The
West Bank ( , ) ( , HaGadah HaMa'aravit)
is a landlocked territory and is the
eastern part of the Palestinian territories
; on the west bank of the River Jordan
in the Middle
East. To the west, north, and south, the West Bank
shares borders with the state of Israel
, which
maintains the security of what it calls the Judea and Samaria Area. To the
east, across the Jordan River, lies the country of Jordan.
The West
Bank also contains a significant coastline along the western bank
of the Dead
Sea
. Since 1967, most of the West Bank has been
under
Israeli military
occupation.
Prior to the
First World War, the
area now known as the West Bank was under
Ottoman rule as part of the province of
Syria. At the 1920
San Remo
conference, the victorious Allied powers allocated the area to
the
British Mandate of
Palestine which included modern day Jordan and Israel.
The
1948 Arab-Israeli War saw the
establishment of Israel in parts of the former Mandate, while the
territory known as the "West Bank" area was captured by Trans-Jordan
. Since it then controlled the territory on
both sides of the Jordan river, Trans-Jordan
renamed itself Jordan
in
1949. The
1949
Armistice Agreements defined its interim boundary. From 1948
until 1967, the area was
under
Jordanian rule, and Jordan did not officially relinquish its
claim to the area until 1988.
Jordan's claim was never recognized by the
international community, with the exception of the United Kingdom
. The West Bank was taken control of by
Israel, during the
Six-Day War in June,
1967. With the exception of
East
Jerusalem, the West Bank was not
annexed by Israel. Most of the residents are
Arabs, although a large number of
Israeli settlements have been built in
the region since 1967.
The West Bank has a land area of 5,640 square kilometers (including
East Jerusalem).
Origin of the name

Arab homes from Jerusalem
West Bank
The region
did not have a separate existence until 1948–1949, when it was
defined by the Armistice
Agreement of April 1949 between Israel and Jordan (until then
known as Transjordan
). The name "West Bank" was apparently first
used by Jordanians at the time of their
annexation of the region in 1950, and has become
the most common name used in
English and some of the other Germanic
languages.
The term was used in order to differentiate
'the West bank of the river Jordan', namely the newly annexed
territory; from the "East
Bank
", namely the East bank of this same River Jordan
(Transjordan
), which today constitutes the present territory of
the Kingdom of Jordan.
Cisjordan
The neo-
Latin name
Cisjordan or
Cis-Jordan (literally
"on this side of the [River] Jordan") is the usual name in the
Romance languages and
Hungarian.
The analogous
Transjordan
has historically been used to designate the
region now comprising the state of Jordan which lies on the "other
side" of the River
Jordan
. In English, the name Cisjordan is
also occasionally used to designate the entire region between the
Jordan
River
and the Mediterranean Sea
, particularly in the historical context of the
British Mandate and earlier times. The use of
Cisjordan to refer to the smaller region discussed in this
article, while common in scholarly fields including archaeology, is
rare in general English usage; the name
West Bank is
standard usage for this geo-political entity. For the low-lying
area immediately west of the Jordan, the name
Jordan
Valley is used instead.
History
The
territory now known as the West Bank was a part of the British Mandate of Palestine
entrusted to the United
Kingdom
by the League of
Nations after World War I.
The terms of the Mandate called for the creation in Palestine of a
Jewish national home without prejudicing the civil and religious
rights of the non-Jewish population of Palestine.
During that time the
area was called by the historic names of its two regions – Judea
and Samaria
.
The current
border of the West Bank
was not a dividing line of any sort during the
Mandate period, but rather the
armistice line between the forces of the neighboring kingdom of
Jordan and those of Israel at the close of the 1948 Arab-Israeli War. When the
United Nations General Assembly voted in 1947 to
partition
Palestine into a Jewish State, an Arab State, and an
internationally administered enclave of
Jerusalem, a more broad region of the modern-day West Bank was
assigned to the Arab State.
The West Bank was controlled by Iraqi and Jordanian forces at the end of
the 1948 War and the area was annexed by Jordan in 1950 but this
annexation was recognized only by the United Kingdom
(Pakistan
is often, but apparently falsely, assumed to have
recognized it also). The idea of an independent Palestinian
state was not on the table.
King
Abdullah of Jordan was crowned King of Jerusalem and granted
Palestinian Arabs in the West Bank and East Jerusalem Jordanian
citizenship.
During the 1950s, there was a significant
influx of Palestinian
refugees and violence together with
Israeli
reprisal raids across the "Green Line".
In May
1967 Egypt ordered out U.N. peacekeeping troops and re-militarized
the Sinai
peninsula
, and
blockaded the straits
of Tiran
. Fearing an Egyptian attack, the government
of
Levi Eshkol attempted to restrict any
confrontation to Egypt alone. In particular it did whatever it
could to avoid fighting Jordan. However, "carried along by a
powerful current of Arab nationalism", on May 30, 1967
King Hussein flew to Egypt and signed a mutual
defense treaty in which the two countries agreed to consider "any
armed attack on either state or its forces as an attack on both".
Fearing an imminent Egyptian attack, on June 5, the Israel Defense
Forces launched a pre-emptive attack on Egypt which began what came
to be known as the
Six Day War.
Jordan
soon began shelling targets in west Jerusalem, Netanya
, and the outskirts of Tel Aviv
. Despite this, Israel sent a message
promising not to initiate any action against Jordan if it stayed
out of the war. Hussein replied that it was too late, "
the die was cast".
On the evening of
June 5 the Israeli cabinet convened to decide what to do; Yigal Allon and Menahem
Begin argued that this was an opportunity to take the Old City of
Jerusalem
, but Eshkol decided to defer any decision until
Moshe Dayan and Yitzhak Rabin could be consulted.
Uzi Narkis made a number of proposals for
military action, including the capture of Latrun
, but the
cabinet turned him down. The Israeli military only commenced
action after
Government
House was captured, which was seen as a threat to the security
of Jerusalem. On June 6 Dayan encircled the city, but, fearing
damage to holy places and having to fight in built-up areas, he
ordered his troops not to go in. However, upon hearing that the
U.N. was about to declare a ceasefire, he changed his mind, and
without cabinet clearance, decided to take the city. After fierce
fighting with Jordanian troops in and around the Jerusalem area,
Israel captured the Old City on 7 June.
No specific decision had been made to capture any other territories
controlled by Jordan. After the Old City was captured, Dayan told
his troops to dig in to hold it.
When an armored brigade commander entered
the West Bank on his own initiative, and stated that he could see
Jericho
, Dayan ordered him back. However, when
intelligence reports indicated that Hussein had withdrawn his
forces across the Jordan river, Dayan ordered his troops to capture
the West Bank. Over the next two days, the IDF swiftly captured the
rest of the West Bank and blew up the Abdullah and Hussein Bridges
over the Jordan, thereby severing the West Bank from the East.
According to Narkis:
First, the Israeli government had no intention of
capturing the West Bank.
On the contrary, it was opposed to it.
Second, there was not any provocation on the part of
the IDF.
Third, the rein was only loosened when a real threat to
Jerusalem's security emerged.
This is truly how things happened on June 5, although
it is difficult to believe.
The end result was something that no one had
planned.
The
Arab League's
Khartoum conference in September
declared continuing belligerency, and stated the league's
principles of "no peace with Israel, no recognition of Israel, no
negotiations with it". In November 1967,
UN Security Council
Resolution 242 was unanimously adopted, calling for "the
establishment of a just and lasting peace in the Middle East" to be
achieved by "the application of both the following principles:"
"Withdrawal of Israeli armed forces from territories occupied in
the recent conflict" (see
semantic
dispute) and: "Termination of all claims or states of
belligerency" and respect for the right of every state in the area
to live in peace within secure and recognised boundaries.Egypt,
Jordan, Israel and Lebanon entered into consultations with the UN
Special representative over the implementation of 242. The text did
not refer to the PLO or to any Palestinian representative because
none was recognized at that time.
In 1988, Jordan ceded its claims to the West Bank to the
Palestine Liberation
Organization, as "the sole legitimate representative of the
Palestinian people."
Administration
The 1993
Oslo Accords declared the final status
of the West Bank to be subject to a forthcoming settlement between
Israel
and the Palestinian leadership. Following
these interim accords, Israel withdrew its military rule from some
parts of the West Bank, which was divided into three areas:
| Area |
Control |
Administration |
% of WB
land |
% of WB
Palestinians |
| A |
Palestinian |
Palestinian |
17% |
55% |
| B |
Israeli |
Palestinian |
24% |
41% |
| C |
Israeli |
Israeli |
59% |
4% |
Area A
comprises Palestinian towns, and some rural areas away from Israeli
population centers in the north (between Jenin
, Nablus
, Tubas
, and
Tulkarm
), the south (around Hebron
), and one in
the center south of Salfit
. Area
B adds other populated rural areas, many closer to the center of
the West Bank.
Area C contains all the Israeli settlements, roads used to
access the settlements, buffer zones (near settlements, roads,
strategic areas, and Israel), and almost all of the Jordan Valley and Judean Desert
.
Areas A and B are themselves divided among 227 separate areas (199
of which are smaller than ) that are separated from one another by
Israeli-controlled Area C.
Areas A, B, and C cross the 11
Governorates
used as administrative divisions by the
Palestinian National
Authority and named after major cities.
While the vast majority of the Palestinian population lives in
areas A and B, the vacant land available for construction in dozens
of villages and towns across the West Bank is situated on the
margins of the communities and defined as area C.
The
Palestinian Authority has full civil control in area A, area B is
characterized by joint-administration between the PA and Israel
, while area
C is under full Israeli control. Israel maintains overall
control over
Israeli settlements,
roads, water, airspace, "external" security and borders for the
entire territory.
An assessment by the UN
Office for
the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs in 2007 found that
approximately 40% of the West Bank was taken up by Israeli
infrastructure. The infrastructure, comprised of
settlements, the
barrier, military bases and closed
military areas, Israeli declared nature reserves and the roads that
accompany them is off-limits or tightly controlled to
Palestinians.
Demographics
.jpg/250px-On_the_road_to_Jericho_(481885917).jpg)
Palestinian resident on the road to
Jericho
In December 2007, an official Census conducted by the Palestinian
Authority found that the Palestinian population of the West Bank
(including Israeli-occupied
East
Jerusalem) was 2,345,000.
There are over 290,000
Israeli
settlers living in the West Bank, as well as around 200,000
living in Israeli-annexed
East
Jerusalem.
There are also small ethnic groups, such as
the Samaritans living in and around
Nablus
, numbering
in the hundreds. Interactions between the two societies have
generally declined following the Palestinian First Intifada and Second Intifada, though an economic
relationship often exists between adjacent Israeli
and Palestinian Arab villages.
As of October 2007, around 23,000 Palestinians in the West Bank
work in Israel every day with another 9,200 working in Israeli
settlements. In addition, around 10,000 Palestinian traders from
the West Bank are allowed to travel every day into Israel.
Approximately 30% of Palestinians living in the West Bank are
refugees or descendants of
refugees from villages and towns located in what became Israel
during the
1948 Arab-Israeli
War (see
Palestinian exodus),
754,263 in June 2008 according to
UNRWA
statistics.
Significant population centers
Significant population centers
| Center |
Population |
Al-Bireh |
40,000 |
Betar Illit |
29,355 |
Bethlehem |
30,000 |
Gush Etzion |
40,000 |
Hebron
(al-Khalil) |
120,000 |
Jericho (Ariha) |
25,000 |
Jenin |
60,000 |
Ma'ale Adummim |
33,259 |
Modi'in Illit |
34,514 |
Nablus |
135,000 |
Qalqilyah |
40,000 |
Ramallah |
23,000 |
Tulkarm |
46,000 |
Yattah |
42,000 |
The most
densely populated part of the region is a mountainous spine,
running north-south, where the Palestinian
cities of Nablus
, Ramallah
, al-Bireh
, Abu
Dis
, Bethlehem
, Hebron
and Yattah
are located
as well as the Israeli
settlements of Ariel, Ma'ale Adumim
and Betar
Illit
. Ramallah, although relatively small in
population compared to other major cities, serves as an economic
and political center for the Palestinians.
Jenin
in the
extreme north of the West Bank is on the southern edge of the
Jezreel
Valley
. Modi'in Illit
, Qalqilyah
and Tulkarm
are in the low foothills adjacent to the Israeli Coastal Plain, and Jericho
and Tubas
are situated
in the Jordan Valley,
north of the Dead
Sea
.
Transportation and communication
Roads
The West Bank has of roads, of which are paved.
In response to shootings by Palestinians, some highways, especially
those leading to
Israeli
settlements, were completely inaccessible to cars with
Palestinian license plates, while many other roads were restricted
only to public transportation and to Palestinians who have special
permits from Israeli authorities.Due to numerous shooting
assaults targeting Israeli vehicles, the
IDF bars Israelis from using most of
the original roads in the West Bank. Israel's longstanding policy
of separation dictates the development of alternative highway
systems for Israelis and Palestinian traffic.
At certain times, Israel maintained more than 600 checkpoints or
roadblocks in the region.As such, movement restrictions were also
placed on main roads traditionally used by Palestinians to travel
between cities, and such restrictions are still blamed for poverty
and economic depression in the West Bank. Since the beginning of
2005, there has been some amelioration of these restrictions.
According to reports, "Israel has made efforts to improve transport
contiguity for Palestinians travelling in the West Bank. It has
done this by constructing underpasses and bridges (28 of which have
been constructed and 16 of which are planned) that link Palestinian
areas separated from each other by Israeli settlements and bypass
roads" and by removal of checkpoints and physical obstacles, or by
not reacting to Palestinian removal or natural erosion of other
obstacles. "The impact (of these actions) is most felt by the
easing of movement between villages and between villages and the
urban centres".
However, some obstacles encircling major Palestinian urban hubs,
particularly Nablus and Hebron, have remained. In addition, the
IDF prohibits Israeli citizens
from entering Palestinian-controlled land (Area A).
, a divided highway is currently under construction that will pass through the West Bank. The highway has a concrete wall dividing the two sides, one designated for Israeli vehicles, the other for Palestinian. The wall is designed to allow Palestinians to freely pass north-south through Israeli-held land.
Airports
The West Bank has three paved airports which are currently for
military use only.
Palestinians were previously able to use
Israel's Ben Gurion International
Airport
with permission; however, Israel has discontinued
issuing such permits, and Palestinians wishing to travel must cross
the land border to either Jordan
(via the
Allenby
Bridge
) or Egypt
in order to
use airports located in these countries.
Telecom
As transportation between the Palestinian cities became very
difficult, due to hundreds of Israeli military checkpoints on
Palestinian roads, telephone and internet play a more important
role in the Palestinian daily life for communication.
The Palestinian
PalTel Group
telecommunication companies provide communication services in the
West Bank, such as
landline,
cellular network and
Internet.
Dialling
code +970 is used in the West Bank and all over
Palestinian
territories
within Palestinian
Authority.
The Palestinian mobile market was until 2007 monopolized by
Jawwal, and a new
mobile operator is expected to launch in
2009 under the name of
Wataniya
Telecom in
Palestine. As the number of
internet users is increasing rapidly (160,000 users in 2005)
Numerous Palestinian websites are growing to helping the
Palestinians communicate and trade through the internet like:
News agencies
Market
Radio and television
The
Palestinian
Broadcasting Corporation broadcasts from an AM station in
Ramallah on 675 kHz; numerous local privately owned stations
are also in operation. Most Palestinian households have a radio and
TV, and satellite dishes for receiving international coverage are
widespread. Recently, PalTel announced and has begun implementing
an initiative to provide ADSL broadband internet service to all
households and businesses.
Israel's
cable television company
'HOT', satellite television provider
(
DBS)
'Yes', AM and FM radio broadcast stations and
public television broadcast stations all operate. Broadband
internet service by Bezeq's ADSL and by the cable company are
available as well.
The
Al-Aqsa Voice broadcasts from Dabas
Mall in Tulkarem
at 106.7 FM. The
Al-Aqsa TV station shares these offices.
Higher education
There
were a few lesser institutions of higher education; for example,
An-Najah
, which started as an elementary school in 1918 and
became a community college in 1963. As the Jordanian
government did not allow the establishment of such universities in
the West Bank, Palestinians could obtain degrees only by travelling
abroad to places such as Jordan, Lebanon, or Europe.
After the region was captured by Israel in the
Six-Day War, several educational institutions
began offering undergraduate courses, while others opened up as
entirely new universities. In total, seven Universities have been
commissioned in the West Bank since 1967:
- Bethlehem University
, a Roman Catholic
institution partially funded by the Vatican, opened its doors in 1973 [5922].
- In
1924, Birzeit College (located in the town of Bir Zeit
north of Ramallah
) became Birzeit University
after adding third- and fourth-year college-level
programs [5923].
- An-Najah College in Nablus
likewise
became An-Najah National University
in 1977 [5924].
- The Hebron University was
established in 1980 [5925]
- Al-Quds University
, whose founders had yearned to establish a
university in Jerusalem since the early days of Jordanian rule,
finally realized their goal in 1995 [5926].
- Also
in 1995, after the signing of the Oslo
Accords, the Arab American University
—the only private university in the West Bank—was
founded right outside of Zababdeh
, with the purpose of providing courses according to
the American system of
education [5927].
- In
2005, the Israeli government recommended to upgrade the College of Judea and Samaria in
Ariel
to become
a full fledged university [5928]. This move to create a university
within an Israeli settlement has
angered some Palestinians, although no official response was made
by the Palestinian authority.
- The
Hebrew
University of Jerusalem
, established in 1918, is one of Israel's oldest,
largest, and most important institutes of higher learning and
research. During the 1948
Arab-Israeli War, the leader of the Palestinian forces in
Jerusalem, Abdul Kader
Husseini, threatened that the Hadassah Hospital and the Hebrew
University would be captured or destroyed "if the Jews continued to
use them as bases for attacks". Medical convoys between the
Yishuv-controlled section of Jerusalem and Mount Scopus were
attacked since December 1947. After the Hadassah medical convoy
massacre in 1948, which also included university staff, the
Mount Scopus campus was cut off from the Jewish part of Jerusalem.
After the War, the University was forced to relocate to a new
campus in Givat Ram in western Jerusalem. After Israel captured
East Jerusalem in the Six-Day War of June 1967, the University
returned to its original campus in Mount Scopus. [Note that Mount
Scopus is technically not part of the West Bank as it is an
internationally recognized Israeli enclave within the West
Bank].
Most universities in the West Bank have politically active student
bodies, and elections of student council officers are normally
along party affiliations. Although the establishment of the
universities was initially allowed by the Israeli authorities, some
were sporadically ordered closed by the Israeli Civil
Administration during the 1970s and 1980s to prevent political
activities and violence against the
IDF. Some universities remained closed
by military order for extended periods during years immediately
preceding and following the first Palestinian Intifada, but have
largely remained open since the signing of the Oslo Accords despite
the advent of the Al-Aqsa Intifada (Second Intifada) in 2000.
The founding of Palestinian universities has greatly increased
education levels among the population in the West Bank. According
to a Birzeit University study, the percentage of Palestinians
choosing local universities as opposed to foreign institutions has
been steadily increasing; as of 1997, 41% of Palestinians with
bachelor degrees had obtained them from Palestinian institutions.
According to UNESCO, Palestinians are one of the most highly
educated groups in the Middle East "despite often difficult
circumstances". The literacy rate among Palestinians in the West
Bank (and Gaza) (89%) is third highest in the region after Israel
(95%) and Jordan (90%).
Religion
The Muslim community makes up 75 percent of the population,
while 17 percent of the population practice
Judaism and the other 8 percent of the
population are
Christian.
Status
Legal status
The
United Nations Security
Council, the United
Nations General Assembly, the International Court of
Justice
, and the International Committee
of the Red Cross refer to it as occupied by
Israel.
According to
Alan Dowty," ... legally the
status of the West Bank falls under the international law of
belligerent occupation, as
distinguished from nonbelligerent occupation that follows an
armistice. This assumes the possibility of renewed fighting, and
affords the occupier "broad leeway". The West Bank has a unique
status in two respects; first, there is no precedent for a
belligerent occupation lasting for more than a brief period, and
second, that the West Bank was not part of a sovereign country
before occupation—thus, in legal terms, there is no "reversioner"
for the West Bank. This means that sovereignty of the West Bank is
currently suspended, and, according to some, Israel, as the only
successor state to the Palestine Mandate, has a status that "goes
beyond that of military occupier alone."
The current status arises from the facts (see above reference) that
Great Britain surrendered its mandate in 1948 and Jordan
relinquished its claim in 1988. Since the area has never in modern
times been an independent state, there is no "legitimate" claimant
to the area other than the present occupier, which currently
happens to be Israel. This argument however is not accepted by the
international community and international lawmaking bodies,
virtually all of whom regard Israel's activities in the West Bank
and Gaza as an occupation that denies the fundamental principle of
self-determination found in the Article One of the
United Nations Charter, and in the
International
Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the
International
Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Further, UN
Security Council Resolution 242 notes the "inadmissibility of the
acquisition of territory by war" regardless of whether the war in
which the territory was acquired was offensive or defensive.
Prominent Israeli human rights organizations such as
B'tselem also refer to the Israeli control of the
West Bank and Gaza as an occupation.
John Quigley has noted that "...a
state that uses force in self-defense may not retain territory it
takes while repelling an attack. If Israel had acted in
self-defense, that would not justify its retention of the Gaza
Strip and West Bank. Under the UN Charter there can lawfully be no
territorial gains from war, even by a state acting in self-defense.
The response of other states to Israel's occupation shows a
virtually unanimous opinion that even if Israel's action were
defensive, its retention of the West Bank and Gaza Strip was
not."
Political positions
The
future status of the West Bank, together with the Gaza Strip
on the Mediterranean shore, has been the subject of
negotiation between the Palestinians and Israelis, although the
current Road Map for Peace,
proposed by the "Quartet"
comprising the United
States
, Russia
, the
European Union, and the United Nations, envisions an independent
Palestinian state in these territories living side by side with
Israel
(see also proposals for a Palestinian
state). However, the "Road Map" states that in the first
phase, Palestinians must end all attacks on Israel, whereas Israel
must dismantle outposts. Since neither condition has been met since
the Road Map was "accepted," by all sides, final negotiations have
not yet begun on major political differences.
The Palestinian Authority believes that the West Bank ought to be a
part of their sovereign
nation, and that the
presence of Israeli military control is a violation of their right
to Palestinian Authority rule. The
United
Nations calls the West Bank and Gaza Strip
Israeli-occupied (see
Israeli-occupied territories).
The
United
States
State Department also refers to the territories as
occupied. Many Israelis and their supporters prefer
the term
disputed
territories, because they claim part of the territory for
themselves, and state the land has not, in 2000 years, been
sovereign.
Israel argues that its presence is justified because:
- Israel's eastern border has never been defined by anyone;
- The disputed territories have not been part of any
state (Jordanian annexation was never officially recognized) since
the time of the Ottoman Empire;
- According to the Camp David Accords with Egypt
, the 1994
agreement with Jordan
and the
Oslo Accords with the PLO, the final status of the territories would be fixed
only when there was a permanent agreement between Israel and the
Palestinians.
Palestinian public opinion opposes Israeli military and settler
presence on the West Bank as a violation of their right to
statehood and sovereignty. Israeli opinion is split into a number
of views:
- Complete or partial withdrawal from the West Bank in hopes of
peaceful coexistence in separate states (sometimes called the
"land for peace" position);
(According to a 2003 poll 76% of Israelis support a peace agreement
based on that principle).
- Maintenance of a military presence in the West Bank to reduce
Palestinian terrorism by
deterrence or by armed intervention, while relinquishing some
degree of political control;
- Annexation of the West Bank while
considering the Palestinian population as (for instance) citizens
of Jordan with Israeli residence permit as per the Elon Peace Plan;
- Annexation of the West Bank and assimilation of the Palestinian
population to fully fledged Israeli citizens;
- Transfer of the East
Jerusalem Palestinian population (a 2002 poll at the height of the
Al Aqsa intifada found 46% of Israelis favoring Palestinian
transfer of Jerusalem residents; in 2005 two polls using a
different methodology put the number at approximately 30%).
Annexation

Principal geographical features of
Israel and south-eastern Mediterranean region
Israel annexed the territory of
East
Jerusalem, and its Palestinian residents (if they should
decline Israeli citizenship) have legal
permanent residency status. Although
permanent residents are permitted, if they wish, to receive Israeli
citizenship if they meet certain conditions including swearing
allegiance to the State and renouncing any other citizenship, most
Palestinians did not apply for Israeli citizenship for political
reasons. There are various possible reasons as to why the West Bank
had not been annexed to Israel after its
capture in 1967. The government of Israel has
not formally confirmed an official reason, however, historians and
analysts have established a variety of such, most of them
demographic. Among those most commonly cited have been:
- Reluctance to award its citizenship to an overwhelming number
of a potentially hostile population whose allies were sworn to the
destruction of Israel
- To ultimately exchange land for
peace with neighbouring states
- Fear that the population of ethnic Arabs, including Israeli
citizens of Palestinian ethnicity, would outnumber the Jewish
Israelis west of the Jordan River.
The importance of demographic concerns to some significant figures
in Israel's leadership was illustrated when
Avraham Burg, a former Knesset Speaker and
former chair of the Jewish Agency for Israel, wrote in
The
Guardian in September 2003,
- "Between the Jordan and the Mediterranean there is no longer a
clear Jewish majority. And so, fellow citizens, it is not possible
to keep the whole thing without paying a price. We cannot keep a
Palestinian majority under an Israeli boot and at the same time
think ourselves the only democracy in the Middle East. There cannot
be democracy without equal rights for all who live here, Arab as
well as Jew. We cannot keep the territories and preserve a Jewish
majority in the world's only Jewish state - not by means that are
humane and moral and Jewish."
Settlements and international law
Israeli settlements on the West Bank beyond the Green Line border
are considered by the
United Nation
among others to be illegal under international law. Other legal
scholars including
Julius Stone, have
argued that the settlements are legal under international law, on a
number of different grounds.
The Independent reported in
March 2006 that immediately after the 1967 war
Theodor Meron, legal counsel of Israel's
Foreign Ministry advised Israeli ministers in a "top secret" memo
that any policy of building settlements across occupied territories
violated international law and would "contravene the explicit
provisions of the Fourth Geneva Convention". A contrasting opinion
was held by
Eugene Rostow, a former
Dean of the Yale Law School and undersecretary of state for
political affairs in the administration of U.S. President Lyndon
Johnson, who wrote in 1991 that Israel has a right to have
settlements in the West Bank under 1967's UN Security Council
Resolution 242. The European Union and the Arab League consider the
settlements to be illegal. Israel also recognizes that some small
settlements are "illegal" in the sense of being in violation of
Israeli law.
In 2005 the United States ambassador to Israel, Dan Kurtzer,
expressed U.S. support "for the retention by Israel of major
Israeli population centres [in the West Bank] as an outcome of
negotiations", reflecting President Bush's statement a year earlier
that a permanent peace treaty would have to reflect "demographic
realities" on the West Bank.
The UN Security Council has issued several non-binding resolutions
addressing the issue of the settlements. Typical of these is UN
Security Council resolution 446 which states
[the] practices of
Israel in establishing settlements in the Palestinian and other
Arab territories occupied since 1967 have no legal validity,
and it calls on Israel
as the occupying Power, to abide
scrupulously by the 1949 Fourth
Geneva Convention.
The Conference of High Contracting Parties to the Fourth Geneva
Convention held in Geneva on 5 December 2001 called upon "the
Occupying Power to fully and effectively respect the Fourth Geneva
Convention in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East
Jerusalem, and to refrain from perpetrating any violation of the
Convention." The High Contracting Parties reaffirmed "the
illegality of the settlements in the said territories and of the
extension thereof."
On December 30, 2007,
Israeli
Prime Minister Ehud Olmert issued an
order requiring approval by both the Israeli Prime Minister and
Israeli Defense Minister of all settlement activities (including
planning) in the West Bank.
West Bank barrier
The
Israeli West Bank barrier
is a physical barrier being
constructed by Israel
, consisting
of a network of fences with vehicle-barrier trenches surrounded by
an on average wide exclusion area (90%) and up to high concrete
walls (10%) (although in most areas the wall is not nearly that
high). It is located mainly within the West Bank,
partly along the 1949
Armistice line, or "Green Line
" between the West Bank and Israel. As of
April 2006 the length of the barrier as approved by the Israeli
government is 703 kilometers (436 miles) long. Approximately 58.4%
has been constructed, 8.96% is under construction, and construction
has not yet begun on 33% of the barrier. The space between the
barrier and the green line is a closed military zone known as the
Seam Zone, cutting off 8.5% of the West
Bank and encompassing tens of villages and tens of thousands of
Palestinians..
The
barrier generally runs along or near the 1949 Jordanian-Israeli
armistice/Green Line, but diverges in many places to include on the
Israeli side several of the highly populated areas of Jewish
settlements in the West Bank such as East
Jerusalem, Ariel, Gush Etzion
, Emmanuel, Karnei
Shomron
, Givat
Ze'ev
, Oranit
, and
Maale
Adumim
.
The barrier is a very controversial project. Supporters claim the
barrier is a necessary tool protecting Israeli civilians from the
Palestinian attacks that increased significantly during the Al-Aqsa
Intifada; it has helped reduce incidents of terrorism by 90% from
2002 to 2005; over a 96% reduction in terror attacks in the six
years ending in 2007, though Israel's State Comptroller has
acknowledged that most of the suicide bombers crossed into Israel
through existing checkpoints
[5929]. Its supporters claim that the
onus is now on the Palestinian Authority to fight
terrorism.
Opponents claim the barrier is an illegal attempt to annex
Palestinian land under the guise of security, violates
international law, has the intent or effect to pre-empt final
status negotiations, and severely restricts Palestinians who live
nearby, particularly their ability to travel freely within the West
Bank and to access work in Israel, thereby undermining their
economy. According to a 2007
World Bank
report, the Israeli occupation of the West Bank has destroyed the
Palestinian economy, in violation of the 2005
Agreement on Movement and
Access. All major roads (with a total length of 700 km)
are basically off-limits to Palestinians, making it impossible to
do normal business. Economic recovery would reduce Palestinian
dependence on international aid by one billion dollars per
year.
Pro-settler opponents claim that the barrier is a sly attempt to
artificially create a border that excludes the settlers, creating
"
facts on the ground" that
justify the mass dismantlement of hundreds of settlements and
displacement of over 100,000 Jews from the land they claim as their
biblical homeland.
Notes
See also
References
- Albin, Cecilia (2001). Justice and Fairness in
International Negotiation. Cambridge University Press. ISBN
0-521-79725-X
- Bamberger, David (1985, 1994). A Young Person's History of
Israel. Behrman House. ISBN 0-87441-393-1
- Dowty, Alan (2001). The Jewish State: A Century Later.
University of California Press. ISBN 0520229118
- Oren, Michael (2002). Six Days
of War, Oxford University Press. ISBN 0195151747
- Gibney, Mark and Frankowski, Stanislaw (1999). Judicial
Protection of Human Rights. Praeger/Greenwood. ISBN
0-275-96011-0
- Playfair, Emma (Ed.) (1992). International Law and the
Administration of Occupied Territories. Oxford University
Press. ISBN 0-19-825297-8
- Shlaim, Avi (2000). The Iron
Wall: Israel and the Arab World, W. W. Norton & Company.
ISBN 0393048160
- Howell, Mark (2007). What Did We Do to Deserve This?
Palestinian Life under Occupation in the West Bank, Garnet
Publishing. ISBN 1859641954
- Gorenberg, Gershom. "The Accidental Empire". Times Books, Henry
Holt and Company. ISBN 0-8050-8241-7. 2006.
External links