The
Tianjin Religious Case (Chinese: 天津教案; Pinyin: Tiānjīn Jiào'àn) occurred in Tianjin
in
1870. It is considered to be one of the archetypal
and most important religious cases or missionary cases of the late
Qing
Dynasty
. The incident marked the end of the
comparative cooperation between foreign powers and the
Tongzhi court, and adversely affected the
ongoing renegotiation of the
Treaties of Tianjin of 1858.
In June 1870, kidnappings (or rumours thereof) spread throughout
China, with the blame frequently being attached to the Catholic
missions. Local Catholic nuns had been active in bringing children
into their orphanages, sometimes with the inducement of payment to
their family. During 1870, the already high number of deaths at
these orphanages increased through outbreaks of disease.
On
June 18, a kidnapper was arrested in
Tianjin
who claimed to have sold children to the janitor of
the orphanage, which seriously raised tensions. Missionaries
and foreign officials blamed local officials and gentry for stoking
the tensions.
Chinese officials met with their French counterparts, who had
assumed responsibility for the Catholic missions to China since the
Arrow War, which led to some reduction in
tensions. However, in a disputed sequenced of events on
June 19, the French consul Fontanier forced his way
into the yamen of the local magistrate. An angry crowd gathered,
and the consul appears to have ordered his guards to fire on the
magistrate. The incited crowd rioted, killing the consul and his
advisor. Catholic institutions were attacked and ransacked, with
30-40 local converts and 21 foreigners killed.
French gunboats were sent to Tianjin. Reparations and reprisals
were demanded by the French government. Chinese negotiations to
mitigate the damage were led by the aging statesman
Zeng Guofan. Sixteen Chinese were executed,
though little evidence was given as to their participation in the
massacre.
A Chinese mission of apology under Imperial Commissioner Chung How
later sailed for France, formally apologising to the provisional
French Head of State
Adolphe Thiers
in November 1871.
See also
References
- Cohen, Paul A., China and Christianity: The Missionary
Movement and the Growth of Chinese Anti-Foreignism, 1860-1870.
(Harvard University Press, Cambridge: 1963)
- Fairbank, John King.
"Patterns Behind the Tientsin Massacre." Harvard Journal of
Asiatic Studies 20, no. 3/4 (1957): 480-511.
- Barend J. ter Haar, Telling Stories: Witchcraft and
Scapegoating in Chinese History, (Brill, Leiden: 2006) chap.
4, ‘Westerners as Scapegoats’ pp. 154-201.