Strategic bombing during World War II is a term
which refers to all aerial bombardment of a strategic nature, which
took place between 1939 and 1945, involving any nations engaged in
World War II. This includes the bombing
of military forces, railways, harbors, cities (civilian areas), and
industrial areas.
In 1939,
many cities, including the Polish capital, Warsaw
, fell victim
to an indiscriminate and unrestricted aerial bombardment
campaign by the German Luftwaffe. As the war continued to expand,
bombing by both
Axis and
Allied powers increased significantly. While military
and industrial were targeted, extensive bombing was also used as a
psychological weapon intended to break an enemy's will to fight.
In
1940–1941, this characterized Germany's Blitz
campaign against the United Kingdom
, which failed.
From 1942 onward, the intensity of the British bombing campaign
increased steadily and became
less restrictive, increasingly
targeting civilian areas in addition to industrial and military
targets. U.S. air forces significantly reinforced these efforts
beginning in 1943. By 1944, the Western Allies had utilized their
bomber fleet to devastating effect on targets inside Germany, with
Allied bomb tonnage dropped on Germany far surpassing that dropped
on the United Kingdom by the
Luftwaffe. In spite of the
enormously greater effort,
Bomber
Command had a limited effect on German industrial production,
and had no more success in breaking Germany's will to fight than
the
Luftwaffe had against the UK.
In the Pacific theatre, U.S. strategic bombing of the Japanese
Empire began in earnest in October 1944.
Earlier, small-scale
attacks out of China had been hampered by the need to deliver
supplies over the Himalaya
foothills
(known as "The Hump"), as well as by
enormous Chinese graft. .
Missions out of Saipan
escalated
into widespread fire-bombing, which culminated in the 1945 atomic bombings of
Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
Legal considerations
The
Hague
Conventions, which address the codes of wartime conduct on land
and at sea, were adopted before the rise of air power. Despite
repeated diplomatic attempts to update
international humanitarian
law to include aerial warfare, it was not updated before the
outbreak of World War II. The absence of specific international
humanitarian law did not mean aerial warfare was not covered under
the
laws of war, but rather that there
was no general agreement of how to interpret those laws.
Europe
Policy at the start of the war
When the war began on 1 September 1939,
Franklin D. Roosevelt, President of the
then-neutral United
States, issued an appeal to the major belligerents to confine their
air raids to
military targets. The French,
the British agreed to abide by the request which included the
provision "that these same
rules of
warfare will be scrupulously observed by all of their
opponents". Germany also agreed to abide by Roosevelt's request and
explained their bombing of Warsaw as within the agreement because
it was a fortified city—Germany did not have a policy of targeting
enemy civilians as part of their doctrine prior to World War II.
The United Kingdom's policy was set out on 31 August 1939: If
Germany initiated unrestricted air action the United Kingdom
"should attack objectives vital to Germany's war effort, and in
particular her oil resources". If Germany confined attacks to
purely military targets the RAF should "launch an attack on the
German fleet at Wilhelmshaven" and "Attack warships at sea when
found within range". The government communicated to their French
allies the intention "not to initiate air action which might
involve the risk of civilian casualties" While it was acknowledged
bombing Germany would cause civilian casualties, the British
government renounced deliberate bombing of civilian property,
outside combat zones, as a military tactic. On 15 May, the day
after the
Rotterdam Blitz, the
British government met and authorised "Bomber Command to carry out
attacks on suitable military objectives, (including marshalling
yards and oil refineries) in the Ruhr as well as elsewhere in
Germany".
First bombings
Poland
From the beginning of the war the German
Luftwaffe engaged in massive air raids against
most Polish cities bombing civilian infrastructures, hospitals,
schools as well as civilian population including refugees. Notably,
the German
Luftwaffe bombed
cities like
Warsaw,
Wieluń and
Frampol.
The directives issued to the
Luftwaffe for
the Polish Campaign were to prevent the Polish Air Force to
influence the ground battles, or to perform attacks on German
territory. In addition, it was to support the advance of the German
ground forces through direct tactical and indirect air support with
attacks against Polish mobilization centres and thus delay an
orderly Polish strategic concentration of forces and to deny
mobility for Polish reinforcements through destruction of strategic
Polish rail routes. Preparations were made for a concentrated
attack (Operation Wasserkante) by all bomber forces against targets
in Warsaw. The bombing of rail network, crossroads and troop
concentrations played havoc on Polish mobilisation, while attacks
upon civilian and military targets in towns and cities disrupted
command and control by wrecking the antiquated Polish signal
network: Shortly after, in a period of a few days,
Luftwaffe numerical and technological superiority took its
toll on the Polish Air Force.
Polish Air Force bases across Poland, including Warsaw's PZL
aircraft factory, were also the subject of Luftwaffe bombing from
September 1, 1939. Subsequent attacks on Warsaw targeted civilian
facilities and historical buildings, water works, hospitals, market
places, schools all bridges on the Vistula river, communications
centers around the city and munitions dumps. On the 13 of
September, following orders of the
ObdL to launch an
attack on Warsaw's Jewish Quarters, justified as being for
unspecified crimes committed against German soldiers but probably
in response to a recent defeat by Polish ground troops, and
intended as a terror attack, 183 bomber sorties were flown with
50:50 load of high explosives and incendiaries, reporting to have
set the Jewish Quarter ablaze. On 22 September
Wolfram von Richthofen requested:
"Urgently request exploitation of last opportunity for large-scale
experiment as devastation terror raid ... Every effort will be made
to eradicate Warsaw completely". His request was rejected. However,
Hitler issued an order to prevent civilians from leaving the city
and to continue with the bombing, which he thought would make the
Poles surrender faster.
On 14 September the French Air
attaché
in Warsaw reported to Paris that "the German Air Force acted in
accordance to the international laws of war [...] and bombed only
targets of military nature. Therefore, there is no reason for
French retorsions." That day - the Jewish New Year - the Germans
concentrated again on the Warsaw's Jewish population, bombing the
Jewish quarter and targeting
synagogues.
Three days later Warsaw was surrounded by the
Wehrmacht, and hundreds of thousands of leaflets
were dropped on the city, instructing the citizens to evacuate the
city pending a possible bomber attack. On 25 September the
Luftwaffe flew 1,150 sorties and dropped 560 tonnes of high
explosive and 72 tonnes of incendiaries. To conserve the strength
of the bomber units for the upcoming western campaign, the modern
He 111 bombers were replaced by
Ju 52 transports using "worse than primitive methods"
for the bombing. Due to prevailing strong winds they achieved poor
accuracy, even causing some casualties to besieging German troops.
As result of the aerial and artillery bombardment, intense street
fighting between German infantry and armor units and Polish
infantry and artillery, 10 percent of the buildings in the city
were destroyed, and 40,000 civilians killed.
The Western Front, 1939 to June 1940
Following the German invasion of Poland and subsequent declaration
of war by the Western Allies, in Hitler's
OKW Direktive Nr
2 and
Luftwaffe Direktive Nr 2 made no mention of
strategic bomber raids, while attacks upon enemy naval forces were
permitted only if the enemy bombed Germany, with the exception in
the German Bight, noting that "The guiding principle must be not to
provoke the initiation of aerial warfare on the part of Germany";
by contrast, Göring's directive permitted restricted attacks upon
warships anywhere, as well as upon troop transports at sea.
The UK and France declared war on Germany on 3 September. On the
Western Front, the early months of the conflict were characterised
by
propaganda warfare: bomber forces of
both sides carried out a series of
leaflet
raids during the winter months of 1939/40.
The British Royal Air Force bombed German warships at sea and in harbour, attacks on land
targets and German warships in port were banned due to the risk of
civilian casualties Germany carried out strikes on the British
naval bases at Rosyth
and Scapa Flow
on 16 and 17 October. Further attacks on
Scapa Flow, on 16 March 1940, caused the first British civilian
deaths from German bombing on land, which prompted another British
attack, against the German seaplane base at Hörnum
.
On 10 May
1940, Germany invaded Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxemburg
, intending to drive through the Ardennes
into France
and strike a quick blow that would end
the war. As the Battle of
France commenced on 10 May 1940, three German bombers from
KG 51 mistakenly bombing the German city of
Freiburg
instead of the French airfield of Dole-Taveux,
having lost their way over the Black Forest
. German propaganda was quick to announce it
as an Allied 'terror attack', and it was not until 1956 when the
mistake was brought to light by researchers.
While Allied light and
medium bombers attempted to delay the German invasion by striking
at troop columns and bridges, the British War Cabinet gave
permission for limited bombing raids against German communications
targets such as roads and railways west of the River Rhine
.
The first
British bombs fell on a German city, Mönchengladbach
, on the night of 11/12 May 1940, while Bomber
Command was attempting to hit roads and railroads near the
Dutch-German border; four people were killed. Targets in Gelsenkirchen
were attacked first on the 14/15 May.Jane's, 1989.
p. 34
- Rotterdam Blitz
The Germans used the threat of bombing Rotterdam to try to get the
Dutch to come to terms and surrender. After a second ultimatum had
been issued by the Germans, it appeared that their effort had
failed, and on 14 May 1940,
Luftwaffe
bombers were ordered to
bomb
Rotterdam in an effort to force the capitulation of the
besieged city. The controversial bombing targeted the center of the
besieged city, instead of providing direct tactical support for the
hard-pressed German 22nd infantry division (under Lt. Gen.
Sponeck, which had airlanded on May
10) in combat with Dutch forces northwest of the city, and in the
eastern part of the city at the Meuse river bridge.
As negotiations for the surrender were in progress, with a Dutch
plenipotentiary and other negotiators delayed on their way over to
German lines, an unsuccessful attempt was made to call off the
assault.

Rotterdam's burning city centre after
the German bombing.
Nevertheless, 57
Heinkel He 111s (out
of 100) did drop 97 tons of bombs, and in the resulting fire of the
city center was devastated, including 21 churches and 4 hospitals,
and killing between 800-1000 civilians, wounding over 1,000, and
making 78,000 homeless. Nearly twenty-five thousand homes, 2,320
stores, 775 warehouses and 62 schools were destroyed.
International news agencies vastly exaggerated the events,
portraying Rotterdam as a city mercilessly destroyed by terror
bombing without regard to civilian life, with 30,000 dead lying
under the ruins. Neither claim was true: the bombing was against
well-defined targets, in direct support of advancing German Army's
operations.
The Germans had threatened to bomb Utrecht
in the same fashion, the threat of a second such
bombing was sufficient to force the surrender of the Netherlands to
Nazi Germany.
Following the attack on Rotterdam,
RAF Bomber Command was authorized to
attack German targets east of the Rhine on May 15, 1940; the Air
Ministry authorized
Air Marshal Charles
Portal to attack targets in the
Ruhr, including
oil plants and other civilian
industrial targets which aided the German war
effort, such as
blast furnaces (which
at night were self-illuminating). The first attack took place on
the night of 15/16 May, with 96 bombers setting off to attack
targets east of the Rhine, 78 of which were against oil targets. Of
these, only 24 claimed to have found their targets. Bomber
Command's strategic bombing campaign on Germany has thus begun.
On the
night of May 17/18, RAF Bomber
Command bombed oil installations in Hamburg
and Bremen
: the H.E.
and 400 incendiaries dropped caused six large, one moderately large
and 29 small fires, 47 people were killed and 127 were wounded; .
"Als die ersten Bomben fielen" Hamburger
Abendblatt Railway yards at Cologne were attacked on
the same night.
During May, Essen
, Duisburg
, Dusseldorf
and Hanover
were similarly attacked for the first time by
Bomber Command, while in June attacks were made on Dortmund
, Mannheim
, Frankfurt
and Bochum
. As
at the time Bomber Command lacked the necessary navigational and
bombing technical background, the accuracy of the bombings during
the night attacks was abysmal, and the bombs usually being
scattered over a large area, causing an uproar in Germany.
Days
after Germany bombed Paris, on the night of 7/8 June 1940 a single
French Navy Farman F.223 bomber attacked Berlin
.
The Battle of Britain and the Blitz
On 22 June 1940, at the end of the
Battle of France, France signed an
armistice with Germany. However, the UK was determined to keep
fighting.
On 1/2 July, the British attacked German
warships Scharnhorst and Prinz
Eugen
in port of Kiel
and the next
day, 16 RAF bombers attacked German train facilities in Hamm
.
Finally, on July 10, the
Luftwaffe
launched a strategic bombing campaign against the United Kingdom.
Thus began the first phase of what came to be known as the
Battle of Britain. The battle began with
probing attacks on British coastal shipping, during which Hitler
called for the British to accept peace, but the British refused to
negotiate.
Hitler's No. 17 Directive, issued 1 August
1940 on the conduct of war against England specifically forbade the
Luftwaffe from conducting terror raids on its own
initiative, and reserved the right of ordering terror attacks as
means of reprisal for the
Führer
himself, despite the raids conducted by
RAF Bomber Command against industries
located in German cities since May 1940. This was echoed in
Hermann Göring's general order
issued on 30 June, 1940 on the air war against the island
fortress:
On August 8 1940, the Germans switched to raids on RAF fighter
bases. To reduce losses, the Luftwaffe also began to use increasing
numbers of bombers at night. By the last week of August, over half
the missions were flown under the cover of dark. Despite Hitler's
orders not to attack London, the city had already been bombed on 15
August, resulting in 60 deaths. There were further minor attacks on
London at night in August, on the 18/19, 22/23, 24/25, 25/26 and
28/29. The raid of 22/23 August, the first Luftwaffe raid on
central London, was described as 'extensive' by British
observers.On August 24, fate took a turn, and several off-course
German bombers accidentally bombed residential areas of London. The
next day, the
RAF bombed Berlin for
the first time, targeting Tempelhof airfield and the Siemens
factories in Siemenstadt, but were seen as indiscriminate bombings
by the Germans due to their inaccuracy, and infuriated Hitler; he
ordered that the 'night piracy of the British' be countered by a
concentrated night offensive against the island, and especially
London. In a public speech in Berlin on 4 September 1940, Hitler
announced that:

"Children in the east end of London,
made homeless by the random bombs of the Nazi night raiders,
waiting outside the wreckage of what was their home".
September 1940 (National Archives)
The
Luftwaffe, which Hitler had prohibited from bombing
civilian areas in the UK, was now ordered to bomb British cities.
The Blitz was underway. Göring - at
Kesselring's urging and with Hitler's
support- turned to a massive assault on the British capital. On 7
September, 318 bombers from the whole
KG 53
supported by eight other
Kampfgruppen, flew almost
continuous sorties against London, the dock area which was already
in flames from earlier daylight attacks. The attack of 7 September
1940 did not entirely step over the line into a clear terror
bombing effort since its primary target was the London docks, but
there was clearly an assumed hope of terrorizing the London
population. Another 250 bomber sorties were flown in the night. By
the morning of the 8 September, 430 Londoners had been killed. The
Luftwaffe issued a press notice announcing they had dropped more
than 1,000,000 kilograms of bombs on London in 24 hours. Many other
British cities were hit in the nine month Blitz, including
Birmingham,
Liverpool,
Southampton,
Manchester,
Bristol,
Belfast,
Cardiff,
Clydebank,
Kingston
upon Hull and
Coventry. Sir Basil
Collier, author of 'The Defence of the United Kingdom', the HMSO's
official history, wrote:
Over the year, an escalating
war of
electronic technology developed: before the war, German
scientists developed a series of radio navigation aids to help
their navigators find targets in the dark and through overcast,
while the British raced to develop countermeasures (most notably
airborne
radar, as well as highly effective
deceptive beacons and jammers).
Despite causing a great deal of damage and disrupting the daily
lives of the civilian population, the bombing of the United Kingdom
failed to have an impact. British
air
defenses became more formidable, and attacks tapered off as
Germany concentrated its attacks on the Soviet Union.
Germany later in the war
The
period of uneasy calm came to an end in April 1942 when, following
a destructive RAF
attack on the Hanseatic medieval city
of Lübeck
, Adolf
Hitler ordered the Luftwaffe to retaliate, leading to the so-called
Baedeker Blitz:
In January 1944, renewed attempt to strike a blow on British morale
took the form of the unsuccessful
Operation Steinbock, called 'the Baby
blitz' by the British, due to small scale of the attack. Due to the
numerical and qualitative inferiority of German conventional
bombing forces at time, and inability of fighter forces to escort
bombers safely through enemy dominated airspace, the most effective
means of strategic attack by Germany became area
terror bombing by means of
vengeance weapons -
V-1 flying bomb and
V-2
ballistic missile.
From June 13 and September 8 1944
respectively, these were used to conduct campaigns of area terror
bombing chiefly against London
and cities
of southern England, although their targets also included Paris
, Liège
, Lille
and Antwerp
.
The British and US directed part of the strategic bombing to the
eradication of these threats in what was later known as
Operation Crossbow. The development of
the V2 was hit preemptively in the British
Peenemunde Raid
of August 1943.
British historian,
Frederick Taylor asserts that
"All sides bombed each other's cities during the war.
Half a million
Soviet
citizens,
for example, died from German bombing during the invasion and
occupation of Russia. That's roughly equivalent to the
number of German citizens who died from Allied raids."
The British later in the war
On 14 February, 1942,
Directive No.
22 was issued to Bomber Command.
Bombing was to be "focused on the morale of the enemy civil
population and in particular of the industrial workers." Factories
were no longer targets.
The effects of strategic bombing were very poorly understood at the
time and grossly overrated. Particularly in the first two years of
the campaign, few understood just how little damage was caused and
how rapidly the Germans were able to replace lost
production—despite the obvious lessons to be learned from the
United Kingdom's own survival of the blitz.
Mid-way through the air war, it slowly began to be realized the
campaign was having very little effect. Despite an ever-increasing
tonnage of bombs dispatched, the inaccuracy of delivery was such
any bomb falling within
five miles of the target was
deemed a "hit" for statistical purposes, and even by this standard,
as the
Butt Report made clear many bombs
missed. Indeed sometimes in post raid assessment the Germans could
not decide which town (not the installation in the town) had been
the intended target because the scattering of bomb craters was so
wide.
These problems were dealt with in two ways: first the precision
targeting of vital facilities (ball-bearing production in
particular) was abandoned in favour of "
area bombing" – This change of policy was
agreed by the
Cabinet
in 1941 and in early 1942 a new
directive was issued and Air Marshal
Arthur Harris (commonly known
as
"Bomber"
Harris) was appointed to carry out the task – second as the
campaign developed, improvements in the accuracy of the RAF raids
were joined by better crew training, electronic aids, and new
tactics such as the creation of a "
pathfinder" force to mark targets for the
main force.
"Bomber" Harris, who ran the bombing campaign, said "for want of a
rapier, a bludgeon was used". He felt that as much as it would be
far more desirable to deliver effective pin-point attacks, as the
capacity to do so simply did not exist, and since it was war, it
was necessary to attack with whatever was at hand. He accepted area
bombing knowing it would kill civilians.
During the first few months of the area bombing campaign, an
internal debate within the British government about the most
effective use of the nation's limited resources in waging war on
Germany continued. Should the
Royal Air
Force (RAF) be scaled back to allow more resources to go to the
British Army and
Royal Navy or should the
strategic bombing
option be followed and expanded? An influential paper was presented
to support the bombing campaign by Professor
Frederick Lindemann,
1st Viscount Cherwell, the British government's leading
scientific adviser, justifying the use of area bombing to "
dehouse" the German workforce as the most
effective way of reducing their morale and affecting enemy war
production.
Mr. Justice Singleton, a High Court Judge, was asked by the Cabinet
to look into the competing points of view. In his report, that was
delivered on 20 May 1942, he concluded that "If Russia can hold
Germany on land I doubt whether Germany will stand 12 or 18 months’
continuous, intensified and increased bombing, affecting, as it
must, her war production, her power of resistance, her industries
and her will to resist (by which I mean morale)". In the end,
thanks in part to the dehousing paper, it was this view which
prevailed and Bomber Command would remain an important component of
the British war effort up to the end of World War II. A very large
proportion of the industrial production of the United Kingdom was
harnessed to the task of creating a vast fleet of heavy bombers—so
much so other vital areas of war production were under-resourced.
Until 1944, the effect on German production was remarkably small
and raised doubts whether it was wise to divert so much effort –
the response being there was no where else the effort could have
been applied to greater effect.
The disruption of the German transportation system was extensive.
Despite German efforts to minimize loss of industrial productivity
through dispersal of production facilities, as well as the
extensive use of
slave labour, the Nazi
regime experienced a decline in the ability to supply
materiel. Furthermore, the
Luftwaffe had been significantly weakened in
the course of their defensive efforts so that by mid 1944, the
Allies experienced day-time air dominance for the balance of the
war, which would be critical to the Allied success in the
Normandy Campaign and subsequent
operations to the end of the war.
US bombing in Europe

Summary of AAF and RAF bombing .
In mid 1942, the
United
States Army Air Forces arrived in the UK and carried out a few
raids across the English Channel against Germany. In January 1943,
at the
Casablanca Conference,
it was agreed that RAF Bomber Command operations against Germany
would be reinforced by the USAAF in a Combined Operations Offensive
plan called
Operation
Pointblank. Chief of the British Air Staff
MRAF Sir Charles
Portal was put in charge of the "strategic direction" of both
British and American bomber operations. The text of the
Casablanca directive read: "Your
primary object will be the progressive destruction and dislocation
of the German military, industrial and economic system and the
undermining of the morale of the German people to a point where
their capacity for armed resistance is fatally weakened.", At the
beginning of the combined strategic bombing offensive on 4 March,
1943 669 RAF and 303 USAAF heavy bombers were available.
In Europe, the American
Eighth Air
Force conducted its raids in daylight and their heavy bombers
carried smaller payloads than British aircraft in part because of
their heavier (as needed) defensive armament. USAAF leaders firmly
held to the claim of "precision" bombing of military targets for
much of the war, and energetically refuted claims that they were
simply bombing cities. In reality, the day bombing was "precision
bombing" only in the sense that most bombs fell somewhere near a
specific designated target such as a railway yard. Conventionally,
the air forces designated as "the target area" a circle having a
radius of 1000 feet around the aiming point of attack. While
accuracy improved during the war, Survey studies show that, in the
over-all, only about 20% of the bombs aimed at precision targets
fell within this target area. . In the fall of 1944, only seven per
cent of all bombs dropped by the Eighth Air Force hit within 1,000
feet of their aim point.
Nevertheless, the sheer tonnage of explosive delivered by day and
by night was eventually sufficient to cause widespread damage, and,
more importantly from a military point of view, forced Germany to
divert resources to counter it. This was to be the real
significance of the Allied strategic bombing campaign—resource
allocation.
U.S. operations began with 'Pointblank' attacks, designed to
eliminate key features of the German economy. These attacks
manifested themselves in the infamous Schweinfurt raids. Formations
of unescorted bombers were no match for German fighters, which
inflicted a deadly toll. In despair, the Eighth halted air
operations over Germany until a long-range fighter could be found;
it proved to be the
P-51 Mustang, which
had the range to fly to Berlin and back.
With the arrival of the brand-new
Fifteenth Air Force, based in Italy,
command of the U.S. Air Forces in Europe was consolidated into the
United States
Strategic Air Forces (USSTAF). With the addition of the Mustang
to its strength, the
Combined
Bomber Offensive was resumed. Planners targeted the
Luftwaffe in an operation known as '
Big Week' (20 - 25 February 1944) and succeeded
brilliantly - losses were so heavy German planners were forced into
a hasty dispersal of industry and the day fighter arm never fully
recovered.
On 27 March, 1944, the
Combined
Chiefs of Staff issued orders granting control of all the
Allied air forces in Europe, including strategic bombers, to
General
Dwight D. Eisenhower, the Supreme Allied
Commander, who delegated command to his deputy in
SHAEF Air Chief Marshal
Arthur Tedder. There was
resistance to this order from some senior figures, including
Winston Churchill, Harris, and
Carl Spaatz, but after some debate,
control passed to SHAEF on 1 April 1944. When the Combined Bomber
Offensive officially ended on 1 April, Allied airmen were well on
the way to achieving air superiority over all of Europe.
While
they continued some strategic bombing, the USAAF along with the RAF
turned their attention to the tactical air battle in support of the
Normandy
Invasion
. It was not until the middle of September
that the strategic bombing campaign of Germany again became the
priority for the
USSTAF.
The twin
campaigns—the USAAF by day, the RAF by night—built up into massive
bombing of German industrial areas, notably the Ruhr, followed by attacks directly on cities
such as Hamburg,
Kassel, Pforzheim, Mainz
and the
often-criticized bombing of
Dresden.
Effectiveness
Strategic bombing has been criticized on practical grounds because
it does not always work predictably. The radical changes it forces
on a targeted population can backfire, including the
counterproductive result of freeing inessential labourers to fill
worker shortages in war industries.

German soldier plots coordinates on a
map in the Duisburg-Wolfsburg anti-aircraft division
Much of the doubt about the effectiveness of the bomber war comes
from the oft-stated fact that German industrial production
increased throughout the war.
While this is true, it fails to note
production also increased in the United States, the United Kingdom,
the Soviet Union, Canada
and Australia. And, in all of those countries,
the rate of production increased much more rapidly than in Germany.
Until late in the war, industry had not been geared for war and
German factory workers only worked a single shift. Simply by going
to three shifts, production could have been tripled with no change
to the infrastructure. However, attacks on the infrastructure were
taking place. The attacks on Germany's canals and railroads made
transportation of
materiel difficult.
The attack on oil production,
oil
refineries and tank farms was, however, extremely successful
and made a very large contribution to the general collapse of
Germany in 1945. In the event, the bombing of oil facilities became
Albert Speer's main concern; however,
this occurred sufficiently late in the war that Germany would soon
be defeated in any case. Nevertheless, it is fair to say the oil
bombing campaign materially shortened the war, thereby saving many
lives.
German insiders credit the Allied bombing offensive with severely
handicapping them. Speer repeatedly said (both during and after the
war) it caused crucial production problems. Admiral
Karl Dönitz, head of the
U-Boat arm, noted in his memoirs that failure to get
the revolutionary
Type XXI
U-boats (which could have completely altered
the balance of power in the
Battle of the
Atlantic) into service was entirely the result of the bombing.
The
United States
Strategic Bombing Survey , however, concluded the delays in
deploying the new submarines cannot be attributed to air
attack.
Effect on morale
Although designed to "break the enemy's will", the opposite often
happened. The British did not crumble under the German
Blitz and other
air
raid early in the war. British workers continued to work
throughout the war and food and other basic supplies were available
throughout.
In Germany, apparently morale did not effectively break down in the
face of the bombing campaign, which was far more extensive and
comprehensive in effect, scope and duration than that endured by
the United Kingdom.
Allied bombing statistics 1939–45
RAF Bombing Sorties & Losses 1939–45
|
Sorties |
Losses |
| Night |
297,663 |
7,449 |
| Day |
66,851 |
876 |
|
RAF & USAAF Bomb Tonnages on Germany 1939–45
| Year |
RAF Bomber
Command (tons) |
US 8th Air
Force (tons) |
| 1939 |
31 |
— |
| 1940 |
13,033 |
— |
| 1941 |
31,504 |
— |
| 1942 |
45,561 |
1,561 |
| 1943 |
157,457 |
44,165 |
| 1944 |
525,518 |
389,119 |
| 1945 |
191,540 |
188,573 |
| Total |
964,644 |
623,418 |
|
Bombing Effort,
entire European Theatre
|
Tons |
Percent |
| 8th Air Force (including fighters) |
692,918 |
|
| 9th Air Force |
225,799 |
|
| 12th Air Force |
207,367 |
|
| 15th Air Force (including fighters) |
312,173 |
|
| 1st Tactical Air Force |
25,166 |
|
| Total USAAF |
1,463,423 |
52.8 |
| Bomber Command |
1,066,141 |
|
| Fighter Command |
3,910 |
|
| 2nd Tactical Air Force |
69,138 |
|
| Mediterranean Command |
167,928 |
|
| Total RAF |
1,307,117 |
47.2 |
| Grand Total |
2,770,540 |
100.0 |
|
|
Asia
Within Asia the majority of strategic bombing was carried out by
the Japanese and the US. The British commonwealth planned that once
the war in Europe was complete, a strategic bombing force of up to
1,000 heavy bombers (
"Tiger
force") would be sent to the Far East. This was never realised
before the end of the Pacific War.
Japanese bombing
Japanese strategic bombing was independently conducted by the
Imperial Japanese
Navy Air Service and the
Imperial Japanese Army Air
Service.
Bombing efforts mostly targeted large
Chinese cities such as Shanghai, Wuhan
and
Chonging, with around 5,000
raids from February 1938 to August 1943 in the later
case.
The
bombing of Nanjing
and Canton
, which
began on 22 and 23 September 1937, called forth widespread protests
culminating in a resolution by the Far Eastern Advisory Committee
of the League of Nations.
Lord Cranborne, the British Under-Secretary of State For Foreign
Affairs, expressed his indignation in his own declaration.
There
were also air raids on Philippines
and northern Australia
(Bombing of
Darwin, 19 February, 1942). The Imperial Japanese Navy Air
Service used tactical bombing against enemy airfields and
military positions, as at Pearl Harbor
. The
Imperial Japanese Army Air
Service also attacked enemy ships and military
installations.
United States strategic bombing of Japan
The United States strategic bombing of Japan took place between
1942 and 1945. In the last seven months of the campaign, a change
to firebombing tactics resulted in great destruction of 67 Japanese
cities, as many as 500,000 Japanese deaths and some 5 million more
made homeless.
Emperor Hirohito's
viewing of the destroyed areas of Tokyo in March 1945, is said to
have been the beginning of his personal involvement in the peace
process, culminating in
Japan's
surrender five months later.
Conventional bombing
The first
U.S. raid on the Japanese main island was the Doolittle Raid of 18 April, 1942 when sixteen
B-25 Mitchells were launched from the
USS
Hornet
(CV-8) to attack targets including Yokohama and Tokyo
and then
fly on to airfields in China
.
The raids were military pin-pricks, but a significant
propaganda victory.
Launched prematurely,
none of the attacking aircraft reached the designated post mission
airfields, either crashing or ditching (except for one aircraft,
which landed in the Soviet
Union
, where the crew was interned). Two crews
were captured by the Japanese.
The key development for the bombing of Japan was the
B-29 Superfortress, which had an
operational range of 1,500 miles (2,400 km); almost 90% of the
bombs dropped on the home islands of Japan were delivered by this
type of bomber (147,000 tons). The first raid by B-29s on Japan
from China was on 15 June, 1944.
The planes took off from Chengdu
, over 1,500 miles away. This first raid was
also not particularly damaging to Japan. Only forty-seven of the
sixty-eight B–29s that took off hit the target area; four aborted
with mechanical problems, four crashed, six jettisoned their bombs
because of mechanical difficulties, and others bombed secondary
targets or targets of opportunity. Only one B–29 was lost to enemy
aircraft. The first raid from the east was on 24 November, 1944
when 88 aircraft bombed Tokyo. The bombs were dropped from around
30,000 feet (10,000 m) and it is estimated that only around 10% of
the bombs hit designated targets.
The initial raids were carried out by the
Twentieth Air Force operating out of
mainland China in
Operation
Matterhorn under
XX Bomber
Command. Initially the Twentieth Air Force was under the
command of
Hap Arnold, and later
Curtis LeMay.
This was never a satisfactory arrangement
because not only were the Chinese airbases difficult to supply via
- materiel being sent over "the Hump" from
India
, but the B-29s operating from them could only reach
Japan if they traded some of their bomb load for extra fuel in
tanks in the bomb-bays. When Admiral
Chester Nimitz's
island-hopping campaign captured islands
close enough to Japan to be within the range of B-29s, the
Twentieth Air Force was assigned to
XXI Bomber Command which organized a much
more effective bombing campaign of the Japanese home islands.
Based in
the Marianas
(Guam
and
Tinian
in
particular) the B-29s were now able to carry their full bomb loads
and were supplied by cargo ships and tankers.
Unlike all other forces in theater, the
Bomber Commands did not report to the
commanders of the theaters but directly to the
Joint Chiefs of Staff. In March 1945,
they were placed under the U.S. Strategic Air Forces in the Pacific
which was commanded by General
Carl
Spaatz.
As in Europe, the
United
States Army Air Forces (USAAF) tried daylight
precision bombing. However, it proved to
be impossible due to the weather around Japan, as bombs dropped
from a great height were tossed about by high winds.
General LeMay,
commander of XXI Bomber Command, instead switched to mass
firebombing night attacks from altitudes of around 7,000 feet
(2,100 m) on the major conurbations of
Tokyo
, Nagoya, Osaka, and Kobe. Despite
limited early success, particularly against Nagoya, LeMay was
determined to use such bombing tactics against the vulnerable
Japanese cities. Attacks on strategic targets also continued in
lower-level daylight raids.
The first successful
firebombing raid
was
on Kobe on 3
February 1945, and following its relative success the
USAAF continued the tactic.
Nearly half of the principal factories of the city were damaged,
and production was reduced by more than half at one of the port's
two shipyards.
Much of the armor and defensive weaponry of the bombers was removed
to allow increased bomb loads; Japanese
air
defense in terms of night-fighters and
anti-aircraft guns was so feeble it was
hardly a risk.
The first raid of this type on
Tokyo
was on the night of 23–24 February when 174 B-29s
destroyed around one square mile (3 km²) of the city.
Following on that success 334 B-29s raided on the night of 9–10
March, dropping around 1,700 tons of bombs. Around 16 square miles
(41 km²) of the city was destroyed and over 100,000 people are
estimated to have died in the
fire storm.
The destruction and damage was at its worst in the city sections
east of the Imperial Palace. It was the most destructive
conventional raid in all of history. The city was made primarily of
wood and paper, and Japanese firefighting methods were not up to
the challenge. The fires burned out of control, boiling canal water
and causing entire blocks of buildings to spontaneously combust
from the heat. The effects of the Tokyo firebombing proved the
fears expressed by Admiral
Yamamoto
in 1939: "Japanese cities, being made of wood and paper, would burn
very easily. The Army talks big, but if war came and there were
large-scale air raids, there's no telling what would happen."
In the following two weeks, there were almost 1,600 further
sorties against the four cities, destroying
31 square miles (80 km²) in total at a cost of 22 aircraft. By
June, over forty percent of the urban area of Japan's largest six
cities (Tokyo, Nagoya, Kobe, Osaka,
Yokohama, and
Kawasaki) was devastated. LeMay's fleet
of nearly 600 bombers destroyed tens of smaller cities and
manufacturing centers in the following weeks and months.
Leaflets were dropped over cities before they were bombed, warning
the people and urging them to escape the city. Though many, even
within the Air Force, viewed this as a form of
psychological warfare, a significant
element in the decision to produce and drop them was the desire to
assuage American anxieties about the extent of the destruction
created by this new war tactic. Warning leaflets were also dropped
on cities that were not to be bombed to create uncertainty and
absenteeism.
A year after the war, the
United States Army Air
Forces's
Strategic Bombing
Survey reported that they had underestimated the power of
strategic bombing combined with naval blockade and previous
military defeats to bring Japan to unconditional surrender without
invasion. By July 1945, only a fraction of the planned strategic
bombing force had been deployed yet there were few targets left
worth the effort. In hindsight, it would have been more effective
to use land-based and carrier-based air power to strike against
merchant shipping and begin aerial mining at a much earlier date so
as to link up with the effective
Allied submarine anti-shipping
campaign and completely isolate the island nation. This would
have accelerated the strangulation of Japan and ended the war
sooner. A postwar
Naval
Ordnance Laboratory survey agreed, finding that naval mines
dropped by B-29s had accounted for 60% of all Japanese shipping
losses in the last six months of the war. In October 1945, Prince
Fumimaro Konoe said that the sinking
of Japanese vessels by U.S. aircraft combined with the B-29 aerial
mining campaign were just as effective as B-29 attacks on industry
alone, though he admitted that "the thing that brought about the
determination to make peace was the prolonged bombing by the
B-29s." Prime Minister Baron
Kantarō
Suzuki reported to U.S. military authorities that it "seemed to
me unavoidable that in the long run Japan would be almost destroyed
by air attack so that merely on the basis of the B-29s alone I was
convinced that Japan should sue for peace."
Nuclear bombing
After six
months of intense
firebombing of 67 other Japanese cities the United States under
President Harry Truman conducted
nuclear attacks on the Empire of
Japan
.
On 6
August, 1945, the "Little
Boy
" enriched uranium nuclear
bomb was dropped on the city of Hiroshima, followed on 9 August by the detonation
of the "Fat
Man
" plutonium core nuclear bomb over Nagasaki. To date these are the
only uses of nuclear weapons in warfare.
Nuclear bombing damage to Japanese cities in
WWII
| Japanese city |
% area
destroyed |
| Hiroshima |
90 |
| Nagasaki |
45 |
As many as 140,000 people in Hiroshima and 80,000 in Nagasaki may
have died from the bombings by the end of 1945, roughly half of the
residential populations on the days of the bombings. Thousands more
have been subsequently killed from injuries or illness
due to radiation. In both cities, the
overwhelming majority of the dead were civilians.
On 15 August, 1945, Japan
announced
its surrender to the Allied Powers, signing the
Instrument of Surrender on
2 September which officially ended World War II. Furthermore, the
experience of bombing led post-war Japan to adopt
Three Non-Nuclear Principles,
which forbade Japan from nuclear armament.
See also
References
Notes
- Levine 1992, p. 21
- Hastings 1979
- Garrett 1993
- Boog 2001, p. 408.
- Pimlott, John. B-19 Superfortress (London: Arms and
Armour Press, 1980), p.40.
- President Franklin D. Roosevelt Appeal against aerial bombardment of civilian
populations, 1 September 1939
- Taylor (2005), Chapter "Call Me Meier", p. 105
- Nelson (2006), p. 104.
- Corum, 1995., p. 7
- Cabinet Office Records CAB 66/1/19
The National Archives
- Cabinet Office Records CAB 65/1/1 The National
Archives
- A.C. Grayling (Bloomsbury 2006), p. 24.
- Cabinet Office Records CAB 65/13/9 The National
Archives
- Norman Davies. (1982). God's Playground: A History of
Poland, Columbia University Press, p 437.
- Bruno Coppieters, N. Fotion, eds. (2002) Moral constraints
on war: principles and cases, Lexington Books, p 74.
- Bob Golan, Jacob Howland, Bette Howland, (2005). A long way
home, University Press of America, p 11.
- Sylwia Słomińska, "Wieluń, 1 września 1939 r.", Z dziejów dawnego
Wielunia "History of old Wielun", site by Dr Tadeusz Grabarczyk,
Historical Institute at University of Lodz,
- Antony Polonsky, Norman Davies. (1991). Jews in Eastern
Poland and the USSR, 1939-46, Macmillan in association with
the School of Slavonic and East European Studies, University of
London p 110.
- Jerzy Lukowski, Hubert Zawadzki, (2001). A concise history
of Poland, Cambridge University Press, 2001, p 225.
- George Topas, (1990). The iron furnace: a Holocaust
survivor's story, University Press of Kentucky, p 23.
- Hempel, Andrew. (2000). Poland in World War II: An
Illustrated Military History ISBN 9780781807586 p 14.
- Hooton 1994, p. 183.
- Speidel, p. 18
- Hooton 1994, p. 182.
- Hooton 1994, p. 181.
- Hooton 1994, p. 186.
- Hooton 1994, p. 187.
- Spencer Tucker, Priscilla Mary Roberts, (2004).
Encyclopedia of World War II: a political, social and military
history, ABC-CLIO, p 1613.
- Daniel Blatman, Rachel Grossbaum-Pasternak, Abraham Kleban,
Shmuel Levin, Wila Orbach, Abraham Wein. (1999). Pinkas Hakehillot: Encyclopedia of Jewish
Communities, Poland (English translation) Volume VII, Yad
Vashem, pp 406-407.
- Poeppel-von Preußen-von Hase, 2000. p. 248.
- Smith&Creek, 2004. p. 63
- Hooton 1994, p. 92.
- Smith&Creek, 2004. pp. 63-64
- Hooton 1994, p. 188.
- Poeppel-von Preußen-von Hase, 2000. p. 249.
- Electronic Encyclopaedia of Civil Defense and
Emergency Management
- Hooton 1994, p. 190.
- Smith&Creek, 2004. p. 64
- Middlebrook, Martin (1985). The Bomber Command War
Diaries. London: Penguin Books. P. 19 ISBN 0 670 80137 2
- Richards 1953, p.67.
- Richards 1953, p.68.
- Raid on Sylt - TIME
- Richards 1953, pp.114—115.
- Hinchliffe, 2000. p. 43
- 60 Jahre Kriegsende - Bombenkrieg
- Rutherford, Ward, Blitzkrieg 1940, G.P.Putnam's Sons,
NY, 1980, p.52.
- Piekalkiewicz, Janusz, The Air War, 1939-1945,
Blandford Press, Poole, Dorset, UK, 1985, p.74.
- DeutschlandRadio Berlin - MerkMal - Der Bombenkrieg
in Europa
- Hooton Vol 2 2007, p. 52.
- Hinchliffe, 2000. p. 42
- Van Nul to Nu Deel 3-De vaderlandse geschiedenis van 1815
tot 1940 Page 42, Square 2- by Thom Roep and Co Loerakker ISBN
90 5425 098 4
- Maass, Walter B., The Netherlands at War: 1940-1945,
Abelard-Schuman, NY, 1970, pp. 38-40.
- Kennett, Lee, A History of Strategic Bombing, Charles
Scribner's Sons, NY, 1982, p.112.
- Boyne,
Walter J., Clash of Wings: World War II in the Air,
Simon & Schuster, NY, 1994, p.61.
- Hastings 1979, p. 6
- Taylor 2005, Chapter "Call Me Meier", p. 111.
- Richards 1953, p.124.
- Hinchliffe, 2000. p. 44
- Hinchliffe, 2000. pp. 44-45
- Green 1967, p.19.
- British Military Aviation in 1940 - Part 4
- Naval Events, 1-14 July 1940
- Grenzlanduniversität
- 1940
- Great Air Battles: The Battle of Britain
- SC Military Museum
- Quester, George "Bargaining and Bombing During World War II in
Europe," World Politics, Vol. 15, No. 3 (Apr., 1963), pp. 421, 425.
Published by: The Johns Hopkins University Press
- Wood and Dempster, 2003. p. 122.
- Royal Air Force, "Phase
2 - Pressure grows" The Battle of Britain
- John Ray, The Night Blitz, chapter "Choosing London",
pages 101–102.
- Overy 2002, pp. 91-92
- Overy 2002, p. 91.
- Quester,George "Bargaining and Bombing During World War II in
Europe," World Politics, Vol. 15, No. 3 (Apr., 1963), pp. 426.
Published by: The Johns Hopkins University Press
- OpEdNews » How The United States Came to Bomb
Civilians
- Wings Over Wairarapa
- BBC - History - British Bombing Strategy in World
War Two
- Richard Overy The Battle Chapter "The Battle" pages
82-83
- Der alliierte Luftkrieg - TEIL IV
- Smith&Creek, 2004. Volume II. p. 122
- Murray 1983, p. 52.
- Price, 2005. p. 195.
- Charles Hawley. "Dresden Bombing Is To Be Regretted Enormously",
Der Spiegel
online, 11 February 2005
- Arthur Travers Harris, Despatch on war operations, 23rd
February, 1942, to 8th May, 1945, Volume 3 of Cass series
--studies in air power, Routledge, 1995, ISBN 071464692X,
9780714646923 p. 35
- Levine 1992, p. 36.
- Nelson, Hank (2003). A different war: Australians in Bomber Command a
paper presented at the 2003 History Conference - Air War
Europe
- Levine 1992, p. 48.
- Levine 1992, p. 39.
- Longmate 1983,p.133
- Copp 1996.
- Issues : Singleton - World War Two
- US Strategic Bombing Survey: Statistical Appendix to Overall
report (European War) (Feb 1947) table 1
- Harris, Arthur Travers, ed Cox, Sebastian (1995). Despatch
on War Operations: 23rd February, 1942, to 8th May, 1945,
Routledge, ISBN 0-7146-4692-X. p.196
- United States Strategic Bombing Survey
- Norman Longmate, The Bombers:The RAF Offensive against
Germany 1939-1945, pp.309-312
- J.K Galbraith, "The Affluent Society", chapter 12 "The Illusion
of National Security". Book first published 1958. Galbraith was a
director of the United States Strategic Bombing Survey.
- The United States Strategic Bombing Survey,
Statistical Appendix (European War), Feb 1947
- Caidin, Martin. A Torch to the Enemy: The Fire Raid on
Tokyo, Bantam War Books, 1960. ISBN 0-553-29926-3 pp.??
- Bradley, F. J. No Strategic Targets Left.
"Contribution of Major Fire Raids Toward Ending WWII", Turner
Publishing Company, limited edition. ISBN 1-56311-483-6. p.
38.
- Spector, Ronald (1985). "Eagle Against the Sun." New York:
Vintage Books. p. 503.
- United States Strategic Bombing Survey, Summary Report
(Pacific War). 1 July 1946
- Hallion, Dr. Richard P. Decisive Air Power Prior to 1950 Air
Force History and Museums Program.
- Major John S. Chilstrom, School of Advanced Airpower Studies.
Mines Away! The Significance of U.S. Army Air Forces Minelaying
in World War II. Diane Publishing, 1992.
- page on Hiroshima casualties.
Bibliography
- Bradley, F. J. (1999) No Strategic Targets Left.
"Contribution of Major Fire Raids Toward Ending WWII",
Turner Publishing. ISBN 1-56311-483-6.
- Copp, Terry. The Bomber Command Offensive, originally
published in the Legion Magazine
September/October 1996
- Collier, Basil. The Defence of the United Kingdom.
HMSO, 1957.
- Corum, James. (2007). The Luftwaffe: The Operational Air
War, 1918-1940. University of Kansas Press. ISBN
0-7006-0836-2
- Davis, Richard G. (2006) Bombing the European Axis Powers.
A Historical Digest of the Combined Bomber
Offensive 1939–1945 Alabama: Air University Press
- Grafton, Brian. Bomber Command on the website Military
History Online
- Hallion, Richard P. Decisive Air Power Prior to 1950 USAF
History and Museums Program.
- Hastings, Max (1979). RAF Bomber Command. Pan Books.
ISBN 0-330-39204-2
- Hinchcliffe, Peter (1996) The other battle : Luftwaffe
night aces versus Bomber Command. Airlife Publishing, ISBN
9781853105470
- Hooton, E.R (1994). Phoenix Triumphant; The Rise and Rise
of the Luftwaffe. London: Arms & Armour Press. ISBN 1
86019 964 X
- Hooton, E.R (1997). Eagle in Flames; The Fall of the
Luftwaffe. London: Arms & Armour Press. ISBN 1 86019 995
X
- Hooton, E.R (2007). Luftwaffe at War; Blitzkrieg in the
West: Volume 2. London: Chervron/Ian Allen. ISBN
978-1-85780-272-6.
- Jane`s (1989). All the World's Aircraft
1940/41/42/43/44/45. London, Random House, ISBN 1 85170 199
0
- Longmate, Norman. (1983) The Bombers. Hutchins. ISBN
0-09-151508-7.
- Murray, Willamson. (1983). Strategy for defeat. The Luftwaffe 1935-1945. Air Power Research
Institute. ISBN 9780160021602
- Nelson, Hank (2003). A different war: Australians in Bomber
Command paper presented at the 2003 History Conference -
Air War Europe
- Nelson, Hank (2006). Chased by the Sun: The Australians in
Bomber Command in World War II, Allen & Unwin, ISBN
1741148472, 9781741148473
- Overy, Richard J. (1980) The Air War Stein and Day.
ISBN 978-1-57488-716-7
- Poeppel, Hans and Prinz von Preußen, Wilhelm-Karl and von Hase,
Karl-Günther. (2000) Die Soldaten der Wehrmacht. Herbig
Verlag. ISBN 978-3776620573
- Price, Alfred. Kampfflieger -Bombers of the Luftwaffe January
1942-Summer 1943, Volume 3. 2005, Classic Publications. ISBN
978-1903223499
- Ray, John. The Night Blitz. Booksales. ISBN
978-0-7858-1601-0.
- Smith, J. Richard and Creek, Eddie J. (2004).
Kampflieger. Vol. 2.: Bombers of the
Luftwaffe July 1940 - December 1941. Classic Publications.
ISBN 978-1903223420
- Smith, J. Richard and Creek, Eddie J. (2004).
Kampflieger. Vol. 2.: Bombers of the
Luftwaffe July 1940 - December 1941. Classic Publications.
ISBN 978-1903223437
- Spector, Ronald (1985). Eagle Against the Sun. Vintage
Books. ISBN 978-0-394-74101-7
- Taylor, Frederick. (2005) Dresden: Tuesday, 13 February,
1945. Bloomsbury. ISBN 0-7475-7074-1
- Saward, Dudley. (1985) Bomber Harris. Doubleday. ISBN
978-0-385-11258-1
- United States Strategic Bombing Survey. Summary
Report(Pacific War) July 1, 1946.
- United States Strategic Bombing Survey. Summary
Report(European War) September 30, 1945.
- United States Strategic Bombing Survey. The Defeat of the German Air Force.
1947.
- United States Strategic Bombing Survey. The Effects of
Strategic Bombing on German Transportation. 1947.
- United States Strategic Bombing Survey. The Effects of
Strategic Bombing on the German War Economy. 1945.
- Willmott, H.P. (1991). The Great Crusade. Free Press,
1991. ISBN 9780029347164
- Wood & Dempster (1990) The Narrow Margin Chapter
"Second Phase" ISBN 978-0-87474-929-8
- Wood, Derek and Dempster, Derek. (1990). The Narrow Margin:
The Battle of Britain and the Rise of Air Power, London:
Tri-Service Press, third revised edition. ISBN 1-854-88027-6.
Further reading
- - Spaight was Principal Assistant Secretary of the Air Ministry
(U.K)
External links