The
Prime Minister of Canada ( ) is the primary
Minister of the Crown,
chairman of the Cabinet, and thus
head of government of Canada
. The
office is not outlined in any of the documents that constitute the
written portion of the
constitution of Canada;
executive authority is formally vested
in the
Canadian sovereign and
exercised on his or her behalf by the
Governor General. The office was
initially modelled after the job as it existed in Britain at time
of Confederation in 1867.
The British
prime
ministership, although fully developed by 1867, was not formally
integrated into the British constitution
until 1905—hence, its absence from Constitution Act, 1867.
The
prime minister is not elected
directly, but is by
constitutional convention the
leader of the
political party that
holds the largest number of seats in the
House of Commons. According to
protocol, all prime ministers are
styled The Right Honourable (in French:
Le Très Honorable) for life.
The current prime minister is
Stephen
Harper, appointed by
Governor General Michaëlle Jean as the 22nd Prime
Minister of Canada on February 6, 2006, after his party earned the
most seats in the general election. He is the leader of the
Conservative Party of
Canada.
Qualifications and selection
The prime minister, along with the other ministers of the Cabinet,
are formally appointed by the governor general on behalf of the
Queen. However, by convention designed to maintain stability in
government, the governor general will almost always call on the
leader of the party that holds the most seats in the House of
Commons to form a government.
Legally, any
citizen of
Canada of
voting age (18 years) can
undoubtedly be appointed to the office of prime minister, these
being the requirements to gain election to the House of Commons.
Since it is not legally necessary for the prime minister to be a
sitting
Member of Parliament
(MP), there is some question as to whether there are technically
even age or citizenship restrictions to the position. In any event,
it is customary for the prime minister to also be a sitting member
of the House of Commons, although two prime ministers have governed
from the
Senate: Sir
John Joseph Caldwell Abbott and
Sir
Mackenzie Bowell. (Both men, in
their roles as Government Leader in the Senate, succeeded prime
ministers who died in office in the 1890s; Canadian convention has
since evolved toward the appointment of an
interim leader in such a scenario.) One prime
minister,
William Lyon
Mackenzie King, having lost his own seat in a general election
while his party retained a plurality in the House of Commons,
briefly governed "from the hallway," until he won a by-election a
few weeks later.
John Turner, who was
previously an MP but had quit politics, was Canada's only non-MP
prime minister. He ran for
Liberal Party leadership to replace
Pierre Trudeau. Turner won a seat at
the next election but his party didn't hold the most seats.
If the prime minister should fail to win his or her seat, a junior
member of parliament in a safe seat would typically resign to
permit a by-election to elect that leader to a seat. However, if
the leader of the governing party is changed shortly before an
election is due and the new leader is not a Member of Parliament,
he or she will normally await the general election before running
for a seat. For example,
John
Turner was briefly prime minister in 1984 without being a
member of the House of Commons; he won his seat in the general
election that swept his party from power.
The official residence
of the prime minister is 24 Sussex Drive
in Ottawa
, Ontario
. All
prime ministers (with the exception of
Kim
Campbell) have lived there since
Louis St. Laurent in 1951.
The prime minister
also has a secondary residence at Harrington Lake
in Gatineau
Park
near Ottawa
.
In earlier years, it was tradition for the sovereign to bestow a
knighthood on each new Canadian prime
minister. As such, several carry the prefix "Sir" before their name
(of the first eight prime ministers, only
Alexander Mackenzie refused knighthood).
After the
Nickle Resolution debate
of 1919, it was against policy for the Sovereign to grant titles to
Canadians; the last prime minister knighted was Sir
Robert Laird Borden, who was in power
when the Nickle Resolution was debated. (Being only a Commons
resolution, it has never been binding.) In addition one prime
minister,
Richard
Bennett, was created a
viscount after
his retirement and the
widow of Sir
John A. Macdonald was created a
baroness.
Mandate
A prime minister does not have a fixed term of office - once
appointed and sworn in (s)he retains the office until (s)he
resigns, is dismissed or dies. The
Constitution of Canada limits the
lifespan of each Parliament to five years after which a
general election for every seat
in the House of Commons must be called; the time limit may be
exceeded only in case of war or
insurrection. The prime minister has typically
asked the governor general to issue a
writ of election during the government's
fourth year in office. If the sitting prime minister's party wins a
general election there is need to re-appoint the prime minister or
swear him or her in again (although after almost any such election
the prime minister will be advising the governor general regarding
any changes to the Cabinet that may be necessary, for example to
replace ministers who have lost their seats).
Amendments to the
Canada Elections
Act passed in 2007 during the first session of the
39th Parliament have brought about
legal changes that are designed to constrain when the prime
minister can request a
dissolution of Parliament. Under
the revised act, a general election must occur on the third Monday
in October every four years starting in 2009. Other than cases of
war or insurrection, the only exceptions provided for under the Act
are when the government is defeated by a
vote of no confidence (discussed
below) or otherwise "prevented from governing." The Canada
Elections Act is not a part of the constitution and can be further
amended or repealed by Parliament.
Otherwise, by constitutional convention, the governor general
cannot refuse a request to issue the writs of election, issue writs
in the absence of a request, or dismiss the prime minister and his
government without having been offered their resignations unless
acting contrary to the prime minister's wishes is necessary to
avoid contravention of either the Constitution or (possibly) an
Act of Parliament (including as
the aforementioned Canada Elections Act). The only time since
Confederation time it was deemed necessary to refuse the prime
minister's request to call an election was 1926 (see the
King-Byng Affair). A Canadian vice-regal's
presumed right and obligation to refuse to grant a dissolution
where the dissolution would only violate an Act of Parliament has
not yet been tested either at the federal level or in those
provinces that have enacted similar "fixed election date"
legislation. The only other situation where an extraordinary use of
the governor general's powers might be acceptable would be if the
prime minister was no longer able to offer competent advice to the
governor general - for example, if (s)he became
incapacitated. There are no formal provisions
regarding what is to be done if a Canadian prime minister becomes
incapacitated and unable to serve for an extended period of time
(this has never happened). Presumably, if such incapacitation
appeared to be long term or permanent and the prime minister could
not sign a letter of resignation the governor general would use
his/her reserve powers to remove him/her and appoint the governing
party's choice for a replacement.
In general, a
majority
government is in power three to five years before a new general
election is called. A
minority
government typically calls a new general election at the first
opportunity when it appears able to win a majority of seats.
Otherwise, it is unusual for minority governments to last more than
two years owing to their vulnerability to votes of non-confidence.
For example, in 1979–1980,
Joe Clark was
prime minister in a minority Progressive Conservative government
only six months before his government lost a motion of
non-confidence and had to call another election. The new Liberal
majority government took office in 1980 just nine months after the
Clark government had taken office in 1979.
A prime minister is required to resign only when an opposition
party wins a
majority of seats
in the House. If the prime minister's party wins a plurality, he or
she normally stays in office. (A prime minister may resign in this
circumstance, but there is no requirement to do so.) If the prime
minister's party wins a minority while an opposition party wins a
plurality (i.e., more seats than any other party but less than a
majority), the prime minister can attempt to remain in office by
forming a coalition with other minority parties. This, however, is
almost never attempted in Canada.
If a governing party loses a
motion of non-confidence, the prime
minister—and, thus, the government—may resign, thereby allowing
another party to form the government. But as this is practical only
if no party in the House has a majority, the convention in Canada
is to immediately ask the governor general to call a general
election.
If a general election gives an opposition party a
plurality of seats, the incumbent prime
minister can continue to try to form the government, but this has
not been done at the federal level since 1925, although it remains
an option under the constitution. The normal practice in this
situation is for the prime minister to resign and for the governor
general to appoint as prime minister the leader of the new largest
party in the House of Commons.
Role and authority

Canadian prime ministers,
1867–1963
Since the prime minister is, in practice, the most powerful member
of the Canadian government, he or she is sometimes erroneously
referred to as Canada's
head of state.
The Canadian head of state is
Elizabeth II,
Queen of Canada, who is represented by
the
Governor General of
Canada. The prime minister is the
head of government. The office of Prime
Minister of Canada is not mentioned in the
Canadian Constitution. In modern-day
Canada, however, his or her prerogatives are largely the duties to
which the constitution refers to as the job of the governor general
(who acts mostly as a
figurehead). The function, duties,
responsibilities, and powers of the prime minister of Canada were
established at Confederation, modeled upon the existing office of
the
Prime Minister
of the United Kingdom. Over time, the role of the Prime
Minister of Canada has evolved, mainly gaining power over the
years.
The prime minister plays a prominent role in most legislation
passed by the Canadian Parliament. The majority of Canadian
legislation originates in the Cabinet of Canada, which is a body
selected by the prime minister, and appointed by the governor
general, largely from the ranks of his party's MPs. The Cabinet
must have "unanimous" consent on all decisions they make, but in
practice whether or not unanimity has been achieved is decided by
the prime minister.
As the monarch or governor general almost always follows the advice
of his or her ministers, the prime minister (and the PMO)
essentially controls the appointments of the following positions:
As to the prime minister's broad
de facto authority over
the Canadian military, see
Canadian
Forces.
Former Prime Minister
Pierre Trudeau
is credited with consolidating power in the
Office of the Prime
Minister (PMO), although the evolution can be seen throughout
Canadian history. The PMO consists of the prime minister's
political and administrative staff hired solely at the PM's
discretion. By coordinating communication with the other agents in
policy arenas, as well as with the central party apparatus, the PMO
can wield considerable influence. This may have the positive effect
of a productive parliament, which in turn provides a valid
criticism of centralized power in majority governments and the
PMO.
There are checks on the prime minister's power.
Cabinet or caucus revolts will bring down
a sitting prime minister quickly, and even the threat of caucus
revolts can persuade and/or compel a prime minister to resign the
office as happened to Jean Chrétien in 2003. The prime minister is
also restricted by the Senate. The Senate can delay and impede
legislation, which occurred when
Brian
Mulroney introduced the
Goods and Services Tax
(GST). In many cases, the conflicts arose primarily because the
Senate was dominated by members appointed by previous governments.
The aforementioned prime ministers proceeded to shift the Senate in
their favour with a flurry of senate appointments to ensure the
smooth passage of legislation. Furthermore, as Canada is a federal
system, the action of the federal government (and thus the prime
minister) is limited to areas of federal jurisdiction. In practice,
however, provincial and federal actions are intertwined in most
areas, and so the prime minister's power can also be thwarted by
concerted opposition from provincial governments.
As well, as executive power is formally vested in the
Canadian monarch and "exercised" by the
governor general as the
vice-regal, either body has the power to
oppose a Prime Minister's will. Senator and constitutional expert
Eugene Forsey stated that a "governor
general must take all steps necessary to thwart the will of a
ruthless prime minister." This power of the governor general was
last used by
Lord
Byng against Prime Minister
William Lyon Mackenzie King in
what is known as the
King-Byng
Affair of 1926. Some, such as the
Canadian Broadcasting
Corporation's
Larry Zolf, also
speculated whether the then Governor General
Adrienne Clarkson would refuse a
recommendation from Prime Minister
Jean Chrétien to dissolve Parliament in
2002. Near the end of her time as Governor General, Clarkson
stated: "My constitutional role has lain in what are called
'reserve powers:' making sure that there is a prime minister and a
government in place, and exercising the right 'to encourage, to
advise, and to warn' [...] Without really revealing any secrets, I
can tell you that I have done all three."
Salary
According to the
Ottawa Citizen, in 2008 the Prime
Minister of Canada had an aggregate annual salary of $301,600
(CAD). Although this sum is several times the national average, it
is only a fraction of the pay of some of Canada's top corporate
executives. Only about half of the Prime Minister's salary is
specific to the role of the prime minister, while the other half is
the normal salary of a Member of Parliament.
Privileges
The Prime
Minister's privileges include the official residence, 24 Sussex Drive
, a country retreat, Harrington Lake
and a armoured long-wheelbase Cadillac STS. He/She is also eligible to
use the Governor General's stretch limousine at various times. The
official residence comes with a number of staff including chefs,
maids, butlers/ushers, gardeners and security forces. The Prime
Minister also has the privilege of using two official aircrafts,
The
CC-150 Polaris for international
flights and the
Challenger 601 for
domestic flights.
The Prime Minister's state car
Criticisms of Prime Ministerial Power
In recent times some analysts — most notably
Jeffrey Simpson and
Donald Savoie, as well as the
Gomery Commission — have argued that
parliament as well as cabinet have become eclipsed by prime
ministerial power. Savoie quotes an anonymous recent Liberal
cabinet minister who says that cabinet has become "a kind of focus
group for the prime minister". Jeffrey Simpson calls cabinet a
"mini-sounding board".
Stephen Brooks, a professor at the University of
Windsor
suggests that "there is little evidence that the
prime minister and those around him who are involved in making
policy pay much attention to the preferences of those in the
legislature, on either the government or opposition side of the
aisle." Ultimately, Savoie arguably has the most
comprehensive and devastating critique on the subject, outlined in
his influential book
Governing from the Centre: The Concentration of Power in Canadian
Politics:
Cabinet has now joined Parliament as an institution
being bypassed.
Real political debate and decision-making are
increasingly elsewhere—in federal-provincial meetings of first
ministers, on Team Canada
flights, where first ministers can hold informal meetings, in the
Prime Minister's
Office, in the Privy
Council Office, in the Department of Finance, and in
international organizations and international summits.
There is no indication that the one person who holds
all the cards, the prime minister, and the central agencies which enable him
to bring effective political authority to the centre, are about to
change things.
The Canadian prime minister has little in the way of
institutional check, at least inside government, to inhibit his
ability to have his way.
The main case given in favour of prime ministerial power has to do
with the federal structure of the nation. Canada is one of the most
decentralized of the world's federations, and provincial premiers
have a great deal of power. Constitutional changes must be approved
by the provincial premiers, and they must be consulted for any new
initiatives in their areas of responsibility, which include many
important sectors such as health care and education. In light of
regional forces such as the
Quebec sovereignty movement,
some have argued there is a need for a national counterbalance to
these pressures.
List of Canadian Prime Ministers
Living former Prime Ministers
There are six living former Prime Ministers of Canada. In order
from most recent they are:
Death of the Prime Minister
Two prime ministers have died in office:
Thompson,
Tupper and Bennett are the only Prime Ministers to have died
outside of Canada (all in England
).
Unlike most state leaders, who are buried in the nation's capital,
Canadian prime ministers are buried in locations of their or their
family's choice. Bennett is the only Canadian prime minister to
have been buried outside of Canada. Diefenbaker is the only one not
to be buried in a cemetery. Most burials are private functions at
the request of the families.
| Name |
Date of death |
Cause of death |
Age |
Place of death |
Funeral |
Place of Burial |
| Macdonald |
1891-06-06 |
stroke |
76 |
Kingston, Ontario |
state funeral and body transported
by train back to Kingston |
Cataraqui Cemetery , Kingston, Ontario |
| Mackenzie |
1892-04-17 |
stroke |
70 |
Toronto , Ontario |
funeral at St. Andrew's
Church, Toronto |
Lakeview Cemetery, Sarnia,
Ontario |
| Abbott |
1893-10-30 |
brain cancer |
72 |
Montreal , Quebec |
state funeral in Montreal |
Mount Royal Cemetery , Montreal, Quebec |
| Thompson |
1894-12-12 |
heart attack |
49 |
Windsor Castle, England |
state funeral at Windsor Castle and body shipped back to
Canada |
Holy
Cross Cemetery, Halifax, Nova Scotia |
| Bowell |
1917-12-10 |
pneumonia |
93 |
Belleville, Ontario |
private funeral in Belleville |
Belleville Cemetery,
Belleville, Ontario |
| Tupper |
1915-10-30 |
heart failure |
94 |
Bexleyheath, England |
body shipped back for state funeral in Halifax |
St. John's
Cemetery, Halifax, Nova Scotia |
| Laurier |
1919-02-17 |
stroke |
77 |
Ottawa, Ontario |
state funeral in Ottawa |
Notre-Dame Cemetery , Ottawa, Ontario |
| Borden |
1937-06-10 |
heart failure |
82 |
Ottawa, Ontario |
state funeral at All
Saints' Church, Ottawa |
Beechwood Cemetery, Ottawa,
Ontario |
| Bennett |
1947-06-26 |
heart attack |
76 |
Mickleham, England |
private funeral |
St.
Michael's Churchyard, Mickleham , England |
| King |
1950-07-22 |
pneumonia |
75 |
Wright County, Quebec |
state funeral in Ottawa, Ontario, casket transported by train
to Ottawa and Toronto |
Mount Pleasant Cemetery , Toronto, Ontario |
| Meighen |
1960-08-05 |
heart failure |
86 |
Toronto, Ontario |
state funeral at St. Andrew's Church, Toronto |
St. Mary's
Cemetery, St.
Marys, Ontario |
| St. Laurent |
1973-07-25 |
natural causes (heart failure) |
91 |
Quebec City, Quebec |
state funeral in Quebec City |
St.
Thomas Aquinas Cemetery, Compton, Quebec |
| Pearson |
1972-12-27 |
cancer |
75 |
Ottawa, Ontario |
state
funeral at Christ Church, Ottawa |
Maclaren
Cemetery, Wakefield, Quebec |
| Diefenbaker |
1979-08-16 |
heart failure |
83 |
Ottawa, Ontario |
state funeral in Ottawa and body transported by train to
Saskatoon, Saskatchewan |
hillside near The Right
Honourable John G. Diefenbaker
Centre at the University of Saskatchewan , Saskatoon, Saskatchewan |
| Trudeau |
2000-09-28 |
Parkinson's disease and prostate cancer |
80 |
Montreal, Quebec |
state
funeral in Ottawa and Notre-Dame Basilica, Montreal ; body transported by train/hearse to Saint-Rémi,
Quebec |
family crypt at St-Rémi-de-Napierville
Cemetery, Saint-Rémi, Quebec |
Canadian prime ministers are buried in Quebec, Ontario, Nova Scotia
and Saskatchewan. Only one is buried in the United Kingdom.
A state funeral for a deceased prime minister, with the casket
lying in state in Centre Block on Parliament Hill, is offered to
their family. Only Bowell and Bennett had private services. Bennett
was the only prime minister to die and be buried outside of Canada.
Bowell is the only prime minister not to have politicians attend
his funeral.
Prime ministers in popular culture
Real
Fictional
Fictional Prime Ministers of Canada have been portrayed in
television series, including
Rideau Hall,
South Park and
The West Wing, televisions films such as
H2O, and the motion pictures
Canadian Bacon and
Buried on Sunday.
Literature
Fictional
- Jean-Jacques Charles: A Very Political Lady (1979) by
Judy LaMarsh, said to be based on
Pierre Elliott Trudeau.
- Ross Hamilton: Party Favours (1997) by Jean Doe, said to be based on Brian Mulroney
- Bobby Laurier: Party Favours (1997) by Jean Doe, said to be based on Jean Chrétien
- Sir Henry Marwood: Pour la patrie (1895) by Jean-Paul
Tardival, said to be based on Sir
John A. Macdonald.
- Barton McGarvie: Scribes and Scoundrels (1997) by
George Galt, said to be based on Brian Mulroney.
- Huntley McQueen: Two
Solitudes (1945) by Hugh
MacLennan, said to be based on William Lyon Mackenzie
King.
- April McTavish: Party Favours (1997) by Jean Doe, said to be based on Kim Campbell.
- Perry Pleaser: Jacob Two Two and the Dinosaur (1987)
by Mordecai Richler
- The Prime Minister: S: Portrait of a Spy (1977) by
Ian Adams, said to be based on Pierre
Elliott Trudeau.
- Jean Rioux: Party Favours (1997) by Jean Doe, said to
be based on Paul Martin.
- Carter Warden: A Very Political Lady (1979) by Judy
LaMarsh, said to be based on John
Turner.
As themselves
Paul Martin and
Stephen Harper have appeared as themselves as
the sitting prime ministers on the
CTV sitcom
Corner Gas:
- Paul Martin in the third-season episode "Fun Run"
- Stephen Harper in the fourth season episode "Gopher It"
Several sitting prime ministers have also appeared as themselves on
the CBC sketch comedy series
Royal Canadian Air Farce,
while Harper appeared in an installment of the satirical CBC series
The Rick Mercer
Report.
Prime minister impersonators
Radio and TV parodies
- Royal Canadian Air
Farce has portrayed several Prime Ministers
- Pierre Trudeau, played by Don
Ferguson
- Joe Clark, played by Don Ferguson
- Brian Mulroney, played by Don Ferguson
- Kim Campbell, played by Luba Goy
- Jean Chrétien, played by Roger
Abbott
- Paul Martin, played by Don Ferguson
- Stephen Harper, played by Craig
Lauzon
- Double
Exposure has portrayed several Prime Ministers
- Joe Clark, played by Bob
Robertson
- Jean Chrétien, played by Bob Robertson
- Pierre Trudeau, played by Bob Robertson
- Brian Mulroney, played by Bob Robertson
- Kim Campbell, played by Linda
Cullen
- Max Ferguson has portrayed several
Prime Ministers on his radio shows
- Pierre Trudeau: on CBC Radio's Max Ferguson Show
- Lester Pearson: on CBC Radio's Rawhide and the Max Ferguson
Show
- John Diefenbaker: on CBC Radio's Rawhide and the Max
Ferguson Show
- Martin Short played Pierre Trudeau
on episodes of SCTV
- Brian Mulroney was portrayed in
the "Robin Sparkles" video on season two of How I Met Your Mother.
See also
Footnotes
- Stephen Brooks, Canadian Democracy: An Introduction,
5th ed. (Don Mills, Ontario: Oxford University Press, 2007),
233-234.
- Brooks, 235.
- Parliamentary Government
- Brooks, 233-235.
- Zolf, Larry; CBC News Viewpoint: Boxing in a
Prime Minister; June 28, 2002
- CTV News: GG reflects on mandate during
farewell address; September 14, 2005
- [1]
- Donald Savoie, Governing from the Centre: The Concentration
of Power in Canadian Politics (Toronto: University of Toronto
Press, 1999), 260.
- Jeffrey Simpson, The Friendly
Dictatorship (Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 2001),
248.
- Brooks, 258.
- Savoie, 362.
- Brian Busby. Character Parts: Who's Really Who in
CanLit. Toronto: Knopf Canada, 2003.
External links