- This article is about Prostitution in Taiwan. See
also Prostitution in Hong
Kong and Prostitution in
the People's Republic of China.
Historical background
During the Japanese colonial period (1895–1945),
geisha houses and brothels had been authorized to
operate in certain districts; later geishas evolved into
"hostesses". As late as the 1950s, many girls who had been
indentured by their parents into prostitution for financial reasons
did so willingly, out of a feeling of
filial piety. During
World War II, the Japanese recruited or coerced
women into serving as
comfort
women.
With the return to Chinese rule in 1945, the
Chinese Nationalist government initially
banned most hostesses and prostitutes, labeling prostitution as an
immoral phenomenon encouraged by the Japanese, although at the same
time the Ministry of Defense maintained official brothels on outer
islands to provide sexual services to the many single military men
who arrived from the mainland in 1949. In the 1950's, the
government revived the policy of registering and licensing
prostitutes.
Rapid industrialization in the 1960's brought an influx of young
people into the cities, giving rise to a coffee-house subculture,
where female hostesses catered to young male workers. At roughly
the same time, the opening of two US army bases spawned bars and
dance halls to cater to the American military population.Government
concern over immorality led to increased police attention directed
at intimacy in public and sometimes private.
The sex trade became
increasingly controversial; in 1974 the government stopped
licensing new brothels, and in the 1980's, a campaign aimed at
rescuing Taiwanese aborigine
girls forced into prostitution grew into an anti-prostitution
movement that successfully lobbied for outright banning of
prostitution across Taiwan, culminating in the 1997 outlawing of
prostitution in the city of Taipei
under then
mayor Chen Shuibian.
Most recent policy
In June 2009, in response to
sex
workers’ demands, the
Ma Ying-jeou
administration announced that prostitution was to be
decriminalized. Treating prostitution as a matter of human rights,
the government concluded that punishing sexual transactions only
forced them underground, leaving sex workers open to abuse. The
government stated that while sexual transactions between consenting
adults should be governed by personal, educational and religious
considerations, rather than by laws, the sex trade should be
regulated like any other occupation. It left the question of where
people could engage in prostitution up to local governments.
International protest against legalization of prostitution
On November 25th, the 10th International Day for the Elimination of
Violence against Women, Garden of Hope Foundation in Taiwan and
Taiwan Anti-Sexual Exploitation Alliance together with several
local and international allies around the world express our deep
concern regarding the recent proposal to legalize prostitution, a
form of violence against women, by the government of Taiwan.
International and national women’s organizations from Canada,
Korea, UK and US spoke in full support of Taiwanese women’s
opposition to legalization of prostitution in Taiwan in the
November 25th press conference in Taipei, Taiwan.
The alliance includes Garden of Hope Foundation; Taiwan Anti-Sexual
Exploitation Alliance, Taiwan; Taipei Women’s Rescue Foundation;
ECPAT-Taiwan; Taiwan Women’s Link; Asian Women Coalition Ending
Prostitution, Canada; Canadian Association of Sexual Assault
Centres, Canada; Coalition against Trafficking in Women, USA;
Equality Now, UK; Pyeong-Taek Sexual Violence Relief Center, Korea;
Sexual Assault Support Center of Ottawa, Canada; Vancouver Rape
Relief and Women’s Shelter, Canada.
Below is the content of the joint statement:"In 2009, the Taiwan
court has ruled that the existent regulation on punishing
prostituted women is against the principle of equality and should
become ineffective in two years. While welcoming the
decriminalization of prostituted women, the impact of this ruling
has misled the Taiwan government toward the establishment of the
sex trade district and legalization of sex industry that are
completely against women’s human rights. We believe that the Taiwan
government has made a critical error by failing to recognize the
highly unequal relationship that exists between men and women
within prostitution.
We strongly urge the Taiwan government not to legalize prostitution
for prostitution is violence against women. Changing the name of
violence will not change the fact that men are enacting violence on
women. Designating red-light districts where men can do legalized
violence to women will not cover the fact that the government
allows for legal violation against women’s basic human rights. In
fact, legalization will allow men's commodification of women, and
develops government's dependency on revenue generated by this
practice. The Taiwan government will become known internationally
as a country supplying women to other countries with sex industries
and as a sex tourism destination. Many countries that had
experimented with sex industry have now realized that it is a total
failure: sex industry does not decrease sexual violence against
women, but turns your country into the destination of international
sex tourism and trafficked women.
The majority of women entered prostitution because of poverty. We
strongly urge the Taiwan government to recognize the STATE
REPONSIBILITIES to address exploitation of poor women and girls in
prostitution and to enact progressive social, economic and
political policies that benefit poor women and advance women’s
equality. This brave step is recognized by many countries around
the globe including Sweden, Norway and Iceland.
Taiwan is really at the critical point in promoting the rights of
women and girls. We strongly urge the Taiwan government not to
legalize prostitution at any circumstances and should take
following actions to protect women against sexual
exploitation:
1. Stop legalizing ‘sex industry’; prostitution is a form of
violence against women, not a job.2. Decriminalize prostituted
women who often enter sex trade out of desperate poverty; however
prostitution should not be recognized as a ‘job’ or an ‘industry’.
By doing so, it only denigrates women's value within the labor
force as being primarily sexual.3. Initiate social, economic and
political policies that benefit poor women and advance women’s
equality. Prostitution should not become the only choice for women
in poverty.4. Purchasers and third parties who profit from sex
trade should be criminalized. The government should strictly
prohibit any information and acts related to recruiting women into
prostitution."
Human trafficking
Taiwan has
been the destination for the trafficking of women for the purposes
of prostitution, typically from Vietnam
and Thailand
.
Women from
Taiwan have also been known to be sold to the Yakuza in Japan
. The
Government estimates there are 30,000 Taiwanese girls involved in
prostitution in Japan.
References
Sex trade to be decriminalized
Precursors and Pathways to Adolescent Prostitution in Taiwan by
Shu-Ling Hwang, Bedford, Olwen, Journal of Sex Research, 00224499,
May2003, Vol. 40, Issue 2
State power, prostitution and sexual order in
Taiwan: towards a genealogical critique of ‘Virtuous
Custom’
External links