Victimology is the scientific study of
victimization, including the relationships between victims and
offenders, the interactions between victims and the
criminal justice system — that is, the
police and
courts, and
corrections officials — and the connections between victims and
other social groups and institutions, such as the media,
businesses, and social movements. Victimology is however not
restricted to the study of victims of crime alone but may cater to
other forms of human rights violations that are not necessarily
crime.
Victim of a crime
In
criminology and
criminal law, a victim of a crime is an
identifiable person who has been harmed individually and directly
by the
perpetrator, rather than merely
the
society as a whole. However, this may
not always be the case, as with victims of
white collar crime, who may not be
clearly identifiable or directly linked to the crime. Victims of
white collar crime are often denied their status as victims by the
social construction of the concept (Croall, 2001). Not all
criminologists accept the concept of victimization or victimology.
It also remains a controversial topic within
women's studies.
The
United States
Supreme Court
first recognized the rights of crime victims to
make a victim impact
statement in the sentencing phase of
a criminal trial in the case of
Payne v.
Tennessee .
A
victim impact panel is a form
of community-based or
restorative
justice in which the crime victims (or relatives and friends of
deceased crime victims) meet with the defendant after conviction to
tell the convict about how the criminal activity affected them, in
the hope of
rehabilitation
or
deterrence.
Consequences of crimes
Emotional distress as the result
of crime is a recurring theme for all victims of crime. The most
common problem, affecting three quarters of victims, were
psychological problems, including: fear, anxiety, nervousness,
self-blame, anger, shame, and difficulty sleeping. These problems
often result in the development of chronic PTSD (post-traumatic
stress disorder). Post crime distress is also linked to
pre-existing emotional problems and sociodemographic variables.
This has known to become a leading case of the elderly to be more
adversely affected.
Victims may experience the following psychological reactions:
- Increase in the belief of personal vulnerability.
- The perception of the world as meaningless and
incomprehensible.
- The view of themselves in a negative light.
The experience of victimization may result in an increasing fear of
the victim of the crime, and the spread of fear in the
community.
Victimization
One of the most controversial sub-topics within the broader topic
is victimization. The concept of "victim-proneness" is a "highly
moralistic way of assigning
guilt" to the
victim of a crime, also known as
victim blaming.One theory, the
environmental theory, posits that the location and context
of the crime gets the victim of the crime and the perpetrator of
that crime together. That may just be an academic way of stating
that the victim and the perpetrator were in the wrong place at the
wrong time.
There have been some studies recently to quantify the real
existence of victim-proneness. Contrary to the
urban legend that more women are repeat
victims, and thus more victim-prone than men, actually men in their
prime (24 to 34 year old males) are more likely to be victims of
repeated crimes. While each study used different
methodology, their results must be taken
seriously and further studies are warranted.
The study of victimology may also include the "culture of
victimhood," wherein the victim of a crime revels in his status,
proclaiming that self-created victimhood throughout a community by
winning the sympathy of professionals and peers.
In the case of juvenile offenders, the study results also show that
people are more likely to be victimized as a result of a serious
offense by someone they know; the most frequent crimes committed by
adolescents towards someone they know were sexual assault, common
assault, and homicide. Adolescents victimizing people they did not
know generally committed common assault, forcible confinement,
armed robbery, and robbery
Examples
One particularly well known example of a class at increased risk to
varying forms of attacks is the prostitute. These people have been
known anecdotally to have an abnormally high incidence of violent
crime, and such crimes go frequently unresolved. Victimological
studies of the matter might investigate current societal mores
(expectations, roles, social status), legal status of prostitutes,
typical working/living conditions, statistical analysis of the
actual increased risk and secondary risk factors, and the economic
activity of a prostitute.
Another example of increased risk is in a situation that the victim
actively precipitates or initiates the crime scene, for example, by
starting a fight or
baiting another
individual.
Victim Facilitation
Victim facilitation, another controversial sub-topic, but a more
accepted theory than victim blaming, finds its roots in the
writings of criminologists Marvin Wolfgang. The choice to use
victim facilitation as opposed to “victim blaming” or some other
term is that victim facilitation is not blaming the victim, but
rather the interactions of the victim that make he/she vulnerable
to a crime.
While victim facilitation relates to “victim blaming” the idea
behind victim facilitation is to study the elements that make a
victim more accessible or vulnerable to an attack . In an article
that summarizes the major movements in victimology internationally,
Schneider expresses victim facilitation as a model that ultimately
describes only the misinterpretation of victim behavior of the
offender . It is based upon the theory of a symbolic interaction
and does not alleviate the offender of his/her exclusive
responsibility .
In Eric Hickey’s
Serial Murderers and their Vicitms, a
major analysis of 329
serial killers
in America is conducted. As part of Hickey’s analysis, he
categorized victims as high, low, or mixed regarding the victim’s
facilitation of the murder. Categorization was based upon lifestyle
risk (example, amount of time spent interacting with strangers),
type of employment, and their location at the time of the killing
(example, bar, home or place of business). Hickey found that 13-15%
of victims had high facilitation, 60-64% of victims had low
facilitation and 23-25% of victims had a combination of high and
low facilitation . Hickey also noted that among serial killer
victims after 1975, one in five victims placed themselves at risk
either by hitchhiking, working as a prostitute or involving
themselves in situations in which they often came into contact with
strangers .
There is importance in studying and understanding victim
facilitation as well as continuing to research it as a sub-topic of
victimization. For instance, a study of victim facilitation
increases public awareness, leads to more research on
victim-offender relationship, and advances theoretical etiologies
of
violent crime . One of the ultimate
purposes of this type of knowledge is to inform the public and
increase awareness so less people become victims. Another goal of
studying victim facilitation, as stated by Godwin, is to aid in
investigations. Godwin discusses the theory of victim social
networks as a concept in which one looks at the areas of highest
risk for victimization from a
serial
killer . This can be connected to victim facilitation because
the victim social networks are the locations in which the victim is
most vulnerable to the serial killer. Using this process,
investigators can create a profile of places where the serial
killer and victim both frequent.
Studies
The study of victims is multidisciplinary. It does not just cover
victims of crime, but also victims of (traffic) accidents, natural
disasters, war crimes and abuse of power. The professionals
involved in victimology may be scientists, practitioners and policy
makers. Studying victims can be done from the perspective of the
individual victim but also from an epidemiological point of
view.
Victimization rate in United States
The
National Crime
Victimization Survey (NCVS) is a tool to measure the existence
of actual, rather than reported crimes -- the victimization rate.
The
National Crime Victimization Survey is the United States
': "primary source of information on crime
victimization. Each year, data are obtained from a
nationally represented sample of 77,200 households comprising
nearly 134,000 persons on the frequency, characteristics and
consequences of criminal victimization in the United States. This
survey enables the (government) to estimate the likelihood of
victimization by
rape,
sexual assault,
robbery,
assault,
theft, household burglary, and motor vehicle theft for
the population as a whole as well as for segments of the population
such as women, the elderly, members of various racial groups, city
dwellers, or other groups." According to the
Bureau of Justice Statistics
(BJS), the NCVS reveals that, from 1994 to 2005, violent crime
rates have declined, reaching the lowest levels ever recorded.
Property crimes continue to decline.
International Crime Victims Survey
Many countries have such victimization surveys. They give a much
better account for the volume crimes but are less accurate for
crimes that occur with a (relative) low frequency such as homicide,
or victimless 'crimes' such as drug (ab)use. Attempts to use the
data from these national surveys for international comparison have
failed. Differences in definitions of crime and other
methodological differences are too big for proper comparison.
A dedicated survey for international comparison: A group of
European criminologists started an international victimization
study with the sole purpose to generate international comparative
crime and victimization data. The project is now known as the
International
Crime Victims Survey (ICVS). After the first round in
1989, the surveys were repeated in 1992, 1996, and 2000 and
2004/2005.
Society as crime victim
There is one strain of thought that society itself is the victim of
many crimes, especially such
homicide
felonies as
murder and
manslaughter. This sentiment has been
espoused by many lawyers, judges, and academics. Some
district attorneys feel they represent all
of society, while some feel they are the lawyer for the crime
victim.
Penal couple
The
penal couple is defined as the relationship between
perpetrator and victim of a crime. A sociologist invented the term
in 1963. The term is now accepted by many
sociologists. The concept is, essentially, that
"when a crime takes place, it has two partners, one the offender
and second the victim, who is providing opportunity to the criminal
in committing the crime." The victim, in this view, is "a
participant in the penal couple and should bear some 'functional
responsibility' for the crime." The very idea is strongly rejected
by some other victimologists as
blaming
the victim.
Rights of Victims
In 1985, the UN General Assembly adopted the
Declaration on the Basic Principles of Justice for Victims
of Crime and Abuse of Power. Also, the International
Victimology Institute (INTERVICT) and the
World Society of Victimology
developed a
draft UN Convention for Victims of Crime and Abuse
of Power.
See also
References
- Andrew Karman, 2003, Crime Victims: An Introduction to
Victimology, Wadsworth Publishing ,ISBN 9780534616328.
- Sebba, L., (1996). Third Parties, Victims and the Criminal
Justice System. Ohio State University Press, Columbus.
- Or victim-proneness. For an overview of victimization,
see Lucia Zedner's article at [1]
- Id., see [2]
- Harrison on the environmental theory, at Theory
- David Thissen (The University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas)
and Howard Wainer (Educational Testing Service,
Princeton, New Jersey), Toward the
Measurement and Prediction of Victim Proneness, Journal of
Research in Crime and Delinquency, Vol. 20, No. 2, 243-261 (1983),
abstract retrieved at [3]
- Johannes Kingma, Repeat Victimization of Victims of
Violence: A Retrospective Study From a Hospital Emergency
Department for the Period 1971-1995 Journal of Interpersonal
Violence, Vol. 14, No. 1, 79-90 (1999), abstract retrieved at
[4]
- See, e.g., [5]
- See [6], [7], [8].
- Richard Lusignan, "Risk Assessment and Offender-Victim
relationship in Juvenile Offenders" International Journal of
Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, Vol 51, No. 4,
433-443 (2007)
- One quarter or 25 % of all homicides have been historically
victim-precipitated. Id., see [9]
- Hickey, Eric W. (2006). The Male serial murderer. In Serial
murderers and their victims (4th ed., pp. 152-159). Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth Group
- Schneider, H. J. (2001). Victimological developments in the
world during the past three decades (I): A Study of comparative
victimology. International journal of offender therapy and
comparative criminology, 45, 449-468
- Schneider, H. J. (2001). Victimological developments in the
world during the past three decades (I): A Study of comparative
victimology. International journal of offender therapy and
comparative criminology, 45, 449-468
- Hickey, Eric W. (2006). Victims. In Serial murderers and their
victims (4th ed., pp. 260-262). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Group
- Hickey, Eric W. (2006). Victims. In Serial murderers and their
victims (4th ed., pp. 260-262). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Group
- Miethe, Terance D. (1985). The Myth or reality of victim
involvement in crime: A Review and comment on victim-precipitation
research. Sociological focus, 18(3), 209- 220
- Godwin, Maurice (1998). Victim target networks as solvability
factors in serial murder. Social behavioral and personality, 26(1),
75-84
- National Crime Victimization Survey Official web
site
- "Criminology Today" (4th ed. Prentice Hall), found at Criminal Justice Glossary at the Prentice Hall
website. Retrieved April 1, 2009.
- Robert Harris, Crime, criminal justice, and the probation
service, (Routledge, 1992) ISBN 9780415050340, at 56 (citing
Mendelsohn 1963), found at Google Books. Retrieved April 1, 2009.
- Pawanjit, "Hiring Domestic Help Without Verification,"
Premier Shield Newsletter, found at Premier Shield Newsletter (pdf). Retrieved April 1,
2009.
- M. C. Sengstock & J. Liang, "Elderly Victims of Crime - A
Refinement of Theory in Victimology," (AARP study 1979), found at Natioonal Criminal Justice Reference service
(NCJRS) Abstracts - a United States government website.
Retrieved April 1, 2009.
- Daniel W. Van Ness, Crime and its victims: what we can
do, (InterVarsity Press, 1986) ISBN 9780877845126 at 29, found
at Google Books. Retrieved April 1, 2009.
External links