In
Sweden
it is illegal to pay for sex (the client commits a
crime, but not the prostitute).
Sweden
considers
prostitution a form of violence
against women, so the crime consists in the customer paying for
sex, not in the prostitute selling sexual
services.
This law
which makes it illegal to pay for sex, but not to be a prostitute
was adopted in 1999, and at that time it was unique; since than a
similar law was adopted by Norway
(in 2009)
and by Iceland
(in
2009).
Several European countries have discussed or are currently
discussing adopting a similar legal system.
The reasons behind this law are the Swedish government's belief
that prostitution is a form of exploitation of women and male
dominance over women (see
feminist arguments against prostitution) and the need to
prevent
human trafficking and
crime. The law, however, is gender neutral. The gender of the
seller and the gender of the buyer is not factor in the law, making
it equally forbidden to buy sexual services from
male prostitutes as from female
prostitutes and regardless of the gender of the buyer.
The law was put in effect on 1 January 1999 and inserted into the
Criminal code on 1 April 2005. The
penalty is
fine or prison of maximum
of six months. So far, the law has led to about 1650 convictions,
but nobody has been sentenced to prison.
The effects of this law are not clear. Several studies were
conducted, but the results were contradictory, and these studies
were accused of being biased and lacking neutrality.
The law enjoys wide public support in Sweden. A recent survey shows
that 80% of Swedes "support the law and the principles behind its
development". Opinion polls conducted by the opinion and social
research consultancy, SIFO, in 1999, and again two years later,
showed a rise – from 76% to 81% – in the number of people who
favoured this law. The percentage of respondents who wanted the law
to be repealed was 15% in 1999 and 14% two years later. The rest
"didn't know". In another survey, 71% of Swedes said they supported
the ban on paying for sex (they wanted the law to remain on the
books). However, the same survey showed a very interesting thing:
despite the fact that most Swedes approve of the law, only 20% of
respondents believe the number of people who pay for sex has been
reduced.
A 2005 sex survey conducted online by Durex has shown that out of
the 34 countries surveyed, Sweden had the lowest percentage of
respondents who had paid for sex (3% of those who answered the
question, however the respondents were both men and women, which
suggests that more than 3% of men have bought sex, since most
clients are male). The highest percentage of people who have paid
for sex was in Vietnam, followed by Hong Kong and Thailand.However,
some people have questioned the reliability of this survey.
The law, however, has also received a lot of criticism. The main
criticism of this legal system is that outlawing prostitution
pushes it underground, on the black market.
Some sex worker organizations have condemned the Swedish government
for refusing to listen to the women who choose to be involved in
the sex trade.
See also
References
External links
- Is sex work? Swedish
and German prostitution policy since the 1970s. by Susanne
Dodillet, Gothenberg University, 2009.
- How Sweden tackles prostitution,
BBC.
- The oldest conundrum, The Economist,
October 30, 2008.
- No prostitution and trafficking-SWEDEN.SE
- The Swedish Law That Prohibits the Purchase of A
Sexual Service: Best Practices for Prevention of Prostitution and
Trafficking in Human Beings by Gunilla S. Ekberg, 2004.
- Prostitutes Rights/Revenge in Society
- Sex
workers and allies union in Sweden
- "A Swedish sexworker on the criminalization of
clients", interview with Pye Jacbsson, film by HCLU-SWAN, at
YouTube
- Sweden revisits prostitution law: Its tough stance
is upheld as a model. But does it work?, Christian Science Monitor,
June 28 2009.
- Sweden Treating Prostitution as Violence Against
Women
- Swedish Prostitution Ban An Apparent Enormous
Success