
View of the Fulton Chain (4th Lake)
from Bald Mountain
Upstate New York is the
region of New York
State
north of the core of the New York
metropolitan area
.
Definition
There is
no clear or official boundary between Upstate New York and Downstate New York, but the term
"Upstate" is sometimes used to refer to the whole of the state
besides New York City and Long Island
. Latitude is
generally a consideration in whether or not a place is "upstate",
as well as elevation and being away from sea level (hence the
prefix "up", meaning both to the north and having a greater
altitude). Distance from New York City is also a consideration.
Complicating any definition is the usage of the word "upstate" (in
lowercase) as a direction, rather than as the name of a
region.
Another common perception of the Upstate/Downstate boundary locates
it at the point at which New York's
suburbs
segue into its
exurbs. This line would
place most, but not all, of Westchester and Rockland counties south
of the boundary, putting the northwestern edge of Rockland as well
as the northernmost quarter of Westchester (such as Peekskill) in
Upstate New York. This definition of Upstate New York corresponds
to the orange, yellow, and green areas on the map above.
A more nuanced view would suggest the boundary lies further north.
Because
most New York City bedroom communities in Dutchess and Orange
counties are situated in the southern part of those counties and
the New York City's suburban public transportation system extends
some distance north, the Upstate/Downstate boundary can be defined
roughly by a border extended from Wassaic
(where
Metro-North's Harlem Line
ends) across to Poughkeepsie
, down to Newburgh
and then across to Middletown
and Port Jervis
. This definition of Upstate New York
corresponds to the yellow and green areas on the map above and
roughly corresponds with the area north of
Interstate 84. This imaginary line also
demarcates the northernmost reach of high housing prices associated
with the Downstate region in contrast to the relatively low housing
costs found further Upstate.
Particularly
within Upstate New York, the definition of
the word "upstate" is often much further north. For instance, many
communities clearly beyond the New York City commuter orbit are
part of New York City's
media market,
which includes Dutchess, Ulster and Sullivan counties, and thus do
not get local television (via cable) from Albany or Binghamton TV
stations.
Many upstate residents note that the state
capital of Albany
, being
mostly dominated by New York City-area politicians, has more in
common with downstate than upstate, and imply that everything in
between, including the Hudson Valley
region and occasionally the Catskill
Mountains, can be considered downstate; for example,
Buffalo News columnist
Donn Esmonde (in defending Caroline
Kennedy's abortive Senate run) criticized Senator Kirsten Gillibrand's upstate credentials
by saying "In the end... [w]e get a [so-called] 'upstate'
senator whose Hudson Valley base is equidistant from New York City
and Albany, the state’s power centers."
Charles Schumer once famously stated "To me,
the West begins across the
Hudson
River." Politics aside, the term "upstate" is occasionally used
(somewhat ambiguously) to refer to
Northern New York, including the
Adirondack Mountains, as
opposed to other areas of traditional upstate such as
Western New York and
Central New York; this definition of
Upstate New York corresponds to the green areas on the map
above.
For some, the term Upstate evokes sentiments of rural lifestyles
and traditional values contrary to those of New York City. In the
New York metropolitan area, usage of the term "Upstate New York"
typically implies unfamiliarity with (and occasionally
condescension towards) the area that the speaker is denoting as
such. It denotes areas that are both somewhat north of and
considerably more rural than the home location of the speaker.
Usage of the term is often taken to be an insulting manifestation
of the famous
New
Yorker magazine's view of the world.
New York
City is dependent on upstate for a variety of services; it is the
source of the city's water supply via the Delaware Aqueduct and the Catskill
Aqueduct
; much of the city's electric power supply comes
from state owned hydroelectric plants
at Niagara
Falls
and the St. Lawrence River
such as the Robert
Moses power station; and most of the state's prisons are
upstate; hence the popular term "being sent up the river" (however,
the term originally referred to Sing Sing
, which is "up the Hudson
River" from New York City, but being in Ossining in Westchester County
is still in the "downstate" region).
Conversely, the operation of state facilities providing these
services is an important part of the upstate economy.
Although
much of the eastern end of Long Island
is rural, it is never considered upstate, due to it
not being contiguous with upstate (one cannot pass from Long Island
to upstate without either navigating waters or passing through New
York City). Long Island is also significantly wealthier than
upstate regions are and has a significantly different
culture.
Culture
The region
is culturally and economically distinct from the New York City
area, though the Hudson Valley counties of Putnam
, Orange
, Dutchess
, and Ulster
are increasingly peripheral sections of the New
York City metro area. The northern upstate area consists of
a handful of small and medium-sized cities, with surrounding
suburbs, amidst vast rural areas. Dutchess, Ulster, and Putnam are
in fact on the border of the New York Upstate. They are a part of
the New York Metro area.
Western New York has many cultural and
economic ties to the other Great Lakes states as
well as Southern Ontario, while the
Capital
District
, the
Hudson Valley, the Mohawk Valley and the Plattsburgh
area have ties to New England
. In fact, cultural leanings in the extreme
northeastern portion of the state also cross the border so-to-speak
with the presence of prominent French and Anglo Canadian ties -
cultural, economic, and familial. Plattsburgh, for example has
close ties to its neighbors in the Montreal area and Vermont. Some
literary and cinematic depictions of upstate present a sense of
small town,
Midwestern lifetyles, such as
It's a Wonderful
Life, set in a small upstate town in the 1940s.
During the 1990s and the 2000s this area has suffered slow job
growth
[53369] and a rapid loss of young adults.
[53370] It has been argued, however, that
Upstate doesn't suffer from "brain drain" as much as it suffers
from lack of "brain gain" (i.e. other areas of the country attract
more educated persons than does Upstate.)

Ancestries from across the United
States.
A common misconception is that the predominant ethnic group in
upstate are
WASP.
Actually residents of English ancestry are dominant in only a
handful of rural counties. but still have a strong presence in the
remaining counties.
The Hudson Valley, the Capital District and
the Syracuse
region are heavily Irish American, while the
North Country is heavily
French Canadian. Italian Americans are the largest ethnic
group in Oneida
County
, Broome County
, Utica
and Schenectady
, while German ancestry is most common across
western New York.Persons of Polish, Irish, German, and
English ancestry are predominant in Buffalo
and its close suburbs. There is also a
significant presence of indigenous Iroquois
Native Americans in the area, who mostly congregate on several
reservations: the Seneca nation and
Tonawanda Band of
Seneca Indians in Western New
York, the Onondaga nation south
of Syracuse, the Oneida nation of
Oneida County and the Mohawk nation in
St. Lawrence
County
.
The only two major league professional sports teams in Upstate New
York are the
Buffalo Bills of the
National Football League
(NFL) and the
Buffalo Sabres of the
National Hockey League (NHL).
As a result, the collegiate sports program at Syracuse University
(
Syracuse Orange) attracts
significant regional attention, as do minor league baseball and
hockey teams.
In addition to teams from Buffalo,
professional sports teams from New York City, northern New Jersey
, Boston
, and Toronto all have followings in Upstate New
York. Rochester
is home to several Minor League sports
teams.
Other Upstate New York minor league professional sports teams
include the
Syracuse Chiefs of the
Triple-A baseball
International
League, the
Binghamton Mets of
the Double-A baseball
Eastern League,
the
Binghamton Senators of the
American Hockey
League(AHL),the
Albany Patroons
of the
Continental
Basketball Association; and the
Auburn Doubledays,
Oneonta Tigers, the
Jamestown Jammers, the
Tri-City ValleyCats and the
Batavia Muckdogs of the Class A baseball
New York - Penn League.
In
auto racing, Watkins Glen
International Speedway
is the major race track in the area and hosts
annual races in the Indy Racing
League and NASCAR Sprint
Cup. Holland
Speedway in Holland
hosts races in the Whelen All-American
Series. In addition, numerous smaller speedways and
dirt tracks exist in Little Valley
, Freedom
, Humphrey
, Granby
(serving the city of Fulton
), Oswego
, Lancaster,
Ransomville
and numerous other cities and towns.
Two of the most important
rock
festivals of the 20th century were held in Upstate New York.
In 1969
the Woodstock
Festival
was held in Bethel, New York
, while in 1973 another multiday festival was held at the
Watkins Glen International
Raceway
.
Linguistically, from Western New York to as
far east as Utica
is part of
the Inland North
region of American English dialectology, a region which includes
Midwestern cities as far west as Chicago and Milwaukee
. The Hudson and lower Mohawk Valley has more
in common dialectologically with western New England and New York
City.
[53371]
The boundary between the use of the words
pop and
soda to
refer to
soft drinks, however, falls further west than the edge of the
Inland North, running just to the east of the city of Rochester:
Buffalo and Rochester use
pop, like the rest of the Inland
North to the west, whereas Syracuse uses
soda, like New
England and New York City.
Foodways
indigenous to regions of Upstate New York include Plattsburgh's
"Michigan" hot dog, a variety of
Coney Island hot dog; the white
hot dog of central and western New York that
is known variously as the "White Hot" or "Coney" (pronounced
alternately as either "coney" or "cooney"); the "Spiedie" of the Binghamton
area, Central New York's salt potatoes, Utica's
Tomato Pie, and Chicken riggies, Rochester's
Garbage
plate
, Buffalo's kummelweck and
perhaps most famously, Buffalo
wings. Calvin Trillin
chronicled the origin of Buffalo wings in the August 25, 1980 issue
of
The New Yorker. Although
the
potato chip was invented in Saratoga
Springs, it has achieved such universal popularity that it is no
longer identified with the region. Winemaking is a growing industry
in the
Finger Lakes.
A
Home Box Office miniseries is
planned that will dramatize the a
New
York magazine article on
natural gas
drillers coming to the region.
Richard
Russo, a winner of the
Pulitzer
Prize, is writing a script for the project.
Geography

Adirondack lakeshore
The headwaters of the
Delaware,
Susquehanna,
Hudson, and
Allegheny rivers are located in the region.
The region is characterized by the major
mountain ranges, large
lakes,
and extensive
forests.
The
Allegheny Plateau extends into
west and central New York from the south. The
Catskill Mountains lie in the
southeastern part of the state, closer to New York City.
The
Catskills and the Allegheny Plateau are both part of the Appalachian
Mountains
. The northernmost part of the state contains
the
Adirondack Mountains, which
are sometimes considered part of the Appalachians but are
geologically separate, a southern extension of the
Canadian Shield.
In the more mountainous eastern part of Upstate New York, the
valleys of the Hudson River and the
Mohawk
River were historically important travel corridors and remain
so today.
Western New York in the vicinity of Buffalo
is very flat, as it was once the bottom of a
glacial lake. The only "hills" in Niagara
County
are the Niagara
Escarpment, which formed the Falls.
Upstate
has a long shared border with Canadian province of Ontario
divided by water; including the Lake Erie
, Niagara
River
, Lake
Ontario
and the St. Lawrence River
. It shares a land border with the province of
Quebec
in the
northernmost part of the state.
The sizes of upstate counties and towns are generally larger in
area and smaller in population, compared with the downstate region,
although there are exceptions.
The state's smallest county in population
(Hamilton
County
) and largest county in area (St. Lawrence
County
on the state's northern border) are both in Upstate
New York, while the largest in population (Kings
County
) and smallest in area (New York County
) are both part of New York City.
Upstate New York is well known for its cold and snowy winters,
particularly in comparison to the more temperate climate of
downstate New York. The snowy reputation is especially true for the
cities of Buffalo, Rochester, Oswego and Syracuse, and is largely
due to
lake-effect snow from Lake
Ontario and Lake Erie.
The village of Old
Forge
in the Adirondacks often vies on winter nights
with places like International Falls,
Minnesota
and Fargo, North Dakota
for the coldest spot in the nation.
Many of
the features of the upstate landscape, such as the Finger Lakes
and the drumlins that dot
the region, are the result of glaciers
during the Ice Age.
History
Before the arrival of European settlement, the area was inhabited
by a mixture of
Iroquois-speaking people
(mainly west of the Hudson) and
Algonquian-speaking people (mainly east
of the Hudson). The conflict between the two peoples was an
important historical force in the days of the early European
colonization. The
Haudenosaunee or
Iroquois confederacy of the Five (later
Six) Nations was a powerful force in its home territory. Their
territory extended from the Mohawk River Valley to the western part
of the state. From this home base they also controlled at various
times large swaths of additional territory throughout what is now
the northeastern United States. The
Guswhenta , made with the
Dutch government in 1613, codified relations between the
Haudenosaunee and European colonizers, and formed the basis of
subsequent treaties.
The
region was important beginning in the very early days of both the
French
Colonization
and Dutch
colonization. Much of the fur trade of the
New Netherland colony was located in the
upper Hudson Valley.
In the seventeenth century, the French
established trading posts as far south as the shores of Onondaga Lake
, although Samuel de
Champlain had alienated the Haudenosaunee during military
forays from Quebec
.
The area was the scene of much of the fighting in the
French and Indian War, events which
were depicted in the work of
James
Fenimore Cooper.
The
region was strategically important in the American Revolution, and was the scene
of several important battles, including the Battle of
Saratoga
, which is considered to have been a significant
turning point in the war. While New York City remained in
the hands of the British during most of the war, the upstate region
was eventually dominated by the Colonial forces. In 1779, the
Sullivan Expedition, a campaign
ordered by Gen.
George Washington,
drove thousands of the Haudenosaunee from their villages, farms and
lands in the region.
Following the American Revolution, the United States signed a
federal treaty, the
Treaty of
Canandaigua, with the Haudenosaunee, affirming their land
rights in what later became Central and Western New York.
Nevertheless, State officials and private land agents continued to
work to extinguish Indian title to these lands via
non-Federally-sanctioned treaties, such as the
Treaty of Big Tree[53372], through the early 19th century.
Many of the settlers of Central and Western New York came from the
New England States. The
Central New York Military
Tract, where many of the townships were given the names of
classical military and literary figures by
Robert Harpur, was established to grant land
to Revolutionary War veterans.
Battles
with British were fought during the war of
1812 (1812–1815), on land, including the Battle of Plattsburgh,
and in the Great Lakes (Ontario and Erie) and St. Lawrence
shorelines, including the Battle of Sackets Harbor
.
Both before and after the Revolution, boundary disputes with
Massachusetts, Vermont and Great Britain, and subsequent surveying
errors, complicated American settlement. The Province of New York
granted lands to settlers in what is now Vermont at the same time
that New Hampshire made grants of the same lands. When Vermont
declared independence in 1777, the new Republic of Vermont
recognized the New Hampshire grants over those of New York. New
Yorkers who lost land in Vermont came to be known as the "Vermont
Sufferers" and were granted new lands in 1788 in the Town of
Bainbridge, New York.
The dispute with Massachusetts over lands to the west of
Massachusetts was settled in the 1786
Treaty of Hartford by dividing the rights
to the land. The treaty granted sovereignty to the State of New
York, but granted to the Commonwealth of Massachusetts the
"pre-emptive" right to seek title to the land from the
Haudenosaunee. The eastern boundary of the Massachusetts lands was
thus known as the
Preemption Line.
This line runs from the Pennsylvania line due north to Lake
Ontario, passing through Seneca Lake. The line was surveyed a
second time due to initial errors. The Commonwealth of
Massachusetts sold this land in large tracts, including the
Phelps and Gorham
Purchase and the
Holland
Purchase.
The
Treaty of Paris that
ended the American Revolution established the 45th Parallel as the
border with Quebec.
This line was surveyed and after the War of
1812, the US Government began to construct Fort Montgomery just south of the border at
Rouses
Point
on Lake
Champlain
.
Subsequently it was discovered that at that point, the actual 45th
parallel was three-quarters of a mile south of the surveyed line,
putting the Fort, which became known as "Fort Blunder," in Canada.
This was not resolved until 1842 with the
Webster-Ashburton Treaty, in which
Great Britain and the United States decided to leave the border on
the meandering line as surveyed.
Slavery existed in
New Netherland and
the
Province of New York. New
York was in the 1690s the largest importer of slaves among the
American colonies. Slavery did not end with the
American Revolution, although
John Jay introduced an emancipation bill in to the
State Assembly as early as 1777.
Sojourner Truth was held as a slave in the
Hudson Valley from the time she was
born in 1797 until she escaped in 1826. Through efforts of the
New York Manumission
Society and others, New York began to adopt a policy of gradual
emancipation in 1799. The law passed in 1817 that would finally
emancipate slaves did not take effect for ten years, giving
slaveowners an entire decade to sell their slaves away to other
states. When the law finally took effect, the last 2,800 slaves in
New York State were emancipated on July 4, 1827.
By 1825, the
Erie Canal opened, allowing
the area to become an important component of the 19th century
industrial expansion in the United States. The canal also promoted
trade with
British North
America and settlement of newer states in western territories.
Later in the century the
New
York Central Railroad followed the "water-level route" from New
York City to the Great Lakes, contributing to the industrialization
of cities along its route.
Several times in the nineteenth century, Upstate New York served as
a staging area and refuge for Canadian rebels against Great
Britain, as well as Irish-American invaders of Canada, straining
British-American relations. In 1837 and 1838, in the aftermath of
the
Lower Canada Rebellion,
some
Québécois rebels
escaped south to the North Country, while on the
Niagara Frontier, events of the
Upper Canada Rebellion, also known as
the
Patriot War, took place.
In the
late 1860s, some of the Fenian Raids
were launched across the Niagara Frontier; Fenians also assembled in Malone
.
Although
now largely discredited, the report of the 1905-1907 Mills Commission, charged with
investigating the origins of
baseball, named Cooperstown
as the place where baseball
was invented in the 1830s or 1840s by Abner Doubleday. Cooperstown is the
home of the National Baseball Hall of Fame
and Museum.
In the pre-Civil War era, Upstate New York became a major center of
radical
abolitionist activity and was
an important nexus of the
Underground Railroad. Resistance to the
Fugitive Slave Act was
particularly heated in the region, as evidenced by such events as
the
Jerry Rescue. The American
women's rights movement was also born in
Upstate New York at this time; the first
women's rights convention was held
at
Seneca Falls in
1848.
Through the nineteenth century, Upstate New York was a hotbed of
religious revivalism. A number of sects, such as the
Shakers and the
Oneida
Community, established themselves in Upstate New York during
that time. This led evangelist
Charles Grandison Finney to coin
the term the "
Burned-Over
District" for the region. Because of the comparative isolation
of the region, many of the sects were non-conformist, and because
of their non-traditional tenets they had numerous difficulties with
government and other local people. The region is considered to be
the cradle of
Mormonism, as well as the
Women's Suffrage movement. The
Mormons,
Seventh-day Adventists and
Spiritualists are
the only 21st century survivors of the hundreds of sects created
during this time.
In the 19th century, extractive industries changed the landscape.
Potash was manufactured as the land was
cleared for farming.
Iron was mined in the
Adirondacks and the North Country. By the 1870s, business leaders,
concerned about the effect of deforestation on the water supply
necessary to the Erie Canal, advocated for the creation of forest
preserves in the Adirondacks and the Catskills. The
Adirondack Park and
Catskill Park were created and strengthened by
a series of legislation between 1885 and 1894, when the "
Forever wild" provision of the
New York State Constitution was
added.
During the era immediately following World War II, Upstate reached
what was probably its peak influence in the national economy. Major
local corporations such as
IBM,
General Electric,
Kodak,
Xerox and
Carrier produced cutting edge products
for business, government and consumers. The opening of the
New York State Thruway in the mid
1950s gave the region superior access to other eastern markets.
This regional advantage faded as many local firms relocated
operations to other states, or downsized in the face of foreign
competition, similar to other areas in the American
Rust Belt.
In recent decades, with the decline of manufacturing, the area has
generally suffered a net population loss. In contrast, many
Amish and
Mennonite
families are recent arrivals to the area.
Beginning in 1974,
many Mennonite families moved to the
Penn
Yan
area of Yates County
from Lancaster County,
Pennsylvania
, seeking cheaper farmland. Recently-established
Amish communities are in St.
Lawrence
, Montgomery
, Chautaugua
and Cattaraugus
counties.
Five of
the six Iroquois nations have filed land claims against New York
State (or have sought settlement of pending claims), based on late
18th-century treaties with the State of New York
and the United States.
Politics
Often attributed to the region's semi-rural character, there is
more
conservatism in culture and
politics than found in the more urban downstate area, and is the
power base of the state's
Republican Party,
especially now that Long Island, a former Republican stronghold,
has become slightly more democratic than republican.
There are
several exceptions to this rule, including Erie
County
(Buffalo), Monroe County
(Rochester), Onondaga
County
(Syracuse), Tompkins County
(Ithaca), Albany County (Albany), Niagara
County
(Niagara Falls), Broome County
(Binghamton), Clinton
(Plattsburgh), Franklin
, St. Lawrence
counties (influence of Canada), and Ulster
County
(City of Kingston, Villages of Woodstock and New
Paltz).
As a whole, Upstate New York is roughly equally divided in Federal
elections between Democrats and Republicans. In
2004,
John Kerry defeated
George W. Bush
by less than 1,500 votes (1,553,246 votes to 1,551,971) in the
Upstate Region.
The conservatism of the upstate region more closely resemble
Rockefeller Republicans,
pro-business and pro-taxation but socially liberal Republicans who
supported the policies of former Governor
Nelson Rockefeller. Others are
libertarians, socially liberal "Live and let
live" conservatism of Vermont, New Hampshire and many of the
western states instead of the social conservatism of the southern
states and the
Religious Right. Some
of the Religious Right's harshest critics within the Republican
Party, in fact, have been Upstate New York Republicans such as
Amo Houghton and
Jack Quinn. The misunderstanding of
the regional differences in upstate's conservative nature has led
to significant political difficulties by both major political
parties in the area. In the
2009
23rd congressional district special election, Republican
candidate
Dede Scozzafava dropped
out of the race in the face of competition from
Conservative Party of New
York candidate
Doug Hoffman, who
was endorsed by non-New York Republicans like
Sarah Palin and
Tim
Pawlenty. Scozzafava ended up endorsing Democratic candidate
Bill Owens, who defeated
Hoffman.
The influence of
public service
labor unions is also a factor in the
Democratic Party's continued strength. Hospitals and
public schools are among
the area's largest employers, and these agencies have unionized
workers. Unionized workers as a whole make up 1 in 4 New York
workers, the most in the nation. These unions, most notably the
Service Employees
International Union and
New York State United
Teachers, make large purchases of television air time on local
television and radio stations during budget negotiations and prior
to school budget votes to air commercials featuring
scare tactics threatening the closure of
hospitals or emergency rooms, larger class sizes, and reduced care
if they don't receive more money. Organized rebuttals have been few
and far between, although more frequent in recent years;
Eliot Spitzer's use of his personal campaign
funds to push through his 2007 reforms was the first, more recent
movements include Rochester businessman
Tom
Golisano's
Responsible New York campaign, and Buffalo developer
Carl Paladino's calls for a
constitutional convention directly to address union-friendly laws
such as the "Wicks Law" and the
Taylor
Law.
Upstate politicians have, in fact, sometimes taken the leading role
in the moves that give the state its liberal reputation.
It was
George Michaels, an assemblyman from
the Finger
Lakes
, who in 1970 stunned not only the state but the
nation by asking that his vote of "no" on the bill to legalize
abortion in New York be changed to "yes,"
causing the bill to pass by one vote. (He lost his seat at
the next
primary election, as he
had anticipated, but never regretted changing his vote).
Nearly
three decades later, voters in Plattsburgh
elected Daniel L. Stewart, the state's first
openly
gay mayor - a
Republican, to boot.
Another upstate mayor, Jason West of New
Paltz
, drew national attention in early 2004 when
he
officiated at the state's first gay weddings.
However,
such "liberal oases," which include New Paltz and Ithaca
, tend to be the state's (and the country's) most
liberal regions and unrepresentative of the region's politics as a
whole.
It should also be noted that the Democratic Party in upstate
cities, particularly in Buffalo, also has traditionally leaned
further to the right than downstate Democrats.
Jack Quinn, a Republican, was elected
from a district that was 57 percent Democratic. Similarly, leading
Democrats in the area, including
Dennis
Gorski,
Anthony Masiello and
James D. Griffin, were noted for their fiscal and
social conservatism and were often cross-endorsed by the
Conservative Party of New
York.
One example of the ideological divide between upstate and downstate
Democrats was the reaction to Governor
David Paterson's appointment of Congresswoman
Kirsten Gillibrand, who
represented the 20th District upstate, to the U.S. Senate.
Downstate Democrats were skeptical of Gillibrand's positions on
gun control and
immigration, which while mainstream in Upstate
New York, were to the right of positions of downstate Democratic
activists such as Congresswoman
Carolyn
McCarthy. Paterson's appointment of Gillibrand was believed to
be an effort to enhance his own chances in a general election by
presenting a balanced ticket whch would appeal to moderates and
Upstate voters; had Gillibrand not been chosen it was likely the
2010 Democratic ticket would be composed entirely of downstate
officeholders. The last time that New York has had a senator of
either party from upstate was Republican
Charles E. Goodell in 1971.
Proponents of the 2008 presidential run by Sen.
Hillary Clinton have pointed to her relative
success upstate (she lost the region by less than 10 percent of the
vote in 2000) as an argument that she could succeed as a candidate
in
red states.
Skeptics of such a bid have responded that upstate is, in fact, not
as conservative as widely believed, at least not conservative in
the manner of what is now the leadership of the Republican Party.
[53373].
Most of
New York State's most successful Republican politicians, however,
such as Rockefeller, George Pataki,
Thomas Dewey, Fiorello La Guardia, Jacob Javits and Alfonse D'Amato, came from the downstate
region, (although some definitions of the boundary would have
Pataki being from upstate, and Pataki also owns a farm in Essex
County
, solidly in upstate). Most upstate
Republicans are politically unacceptable to even downstate
Republican voters, and the party's financial backers are mostly
based downstate (the corollary, of course, being that incumbent New
York City politicians rarely win statewide elections, either).
Democratic politicians upstate often tend to be (or at least run)
more moderate than their downstate compatriots, and sometimes seek
the endorsement of the state's
Conservative Party to
inoculate them against perceptions of extreme liberalism.
Nevertheless, Republican attempts upstate to court votes by openly
appealing to suspicion of New York City have usually backfired.
In 1998
incumbent (and Long
Island
native) Republican Senator Al
D'Amato's Senate campaign ran television ads in some upstate
markets attempting to link his opponent, Charles Schumer, to a flock of hungry
sharks released from New York City to fleece
upstate. Schumer went on to win the election and did
surprisingly well in areas considered by New York City residents to
be "upstate".
In turn, he has probably lobbied for
"upstate" interests both in and out of government more than any
past "downstate" Democratic senator (for
example, he lobbied for JetBlue to
provide flights to Buffalo
and Syracuse
, producing more competition and lower fares at
those airports).
Downstate candidates seeking statewide office have often sealed
their fate by displaying profound ignorance of upstate geography.
One candidate at a forum in Buffalo once referred to "your airport
in Albany" ... a city more than 200 miles (320 km) away.
In the
2000 Senate race, Rudolph Giuliani
confused the Orange County village of Monroe
with Monroe County, and the ultimate Republican
nominee, Rick Lazio, later released an
itinerary confusing Owego
and Oswego
, two communities a considerable distance from each
other. Hillary Clinton won the race, doing much better
upstate than expected.
Like Charles Schumer, she too has "given
back" and lobbied for "upstate" interests more than most past
"downstate" Democratic senators (for example, unsuccessfully
lobbying for larger Homeland
Security funding for the Buffalo area than its size would
normally warrant on the basis of it being on the Canadian border,
the finding of a putative sleeper cell
in the nearby city of Lackawanna
in 2002, and the presence of the Eastern United
States' most vital electrical power generation facilities, the
Robert Moses Niagara Power Plant and the Lewiston Pump Generating
Plant).
But while politicians based upstate rarely win elections for
governor or U.S. Senator, some have been elected to other lesser
statewide offices, such as
lieutenant governor
(
Stan Lundine,
Maryanne Krupsak and
Mary Donohue, for instance),
comptroller (
Edward
Regan) and
attorney general
(
Dennis Vacco).
The late Daniel Patrick Moynihan officially
lived on a farm in Delaware County
while serving in the Senate, but he grew up in
New York City and spent much of his career there, making him a
familiar face to downstate voters.
The sharp differences in ideology have historically fueled many
political struggles by upstate conservatives with largely
downstate-based Democrats in the
New York Legislature; however the feuds
quite often tend to be more on regional lines than on party lines.
The most recent major examples were the failed attempt by
Syracuse-area assemblyman
Michael
Bragman, the
majority leader of
that body to seize control of the downstate-dominated state
Democratic party in 2000, which was immediately followed by a
strong retaliatory backlash against all upstate politicians in
state government and the attempt by both Republicans and Democrats
to cater to upstate voters by promising to disband the
New York State Thruway, whose toll
portions are entirely upstate.
Both candidates in the 2006 gubernatorial
election (Democrat Eliot Spitzer and
Republican John Faso) pledged to eliminate
the tolls however at the present time only an eight mile stretch of
I-190 in downtown Buffalo
, which had been collecting tolls to be used to keep
I-84 downstate a free highway,
has been made toll-free, and in fact the thruway authority has
steadily increased tolls annually since 2006. Critics
upstate feel that it is unlikely that either party would genuinely
be willing to give up such a significant source of revenue, despite
promises to the contrary, particularly one that does not draw its
funding from the population core downstate.
While Republicans have traditionally controlled the State Senate by
virtue of holding most seats upstate, the leadership has often been
split between upstate senators such as
Joseph Bruno and Long Islanders such as the
current leader,
Dean Skelos.
The 2008 state senate elections shifted political power in the
chamber from the upstate-heavy Republicans to the New York
City-centered Democrats. Skelos, a Long Island native, hatched a
plan to lure four conservative New York City Democrats (known
collectively as the "Gang of Four") to vote for Skelos as leader of
the Senate in exchange for committee assignments, but the move
backfired: the Democrats in question got the committee assignments
(ahead of the upstate senators who were expected to get them) but
instead turned and announced their support for Senate Democratic
leader
Malcolm Smith, as part of a
deal ironically hatched by upstate politicians Steven Pigeon and
Tom Golisano. As a result, several state Senate Republicans have
considered reaching out to the five upstate Democrats (compared to
27 downstate Democrats) in the chamber to form a coalition,
including Buffalo Democrat
William
Stachowski, who would have earned a powerful committee
leadership position had it not been for the Gang of Four deal.
Stachowski and the others have so far rebuffed any suggestions they
would break ranks. In an effort to retain the upstate Democrats,
Smith nominated Syracuse senator
David
Valesky as his second-in-command. Upstate Democrats such as
Valesky, Stachowski and
Darrel
Aubertine often face significant pressure from constituents and
other upstate lawmakers to hold more conservative positions than
their downstate counterparts.
In the congressional elections of 2006 and 2008, many upstate
Congressional seats historically held by Republicans came under
serious challenge by Democratic contenders, and some (such as the
20th, 24th, and 29th districts) were lost to Democrats, even with
Republican voter enrollment advantages remaining in place. Slow
population growth in the 1990s led legislators to eliminate two
upstate House districts in the 2002
reapportionment and leave all downstate
districts alone, hence, the influence of upstate in Congress has
faded from the days in which
Jack Kemp;
Barber Conable, and
Sam Stratton were prominent House
leaders.
Upstate New York
Presidential elections results
| Year |
Republican |
Democratic |
| 2008 |
46.82% 1,504,543 |
53.18%
1,708,772 |
| 2004 |
49.19% 1,551,971 |
49.23%
1,553,246 |
| 2000 |
45.30% 1,348,93 |
49.33%
1,469,087 |
| 1996 |
36.76% 1,050,511 |
49.66%
1,419,077 |
| 1992 |
36.72% 1,159,280 |
39.31%
1,241,203 |
| 1988 |
52.49%
1,506,011 |
46.71% 1,340,248 |
| 1984 |
60.17%
1,765,919 |
34.49% 1,158,830 |
| 1980 |
47.93%
1,327,072 |
41.65% 1,153,234 |
| 1976 |
55.57%
1,555,430 |
44.06% 1,233,220 |
| 1972 |
63.45%
1,805,076 |
36.30% 1,032,633 |
| 1968 |
49.60%
1,330,622 |
44.12% 1,183,698 |
| 1964 |
31.73% 873,257 |
68.18%
1,876,429 |
| 1960 |
54.05%
1,552,646 |
45.87% 1,317,838 |
|
Downstate New York
Presidential elections results
| Year |
Republican |
Democratic |
| 2008 |
30.14% 1,320,570 |
69.86%
3,060,928 |
| 2004 |
33.39% 1,409,657 |
65.42%
2,761,973 |
| 2000 |
27.42% 1,054,391 |
68.64%
2,638,820 |
| 1996 |
25.53% 882,981 |
67.58%
2,337,100 |
| 1992 |
31.24% 1,187,369 |
57.97%
2,203,247 |
| 1988 |
43.57 1,575,860 |
55.51%
2,007,634 |
| 1984 |
49.04% 1,898,844 |
50.64%
1,960,779 |
| 1980 |
45.64% 1,566,759 |
45.88%
1,575,138 |
| 1976 |
41.47% 1,545,361 |
57.87%
2,156,338 |
| 1972 |
55.31%
2,387,702 |
44.44% 1,918,451 |
| 1968 |
40.84% 1,677,310 |
53.44%
2,194,772 |
| 1964 |
31.05% 1,370,302 |
68.80%
3,036,727 |
| 1960 |
42.86% 1,893,773 |
56.86%
2,512,247 |
|
The People, Events and Ideas of Upstate New York
The Arts
See
The Arts of Upstate New
York
Athletes and athletic events
- Billy Backus,
boxer from Canastota

- Carmen
Basilio, boxer from Canastota

- Funny Cide, the first New York-bred
horse to win the Kentucky Derby
- Tim Green
- Walter Hagen, early American
golfer, holds 11 majors, 3rd behind Jack Nicklaus and Tiger
Woods.
- Baby Joe Mesi, heavyweight boxing
contender from Tonawanda
- Matt Morris, professional
baseball player from Wallkill
- Joe Nathan, professional
baseball player from wallkill
- Jason Motte,
professional baseball player, graduate of Valley Central Highschool
in Montgomery

- The "Miracle on Ice"
- The
1932 Winter Olympics and the
1980 Winter Olympics, both held
at Lake
Placid

- The Tour de New York bicycle
race
Crimes and criminals
Educators and Librarians
Emigrants
"Go West, young man!" said Horace Greeley, editor of the
New
York Tribune, and many Upstate New Yorkers did. The dream of
moving west or south, or abroad, is common to this day. Here is a
link to a list of Upstate New Yorkers who in Huck Finn’s phrase,
"lit out for the territories":
Emigrants from Upstate
New York
Environment
- Acid rain, caused in Upstate New York
by Midwestern coal-fired power plants[53375]
Flora and fauna
Diseases
- White nose syndrome (WNS) is
a poorly understood malady associated with the deaths of hundreds
of thousands of bats. The condition was
first identified in several caves near Albany
in February
2006.
Endangered species
Extinctions
Invasive species
Superfund sites
(for a comprehensive list see
[53376])
Historic events
- Hurricane Agnes, 1972
- The
first execution via the electric
chair, in Auburn
Prison
in 1890
- The Jerry Rescue
- The
1901 assassination of President William
McKinley
in Buffalo, prompting his Vice-President Teddy Roosevelt to travel to Buffalo twice:
first, after learning of McKinley's shooting, from Isle La Motte,
Vermont in Lake Champlain; then, having left Buffalo as McKinley
was appearing to recover, from an Adirondack hunting trip upon
learning of McKinley's death, to be sworn in as McKinley's
successor. Anarchist Leon
Czolgosz, McKinley's assassin, was subsequently electrocuted in
Auburn
Prison
.
- The Northeast Blackout of
1965
- The Northeast Blackout of
2003
- The 1848 Seneca Falls
Convention, the first women's
rights convention held in the United States
- The
Battle of
Saratoga
, turning point of the revolution.
Innovation and business
See
Inventors and
Business Leaders of Upstate New York
Inventions
Manufactures
- Adirondack baseball bats, made in Dolgeville

- the Grumman aluminum canoe [53378][53379], built in Marathon, an innovative use of the
material and an example of post-World War II conversion of
aircraft-industry resources to peacetime use
- The Gunlocke Company,
Office Furniture made in Wayland, NY [53380]
- Carousels, built in
North
Tonawanda
by the Allan
Herschell Company and others in the same city[53381]
- Locomotives,
built in Schenectady
by the American Locomotive
Company
- the
Penn
Yan
boat[53382]
- Sailplanes, made by Schweizer Aircraft in Horseheads
- Salt, made from brine in Syracuse and mined
in Western New York
- the
Wurlitzer organ and jukebox, made in
North
Tonawanda

Upstate New York companies that have moved manufacturing
away
Journalists
- Samuel
Hopkins Adams, muckraker, born in Dunkirk

- Amy Dickinson,
Chicago Tribune advice
columnist, who grew up on a dairy farm in Freeville

- Verlyn Klinkenborg, member of
the New York Times editorial
board; writer and farmer
- Francis
Mallison of Rome
.
Journalist, editor and public servant. Editor of the Rome Sentinel,
reporter for the Brooklyn Eagle. He and editor Joseph Howard, Jr.
organized the "Great Civil War Gold Hoax", for which he was held as
a prisoner of war.
- Tim Russert, host
of NBC's Meet the Press,
born and raised in Buffalo

- Dorothy
Thompson, born in Lancaster

- John Zogby of
Utica
, pollster
and blogger
Legends and hoaxes
Physicians and Scientists
- William Martin
Beauchamp, ethnologist and clergyman. Born in Orange
County
, he served an Episcopal parish in Baldwinsville
for 35 years while also performing archæological
research, particularly concerning the Haudenosaunee, and publishing
his findings in eight books between 1892 and 1908.
- Dr.
Elizabeth Blackwell,
abolitionist, women's rights activist, and the first female doctor
in the United States, studied medicine at Geneva College
.
- Dr. Asa Fitch of Salem, the first occupational entomologist
in the United States. In 1838 he began to collect and study insects
for New York state. In 1854 he became the first professional
Entomologist of New York State Agricultural Society, commissioned
by the State of New York.
- Dr. George Franklin Grant.
Born in
Oswego
, he was the first African American professor at
Harvard. He was also a Boston dentist, and the inventor of
the golf tee.
- James Hall
- Prof.
Joseph Henry, scientist who advanced
the understanding of electricity, and who served as the first
Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution
.
- Irving Langmuir, chemist and
physicist, Nobel laureate and resident of Schenectady.
- Lewis Henry
Morgan of Aurora and Rochester
, ethnologist, anthropologist, writer and
attorney. Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels relied on his accounts of
the evolution of indigenous peoples to fill in their own account of
the development of capitalist society.
- Roger Tory
Peterson, naturalist, ornithologist, writer and educator, born
in Jamestown
.
- Prof. Carl Sagan
- Henry Rowe
Schoolcraft, geographer, geologist, and ethnologist, born in
Guilderland
.
- Dr.
Edward Livingston Trudeau,
who established the Adirondack Cottage
Sanitarium
at Saranac Lake
for treatment of tuberculosis.
- Charles Doolittle
Walcott, paleontologist
- Dr.
Mary Edwards Walker of Oswego
, feminist, abolitionist, prohibitionist,
suffragist, alleged spy, prisoner of war, surgeon, and the only
woman to receive the Medal of Honor.
Political figures
See
Political
Figures of Upstate New York
Shipwrecks
Social, political and religious movements
Spiritual and religious figures
- Jehudi Ashmun,
religious leader and social reformer born in Champlain,
New York
. He was an agent of the American Colonization Society
which promoted the settlement of blacks at Monrovia,
Liberia
and was effectively governor of the colony from
1824 to 1828.
- Antoinette Brown, minister,
abolitionist and suffragist. Born in Henrietta
, she was the first woman to be ordained as a
minister in the United States. She served a
congregation in South
Butler
.
- Avery Dulles,
S.J., born in Auburn

- Charles Grandison
Finney
- Harry Emerson Fosdick,
clergyman. He was born in Buffalo, and graduated from Colgate
University.
- David Marks, missionary who
travelled upstate New York preaching false sermons that Westchester
County is to be considered "downstate".
- George Washington
Gale
- Handsome Lake
- Mother Ann Lee
- Oren Lyons
- William Miller
- Mordecai Manuel Noah
- John Humphrey Noyes
- Joseph Smith
- Kateri Tekakwitha
Tragedies
Unsolved mysteries
Places of Upstate New York
Major cities
Major highways
Major tourist attractions and destinations
Major universities and colleges
Subregions
See also
External links
References