A
protest song is a song which is associated with
a movement for social change and hence part of the broader category
of
topical songs (or songs connected to current events).
It may be folk, classical, or commercial in genre. Among social
movements that have an associated body of songs are the
abolition movement, women's
suffrage, the
labor
movement,
civil rights, the
anti-war movement, the
feminist movement, and
Environmentalism. Protest songs are
frequently situational, having been associated with a social
movement through context. "
Goodnight
Irene", for example, acquired the aura of a protest song
because it was written by Lead Belly, a black convict and social
outcast, although on its face it is a love song. Or they may be
abstract, expressing, in more general terms, opposition to
injustice and support for peace, or free thought, but audiences
usually know what is being referred to. Beethoven's "
Ode to Joy", a song in support of universal
brotherhood, is a song of this kind. It is a setting of a poem by
Schiller celebrating the continuum of
living beings (who are united in their capacity for feeling pain
and pleasure and hence for empathy), to which
Beethoven himself added the lines that all men are
brothers. Songs which support the status quo do not qualify as
protest songs.
Protest song texts have significant cognitive content. The labor
movement musical
Pins and
Needles deftly summed up the definition of a protest song
in a number called "Sing Me a Song of Social Significance."
Phil Ochs once explained, "A protest song
is a song that's so specific that you cannot mistake it for
bullshit"
Many
well-known protest songs come from the United States
, a country founded on the basis of Enlightenment
ideals of human betterment and which had known continuous social
movements since its inception, as new and diverse groups and ideals
were successively absorbed into the social fabric. Well
known American protest songs include "
We Shall Overcome", first associated with
labor organizing and later with the
Civil
rights movement;
Bob Dylan's "
Blowin' in the Wind" and
Marvin Gaye's "
What's Going On".
John Lennon's "
Give Peace A Chance" referenced the
American anti-Vietnam war movement and the arms race, although he
was British. Many key figures worldwide have contributed to their
own nations' traditions of protest music, such as
Victor Jara in Chile,
Silvio Rodríguez in Cuba,
Karel Kryl in Czechoslovakia,
Jacek Kaczmarski in Poland, and
Vuyisile Mini in
anti-apartheid South Africa.
Types of protest song
Writing from a somewhat 1950s-oriented, Cold War, functionalist
perspective, sociologist R. Serge Denisoff saw protest songs rather
narrowly in terms of their function, as forms of persuasion or
propaganda. He saw the protest song
tradition as originating in the "psalms" or songs of grass-roots
Protestant religious revival movements, terming these hymns
"protest-propaganda", as well.
Denisoff subdivided protest songs as either "magnetic" or
"rhetorical". "Magnetic" protest songs were aimed at attracting
people to the movement and promoting group solidarity and
commitment, as for example, "
Eyes on
the Prize" and "
We Shall
Overcome". "Rhetorical" protest songs, on the other hand, are
often characterized by individual indignation and offer a
straightforward political message designed to change political
opinion. Denisoff argued that although "rhetorical" songs often are
not overtly connected to building a larger movement, they should
nevertheless be considered as "protest-propaganda". Examples
include Bob Dylan's "Masters of War" (which contains the lines "I
hope that you die / And your death'll come soon") and "What's Going
On" by Marvin Gaye.
A more modern and broadly sympathetic treatment of the history and
function of song (and particularly traditional song) in social
movements is found in Ron Ayerman and Andrew Jamison's
Music
and Social Movements: Mobilizing Tradition in the Twentieth
Century (1998). Denisoff had paid little attention to the song
tunes of protest music, considered them strictly subordinate to the
texts, a means to the message. It is true that in the highly
text-oriented western European song tradition, tunes can be
subordinate, interchangeable, and even limited in number (as in
Portuguese
fado, which only has 64
tunes), nevertheless, Ayerman and Jamison point out that some of
the most effective protest songs gain power through their
appropriation of tunes that are bearers of strong cultural
traditions. They also note that:There is more to music and
movements than can be captured within a functional perspective,
such as Denisoff's, which focuses on the use made of music within
already-existing movements. Music, and song, we suggest, can
maintain a movement even when it no longer has a visible presence
in the form of organizations, leaders, and demonstrations, and can
be a vital force in preparing the emergence of a new movement. Here
the role and place of music needs to be interpreted through a
broader framework in which tradition and ritual are understood as
processes of identity and identification, as encoded and embodied
forms of collective meaning and memory.
Dr.
Martin Luther King, Jr.
described the freedom songs this way: "They invigorate the movement
in a most significant way [...] these freedom songs serve to give
unity to a movement."
North American protest songs
Eighteenth century
Prior to the
American
Revolutionary War, topical songs proliferated. Some supported
the
Whigs and
Tories, or were about such issues as the stamp act.
"American Taxation" written by Peter St. John and sung to the tune
of "
The British Grenadiers"
was one such song which protested against "the cruel lords of
Britain" who were "striving after our rights to take away, and rob
us of our charter, in North America". "Come On, Brave Boys" (1734),
"The American Hero" by
Andrew Law, "Free
America" by Dr. Joseph Warren, and "Liberty Song" by John Dickinson
(1768) all equally protested against the British rule in America,
and called for freedom. The earliest known American election
campaign song was "God Save George Washington", issued in 1780 and
sung to the tune of "
God Save the
King". Such songs were disseminated by means of broadside
ballads, with directions that they were to be "sung to the tune of"
well known songs.
"Rights of Woman" (1795), sung to the tune of "
God Save the King", written anonymously by
"A Lady", and published in the
Philadelphia Minerva,
October 17, 1795, is one of the earliest American topical songs in
support of women's rights. The song contains such lines as "God
save each Female's right", "Woman is free" and "Let woman have a
share".
Nineteenth century
Nineteenth-century protest songs dealt for the most part, with
three key issues: War, and the
American Civil War in particular (such as
"
Johnny I Hardly Knew Ye"
from Ireland, and its American variant, "
When Johnny Comes Marching
Home Again", among others); The
abolition of
slavery
("
Song of the Abolitionist"
and "
No More Auction Block
for Me", among others) and
women's
suffrage, both for and against in both Britain and the
U.S.
Perhaps the most famous voices of protest at the time - in America
at least - were the
Hutchinson
Family Singers. From 1839, the
Hutchinson Family Singers became
well-known for their songs supporting
abolition.
They sang at the White House
for President John Tyler,
and befriended Abraham
Lincoln. Their subject matter most often touched on
relevant social issues such as
abolition,
temperance,
politics,
war and
women's suffrage. Much of their music
focused on
idealism,
social reform,
equal
rights, moral improvement, community activism and
patriotism.
The Hutchinsons' career spanned the major social and political
events of the mid-19th century, including the Civil War. The
Hutchinson Family Singers established an impressive musical legacy
and are considered to be the forerunners of the great protest
singers-songwriters and folk groups of the 1950s and 60s such as
Woody Guthrie and
Bob Dylan, and are often referred to as America's
first protest band.
Many
Negro spirituals have been
interpreted as thinly veiled expressions of protest against slavery
and oppression. For example, "
Oh,
Freedom" and "
Go Down Moses" draw
implicit comparisons between the plight of enslaved African
Americans and that of enslaved Hebrews in the Bible. These
spiritual songs antedated the Civil War but were collected and
widely disseminated only after the ratification of the
Thirteenth
Amendment to the United States Constitution in 1865. The first
collection of African-American spirituals were appeared in
Thomas Wentworth Higginson's
famous book
Army Life in a Black Regiment, published in
1870, but collected in 1862-64 while Higginson was serving as a
colonel of the First South Carolina Volunteers, the first regiment
recruited from former slaves for the Federal service (Secretary of
War Edwin M. Stanton required that black regiments be commanded by
white officers).
A fervent abolitionist, Transcendentalist critic, and poetry
lover—who was a friend and enthusiastic champion of American poet
Emily Dickinson) -- Higginson had been deeply impressed by the
beauty of the devotional songs he heard the soldiers singing around
the regiment's campfires. Higginson wrote down the texts, in
dialect, as he heard them, but didn't provide tunes. The second
influential book about African-American spirituals was the 1872
collection
Jubilee Songs as Sung by the Jubilee Singers of Fisk
University, by Thomas F. Steward, comprising songs sung by
students of Fisk University on their fund-raising tours throughout
the county, arranged and harmonized according to nineteenth-century
classical music conventions.
Arguably, one of the best known African-American spirituals is the
anthem, "
Lift Every Voice and
Sing".
Originally written as a poem by noted
African-American novelist and composer James Weldon Johnson (1871-1938), it
was set to music in 1900 by his brother John Rosamond Johnson (1873-1954) in 1900
and first performed in Jacksonville, Florida
as part of a celebration of Lincoln's Birthday on February 12, 1900 by a
choir of 500 schoolchildren at the segregated Stanton School, where
James Weldon Johnson was principal. In 1919, the
NAACP adopted the song as "The Negro National Anthem."
This song contained strong appeals to the ideals of justice and
equality, and singing it could be interpreted as an act of
grass-roots self assertion by people who were officially still
barred from speaking out too overtly against Jim Crow and the
resurgence of
Ku Klux Klan activity in
the 1920s. By the 1920s, copies of "Lift Every Voice and Sing"
could be found in black churches across the country, often pasted
into the hymnals by the congregation members.
A topical parlor song that is arguably a precursor of
environmental movement is an
1837 musical setting of "Woodman Spare That Tree!",. The text is
from a poem by
George Pope
Morris, founder of the
New York
Mirror, and published in that paper, set to music British-born
composer
Henry Russell.
Verses include: "That old familiar tree,/Whose glory and renown/Are
spread o'er land and sea/And wouldst thou hack it down?/Woodman,
forbear thy stroke!/Cut not its earth, bound ties;/Oh! spare that
ag-ed oak/Now towering to the skies!"
This song has never caught on as a movement song, however.
Twentieth century
In the 20th century, the
union
movement, the
Great Depression,
the
Civil Rights movement, and
the
war in Vietnam (see
Vietnam War protests) all spawned
protest songs.
1900–1920; Labor Movement, Class Struggle, and The Great
War
The vast majority of American protest music from the first half of
the 20th century was based on the struggle for fair wages and
working hours for the working class, and on the attempt to unionize
the American workforce towards those ends. The
Industrial Workers of the
World (IWW) was founded in Chicago in June 1905 at a convention
of two hundred socialists, anarchists, and radical trade unionists
from all over the United States who were opposed to the policies of
the American Federation of Labor. From the start they used music as
a powerful form of protest.
One of the most famous of these early 20th century "
Wobblies" was
Joe Hill, an
IWW activist who traveled widely, organizing workers and writing
and singing political songs. He coined the phrase "pie in the sky",
which appeared in his most famous protest song "
The Preacher and the Slave"
(1911). The song calls for "Workingmen of all countries, unite/
Side by side we for freedom will fight/ When the world and its
wealth we have gained/ To the grafters we'll sing this refrain."
Other notable protest songs written by Hill include "The Tramp",
"There Is Power in a Union", "Rebel Girl", and "Casey Jones--Union
Scab".
Another
one of the best-known songs of this period was "Bread and Roses" by James Oppenheim and Caroline Kolsaat, which was sung in protest
en masse at a textile strike in Lawrence
, Massachusetts
during January-March 1912 (now often referred to as
the "Bread and Roses
strike") and has been subsequently taken up by protest
movements throughout the 20th century.
The advent of
The Great War
(1914-1918) resulted in a great number of songs concerning the
20th's most popular recipient of protest: war; songs against the
war in general, and specifically in America against the U.S.A.'s
decision to enter the European war started to become widespread and
popular. One of the most successful of these protest songs to
capture the widespread American skepticism about joining in the
European war was “I Didn’t Raise My Boy to Be a Soldier,” (1915) by
lyricist
Alfred Bryan and composer
Al Piantadosi.. Many of these war-time
protest songs took the point of view of the family at home, worried
about their father/husband fighting overseas. One such song of the
period which dealt with the children who had been orphaned by the
war was "War Babies"(1916) by
James
F. Hanley (music) and
Ballard MacDonald (lyrics) which spoke to
the need for taking care of orphans of war in an unusually frank
and open manner.For a typical song written from a child's
point-of-view see
Jean Schwartz
(music),
Sam M. Lewis &
Joe
Young (lyrics) and their song "Hello Central! Give Me No Man's
Land"(1918), in which a young boy tries to call his father in
No Man's Land on the
telephone (then a recent invention), unaware that
he has been killed in combat..
1920s–1930s; The Great Depression and Racial
Discrimination
The 1920s and 30s also saw the continuing growth of the union and
labor movements (the IWW claimed at its peak in 1923 some 100,000
members), as well as widespread poverty due to the
Great Depression and the
Dust Bowl, which inspired musicians and singers to
decry the harsh realities which they saw all around them.
It was
against this background that folk singer Aunt Molly Jackson was singing songs with
striking Harlan coal miners in Kentucky
in 1931, and
writing protest songs such as "Hungry Ragged Blues" and "Poor
Miner's Farewell", which depicted the struggle for social justice
in a Depression-ravaged America. In New York City
, Marc Blitzstein's
opera/musical The Cradle Will
Rock, a pro-union musical directed by Orson Welles, was produced in 1937.
However, it proved to be so controversial that it was shut down for
fear of social unrest. Undeterred, the IWW increasingly used music
to protest working conditions in the United States and to recruit
new members to their cause.
The 1920s and 30s also saw a marked rise in the number of songs
which protested against racial discrimination, such as
Louis Armstrong's "(What Did I Do to Be So)
Black and Blue" (1929), and the anti-lynching song, "
Strange Fruit" by
Lewis
Allan (which contains the lyrics "Southern trees bear strange
fruit / Blood on the leaves and blood at the root / Black bodies
swinging in the southern breeze"). It was also during this period
that many
African American blues
singers were beginning to have their voices heard on a larger scale
across America through their music, most of which protested the
discrimination which they faced on a daily basis. Perhaps the most
famous example of these 1930s blues protest songs is
Leadbelly's "
The
Bourgeois Blues", in which he sings "The home of the Brave /
The land of the Free / I don't wanna be mistreated by no
bourgeoisie".
1940s- 1950s; The labor movement vs McCarthyism; Anti-Nuclear
songs

1940s protest singer Woody
Guthrie
The 1940s and 1950s saw the rise of music that continued to protest
labor, race, and class issues. Protest songs continued to increase
their profile over this period, and an increasing number of artists
appeared who were to have an enduring influence on the protest
music genre. However, the movement and its protest singers faced
increasing opposition from
McCarthyism.
One of the most notable pro-union protest singers of the period was
Woody Guthrie ("
This Land Is Your Land", "
Deportee", "Dust Bowl Blues", "Tom Joad"), whose
guitar bore a sticker which read: "This Machine Kills Fascists".
Guthrie had also been a member or the hugely influential
labor-movement band
The Almanac
Singers, along with
Millard
Lampell,
Lee Hays, and
Pete Seeger. Politics and music were closely
intertwined with the members' political beliefs, which were
far-left and occasionally led to controversial associations with
the Communist Party USA. Their first release, an album called
Songs For John Doe,
urged non-intervention in World War II. In fact, an article written
in 2006 by an official of the American libertarian
Cato Institute reported that in the early
years of World War II, political opponents had referred to Seeger
as "
Stalin's Songbird". Their second album
"Talking Union", was a collection of labor songs, many of which
were intensely anti-Roosevelt owing to what Seeger considered the
President's weak support of workers' rights.
A similarly influential folk music band who sang protest songs were
The Weavers, of which future protest
music leader
Pete Seeger was a member.
The Weavers were the first American band
to court mainstream success while singing protest songs, and they
were eventually to pay the price for it. While they specifically
avoided recording the more controversial songs in their repertoire,
and refrained from performing at controversial venues and events
(for which the leftwing press derided them as having sold out their
beliefs in exchange for popular success), they nevertheless came
under political pressure as a result of their history of singing
protest songs and folk songs favoring labor unions, as well as for
the leftist political beliefs of the individuals in the group.
Despite
their caution they were placed under FBI
surveillance
and blacklisted by parts of the entertainment industry during the
McCarthy era, from 1950. Right-wing and anti-Communist
groups protested at their performances and harassed promoters. As a
result of the blacklisting, the Weavers lost radio airplay and the
group's popularity diminished rapidly.
Decca Records eventually terminated their
recording contract.
Paul Robeson, singer, actor, athlete, and civil
rights activist, was investigated by the FBI
and was called before the House Un-American
Activities Committee (HUAC) for his outspoken political
views. The State Department
denied Robeson a passport and issued a "stop
notice" at all ports, effectively confining him to the United
States. In a symbolic act of defiance against the
travel ban, labor unions in the U.S. and Canada
organized a
concert at the International Peace Arch
on the border between Washington
state and the Canadian province of British
Columbia
on May 18, 1952. Paul Robeson stood on the
back of a flat bed truck on the American side of the U.S.-Canada
border and performed a concert for a crowd on the Canadian side,
variously estimated at between 20,000 and 40,000 people. Robeson
returned to perform a second concert at the Peace Arch in 1953, and
over the next two years two further concerts were scheduled.
In the 1940s, one of the leading musical voices of protest from the
African American community in America was
Josh White, one of the first musicians to make a
name for himself singing political blues.. White enjoyed a position
of political privilege, especially as a black musician, as he
established a long and close relationship with the family of
Franklin and
Eleanor Roosevelt, and would become the
closest African American confidant to the
President of the United
States. He made his first foray into protest music and
political blues with his highly controversial
Columbia Records album
Joshua White
& His Carolinians: Chain Gang, produced by
John H. Hammond, which included the song "Trouble,"
which summarised the plight of many African Americans in its
opening line of "Well, I always been in trouble, ‘cause I’m a
black-skinned man." The album was the first race record ever forced
upon the white radio stations and record stores in America's South
and caused such a furor that it reached the desk of President
Franklin Roosevelt.
On December 20, 1940, White and the Golden Gate Quartet, sponsored by
Eleanor Roosevelt, performed in a historic Washington,
D.C.
concert at the Library of Congress's Coolidge
Auditorium to celebrate the 75th Anniversary of the Thirteenth
Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, which
abolished slavery. In January 1941, Josh performed at the
President's Inauguration, and two months later he released another
highly controversial record album,
Southern Exposure,
which included six anti-segregationist songs with liner notes
written by the celebrated and equally controversial African
American writer
Richard
Wright, and whose sub-title was "An Album of Jim Crow Blues".
Like the
Chain Gang album, and with revelatory yet
inflammatory songs such as "Uncle Sam Says", "Jim Crown Train",
"Bad Housing Blues", Defense Factory Blues", "Southern Exposure",
and "Hard Time Blues", it also was forced upon the southern white
radio stations and record stores, caused outrage in the South and
also was brought to the attention of President Roosevelt.
However,
instead of making White persona-non-grata in segregated America, it
resulted in President Roosevelt asking White to become the first
African American artist to give a White House
Command Performance, in 1941.
After the
Atomic bombings of
Hiroshima and Nagasaki on August 6 and 9, 1945, many people the
world over feared
nuclear warfare,
and many protest songs were written against this new danger. The
most immediately successful of these post-war anti-nuclear protest
songs was Vern Partlow's "Old Man Atom" (1945) (also known by the
alternate titles "Atomic Talking Blues" and "Talking Atom"). The
song treats its subject in comic-serious fashion, with a
combination of black humour puns (such as "We hold these truths to
be self-evident/All men may be cremated equal" or "I don't mean the
Adam that Mother Eve mated/I mean that thing that science
liberated") on serious statements on the choices to be made in the
nuclear age ("The people of the world must pick out a thesis/"Peace
in the world, or the world in pieces!""). Folk singer
Sam Hinton recorded "Old Man Atom" in 1950 for
ABC Eagle, a small California independent label. Influential New
York disc jockey
Martin Block played
Hinton's record on his 'Make Believe Ballroom.' Overwhelming
listener response prompted
Columbia
Records to acquire the rights for national distribution. From
all indications, it promised to be one of the year's biggest
novelty records. RCA Victor rush-released a cover version by the
Sons of the Pioneers. Country
singer Ozzie Waters recorded the song for Decca's Coral subsidiary.
Fred Hellerman - then contracted to Decca as a member of the
Weavers - recorded it for Jubilee under the pseudonym 'Bob Hill.'
Bing Crosby was reportedly ready to
record "Old Man Atom" for Decca when right-wing organizations began
attacking Columbia and RCA Victor for releasing a song that
reflected a Communist ideology. According to a New York Times
report on September 1, 1950.
Those who protested against the song's issuance on
records insisted that it parroted the Communist line on peace and
reflected the propaganda for the Stockholm 'peace
petition.'
Mr. Partlow said yesterday, according to an Associated
Press dispatch from Los Angeles, that his song was 'not part of the
Stockholm or any other so-called peace offensive.'
He added, 'It was written five years ago long before
any of these peace offensives.'
Buckling under pressure, both Columbia and RCA Victor withdrew "Old
Man Atom" from distribution.
Other anti-nuclear protest songs of the period include "Atom and
Evil" (1946) by
Golden Gate
Quartet ("if Atom and Evil should ever be wed/Lord, then darn
if all of us are going to be dead") and "Atomic Sermon" (1953) by
Billy Hughes and his Rhythm Buckeroos
1960s; the Civil Rights Movement, The Vietnam War, and Peace
and Revolution
The 1960s was a fertile era for the genre, especially with the rise
of the
Civil Rights movement,
the ascendency of
counterculture
groups such as
Hippies and the
New Left, and the escalation of the
War in Vietnam. The protest songs of the period
differed from those of earlier leftist movements; which had been
more oriented towards labor activism; adopting instead a broader
definition of political activism commonly called
social activism, which incorporated notions
of equal rights and of promoting the concept of 'peace'. The music
often included relatively simple instrumental accompaniment
including
acoustic guitar and
harmonica.
One of the key figures of the 1960s protest movement was
Bob Dylan, who produced a number of landmark
protest songs such as "
Blowin' in
the Wind" (1962), "
Masters of
War" (1963), "
Talking
World War III Blues" (1963), and "
The Times They Are A-Changin'"
(1964). While Dylan is often thought of as a 'protest singer', most
of his protest songs spring from a relatively short time-period in
his career; Mike Marqusee writes:
The protest songs that made Dylan famous and with which
he continues to be associated were written in a brief period of
some 20 months – from January 1962 to November 1963.
Influenced by American radical traditions (the
Wobblies, the Popular Front of the thirties and forties, the Beat
anarchists of the fifties) and above all by the political ferment
touched off among young people by the civil rights and ban the bomb
movements, he engaged in his songs with the terror of the nuclear
arms race, with poverty, racism and prison, jingoism and
war.
Dylan often sang against injustice, such as the murder of
African American civil
rights activist Medgar Evers in ‘
Only A Pawn In their Game’ (1964),
or the killing of the 51-year-old African American barmaid Hattie
Carroll by the wealthy young tobacco farmer from Charles County,
William Devereux "Billy" Zantzinger in '
The Lonesome Death of
Hattie Carroll" (1964) (Zantzinger was only sentenced to six
months in a county jail for the murder). Many of the injustices
about which Dylan sang were not even based on race or civil rights
issues, but rather everyday injustices and tragedies, such as the
death of boxer
Davey Moore in
the ring ("Who Killed Davey Moore?" (1964) ), or the breakdown of
farming and mining communities ("Ballad of Hollis Brown" (1963),
"
North Country Blues" (1963)).
By 1963, Dylan and then-singing partner
Joan
Baez had become prominent in the
civil
rights movement, singing together at rallies including the
March on
Washington where
Martin
Luther King, Jr. delivered his famous "
I have a dream" speech., however Dylan is
reported to have said: "“Think they’re listening?” Dylan asked,
glancing towards the Capitol. “No, they ain’t listening at all.”
Many of Dylan's songs of the period were to be adapted and
appropriated by the 60s Civil Rights and counter-culture
'movements' rather than being specifically written for them, and by
1964 Dylan was attempting to extract himself from the movement,
much to the chagrin of many of those who saw him as a voice of a
generation. Indeed, many of Dylan's songs have been retrospectively
aligned with issues which they in fact pre-date; while "
Masters of War" (1963) clearly protests
against governments who orchestrate war, it is often misconstrued
as dealing directly with the
Vietnam
War. However the song was written at the beginning of 1963,
when only a few hundred Green Berets were stationed in South
Vietnam. The song only came to be re-appropriated as a comment on
Vietnam in 1965, when US planes bombed North Vietnam for the first
time, with lines such as “you that build the death planes” seeming
particularly prophetic (in fact, unlike many of his contemporary
'protest singers', Dylan never mentioned Vietnam by name in any of
his songs). Dylan is quoted as saying that the song "is supposed to
be a pacifistic song against war. It's not an anti-war song. It's
speaking against what
Eisenhower was calling a
military-industrial complex as
he was making his exit from the presidency. That spirit was in the
air, and I picked it up." Similarly ‘A Hard Rain’s A-Gonna Fall’
(1963) is often perceived to deal with the
Cuban missile crisis, however Dylan
performed the song more than a month before
John F. Kennedy's TV address to the nation
(October 22, 1962) initiated the Cuban missile crisis. After this
brief, but extremely fruitful, 20 month period of 'protest songs',
Dylan decided to extract himself from the movement, changing his
musical style from folk to a more rock-orientated sound, and
writing increasingly abstract lyrics, which had more in common with
poetry and biblical references than social injustices. As he
explained to critic Nat Hentoff in mid-1964: “Me, I don’t want to
write for people anymore - you know, be a spokesman. From now on, I
want to write from inside me …I’m not part of no movement… I just
can’t make it with any organisation…”. His next acknowledged
'protest song' would be "
The
Hurricane", written twelve years later in 1976.
Pete Seeger, formerly of the
Almanac Singers and
The Weavers, was a major influence on Dylan and
his contemporaries, and continued to be a strong voice of protest
in the 1960s, when he produced "
Where Have All the Flowers
Gone", and "
Turn, Turn, Turn"
(written during the 1950s but released on Seeger's 1962 album
The Bitter and The Sweet). Seeger's song "
If I Had a Hammer" had been written in
1949 in support of the
progressive
movement, but rose to Top Ten popularity in 1962 when covered
by
Peter, Paul and Mary), going
on to become one of the major
Civil
Rights anthems of the
American Civil Rights
movement. "
We Shall Overcome",
Seeger's adaptation of an American gospel song, continues to be
used to support issues from
labor
rights to
peace movements. Seeger
was one of the leading singers to protest against then-
President Lyndon Johnson through song. Seeger first
satirically attacked the president with his
1966 recording of
Len Chandler's
children's song, "
Beans in My
Ears". In addition to Chandler's original lyrics, Seeger sang
that "Mrs. Jay's little son Alby" had "beans in his ears", which,
as the lyrics imply, ensures that a person does not hear what is
said to them. To those opposed to continuing the
Vietnam War the phrase suggested that "Alby
Jay", a loose pronunciation of Johnson's nickname "LBJ", did not
listen to anti-war protests as he too had "beans in his ears".
Seeger
attracted wider attention in 1967 with his song "Waist Deep in the Big Muddy",
about a captain — referred to in
the lyrics as "the big fool" — who drowned while leading a platoon
on maneuvers in Louisiana
during World War
II. In the face of arguments with the management of
CBS about whether the song's political weight
was in keeping with the usually light-hearted entertainment of the
Smothers Brothers
Comedy Hour, the final lines were "Every time I read the
paper/those old feelings come on/We are waist deep in the Big Muddy
and the big fool says to push on." And it was not seriously
contested that much of the audience would grasp Seeger's
allegorical casting of Johnson as the "big fool" and the
Vietnam War the foreseeable danger. Although the
performance was cut from the September 1967 show, after wide
publicity, it was broadcast when Seeger appeared again on the
Smothers' Brothers show in the following January.
Phil Ochs, one of the leading protest singers of
the decade (or, as he preferred, a "topical
singer"), performed at many political events, including
anti-Vietnam War and
civil rights rallies,
student events, and organized labor events over the course of his
career, in addition to many concert appearances at such venues as
New York City's The Town Hall and
Carnegie
Hall
. Politically, Ochs described himself as a
"left social democrat" who turned into an "early revolutionary"
after the
1968
Democratic National Convention in Chicago, which had a profound
effect on his state of mind. Some of his best known protest songs
include "
Power and the Glory",
"
Draft Dodger Rag", "
There But for Fortune",
"Changes", "Crucifixion, "When I'm Gone", "Love Me I'm a Liberal",
"Links on the Chain", "Ringing of Revolution", and "
I Ain't Marching Anymore".
Other notable voices of protest from the period included
Joan Baez,
Buffy
Sainte-Marie (whose anti-war song "
Universal Soldier" was later made
famous by
Donovan), and
Tom Paxton ("Lyndon Johnson Told the Nation" -
about the escalation of the war in Vietnam, "Jimmy Newman" - the
story of a dying soldier, and "My Son John" - about a soldier who
returns from war unable to describe what he's been through), among
others. The first protest song to reach number one in the United
States was
P.F. Sloan's
Eve
of Destruction, performed by
Barry
McGuire in 1965.
The
American civil rights
movement of the 1950s and 1960s often used
Negro spirituals as a source of protest,
changing the religious lyrics to suit the political mood of the
time. The use of religious music helped to emphasize the peaceful
nature of the protest; it also proved easy to adapt, with many
improvised
call-and-response songs
being created during marches and sit-ins. Some imprisoned
protesters used their incarceration as an opportunity to write
protest songs. These songs were carried across the country by
Freedom Riders, and many of these
became
Civil Rights anthems.
Many soul singers of the period, such as
Sam
Cooke ("
A Change Is
Gonna Come" (1965)),
Otis Redding
and
Aretha Franklin ("
Respect"),
James Brown
("
Say It Loud -
I'm Black and I'm Proud"[1968]; "I Don’t Want Nobody to Give Me
Nothing (Open Up the Door, I’ll Get It Myself) ” [1969]) and
Nina Simone ("
Mississippi Goddam" (1964), "
To Be Young, Gifted and Black"
(1970)) wrote and performed many protest songs which addressed the
ever-increasing demand for equal rights for
African Americans during the
American civil rights
movement. The predominantly white music scene of the time also
produced a number of songs protesting racial discrimination,
including
Janis Ian's "Society's Child
(Baby I've Been Thinking), (1966)" about an interracial romance
forbidden by a girl's mother and frowned upon by her peers and
teachers and a culture that classifies citizens by race.
Steve Reich's 13-minute long "Come Out" (1966),
which consists of manipulated recordings of a single spoken line
given by an injured survivor of the Harlem Race Riots of 1964,
protested police brutality against African Americans.
In the 1960s and early 1970s many protest songs were written and
recorded condemning the
War in
Vietnam, most notably "
Simple
Song of Freedom" by
Bobby Darin
(1969), "
I Ain't Marching
Anymore" by
Phil Ochs (1965), "Lyndon
Johnson Told The Nation" by
Tom Paxton
(1965), "Bring Them Home" by
Pete Seeger
(1966), "Requiem for the Masses" by
The
Association (1967), "Saigon Bride" by
Joan
Baez (1967), "
Waist Deep
in the Big Muddy" by
Pete Seeger
(1967), "Suppose They Give a War and No One Comes" by
The West Coast Pop Art
Experimental Band(1967), "_I-Feel-Like-I'm-Fixin'-To-Die_Rag"
href="/The_"Fish"_Cheer_/_I-Feel-Like-I'm-Fixin'-To-Die_Rag">The
"Fish" Cheer / I-Feel-Like-I'm-Fixin'-To-Die Rag" by
Country Joe and the Fish (1968),
"
The Unknown Soldier " by
The Doors (1968), "
One Tin Soldier" by
Original Caste (1969), "Volunteers" by
Jefferson Airplane (1969), and
"
Fortunate Son" by
Creedence Clearwater Revival
(1969).
Woody Guthrie's
son Arlo Guthrie also wrote one of the
decade's most famous protest songs in the form of the 18 minute
long talking blues song "Alice's Restaurant Massacree
", a bitingly satirical protest against the Vietnam War draft. As
an extension of these concerns, artists started to protest the
ever-increasing escalation of
Nuclear
weapons and threat of
Nuclear
warfare; as for example on
Tom
Lehrer's ""So Long, Mom (A Song for World War III)", "Who's
Next?" (about
Nuclear
proliferation) and "
Wernher von
Braun" from his 1965 collection of political satire songs
That Was the Year That
Was.
The 1960s also saw a number of successful protest songs from the
opposite end of the spectrum; the political right which supported
the war. Perhaps the most successful and famous of these was
"
Ballad of the Green
Berets" (1966) by
Barry Sadler,
which was one of the very few songs of the era to cast the military
in a positive light and yet become a major hit.
Merle Haggard & the Strangers' “
Okie from Muskogee” (1969),
despite being strongly patriotic, was listed in
PopMatters' July 2007 list of the top 65 protest
songs because it is, as the
webzine puts it,
in fact a protest against changing social mores,
alternative lifestyles, and, well, protests[...] In a time when
protest songs filled the airwaves, it is ironic that Haggard scored
his biggest hit protesting the rise of a discontented
culture.
1970s; The Vietnam War, Soul Music
The
Kent State
shootings
of May 4, 1970 amplified sentiment that was
portrayed by the United States' invasion of Cambodia and the
Vietnam War in general, and protest songs about The Vietnam War continued to grow in
popularity and frequency. There were anti-war songs such as
Chicago's "It Better End Soon"
(1970), "
War" (1970) by
Edwin Starr, and "
Ohio" (1970) by
Crosby, Stills, Nash, and
Young (about the May 4th Kent State shootings). Another great
influence on the anti-Vietnam war protest songs of the early
seventies was the fact that this was the first generation where
combat veterans were returning prior to the end of the war, and
that even the veterans were protesting the war, as with the
formation of the '
Vietnam Veterans Against the
War' (VVAW).
Graham Nash wrote his
"Oh! Camil (The Winter Soldier)" (1973) to tell the story of one
member of VVAW, Scott Camil. Other notable anti-war songs of the
time included
Stevie Wonder's frank
condemnation of
Richard Nixon 's
Vietnam policies in his 1974 song "
You Haven't Done Nothin'." Protest
singer and activist
Joan Baez dedicated
the entire B side of her album
Where Are You Now, My Son?
(1973) to
recordings she had made of bombings while in Hanoi
.
Steely Dan's "King of the World" on their
1973 album
Countdown to
Ecstasy joined the protest against
nuclear war.
While war continued to dominate the protest songs of the early 70s,
there were other issues addressed by bands of the time, such as
Helen Reddy's feminist hit "
I Am Woman" (1972), which became an anthem for
the
women’s liberation movement.
Bob Dylan also made a brief return to protest
music after some twelve years with "
Hurricane" (1976), which protested the
imprisonment of
Rubin "Hurricane" Carter as a
result of alleged acts of racism and profiling against Carter,
which Dylan describes as leading to a false trial and
conviction.
Soul music carried over into the early part of the 70s, in many
ways taking over from folk music as one of the strongest voices of
protest in American music, the most important of which being
Marvin Gaye's seminal 1971 protest album
"
What's Going On", which included
"
Inner City Blues", "
Mercy Mercy Me ", and the
title track. Another hugely
influential protest album of the time was poet and musician
Gil Scott-Heron's "Small Talk at
125th and Lenox", which contained the oft-referenced protest song
"
The Revolution
Will Not Be Televised". The album's 15 tracks dealt with myriad
themes, protesting the superficiality of television and mass
consumerism, the hypocrisy of some would-be Black revolutionaries,
white middle-class ignorance of the difficulties faced by
inner-city residents, and fear of homosexuals.
1980s: Anti-Reagan protest songs, and the birth of Rap
The Reagan administration was also coming in for its fair share of
criticism, with many mainstream protest songs attacking his
policies, such as
Bruce
Springsteen's "
Born in the
U.S.A." (1984), and "
My Brain
Is Hanging Upside Down" by
The
Ramones. This sentiment was countered by songs like "God Bless
The USA" by
Lee Greenwood which was
seen by many as a protest against protests against the Reagan
Administration.
Billy Joel's "
Allentown" protested the decline of the
rust belt, and represented those coping
with the demise of the American manufacturing industry.
Reagan
came under significant criticism for the Iran-Contra Affair, in which it was
discovered that his administration was selling arms to the radical
Islamic regime in Iran and using proceeds from the sales to
illegally fund the Contras, a
guerilla/terrorist group in Nicaragua
. A number of songs were written in protest
of this scandal. "
All She
Wants to Do Is Dance," (1984) by
Don
Henley, protested against the U.S. involvement with the Contras
in Nicaragua, while chastising Americans for only wanting to dance,
while
molotov cocktails, and sales
of guns and drugs are going on around them, and while "the boys"
(the CIA, NSA, etc.) are "makin' a buck or two". Other songs to
protest America's role in the Iran-Contra affair include "The Big
Stick," by
Minutemen, "Nicaragua," by
Bruce Cockburn, and "Please Forgive
Us," by
10,000 Maniacs.
The 1980s also saw the rise of rap and hip-hop, and with it bands
such as
Grandmaster Flash
("
The Message [1982]"),
Boogie Down Productions ("Stop the
Violence" [1988]),"
N.W.A ("
Fuck tha Police" [1988]) and
Public Enemy ("
Fight the Power" [1989], "911 (Is a Joke)"
etc.) who vehemently protested the discrimination and poverty which
the black community faced in America, in particular focusing on
police discrimination. In 1988 The
Stop the Violence Movement was
formed by rapper
KRS-One in response to
violence in the hip hop and black communities. Including some of
the biggest stars in contemporary East Coast hip hop (including
Public Enemy), the movement
released a single, "Self Destruction", in 1989, with all proceeds
going to the
National Urban
League.
Punk music continued to be a strong voice of protest in the 1980s,
however it had for the most part, developed a heavier and more
aggressive sound, as typified by
Black
Flag (whose debut album
Damaged (1981) was described by
the
BBC as "essentially an album of electric
protest songs[..., which] takes a swing at the insularities and
shortcomings of the ‘me’ generation."),
Dead Kennedys (whose sweeping criticism of
America, "Stars and Stripes of Corruption" (1985), contains the
lyric "Rednecks and bombs don't make us strong/ We loot the world,
yet we can't even feed ourselves"), and
Bad
Religion; a tradition carried on in the following decades by
punk revivalists like
Anti-Flag and
Rise Against. Of the few remaining
old-school punks still recording in the late 80s, the most notable
protest song is
Patti Smith's 1988
recording "
People Have the
Power."
1990s; Hard-Rock Protest Bands, Women's Rights, and Protest
Parodies
In 1990, singer
Melba Moore released a
modern rendition of the 1900 song "
Lift Every Voice and Sing" - which
had long been considered "The Negro National Anthem" and one of the
20th Century's most powerful civil rights anthems - which she
recorded along with others including R&B artists
Anita Baker,
Stephanie Mills,
Dionne Warwick,
Bobby
Brown,
Stevie Wonder,
Jeffrey Osborne, and
Howard Hewett; and gospel artists
BeBe and
CeCe Winans,
Take 6, and
The
Clark Sisters. Partly because of the success of this recording,
Lift Ev'ry Voice and Sing was entered into the
Congressional Record as the official
African American National Hymn.
Rage Against the Machine,
formed in 1991, has been one of the most popular
'social-commentary' bands of the last 20 years. A fusion of the
musical styles and lyrical themes of punk, hip-hop, and thrash,
Rage Against the Machine railed against corporate America
("
No Shelter", "
Bullet in the Head"), government
oppression ("
Killing in the
Name"), and Imperialism ("
Sleep Now in the Fire", "
Bulls on Parade"). The band used its music
as a vehicle for
social activism, as
lead singer
Zack de la Rocha
espoused: "Music has the power to cross borders, to break military
sieges and to establish real dialogue".
The 90s also saw a huge movement of pro-women's rights protest
songs from most musical genres as part of the
Third-wave feminism movement.
Ani DiFranco was at the forefront of this
movement, protesting
sexism,
sexual abuse,
homophobia,
reproductive rights as well as
racism,
poverty, and
war. Her "Lost Woman Song" (1990) concerns itself with
the hot topic of abortion, and with DiFranco's assertion that a
woman has a right to choose without being judged. A particularly
prevalent movement of the time was the
underground feminist punk Riot Grrrl movement, including a number of
outspoken protest bands such as
Bikini
Kill,
Bratmobile,
Jack Off Jill,
Excuse
17,
Heavens to Betsy,
Huggy Bear,
Sleater-Kinney, and also
lesbian queercore bands
such as
Team Dresch.
Sonic Youth's "Swimsuit Issue" (1992) protested
the way in which women are objectified and turned into a commodity
by the media. The song, in which
Kim
Gordon lists off the names of every model featured in the 1992
Sports Illustrated
Swimsuit Issue, was selected as one of
PopMatters' 65 greatest protest songs of all time
with the praise that "Sonic Youth reminds us that protest songs
don’t have to include acoustic guitars and twee harmonica melodies
stuck in 1965. They don’t even have to be about war."
For the most part the 1990s signaled a decline in the popularity of
protest songs in the mainstream media and public consciousness -
even resulting in some parodies of the genre. The 1992 film
Bob Roberts is an example of protest
music parody, in which the title character - played by American
actor
Tim Robbins - is a guitar-playing
U.S. Senatorial candidate who writes and performs songs with a
heavily
reactionary tone.
Twenty-first century
The Iraq War and the Revival of the Protest Song
After the 90s the protest song found renewed popularity around the
world after the turn of the century as a result of the
9/11 attacks in America, and the Afghanistan
and Iraq wars in the
Middle East, with
America's former president
George W.
Bush facing the majority of the
criticism. Many famous protest singers of yesteryear, such as
Neil Young,
Patti
Smith,
Tom Waits, and
Bruce Springsteen, have returned to the
public eye with new protest songs for the new war. Young approached
the theme with his song, "
Let's Impeach the President" - a
stinging rebuke against former President George W. Bush and the
War in Iraq - as well as
Living With War, an album of anti-Bush and
anti-War protest songs.
Smith has written
two new songs indicting American and Israeli foreign policy -
"Qana", about the Israeli airstrike on the Lebanese village of
Qana
, and "Without Chains", about the U.S. detention
center at Guantanamo Bay
.
R.E.M., who had been known for their
politically charged material in the 1980s, also returned to
increasingly political subject matter since the advent of the Iraq
War. For example "Final Straw" (2003) is a politically-charged
song, reminiscent in tone of "World Leader Pretend" on Green. The
version on their
Around the
Sun album is a remix of the original , which was made
available as a free download on March 25, 2003 from the band's
website. The song was written as a protest of the U.S. government's
actions in the Iraq War.
Tom Waits has also covered increasingly
political subject matter since the advent of the Iraq war. In "The
Day After Tomorrow" Waits adopts the
persona
of a soldier writing home that he is disillusioned with war and
thankful to be leaving. The song does not mention the
Iraq war specifically, and, as Tom Moon writes, "it
could be the voice of a
Civil War
soldier singing a lonesome late-night dirge." Waits himself does
describe the song as something of an "elliptical" protest song
about the
Iraqi invasion,
however. Thom Jurek describes "The Day After Tomorrow" as "one of
the most insightful and understated
anti-war songs to have been written in decades. It
contains not a hint of banality or sentiment in its folksy
articulation." Waits' recent output has not only addressed the
Iraqi war, as his "Road To Peace" deals explicitly with the
Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the Middle East in general.
Bruce Springsteen has also been
vocal in his condemnation of the Bush government, among other
issues of social commentary. In 2000 he released "
American Skin " about tensions
between immigrants in America and the police force, and of the
police shooting of
Amadou Diallo in
particular. For singing about this event, albeit without mentioning
Diallo's name, Springsteen was denounced by the
Patrolmen's Benevolent
Association in New York who called for the song to be
blacklisted and by Mayor
Rudolph
Giuliani amongst others. In the aftermath of
9/11 Springsteen released
The Rising, which exhibited his
reflections on the tragedy and America's reaction to it. In 2006 he
released
We
Shall Overcome: The Seeger Sessions, a collection of 13
covers of protest songs made popular by
Pete
Seeger, which highlighted how these older protest songs
remained relevant to the troubles of the modern America. An
extended version of the album included the track "
How Can a Poor Man
Stand Such Times and Live?" in which Springsteen actually
rewrote the lyrics of the original to directly address the issue of
Hurricane Katrina. His 2007
long-player,
Magic, continues
Springsteen's tradition of protest song-writing, with a number of
songs which continue to question and attack America's role in the
Iraqi war. "Last to Die", with its chorus of "Who'll be the last to
die for a mistake.... Whose blood will spill, whose heart will
break," is believed to have been inspired by Senator-to-be
John Kerry's 1971 testimony to the
US Senate, in which he asked "How do you ask a man
to be the last man to die in Vietnam? How do you ask a man to be
the last man to die for a mistake?" "Gypsy Biker" deals with the
homecoming of a US Soldier killed in action in Iraq, and
Springsteen has said that "Livin' in the Future" references
extraordinary rendition and illegal wiretapping. "
Long Walk Home" is an account of the
narrator's sense that those people living at home "he thought he
knew, whose ideals he had something in common with, are like
strangers." The recurring lyric "it’s gonna be a long walk home" is
a response to the violation of "certain things", such as "what
we'll do and what we won't", in spite of these codes having been
(in the words of the narrator's father) "set in stone" by the
characters' "flag flyin' over the courthouse."
Contemporary Protest Songs
Modern-day mainstream artists to have written protest songs on this
subject include
Pink with her appeal
to Bush in "
Dear Mr. President"
(2006),
Bright Eyes with
"
When the President
Talks to God" (2005) (which was hailed by the Portland, Oregon,
alternative paper
Willamette Week as
"this young century's most powerful protest song."),
Dispatch's anti-war underground hit "The
General", and
Devendra Banhart's
"Heard somebody Say" (2005) in which he sings "it's simple, we
don't want to kill". In 2003
Lenny
Kravitz recorded the protest song "We Want Peace" with Iraqi
pop star
Kadim Al Sahir, Palestinian
strings musician
Simon Shaheen and
Lebanese percussionist
Jamey Hadded.
According to Kravitz the song "is about more than Iraq. It is about
our role as people in the world and that we all should cherish
freedom and peace."
The
Decemberists, while not normally known for writing political
songs (or songs set in the present day, for that matter),
contributed to the genre in 2005 with their understated but
scathing song "
16 Military Wives,"
which singer
Colin Meloy described thus:
"It's kind of a protest song, [...] My objective is to make sense
of
foreign
policy decisions taken by the current Bush administration and
showing how they resemble solipsistic bullying."
Pearl Jam also included two anti-Bush songs
("
World Wide Suicide", "Marker In
The Sand") in their 2006 album
Pearl Jam. Even the banking
system can be the focus of a protest song as in "National Strike!",
by Loren Dean, on showcaseyourmusic.com
The hip-hop group
The Beastie Boys
had a number of protest songs on their 2004 release
To the 5 Boroughs. Songs such as
"
It Takes Time To Build" and
"
Right Right Now Now" take
particular aim at the Bush administration and its policies.
Even members of the
US Military have
spoken out against the ambiguous nature of the
Iraq War, and sanitized US media coverage of
coalition troop casualties with protest songs, as evidenced by the
2006 underground release of "Suicide Bomber (of Truth)" and
"Welcome to the War (It's Over)", by the now-defunct group
Seriously, Argon Duck, which was composed of soldiers from
the
US Army Signal Corps.
American avant-garde singer
Bobby Conn
wrote an album of anti-Bush songs with his 2001 collection
The Homeland. Conn has stated
that "[a]ll the records that I've done are a critique of what's
going on in contemporary America," and he was an outspoken critic
of the Bush regime. Conn has admitted that while he actively
protests what he sees as the evils of American society, he is not
always at ease with such a label for himself. "I’ve always done
lots of social commentary that I believe in pretty strongly but I
am very uncomfortable with the role of the artist as a meaningful
social critic...my whole generation [is] a confused group of people
with an ambivalent way of dealing with protest." Discussing his
2007 album
King For a Day, Conn stated "it's political,
but just in a contemporary culture kind of way [...] Two of the
songs are about
Tom Cruise, and I don't
know if there's a more political statement than Tom Cruise. He kind
of symbolizes a lot of what's going on in this country right now
and how people are responding to it."
Bobb Conn on being a 'protest singer':
Arcade Fire's 2007 Neon Bible contains many oblique protests against the paranoia of a contemporary America 'under attack by terrorism'. The album also contains two more overtly political protest songs in the form of "Windowsill", in which Win Butler sings "I don't want to live in America no more", and "Intervention", which contains the line "Don't want to fight, don't want to die", and criticizes religious fanaticism in general. However the protest album to achieve the most mainstream success in the first decade of the 21st century has been Green Day's "American Idiot, which was awarded a Grammy for "Best Rock Album" in 2005, despite its strong criticism of current American foreign policy and George Bush. The title track from the album has been described by the band as their public statement in reaction to the confusing and warped scene that is American pop culture since 9/11.
In particular, rapper
Eminem has encountered
controversy over protest songs directed towards George W. Bush.
Songs such as
Mosh,
White America, and
We As Americans have either targeted Bush or the U.S.
government in general. Eminem, in fact, registered to vote for the
first time in 2004, just for the sake of
voting Bush out of
office, which would ultimately prove unsuccessful.
Outside of pop music, folk, punk and country music continue to
follow their strong traditions of protest.
Utah Philips, and
David
Rovics, among many other singers have continued the folk
tradition of protest. In John Mayer's 2006 release CONTINUUM, the
lead single " Waiting on the World to Change", Mayer is critical of
the desensitizing of politics in youths. He goes on to say in
"Belief", "What puts a hundred thousand children in the sand?
Belief can. What puts the folded flag inside his mother's hand?
Belief can." Folk singer
Dar Williams's
song "Empire" from her 2005 album
My
Better Self accuses the Bush administration of building a
new empire based on the fear of terror, as well as protesting the
administration's policy on torture: "We'll kill the terrorizers and
a million of their races, but when our people torture you that's a
few random cases."
Lucy Kaplansky,
who has also performed protest songs with Dar Williams in their
side project
Cry Cry Cry, has
written many songs of protest since 9/11, including her tribute to
that day - "Land of the Living" - however her most recognised
protest song to date is "Line in the Sand", which includes the line
: "Another bomb lights up the night of someone's vision of paradise
but it's just a wasted sacrifice that fuels the hate on the other
side."
Tracy Grammer's song "Hey ho",
from her 2005 album
Flower of
Avalon addresses how children are taught from a young age
to play at war as soldiers with plastic guns, perpetuating the war
machine: "Wave the flag and watch the news, tell us we can count on
you. Mom and dad are marching too; children, step in line."
Punk rock still is a formidable force and constitutes a majority of
the protest songs written today. Artists such as
Anti-Flag,
Bad
Religion,
NOFX,
Rise Against,
Authority Zero, to name just a few, are noted
for their political activism in denouncing the Bush administration
and the policies of the American government in general. The
political campaign
Punkvoter, which
started the project
Rock Against
Bush, was kicked off with a collection of punk rock songs
critical of President Bush called "
Rock Against Bush, Vol. 1", and a
sequel was released in 2004.
Representatives from the punk community such as
Fat Mike of
NOFX,
Henry Rollins (formerly of
Black Flag), and
Jello Biafra of
The Dead Kennedys are noted for their
continuing political activism.
While country music has offered the loudest voice in support of the
war through artists such as
Toby Keith's
"
Courtesy
of the Red, White, & Blue " (which
Natalie Maines publicly criticized as
"ignorant, and it makes country music sound ignorant."),
Darryl Worley's "
Have You Forgotten?" and
Charlie Daniels, many established country
artists have released strongly critical anti-war songs. These
include
Willie Nelson,
Merle Haggard,
Emmylou Harris, the
Dixie Chicks ("
Not Ready to Make Nice" (2006)) and
Nanci Griffith.
Criticism
Some artists who are not traditionally right-leaning have
questioned the validity of the recent spate of anti-war protest
songs.
Florida
-based punk-folk band Against
Me! released a song called White People For Peace that questions
the effectiveness of people singing "protest songs in response to
military aggression" when their governments simply ignore
them.
More recently anti-globalization writer
Naomi Klein has attacked the replacement of
grass-roots protest by celebrity-endorsed festivals or events, such
as the
Make Poverty History
campaign; a trend which she calls the “Bono-isation” of protests
against world poverty. She is quoted in
The
Times newspaper as attesting that "The
Bono-isation of protest, particularly in the UK, has
reduced discussion to a much safer terrain [...] there’s
celebrities and then there’s spectators waving their bracelets.
It’s less dangerous and less powerful [than grass roots street
demonstrations].”
European protest songs
Protest songs from the U.K.
Early protest songs from Britain
English folk song from the later medieval period onwards contained
two major themes, that of social or political criticism and of
anti-war protest.
A. L. Lloyd claimed that
the oldest European protest song is "
The
Cutty Wren" and that it dated from the
English peasants' revolt of
1381 as an anthem against feudal oppression, but no version is
recorded before a Scottish one in 1776 and the meaning of the song
is obscure. A more obvious example that was clearly used by the
rebels in 1381 was the rhyme ‘When Adam delved and Eve span, who
was then the gentleman?’, which attacked the basis of social
inequality. It had expanded to at least a verse before the end of
the fourteenth century. In a more subtle way songs that celebrated
social bandits like
Robin Hood, from the
fourteenth century onwards can be seen as a form of protest,
although social criticism was usually implied rather than
stated.
With the rise of more articulate social protest movements such as
the
Levellers and
Diggers in the mid-seventeenth century, more overt
criticism surfaced, as in the ballad ‘The
Diggers' Song. From roughly the same period
songs of protest at war, pointing out the costs to human lives, if
rarely actually condemning the wars themselves, also begin to
appear, like ‘The Maunding Souldier or The Fruits of Warre is
Beggery’, framed as a begging appeal from a crippled soldier of the
Thirty Years War.
With the advent of industrialisation and a series of protest
movements from the eighteenth centuries the number of social
protest songs began to increase rapidly. An important example is
‘The Triumph of General Ludd,’ which built a fictional persona for
the alleged leader of the early nineteenth century
anti-technological
Luddite movement in the
cloth industry of the north midlands, and which made explicit
reference to the Robin Hood tradition. A surprising English folk
hero immortalised in song is
Napoleon
Bonaparte, the military figure most often the subject of
popular ballads, many of them treating him as the champion of the
common working man in songs such as the ‘Bonny Bunch of Roses’ and
‘Napoleon’s Dream’. As labour became more organised songs were used
as anthems and propaganda, for miners with songs like ‘The Black
Leg Miner’, and for factory workers with songs like ‘The Factory
Bell’.
These industrial protest songs were largely ignored during the
first English folk revival of the later nineteenth and early
twentieth century, which focused on a rural idyll, but were
recorded by figures like
A. L. Lloyd on albums
such as
The Iron Muse (1963). In the 1980s the anarchist
rock band
Chumbawamba recorded several
versions of traditional English protest songs as
English Rebel Songs
1381-1914.
20th Century U.K. songs of protest
Colin
Irwin, journalist for The Guardian,
identifies the birth of the modern British protest with the
Campaign for Nuclear
Disarmament's 1958 53-mile protest march from Trafalgar
Square
to Aldermaston
, which "fired up young musicians to write
campaigning new songs to argue the case against the bomb and whip
up support along the way. Suddenly many of those in skiffle
groups playing American songs were changing course and writing
fierce topical songs to back direct action." A theme protest song
was specially written for the march: "The H-Bomb's Thunder", a poem
by novelist
John Brunner set to the
tune of "Miner's Lifeguard", including lyrics such as: "Men and
women, stand together/Do not heed the men of war/Make your minds up
now or never/Ban the bomb for evermore."
The leading voice of this new British protest movement was
Ewan MacColl, who by the 1950s was singing
pro-communist songs such as "The Ballad of
Ho Chi Minh" and "The Ballad of
Stalin", as well as volatile protest and topical
songs concerning the nuclear threat to peace, most notably "Against
the Atom Bomb". "There are now more new songs being written than at
any other time in the past 80 years - young people are finding out
for themselves that folk songs are tailor-made for expressing their
thoughts and comments on contemporary topics, dreams and worries,"
MacColl told the
Daily Worker in 1958.
In the 1960s the American anti-war tradition was taken up by
Donovan in his version of "
Universal Soldier" (1965) and "The War
Drags On" (1965).

John Lennon rehearsing the
anti-Vietnam War anthem
Give Peace a Chance
As their fame and critical appreciation increased in the late
1960s,
The Beatles- and
John Lennon in particular - became increasingly
political in their subject matter, writing a number of the era's
notable protest songs. Tariq Ali, a socialist and leader of the
student movement in Britain, summarised the reason for this as:
“The whole culture had been radicalized, [Lennon] was engaged with
the world, and the world was changing him." Although The Beatles'
first overtly political song was "
Revolution" (1968), Lennon became
increasingly determined to use his fame to spread a political
message.
When he and Yoko Ono
married in 1969, they staged a weeklong “bed-in for peace” in the
Amsterdam
Hilton. The
protest attracted worldwide
media
coverage. At the second "Bed-in" in Montreal, in June 1969, they
recorded "
Give Peace a Chance"
in their hotel room.
The song was sung by over half a million
demonstrators in Washington,
D.C.
at the second Vietnam Moratorium Day,
on 15 October 1969. In 1972 Lennon released his most
politically charged collection of "protest songs" with the album
Some Time In New York
City. The album's lead single "
Woman Is the Nigger of the
World" (a phrase Ono had coined in the late 1960s), was
intended to protest
sexism and was met by a
controversial reaction, and – as a consequence – little airplay and
much banning. The Lennons went to great lengths (including a press
conference attended by staff from
Jet and
Ebony magazines) to explain that the
word "
nigger" was being used in an
allegorical sense and not as an affront to African-Americans.
On the
album Lennon also protests police brutality in general - and the
Attica
Prison riots
of 9 September 1971 in particular - in "Attica
State", the hardships of war-torn Northern Ireland
in "Sunday Bloody Sunday" and "The Luck Of The
Irish" and pay tribute to Angela Davis
with, "Angela". Lennon performed at the "Free John Sinclair" concert in Ann Arbor
, Michigan
, on 10 December 1971. Sinclair was an
antiwar activist and poet who was serving ten years in state prison
for selling two
joint of
marijuana to an undercover cop. Lennon and
Ono appeared on stage with Phil Ochs, Stevie Wonder and other
musicians, plus antiwar
radical Jerry
Rubin and
Bobby Seale of the
Black Panthers. Lennon performed the song,
"John Sinclair" (also from Lennon's "Some Time In New York City"
album), calling on the authorities to "Let him be, set him free,
let him be like you and me". Some 20,000 people attended the rally,
and three days after the concert the State of Michigan released
Sinclair from prison.
The 1970s saw a number notable songs by British acts that protested
against war, including "
Peace Train" by
Cat Stevens (1971), and "
War Pigs" by
Black
Sabbath (1970). Sabbath also protested environmental
destruction, describing people leaving a ruined Earth ("
Into the Void" including, "
Iron Man").
The
Rolling Stones sang against
police
brutality in "
Doo
Doo Doo Doo Doo " (1973).
Renaissance added political repression as
a protest theme with "
Mother Russia" being based
on
One Day in
the Life of Ivan Denisovich and being joined on the second
side of their 1974 album
Turn of
the Cards by two other protest songs in "Cold Is Being"
(about ecological destruction) and "Black Flame" (about the Vietnam
War).
As the 1970s progressed, the louder, more aggressive Punk movement
became the strongest voice of protest, particularly in the UK,
featuring anti-war, anti-state, and anti-capitalist themes. The
punk culture, in stark contrast with the 1960s' sense of power
through union, concerned itself with individual freedom, often
incorporating concepts of
individualism,
free
thought and even
anarchism. According
to
Search and Destroy founder
V.
Vale, "Punk was a total cultural revolt. It
was a hardcore confrontation with the black side of history and
culture, right-wing imagery, sexual taboos, a delving into it that
had never been done before by any generation in such a thorough
way." The most significant protest songs of the movement included
"
God Save the
Queen" (1977) by the
Sex Pistols,
"If the Kids are United" by
Sham 69,
"
Career Opportunities" (1977)
(protesting the political and economic situation in England at the
time, especially the lack of jobs available to the youth), and
"
White Riot" (1977) (about class
economics and race issues) by
The Clash,
and "Right to Work" by
Chelsea. See
also
Punk ideology.
War was still the prevalent theme of British protest songs of the
1980s - such as
Kate Bush's "
Army Dreamers" (1980), which deals with the
traumas of a mother whose son dies while away at war. However, as
the 1980s progressed, it was British prime minister
Margaret Thatcher who came under the
greatest degree of criticism from native protest singers, mostly
for her strong stance against
trade
unions, and especially for her handling of the
UK miners' strike .
The leading voice of protest in
Thatcherite Britain in the 1980s was
Billy Bragg, whose style of protest song
and grass-roots political activism was mostly reminiscent of those
of
Woody Guthrie, however with themes
that were relevant to the contemporary Briton. He summarised his
stance in "Between the Wars" (1985) in which he sings "I'll give my
consent to any government that does not deny a man a living
wage."
Britain's current involvement in Iraq and Afghanistan has also
garnered criticism from native singers; including
George Michael's anti-
Tony Blair single "
Shoot
the Dog" (2002)- which criticised Blair's overly-friendly
relationship with
George W. Bush and support for the Iraq War- and the
more recent example of
Ian Brown and
Sinéad O'Connor's "Illegal
Attacks" (2007) ("So what the fuck is this UK/Gunning with this US
of A/ in Iraq and Iran and in Afghanistan?/These are illegal
attacks/So bring the soldiers back"). Ex-
Smiths frontman
Morrissey has also attacked both sides of the
Atlantic with "America is Not the World" and "Irish Blood, English
Heart" from his 2004
You Are the
Quarry album.
Irish Rebel Songs
Irish rebel music is a sub genre
of Irish folk music, played on typically Irish instruments (such as
the
Fiddle,
tin
whistle,
Uilleann pipes,
accordion,
bodhrán
etc.) and acoustic guitars. The lyrics deal with the fight for
Irish freedom, people who were involved in liberation movements,
the persecution and violence during
Northern Ireland's Troubles and the history of
Ireland's numerous rebellions.
Among the many examples of the genre, some of the most famous are
"
A Nation Once Again", "
Come out Ye Black and Tans",
"Erin go Bragh", "
The Fields of
Athenry", "
The Men Behind
the Wire" and the Republic of Ireland's national Anthem
"
Amhrán na bhFiann" ("The
Soldier's Song").Music of this genre has often courted controversy,
and some of the more outwardly anti-British songs have been
effectively banned from the airwaves in both England and the
Republic of Ireland.
Paul McCartney also made a
contribution to the genre with his 1972 single "
Give Ireland Back to the
Irish" which he wrote as a reaction to
Bloody Sunday in Northern Ireland on
January 30, 1972. The song also faced an all-out ban in the UK, and
has never been re-released or appeared on any Paul McCartney or
Wings best-ofs. His former colleague
John Lennon wrote a song called
Sunday Bloody Sunday in 1972 shortly
after the massacre of Irish civil rights activists, this song
differs from U2's 1983 version of Bloody Sunday in that it directly
supports the Irish Republican cause and does not call for peace.
The same
year John Lennon also released two
protest songs concerning the hardships of war-torn Northern
Ireland
in the form of "Sunday Bloody Sunday" and "The Luck
Of The Irish," both from his 1972 album Some Time in New York
City.
The
Wolfe Tones have become legendary in
Ireland for their contribution to the Irish rebel genre. The band
has been recording since 1963 and has attracted worldwide fame and
attention through their renditions of traditional Irish songs and
originals, dealing with the former conflict in Northern Ireland. In
2002 the Wolfe Tone's version of
A
Nation Once Again, a nationalist song from the 19th century,
was voted the greatest song in the world in a poll conducted by the
BBC World Service
Christy Moore is another famous figure
in Irish rebel music, and together with his original band
Planxty he recorded traditional music during the
1970s. Following his departure from the band in 1975 he embarked on
a solo career, lending his support to a wide variety of left-wing
causes.
Until 1987 the Provisional IRA was among the groups he
supported, however this came to an end following the Enniskillen
bombing
. During his career he has sung about human
rights in El
Salvador
, republican
volunteers from the Spanish Civil War, South African anti-apartheid
activist and martyr Steven Biko, the
murdered Chilean singer, songwriter, poet, playwright and activist
Victor Jara, the late Palestinian
solidarity activist Rachel Corrie, not
to mention numerous events of Irish history.
An Irish
alternative rock/post punk band from Dublin
, U2 broke with the rebel musical tradition when they wrote
their song, Sunday Bloody
Sunday in 1983. The song makes reference to two separate
massacres in Irish history of civilians by British forces (
Bloody Sunday and
Bloody Sunday 1972), however unlike other
songs dealing with those events, the lyrics call for peace as
opposed to revenge.
The song
Zombie by the Irish band, The Cranberries - written in 1994 in
response to the Warrington Bomb Attacks
of 1993 - protests the cycle of violence and
retribution in Northern Ireland and the pain and suffering it has
caused to both communities.
French socialist anthem, protest songs and singers
French socialist anthems
The Internationale
(
L'Internationale in
French) is a famous
socialist,
anarchist,
communist, and
social-democratic anthem and one of the most widely recognized songs in
the world.
The
Internationale became the anthem of international
socialism. Its original French refrain is
C'est la lutte finale/ Groupons-nous et demain/
L'Internationale/ Sera le genre humain. (Freely translated:
"This is the final struggle/ Let us join together and tomorrow/ The
Internationale/ Will be the human race.") The
Internationale has been translated into most of the
world's languages. Traditionally it is sung with the hand raised in
a clenched fist salute.
The Internationale is sung not
only by
communist but also (in many
countries) by socialists or social democrats.
The Chinese version was also a rallying song
of the students and workers at the Tiananmen
Square protests of 1989
.
French "protest singers"
We can not speak in France about a protest song trend, but rather
of a permanent background of criticism and contestation, and
individuals who personify it. The 39-45 war and its horrors forced
French singers to think more critically about war in general,
forcing them to question their governments and the powers who ruled
their society.
Jazz trumpeter and singer
Boris Vian's
was one of the first to protest against the Algerian war with his
anti-war song "Le déserteur" (The deserter), which was banned by
the government.
Several French songwriters, such as
Georges Brassens (1921-1981),
Jacques Brel (1929-1978),
Léo Ferré (1916-1993),
Maxime Le Forestier (born 1949) or
interpreters (
Yves Montand,
Marcel Mouloudji,
Serge Reggiani, Graeme Allwright...) often
wrote or sang songs aligned against majority ideas and political
powers. Because racial tensions did not rise to the same levels as
those in the United States, criticism was focused more toward
bourgeoisie, power, religion, and songs defending liberty of
thought, speech and action. After 1945, immigration became a source
of inspiration for some singers:
Pierre
Perret (born 1934), well known for his humorous songs, started
writing several more "serious" and committed songs against racism
("Lily" 1977), which critically pointed out everyday racist
behavior n French society.
Brassens wrote several songs protesting war, hate, intolerance
("Les deux oncles", "
The two uncles"; "La Guerre de
14-18", "
14-18 war"; "Mourir pour des idées", "
To die
for ideas"; "Les patriotes", "
The patriots"), against
chauvinism ("La ballade des gens qui sont nés quelque part",
"Ballad of People Who Are Born Somewhere"), against bourgeoisie
("La mauvaise réputation" = "
The bad reputation", "Les
Philistins" = "
The Philistines"). He was often called
"anarchist" because of his songs on representatives of law and
order (and religion) ("Le gorille" = "
The gorilla";
"Hécatombe", "
Slaughter"; "Le nombril des femmes
d'agents", "
The navel of cops wives"; "Le mécréant" =
"
The miscreant"...).Brel's work is another ode to freedom
("Ces gens-là" = "
These people", "Les bourgeois" =
"
The bourgeois", "Jaurès", "Les bigotes" = "
The
bigots", "Le colonel" = "
The colonel", "Le Caporal
Casse-Pompon" = "
Corporal Break-Nots"), and Ferré was even
classified as "red" singer.
All these songs reveal, more than a party anthem, awareness of
human being, of universal human problems, and try to touch
intimately (and change) individual souls rather than struggle
against social or political movements, a government or another,
even if the French government, involved in wars in Indochina and
Algeria, has often tried to prohibit some of these songs.
German protest music: The "Deutschpunk" movement
Ton Steine Scherben, one of the
first and most influential
German
language rock bands of the 1970s
and early 1980s, were well-known for the highly political lyrics of
vocalist
Rio Reiser. The band became a
musical mouthpiece of
new left
movements, such as the
squatting
movement, during that time in Germany and their hometown of
West Berlin in particular. Their lyrics
were, at the beginning,
anti-capitalist and
anarchist, and the band had connections to the
German
Red Army Faction terrorists
before the latter turned to violent crime and murder. Later songs
were about more complex issues such as
unemployment (
Mole Hill Rockers) or
homosexuality (
Mama war so).
They also contributed to two full-length
concept album about homosexuality which were
issued under the name
Brühwarm (literally: boiling warm)
in cooperation with a gay-revue group.
A
dissatisfied German
youth in
the late 1970s and early 80s resulted in a strand of highly
politicized new wave punk known as the "Deutschpunk" movement,
which mostly concerned itself with politically radical left-wing
lyrics, mostly influenced by the Cold
War.Probably the most important Deutschpunk band was Slime from Hamburg, who were the first band
whose LP was banned because of political topics.
Their
songs "Deutschland" ("Germany"), "Bullenschweine", "Polizei SA/SS",
and the anti-imperialist "Yankees raus" ("Yankees out") were
banned, some of them are still banned today, because they
propagated the use of violence against the police or compared the
police to the SA
and
SS
of Nazi Germany.
A 1983
protest song from Germany
which gained considerable attention worldwide was
"99 Luftballons" by Nena. The song protested the escalating rhetoric
and strategic maneuvering between the United States
and the Soviet Union
during the Cold
War.
Russian protest music
The most famous source of Russian protest music in the 20th century
has come those known locally as
bards.
The term, (бард in Russian) came to be
used in the Soviet
Union
in the early 1960s, and continues to be used in
Russia
today, to
refer to singer-songwriters who
wrote songs outside the Soviet establishment. Many of the
most famous bards wrote numerous songs about war, particularly The
Great Patriotic War (WWII).
Bards had various reasons for writing and singing songs about war.
Bulat Okudzhava, who actually fought
in the war, used his sad and emotional style to illustrate the
futility of war in songs such as "The Paper Soldier" ("Бумажный
Солдат").
Many political songs were written by bards under Soviet rule, and
the genre varied from acutely political, "
anti-Soviet" songs, to witty satire in the best
traditions of
Aesop. Some of
Bulat Okudzhava's songs provide examples of
political songs written on these themes.
Vladimir Vysotsky was perceived as a
political song writer, but later he gradually made his way into the
more mainstream culture. It was not so with
Alexander Galich, who was forced to
emigrate—owning a tape with his songs could mean a prison term in
the USSR.
Before emigration, he suffered from KGB
persecution, as did another bard, Yuliy
Kim. Others, like
Evgeny
Kliachkin and
Aleksander
Dolsky, maintained a balance between outright anti-Soviet and
plain romantic material. Since most of the bards' songs were never
permitted by
Soviet censorship,
most of them, however innocent, were considered to be
anti-Soviet
Latin American protest songs
Chilean and Latin American protest music
While the protest song was enjoying its Golden Age in America in
the 1960s, it also saw many detractors overseas who saw it as
having been commercialized. Chilean
singer-songwriter Victor Jara, who played a pivotal role in the
folkloric renaissance that led to the
Nueva Cancion
Chilena [
NCC] (New Chilean Song) movement
which created a revolution in the popular music of his country,
criticised the "commercialized" American
‘protest song
phenomenon’ which had been imported into Chile. He criticized
it thus:
The cultural invasion is like a leafy tree which
prevents us from seeing our own sun, sky and stars.
Therefore in order to be able to see the sky above our
heads, our task is to cut this tree off at the roots.
US imperialism understands very well the magic of
communication through music and persists in filling our young
people with all sorts of commercial tripe.
With professional expertise they have taken certain
measures: first, the commercialization of the so-called ‘protest
music’; second, the creation of ‘idols’ of protest music who obey
the same rules and suffer from the same constraints as the other
idols of the consumer music industry – they last a little while and
then disappear.
Meanwhile they are useful in neutralizing the innate
spirit of rebellion of young people.
The term ‘protest song’ is no longer valid because it
is ambiguous and has been misused.
I prefer the term ‘revolutionary song’
Nueva canción (literally "new song" in
Spanish) was a type of protest/social song in Latin American music which took root in
South America, especially Chile
and other
Andean countries, and gained extreme
popularity throughout Latin America. It combined traditional
Latin American folk music idioms (played on the
quena,
zampoña,
charango or
cajón with
guitar accompaniment) with some popular (esp. British) rock music,
and was characterised by its progressive and often politicized
lyrics. It is sometimes considered a precursor to
rock en español. The lyrics are
typically in Spanish, with some indigenous or local words mixed
in.
Its lyrics characteristically revolve around about
poverty,
empowerment, the
Unidad Popular,
imperialism,
democracy,
human rights, and
religion. There are some hundreds of songs with
influences from British and American pop rock that was popular with
college youths. The
Chilean coup of
1973 impacted the genre's growth, as the musical movement was
forced to go underground. During the days of the coup, Victor Jara,
a well known singer/song-writer, was kidnapped, jailed, tortured
and shot. Other groups, such as Inti-Illimani and Quilapayun found
safety outside the country. The military government went as far as
to ban many traditional Andean instruments, but as a testament to
how far the country has come since then, the stadium where
Victor Jara was murdered now bears his
name.
Cuban and Puerto Rican protest music
A type of Cuban and Puerto Rican protest music, "
Nueva trova," started in the mid-1960s when a
movement in
Cuban music emerged that
combined traditional
folk music idioms
with progressive and often politicized lyrics. This movement of
protest music came to be known as
Nueva
trova, and was somewhat similar to that of
Nueva canción, however with the advantage
of support from the Cuban government, as it promoted the
Cuban Revolution.
Though originally and
still largely Cuban, nueva trova has become popular across Latin America, especially in Puerto Rico and Venezuela
. The movements biggest stars included Cubans
Silvio Rodríguez,
Vicente Feliu,
Noel
Nicola and
Pablo Milanés, as
well as Puerto Ricans such as
Roy Brown,
Andrés Jiménez,
Antonio Caban Vale and the group
Haciendo Punto en Otro Son.
In both
Cuba and Puerto Rico, the politicized lyrics of nueva trova were
very often critical of the United States; Puerto Rican singers were
especially critical of Vieques
' continued use as a United States Navy training
ground. The most recent topic of protest songs from the
movement has been demanding sovereignty for
Puerto Rico and adding their name and signature
to the Latin American and Caribbean Congress's Proclamation for the
Independence of Puerto Rico.
African protest songs
Algerian Raï protest music
Raï ( ), which is the Arabic word for "opinion", is
a form of folk music, originated in
Oran,
Algeria
from Bedouin shepherds, mixed with Spanish, French, African
and Arabic musical forms, which dates
back to the 1930s and has been primarily evolved by women in the
culture. Raï has been forbidden music in Algeria, to the
point of one popular singer being assassinated, although since the
1980s it has enjoyed some considerable success. The song "Parisien
Du Nord" by
Cheb Mami is a recent example
of how the genre has been used as form of protest, as the song was
written as a protest against the racial tensions that sparked the
2005 French riots.
According to Memi:
It is a song against racism, so I wanted to sing it
with a North African who was born in France [...] Because of that
and because of his talent, I chose K-Mel.
In the song, we say, ‘In your eyes, I feel like
foreigner.’ It’s like the kids who were born in France but they
have Arab faces.
They are French, and they should be considered
French.”
South African anti-apartheid protest music
The majority of South African protest music of the 20th century
concerned itself with
apartheid, a system
of legalized
racial segregation
in which blacks were stripped of their citizenship and rights from
1948 to 1994. As the apartheid regime forced Africans into
townships and industrial centers, people sang about leaving their
homes, the horror of the coal mines and the degradation of working
as domestic servants. Examples of which include
Benedict Wallet Vilakazi's
"Meadowlands", the "
Toyi-toyi" chant and
"Bring Him Back Home" (1987) by
Hugh
Masekela, which became an anthem for the movement to free
Nelson Mandela. Masekela's song
"Soweto Blues", sung by his former wife,
Miriam Makeba, is a blues/jazz piece that
mourns the carnage of the
Soweto riots
in 1976.
Basil Coetzee and
Abdullah Ibrahim's "Mannenberg", became an
unofficial soundtrack to the anti-apartheid resistance. "Madam,
Please," the song of a maid angrily addressing her boss, includes
the verse "Madam please/Before you laugh at your servant’s
English/Try to speak to him in his Zulu language/Madam
please/Before you complain your servant stinks/Try washing your
clothes in a Soweto sink."
Vuyisile
Mini, the executed union organizer who’s considered the father
of South African freedom songs, performed music for a militant
struggle against the regime in songs such as "Watch Out
Verwoerd". The 2002 documentary
Amandla!: A
Revolution in Four-Part Harmony depicted the struggles of
black South Africans against the injustices of Apartheid through
the use of music and protest songs. In more recent times protest
music of the country has begun to target social issues, such as
crime and the impact of
AIDS.
A number of international singers also composed anti-apartheid
protest songs, such as
Eddy Grant's
"
Gimme Hope Jo'anna" (1988) –
which was banned by the South African government when it was
released – and
Peter Gabriel's
"
Biko" (1980) about
Steve Biko, a noted black South African
anti-apartheid activist. Biko has also been covered by Cameroonian
saxophonist and vibraphone player
Manu
Dibango.
Asian protest songs
Filipino protest music
From the revolutionary songs of the Katipunan to the songs being
sung by the
New Peoples Army,
Filipino protest music deals with poverty, oppression as well as
anti-imperialism and independence. A typical example was euring the
American era, as
Jose Corazon de
Jesus created a well known protest song entitled "
Bayan Ko", which calls for redeeming the nation
against oppression, mainly colonialism, that also became popular as
a song dealt against the Marcos regime.
However, during the 1960s, Filipino protest music became aligned
with the ideas of Communism as well as of revolution. "Ang Linyang
Masa", a protest song was came from
Mao
Zedong and his Mass Line and "Papuri sa Pagaaral" was from
Bertolt Brecht. These songs, although
filipinized, rose another part of Filipino protest music known as
Revolutionary songs, that became popular during protests and
campaign struggles.
Singer-songwriters of protest music include
Ramon Ayco, a former rebel, who made a song
entitled "Tano", which tackles about a farmer who, due to the
prevailing conditions, forced himself to join the struggle, and
"Babae", which also deals with women's empowerment and national
liberation, other singer-songwriters like
Gary Granada,
Inang
Laya,
Noel Cabangon are also
became popular in creating protest music and making it popular like
the song "Tatsulok", that originally from Cabangon's Buklod, was
revived by
Bamboo Manalac.
Israeli protest music
Israel's protest music has often become associated with different
political factions.
During the 1967 war, Naomi Shemer wrote
Jerusalem of Gold, sung by
Shuli Natan, about the recapturing of
Jerusalem
after 2000 years.. Later on that year A different
point of view of this song was introduced by the folk singer
Meir Ariel, who recorded an anti-war
version of this song and named it "Jerusalem of Iron".
Gush Emunim supporters have taken a
repertoire of old religious songs and invested them with political
meaning. An example is the song "Utsu Etsu VeTufar" (They gave
counsel but their counsel was violated). The song signifies the
ultimate rightness of those steadfast in their beliefs, suggesting
the rightness of Gush Emunim's struggle against anti-settlement
policy by the government.
Minutes
before Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin was
murdered
at a political rally in November 1995, Israeli folk
singer Miri Aloni sang the Israeli pop
song Shir Lashalom (Song for
Peace). This song, originally written in 1969 and performed
extensively at the time by an Israeli military performing group,
has become one of the anthems of the
Israeli peace camp.
During the Arab uprising known as the
First Intifada, Israeli singer
Si Heyman sang
Yorim VeBokhim (Shoot and
Weep), written by Shalom Hanoch, to protest Israeli policy in the
territories. This song was banned from the radio for a certain
period of time on charges of subversiveness.
Pink Floyd's
Another Brick in the Wall is
used as a protest song by many opponents of Israel's barrier in the
West Bank, which is now half finished. The lyrics have been adapted
to: "We don't need no occupation. We don't need no racist
wall."
Since the onset of the
Oslo
Process and, more recently,
Israel's unilateral
disengagement plan, protest songs became a major avenue for
opposition activists to express sentiments. Songs protesting these
policies were written and performed by Israeli musicians, such as
Ariel Zilber, Shalom Flisser,
Aharon Razel, Eli Bar-Yahalom, Yuri
Lipmanovich, Ari Ben-Yam, and many others.
Palestinian protest music
Palestinian music ( ) deals with the
conflict with Israel
, the
longing for peace, and the love of the Palestinian's land. A
typical example of such a song is "
Biladi,
Biladi" (My Country, My Country), which has become the unofficial
Palestinian national
anthem.
Another example is the song "AlKuds (Jerusalem) our Land", with
words by
Sharif Sabri.
The song, sung by
Amar Diab from Port Said
, Egypt
, won first
prize in 2003 in a contest in Egypt for video clips produced in the
West Bank and Gaza.
DAM is an
Arabic
hip-hop group,
rapping in
Arabic and
Hebrew about the problems faced by
Palestinians under occupation and calling for change. Kamilya
Joubran's song "Ghareeba", a setting of a poem by
Khalil Gibran, deals with a sense of isolation
and loneliness felt by the Palestinian woman.

Ghareeba, by Kamilya Joubran
Unlike during the Anti-Apartheid era, international artists have
largely avoided the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict as lyrical fodder.
Since 2000, this has been changing, with
Electronic Intifada cofounder Nigel
Parry's 2001 album, This Side of Paradise
[3830], an early example. The increasing number
of lyrics dealing with the conflict is primarily noted in the hip
hop community, particularly from underground artists such as
Immortal Technique and
Invincible.
South Korean protest songs
Commonly,
protest songs in South
Korea
are known as Min-joong Ga-yo ( , literally
People's song), and the genre of protest songs is called
Norae Undong, literally "Song movement". It was
raised by people in 1970s~1980s to be against the military
governments of President
Park
Jeong-hee ( ),
Jeon Doo-hwan (
).
In 2002
South
Korean
artist Yoon Min-suk ( ) wrote an anti-Bush and
anti-US Foreign Policy song, in particular the US policy on his own
peninsula, based on the song "Surfin' USA" entitled "Fucking USA" a vitriolic attack
indeed. It became popular initially in South Korea but was
inevitably released onto the internet and received massive amounts
of attention from people sympathetic to his views all over the
world.
Chinese Protest Music
Chinese-Korean Cui
Jian’s 1986 song Nothing to
My Name was popular with protesters in Tiananmen
Square
. After the crackdown, he frequently played
in public wearing a symbolic red blindfold when playing
A Piece
of Red Cloth, a practice which led to censorship officials
canceling concerts.
Malaysian Protest Music
Australian protest music
Indigenous issues feature prominently in politically inspired
Australian music and include the topics of
land rights, and aboriginal
deaths in custody. One of the most
prominent Australian bands to confront these issues is
Yothu Yindi. Other Australian bands to have
confronted indigenous issues include
Tiddas,
Kev Carmody,
Archie Roach,
Christine Anu,
Neil
Murray,
Blue King Brown, the
John Butler Trio,
Midnight Oil,
Warumpri
Band,
Powderfinger and
Xavier Rudd.
In addition to Indigenous issues, many Australian protest singers
have sung about the futility of war. Notable anti-war songs include
"
And The Band
Played Waltzing Matilda" (1972) by
Eric
Bogle, and "
A walk in the
Light Green" (1983) by
Redgum, most often
remembered by its chorus "I was only nineteen".
Other notable themes in politically inspired Australian music
include racism (for example,
The Herd) and
the environment (for example,
Midnight
Oil). In recent years increasing numbers of protest songs have
emerged in support of imprisoned Australian Schapelle Corby
See also
References
Footnotes
Further reading
- Fowke, Edith and Joe Glazer, Songs of Work and Protest
(Dover Publications, Inc., 1973; New York)
- John Greenway, American Folksongs of Protest
(University of Pennsylvania Press, 1953; New York: A.S. Barnes,
1960).
- Ronald D. Cohen & Dave Samuelson, liner notes for Songs
for Political Action, Bear Family Records, BCD 15 720 JL,
1996.
External links