Proposals for a Palestinian
state refer to the proposed establishment of an
independent state for the Palestinian
people in the Palestinian territories
that have been occupied by Israel
since the
Six-Day War of 1967 and before by
Egypt
(Gaza
) and by
Jordan
(West
Bank
) since 1949. The proposals include the Gaza Strip
, which is currently controlled by the Hamas faction of the
Palestinian National
Authority, the West
Bank
, which is administered by the Fatah faction of the Palestinian National
Authority, and East Jerusalem
which is under Israeli administration.
The
State of Palestine is
currently recognized by
about
100 countries. The Israeli military commander exercises
usufructuary rights in accordance with international law, but he is
not the legal sovereign of the occupied territory. The permanent
sovereignty of the Palestinian people over the natural resources of
the Palestinian territories has been recognized by 139 countries.
Under agreements reached with Israel, the Palestinian Authority
exercises de jure control over many natural resources, while
interim cooperation arrangements are in place for others.
Historical background
At the dissolution of the
Ottoman
Empire following
World War I, the
victorious
European states divided many of
its component regions into political entities - under
League of Nations mandates - for
their own goals, and, to a much lesser extent, according to deals
that had been struck with other interested parties.
In the Middle East, Syria (including the Ottoman
autonomous Christian Lebanon and the surrounding areas that became
the Republic of Lebanon
) came under
French
control, while Mesopotamia, and Palestine (including what
became Transjordan
) were allotted to the British
.
Most of these territories achieved independence during the
following three decades without great difficulty, though in some
regimes, the colonial legacy continued through the granting of
exclusive rights to market/manufacture oil and maintain troops to
defend it. However, the case of Palestine remained
problematic.
Following the war, two new movements based on European
nationalism arose:
Arab nationalism, which hinges on the
cultural commonalities of all Arab peoples, and
Pan-Arabism, which calls for the creation of a
united state for all Arabs.
Historical proposals and events
(
see also Palestinian
nationalism).(
Key terms, events, and proposals are
bolded)
The Mandate Period
The future of Palestine ((pronounced PAL-es-tine)) was contentious
from the beginning of the Palestine Mandate since the British
declared support for a "
Jewish
national home in Palestine" even though most of the population
were
Arabs. It was also, according to one
common view, the subject of British promises to the Arabs (creation
of a large
Pan-Arab state; promised to the
Sharif of Mecca in exchange for Arab
help fighting the
Ottoman Empire)
during
World War I. Therefore, it is not
surprising that many different proposals have been made and
continue to be made, including an Arab state, with or without a
significant Jewish population, a Jewish state, with or without a
significant Arab population, a
single
bi-national state, with or without some degree of
cantonization, two states, one bi-national and one Arab, with or
without some form of federation, and two states, one Jewish and one
Arab, with or without some form of federation.
At the same times, many Arab leaders believed that Palestine should
join a larger Arab state covering the imprecise region of the
Levant. These hopes were expressed in the
Faisal-Weizmann Agreement,
which was signed by soon-to-be Iraqi ruler
Faisal I and the Zionist leader
Chaim Weizmann, which called for a Jewish
homeland in Palestine amidst a larger Arab state.
Despite this, the
promise of a Pan-Arab state including Palestine were dashed as
Syria
, Lebanon
, and
Jordan
declared independence from their European rulers,
while Palestine festered in the developing Arab-Israeli Conflict.
In light of these developments, Palestinian Arabs began calling for
both their own state in the British Mandate of Palestine and an end
to the British support of the
Jewish
homeland's creation and to
Jewish
immigration. The movement gained steam through the 1920s and
1930s as Jewish immigration picked up. Under pressure from the
arising nationalist movement, the British enforced the White
Papers, a series of laws greatly restricting Jewish immigration and
the sale of lands to Jews. The laws, passed in
1922, 1930, and
1939, varied in severity, but all
attempted to find a balance between British sympathies with the
Jews and the Arabs.
Finally, the
1936-1939 Arab revolt in
Palestine led the British to create the
Peel Commission, which produced the
first concrete suggestion for a Palestinian state.
The Commission's
report published in 1937 called for a small Jewish state in the
Galilee and maritime strip, a British enclave stretching from
Jerusalem
to Yafo
and an Arab
state covering the rest. The plan also called for a large
population transfer. Jewish
leaders accepted the plan, while Arab leaders rejected it and the
two subsequent proposals offered by the Peel Commission.
Proposals for Arab or Jewish states in the early mandate
period

- The 1937 Peel Commission
proposal. A British Royal Commission led by Lord Peel
examined the Palestine question beginning late in 1936. Its report,
published in July 1937, recommended the creation of a small Jewish
state in a region less than 1/5 of the total area of Palestine.
The
remainder was to be joined to Transjordan
except for some parts, including Jerusalem
, that would remain under British control.
The Arab population in the Jewish areas was to be removed, by force
if necessary, and vice versa, although this would mean the movement
of far more Arabs than Jews. The Zionist leaders accepted the
proposal, while the Arab leadership rejected the proposal outright.
Two more partition plans were also considered: Plan B and Plan C . It all came to nothing, as the
British government had shelved the proposal altogether by the
middle of 1938. In February 1939, the St. James Conference convened in
London, but the Arab delegation refused to formally meet with its
Jewish counterpart or to recognize them. The Conference ended on
March 17, 1939 without making any progress. On May 17, 1939, the
British government issued the White
Paper of 1939, in which the idea of partitioning the Mandate
was abandoned in favor of Jews and Arabs sharing one government and
put strict quotas on further Jewish immigration. Due to impending
World War II and the opposition from
all sides, the plan was dropped.
World War II (1939–1945) gave a boost
to the Jewish nationalism, as the
Holocaust reaffirmed their call for a Jewish
homeland. At the same time, many Arab leaders had even supported
Nazi Germany, a fact which could not
play well with the British. As a result, Britain pooled its energy
into winning over Arab opinions by abandoning the Balfour
Declaration and the terms of the League of Nations mandate which
had been entrusted to it in order to create a "Jewish National
Home". Britain did this by issuing the 1939 white paper which
officially allowed a further 75,000 Jews to move over five years
(10,000 a year plus an additional 25,000) which was to be followed
by Arab majority independence. The British would later claim that
that quota had already been fulfilled by those who had entered
without its approval.
1947 UN Partition Plan

Map of the UN Partition plan
In 1947, the
United Nations created
the
United
Nations Special Committee on Palestine (UNSCOP) to find an
immediate solution to the Palestine question, which the British had
handed over to the UN. As recommended by UNSCOP, the
UN General Assembly approved what is
known as the
Partition
Plan in Resolution 181 on November 29, 1947. The plan
determined a specific date for the end of the British Mandate, May
15, 1948. More importantly, the proposal called for the creation of
two states, while Jerusalem and Bethlehem would be placed under
United Nations control.
Jewish leaders of the Jewish agency accepted parts of the plan,
while Arab leaders refused it. Large-scale fighting soon broke out
between the Jews and the Arabs.
King Abdullah I of Jordan met with a
delegation headed by
Golda Meir to
negotiate terms for accepting the partition plan, but rejected its
proposal that Jordan remain neutral. Indeed, the king knew that the
nascent Palestinian state would soon be absorbed by its Arab
neighbors, and therefore had a vested interest in being party to
the imminent war.
As the Mandate was set to end, the State of
Israel
declared its independence on May 14, 1948.
Almost
immediately, Transjordan
, Egypt
, Lebanon
, Syria
, Saudi Arabia
, Yemen
, and the
Arab Liberation Army declared
war against Israel (see 1948 Arab-Israeli War, known
to Israelis as the War of Independence and to Palestinians as
the Nakba -
the disaster). Over the course of the war, scores of Arab
settlements in the new state, mostly small villages, were
depopulated due to a variety of often-disputed reasons, including
expulsion by Jewish or Israeli troops, fear from attack, or
encouragement by the British or Arab officials to leave until the
situation had died down (
see Palestinian exodus).
Meanwhile, Abdullah of Transjordan sent the Arab Legion into the
West Bank with no intention of withdrawing it following the war.
Egypt, for its part, annexed the Gaza Strip, the last remnant of
the Palestinian state. The territory which Israel did not annex,
Palestine's allies had taken in its place. As the Palestinian
writer
Hisham Sharabi would observe,
Palestine had "disappeared from the map," 26 years after appearing
as an officially defined, bordered territory.
- The All-Palestine government. In September
1948, partly as an Arab League move to limit the influence of
Jordan over the Palestinian issue, a Palestinian government was
declared in Gaza. The former mufti of Jerusalem, Haj Amin al-Husseini, was appointed as
president. On October 1, the All-Palestine government declared an
independent Palestinian state in all of Palestine region with
Jerusalem as its capital. This government was recognised by Egypt
, Syria
, Lebanon
, Iraq
, Saudi Arabia
, and Yemen
, but not by
Jordan
or any non-Arab country. However, it was
little more than a facade under Egyptian control and had negligible
influence or funding. Palestinians living in the Gaza Strip
or Egypt were issued with All-Palestine passports
until 1959, when Gamal Abdul
Nasser, president of Egypt, annulled the All-Palestine
government by decree.
History
The violent birth of Israel led to a major displacement of the Arab
population, who either were driven out by Zionist military forces
before May 15, 1948, or by the Israeli army after that date or fled
for fear of violence by these forces. Many wealthy merchants and
leading urban notables from Jaffa, Tel Aviv, Haifa, and Jerusalem
fled to Lebanon, Egypt, and Jordan, while the middle class tended
to move to all-Arab towns such as Nābulus and Nazareth. The
majority of fellahin ended up in refugee camps. More than 400 Arab
villages disappeared, and Arab life in the coastal cities
(especially Jaffa and Haifa) virtually disintegrated. The centre of
Palestinian life shifted to the Arab towns of the hilly eastern
portion of the region—which was immediately west of the Jordan
River and came to be called the West Bank.
Nearly 1,400,000 Arabs lived in Palestine (there were also 700,0000
Jews) when the war broke out. Estimates of the number of Arabs
displaced from their original homes, villages, and neighbourhoods
during the period from December 1947 to January 1949 range from
about 520,000 to about 1,000,000; there is general consensus,
however, that the actual number was more than 600,000 and likely
exceeded 700,000. Some 276,000 moved to the West Bank; by 1949 more
than half the prewar Arab population of Palestine lived in the West
Bank (from 400,000 in 1947 to more than 700,000). Between 160,000
and 190,000 fled to the Gaza Strip. More than one-fifth of
Palestinian Arabs left Palestine altogether. About 100,000 of these
went to Lebanon, 100,000 to Jordan, between 75,000 and 90,000 to
Syria, 7,000 to 10,000 to Egypt, and 4,000 to Iraq.
Under Arab rule
At war's
end in 1949, Jordan
had control
of the West
Bank
of the Jordan River
, including East Jerusalem
and Bethlehem
. Egypt
took control
of the narrow Gaza
Strip
, while Israel controlled the rest of the British
Mandate.
King Abdullah I of Jordan decided to grant citizenship to the
Palestinian refugees and residents living in the West Bank against
the wishes of many Palestinian leaders who still hoped to establish
a Palestinian state. Under Abdullah's leadership, Palestinian hopes
of independence were dealt a severe blow. In March he issued a
royal decree forbidding the use of the term "Palestine" in any
legal documents, and pursued other measures designed to make the
fact that there would not be an independent Palestine clear and
certain.
In Gaza, a government calling itself the
All-Palestine Government formed,
even before the war's end in September 1948. The government, under
the leadership of the Mufti of Jerusalem
Mohammad Amin al-Husayni, declared
the independence of the Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its
capital.
The All-Palestine Government would go on to
be recognized by Egypt
, Syria
, Lebanon
, Iraq
, Saudi Arabia
, and Yemen
, while
Jordan
and the other Arab
states refused to recognize it.
In practice, the All-Palestine government was only a publicity
stunt, as it was given no real authority by the Egyptian
government. In 1959, Egypt's new leader
Gamal Abdul Nasser ordered the
dismantling of the All-Palestine Government, yet notably refused to
grant Palestinians in Gaza Egyptian citizenship.
The Six-Day War
In June
1967, Israel captured the West Bank
from Jordan, the Gaza Strip
and Sinai Peninsula from Egypt, and the area known
as the Golan
Heights
from Syria during the Six-Day War. Israel, which was
ordered to withdraw from some of the conquered territories and
negotiate final borders by United Nations
Security Council Resolution 242, annexed East Jerusalem and extended its laws over the
Golan
Heights
.
Jordan continued to have economic influence over the West Bank
until the 1980s, when
King Hussein
unilaterally cut the link between his kingdom and its residents and
the Palestinians of the West Bank. Israel
unilaterally withdrew
from the Gaza Strip in 2005.
The PLO and the State of Palestine
Before the Six-Day War, the movement for an independent Palestine
received a boost in 1964 when the
Palestine Liberation
Organization was established. Its goal, as stated in the
Palestinian National
Covenant was to create a Palestinian state in the whole British
Mandate, a statement which nullified Israel's
right to exist.
The PLO would become the leading force in the Palestinian national
movement politically, and its leader,
Yassir Arafat, would become regarded as the
leader of the Palestinian people.
In 1974, the PLO adopted the
Ten Point
Program, which notably called for the establishment of
an Israeli-Palestinian democratic, bi national state (a
one state solution). It also called for
the establishment of Palestinian rule on "any part" of its
liberated territory, as a step towards "completing the liberation
of all Palestinian territory, and as a step along the road to
comprehensive Arab unity." While this was not seen by Israel as a
significant moderation of PLO policy, the phrasing was extremely
controversial within the PLO itself, where it was widely regarded
as a move towards a
two-state
solution. The adoption of the program, under pressure from
Arafat's
Fatah faction and some minor groups
(eg.
DFLP,
al-Sa'iqa)
led many hard-line groups to break away from the Arafat and the
mainstream PLO members, forming the
Rejectionist Front. To some extent, this
split is still evident today.
- Various declarations of Palestinian independence
- During the 1978 Camp David negotiations between
Israel and Egypt Anwar Sadat proposed
the creation of a Palestinian state in the West Bank
and Gaza
.
Israel refused.
Declaration of the state in 1988
The
declaration of a
State of Palestine ( ) took place
in Algiers
on November 15, 1988, by the Palestinian National Council,
the legislative body of the Palestinian Liberation
Organization (PLO).
Currently, the Palestinian National
Authority (PNA), along with the United States
, the European Union,
and the Arab League, envision the
establishment of a State of Palestine to include all or part of the
West
Bank
, the Gaza
Strip
, and East Jerusalem,
living in peace with Israel
under a
democratically elected and transparent government. The PNA,
however, does not claim sovereignty over any territory and
therefore is not the government of the State of Palestine
proclaimed in 1988.
The 1988
declaration was approved at a meeting in Algiers
, by a vote of 253-46, with 10 abstentions.
The
declaration invoked the Treaty of
Lausanne (1923) and UN General Assembly
Resolution 181 in support of its claim to a "State of Palestine
on our Palestinian territory with its capital Jerusalem
". The proclaimed state of Palestine was
recognized immediately by the
Arab
League, and about half the world's governments recognize it
today. It maintains embassies in many of these countries and
special or general delegations in others. Palestine is also an
Observer Member in the
United
Nations. (See
State of
Palestine#United Nations representation.)
The declaration is generally interpreted to have recognized Israel
within its pre-1967 boundaries, or was at least a major step on the
path to recognition. Just as in
Israel's declaration of
independence, it partly bases its claims on
UN GA 181.
By reference to
"resolutions of Arab Summits" and "UN resolutions since 1947" (like
SC 242) it
implicitly and perhaps ambiguously restricted its immediate claims
to the Palestinian
territories
and Jerusalem
. It was accompanied by a political statement
that explicitly mentioned SC 242 and other UN resolutions and
called only for withdrawal from "
Arab
Jerusalem" and the other "Arab territories occupied."
Yasser Arafat's statements in Geneva a month
later were accepted by the United States as sufficient to remove
the ambiguities it saw in the declaration and to fulfill the
longheld conditions for open dialogue with the United States
.
Current proposals

300 px
The
current position of the Palestinian Authority is that all of
the West
Bank
and Gaza
Strip
should form the basis of a future Palestinian
state. For additional discussion, see Palestinian
territories
.
The main
discussion during the last fifteen years has focused on turning
most or the whole of the Gaza Strip
and the West
Bank
into an independent Palestinian state. This
was the basis for the
Oslo
accords[7812] and it is favoured by the U.S.
[7813] The status of Israel within the
1949 Armistice lines has not been
the subject of international negotiations. Some members of the PLO
recognize Israel's right to exist within these boundaries; others
hold that Israel must eventually be destroyed . Consequently, some
Israelis hold that Palestinian statehood is impossible with the
current PLO as a basis, and needs to be delayed.
The specific points and impediments to the establishment of a
Palestinian state are listed below. They are a part of a greater
mindset difference. Israel declares that its security demands that
a Palestinian entity would not have all attributes of a state, at
least initially, so that in case things go wrong, Israel would not
have to face a dangerous and nearby enemy. Israel may be therefore
said to agree (as of now) not to a complete and independent
Palestinian state, but rather to a self-administering entity, with
partial but not full sovereignty over its borders and its
citizens.
The central Palestinian position is that they have already
compromised greatly by accepting a state covering only the areas of
the West Bank and Gaza. These areas are significantly less
territory than allocated to the Arab state in UN
Resolution 181. They feel
that it is unacceptable for an agreement to impose additional
restrictions (such as level of militarization, see below) which,
they declare, makes a viable state impossible. In particular, they
are angered by significant increases in the population of Israeli
settlements and communities in the West Bank and Gaza Strip during
the interim period of the Oslo accords. Palestinians claim that
they have already waited long enough, and that Israel's interests
do not justify depriving their state of those rights that they
consider important. The Palestinians have been unwilling to accept
a territorially disjointed state. It is feared that it would face
difficulties similar to
Bantustans.
During the Annapolis conference, then Prime Minister, Ehud Olmert,
offered East Jerusalem as the capital of Palestine and 99.3% of the
West Bank, in which .7% of the land would constitute as a safe
passage between the borders of Israel and Palestine, Mahmoud Abbas
rejected the offer due to the non-inclusion of the Gaza Strip and
continuation of settlement construction.
Peace process
A peace process has been in progress in spite of all the
differences and conflicts.
In the 1990s, outstanding steps were taken which formally began a
process the goal of which was to solve the Arab-Israeli conflict
through a
two-state solution.
Beginning with the
Madrid
Conference of 1991 and culminating in the 1993
Oslo Peace Accords between Palestinians and
Israelis, the peace process has laid the framework for Palestinian
autonomy in the West Bank and in Gaza.
According to the Oslo
Accords, signed by Yassir Arafat and then Israeli Prime Minister
Yitzhak Rabin in Washington
, Israel would pull out of the Gaza Strip and cities
in the West Bank, leaving contested East Jerusalem in
question.
Following the landmark accords, the
Palestinian National
Authority (PNA) was established to govern those areas from
which Israel was to pull out. The PNA was granted limited autonomy
over a non-contiguous area, though it does govern most Palestinian
population centers.
The process stalled with the collapse of the
Camp
David 2000 Summit between Palestinians and Israel, after which
the
second Intifada broke out.
Israel ceased to act in cooperation with the PNA and later on would
occupy some Palestinian cities anew.
In the shadow of the
rising death toll from the violence, the United States
initiated the Road
Map for Peace (published on June 24, 2002), which is intended
to end the Intifada by disarming the Palestinian terror groups and
creating an independent Palestinian state. The Road Map has
stalled awaiting the implementation of the step required by the
first phase of that plan. It remains stalled due to the civil war
between
Hamas and
Fatah.
In 2005, Israel unilaterally withdrew from the Gaza Strip as part
of the
Disengagement Plan, which
was seen as a move toward creating an independent Palestinian
state.
Historical views
Palestinian view
The
Palestinian People see the
mass immigration - mainly from Europe, the United States of
America, and Arabic countries - of modern-day Israelis to this
region of the world, their acts of warfare, and the establishment
of the state of Israel as an act of illegal occupation. This
occupation has consequences for hundreds of thousands of Arab
Palestinians living in refugee camps in several countries in the
world, including destruction of villages perpetrated against those
Palestinians that are still living in their land today, and the
increase in Israeli settlements in the remaining Palestinian
villages and lands.
Israeli views
The
traditional Israeli
view has
been that there is no such thing as a separate Palestinian people,
distinct from other Arabs, at least historically. The
borders of historical Palestine and surrounding countries were
arbitrarily determined and there are already several Arab nations.
Therefore, it is unreasonable to demand that Israel should have any
responsibility or part in establishing a nation for them. This is
summarized by the famous statement of
Israeli Prime Minister (1969-74)
Golda Meir: "There was no such thing as
Palestinians ... It was not as though there was a Palestinian
people in Palestine considering itself as a Palestinian people and
we came and threw them out and took their country away from them.
They did not exist."
Arab views
Before the creation of Israel, Arab leaders supported the creation
of a united Arab state encompassing all Arab peoples including
Palestine, so that no independent Palestinian state would exist,
but this became a minority view amongst Palestinians during the
British Mandate, and
after 1948 became rare. It is still an opinion expressed regularly
in the Arab states outside Palestine (especially Syria due to its
attachment to the
Greater Syria
Movement which was launched in 1944 to establish a "Syrian
Arab" state that would include Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and
Palestine.) However, it is generally recognised that such a
development has become implausible under current political
realities and even those who might favor it in some circumstances
support an independent Palestinian state as the most achievable
option.
Syria
joined
Egypt
in founding the United Arab Republic (UAR) in 1958
during a period of Pan-Arabism as the
first step toward the recreation of Pan-Arab state. The UAR
was to include, among others, Palestine. The UAR disintegrated into
its constituent states in 1961.
Egypt held Gaza and Jordan annexed the West Bank between 1948 and
1967. During those years, Egyptian President Nasser created the
Palestine Liberation
Organization (PLO) in 1964.
In 1959 Fatah was formed in Kuwait City,
Kuwait
by a group
of ex-pat Palestinian professionals, including Yasser Arafat working in the Gulf states, with similar aims.
Nowadays, most Arabs (Christians and Muslims), and some
anti-zionists Jews , support Palestinians' rights to
self-determination and support Palestinian refugees and their right
to return to their homes and lands of origin in Palestine
(what it is now Israel and Palestinian territories
) (see return of Palestinian refugees).
Obstacles to establishing a Palestinian state
Note that the materials in this section are mainly based on the
Israeli (
[7814],
[7815]) and Palestinian (
[7816],
[7817]) positions during the ill-fated
Camp David negotiations.
This mistrust is manifested through various issues including the
Positions on the status of Jerusalem and the holy places, the
return of Palestinian
refugees and the issue of
Israeli
settlements.
Plans for a solution

300 px
250 px
There are several plans for a possible Palestinian state. Each one
has many variations. Some of the more prominent plans include:
- Creation of a Palestinian state out of the
Gaza
Strip
and the West
Bank
, with its capital in East
Jerusalem. This would make the 1949 Armistice lines, perhaps with
minor changes, into permanent de jure
borders. This long-extant idea forms the basis of a
peace plan put forward by
Saudi
Arabia
in March 2002, which was accepted by the Palestinian Authority and all other
members of the Arab League. This
plan promised in exchange for withdrawal complete recognition of
and full diplomatic relations with Israel by the Arab world. Israel
claims its security would be threatened by (essentially) complete
withdrawal as it would return Israel to its pre-1967 10-mile
strategic depth. Moreover some claim
that the Palestinians had rejected very similar offers made during
and after the Camp David 2000
Summit. The plan spoke only of a "just settlement of the
refugee problem", but insistence on a Palestinian right of return to
the pre-1967 territory of Israel could result in two Arab states,
one of them (pre-1967 Israel) with a significant Jewish minority,
and another (the West Bank and Gaza) without Jews.
- Other, more limited, plans for a Palestinian state have also
been put forward, putting parts of Gaza and the West Bank which
have been settled by Israelis or are of particular strategic
importance remaining in Israeli hands. Areas that are currently
part of Israel could be allocated to the Palestinian state in
compensation. The status of Jerusalem is particularly
contentious.
- A
plan proposed by former Israeli tourism minister MK Binyamin Elon and popular with the Israeli
right wing advocates the expansion of Israel up to the Jordan River
and the "recognition and development of Jordan as
the Palestinian State". The legitimacy for this plan leans on the
fact that an overwhelming majority of Jordanian citizens are
Palestinian, including King
Abdullah's wife, Queen Rania, as well as the fact that
the Kingdom of
Jordan
is composed of lands that until 1921 were part of
the British Mandate of
Palestine and thus was claimed by at least some Zionists (such
as Ze'ev Jabotinsky and his
Etzel) as part of the "Jewish national home"
of the Balfour
Declaration. Palestinian residents of Gaza
and the West
Bank
would become citizens of Jordan and many would be
settled in other countries. Elon claims this would be part
of the population exchange
initiated by the mass exodus [7818] of
Jews from Arab states to Israel in the 1950s. See Elon Peace Plan. A September 2004 poll
conducted by the Jaffee Center for Strategic Studies reported that
46% of Israelis support transferring the Arab population out of the
territories and that 60% of respondents said that they were in
favor of encouraging Israeli Arabs to leave the country. Initially,
the plan caused significant outcry and had been almost universally
condemned by other countries. However, On July 16, 2008, a
bi-partisan panel of Israeli parliament members endorsed the
initiative, including left-wing MK Dr. Yossi Beilin who called on the EU to absorb
Palestinian refugees as part of a wider process of habilitating
refugees.
- RAND has proposed a solution entitled
The Arc in which the West Bank is joined with
Gaza in an infrastructural arc. The development plan includes
recommendations from low level civic planning to banking reform and
currency reform.
- Another plan which has gained some support
is one where the Gaza
Strip
is given independence as a Palestinian enclave,
with parts of the West
Bank
split between Israel and Jordan
respectively. The Jerusalem problem may be addressed by
administration by a third party such as the United Nations as put forward in their
initial partition plan.
Several
plans have been proposed for a Palestinian state to incorporate all
of the former British mandate of Palestine (pre-1967 territory of Israel,
the Gaza
Strip
and the West
Bank
). Some possible configurations include:
- A secular Arab state (as described in the Palestinian National Covenant
before the cancellation of the relevant clauses in 1998).
Accordingly, only those "Jews who had normally resided in Palestine
until the beginning of the Zionist invasion will be considered
Palestinians", which excludes at least 90% of the Jewish population
of Israel.
- A strictly Islamic state (advocated by Hamas and the Islamic Movement). This arrangement
would face objection from the Jewish population as well as secular
Muslim and non-Muslim Palestinians.
- A federation (likely consociational) of separate Jewish and
Arab areas (some Israelis and Palestinians). It is not clear how this
arrangement would distribute natural resources and maintain
security.
- A single, bi-national state
(advocated by various Israeli and Palestinian groups). Palestinian
and Israeli critics of this arrangement fear that the new state is
likely to give the two sides an asymmetric status (though not
necessarily an unequal one). Others say that such a state is likely
to fail, as was seen in places where similar things were tried,
like Yugoslavia and Lebanon. Strong nationalist sentiment among
many Israelis and Palestinians would be an obstacle to this
arrangement. After what he perceived as the failure of the Oslo
Process and the two-state solution, Palestinian-American professor
Edward Said became a vocal advocate of
this plan.
- A United Arab Kingdom plan
which returns Palestine to nominal Jordanian control under the
supervision of a Hashemite monarch. This idea was first proposed by
the late King Hussein. In October 2007,
King Abdullah stated that the
Palestinian independence must be achieved before Jordan will
entertain expanding its role in Palestine beyond religious sites.
This plan is buttressed by a Jordanian infrastructure which is
vastly superior to the 1948-1967 area with particular attention
paid to tourism, healthcare, and education. A Palestinian state
would rely heavily on tourism, which Jordan would assist with
considerable experience and established departments.
Parties which already recognize Palestine as separate to
Israel
- 96 other nations recognize the State of Palestine. They are
listed in the Foreign
relations of the Palestinian National Authority article.
These
include most Arab League nations,
Australia, most African nations, some Eastern European nations, Russia
, and several
Asian nations, including China
and India
.
- Since
the 1996 Summer Olympics, the
International Olympic
Committee
have recognized a separate Palestine Olympic Committee and
Palestinian team. Two track & field athletes, Majdi Abu
Marahil and Ihab Salama, competed for the inaugural Palestinian
team.
- Since
1998, football's world governing body FIFA
have
recognized the Palestine national football
team as a separate entity. On 26 October 2008
Palestine played their first match at home, a 1-1 draw against
Jordan in the West Bank
.
See also
References
External links