events, such as a national tragedy, can be difficult to
handle. A
9/11 update of
George Orwell's novella
Animal Farm—
Snowball's Chance by U.S. author
John Reed—raised the ire of the George Orwell
estate, and critics such as
Christopher Hitchens. Chet Clem,
Editorial Manager of the news parody publication
The Onion, told
Wikinews in an interview the questions that
are raised when addressing difficult topics:
Parody is by no means necessarily satirical, and may sometimes be
done with respect and appreciation of the subject involved, while
not being a heedless sarcastic attack.
Parody has also been used to facilitate dialogue between cultures
or subcultures. Sociolinguist
Mary
Louise Pratt identifies parody as one of the "arts of the
contact zone," through which marginalized or oppressed groups
"selectively appropriate," or imitate and take over, aspects of
more empowered cultures.
[702194]
Shakespeare often uses a series of parodies to convey his meaning.
In the social context of his era, an example can be seen in
King Lear where the
fool is introduced with his
coxcomb to be a parody of the
king.
See also
Examples
Historic examples
- Sir Thopas
in Canterbury Tales, by Geoffrey Chaucer
- Don Quixote by Miguel
Cervantes
- Beware the Cat by
William Baldwin
- The Knight of
the Burning Pestle by Francis
Beaumont and John
Fletcher
- Dragon of Wantley, an
anonymous 17th century ballad
- Hudibras by Samuel Butler
- "MacFlecknoe", by John Dryden
- A Tale of a Tub by
Jonathan Swift
- The Rape of the
Lock by Alexander Pope
- Namby Pamby by Henry Carey
- Gulliver's Travels
by Jonathan Swift
- The Dunciad by Alexander Pope
- Memoirs of
Martinus Scriblerus by John Gay,
Alexander Pope, John Arbuthnot,
et al.
- Kat Kongby Dav Pilkey
- The
History of Rasselas, Prince of Abissinia [sic] by Samuel
Johnson
- Mozart's A Musical Joke (Ein musikalischer
Spaß), K.522 (1787) - parody of incompetent contemporaries of
Mozart, as assumed by some theorists
- Sartor Resartus by
Thomas Carlysle
- Ways and Means, or
The aged, aged man, by Lewis
Carroll. Much of Alice in
Wonderland and Through the Looking-Glass is
parodic of Victorian schooling.
- Batrachomyomachia
(battle between frogs and mice), an Iliad
parody by an unknown ancient Greek author
- Britannia Sitting On
An Egg a machine-printed illustrated envelope published by the stationer W.R. Hume of
Leith, Scotland, parodying the machine-printed illustrated envelope
(commissioned by Rowland
Hill and designed by the artist William Mulready) used to launch the
British postal service reforms of 1840.
References
- http://thetyee.ca/Mediacheck/2008/12/11/CanwestSuit/ Canwest
Suit May Test Limits of Free Speech, 11 December 2008.