The
Workers Party of Ireland (in Irish Páirtí na nOibrithe, though
its logo translates it erroneously as Pairti Na nOibri),
is a left-wing republican
political party in Ireland
. The
party evolved from
Official Sinn Féin, which
emerged from the
split in Sinn
Féin in 1970. In the past the party had close links to the
Official IRA.
Origins
The modern origins of the party can be found in the early 1960s.
After the failure of the
then IRA's 1956-62
"
Border Campaign" the
republican movement, with a new military and political leadership,
undertook a complete reappraisal of its raison d'être. Under the
guidance of figures such as
Cathal
Goulding and
Sean Garland, the
leadership of both Sinn Féin and the IRA sought to shift their
emphasis away from the traditional republican goal of a 32 County
Irish Republic
redeemed (since Republicans regard the
republic declared in 1916 as still in existence and the Anglo-Irish
Treaty as invalid) by military action and concentrate more on
socialism and civil rights related activities. In doing so they
gradually abandoned the military focus that had previously
characterised republicanism. The leadership were substantially
influenced by a group who had been active in the
Communist Party of Great
Britain's
Connolly
Association. In their analysis, the primary obstacle to
Irish unity was the continuing division
between the Protestant and Catholic working classes. This they
attributed to the 'divide and rule' policies of Capital, whose
interests a divided working class served. Military activity was
seen as counterproductive since its effect (whatever the intent)
was to further entrench the sectarian divisions. If the working
classes could be united in class struggle to overthrow their common
rulers, a 32 county socialist republic would be the inevitable
outcome.
This Marxist outlook became unpopular with many more traditionalist
republicans, and the party/army leadership was criticized for
failing to defend northern Catholic enclaves from
loyalist attacks. [These debates were held
against the background of
the
violent beginning of what were to become
The Troubles].
A growing minority within the
rank-and-file wanted to maintain traditional militarist policies
aimed at ending British rule in Northern Ireland
. A
troika consisting
of
Seán Mac Stiofáin,
Dáithí Ó Conaill and
Seamus Twomey together with others
established themselves as a "Provisional Army Council" in 1969 in
anticipation of a contentious 1970 Sinn Féin Árd Fheis. In this Árd
Fheis, the leadership of Sinn Féin failed to attain the
prerequisite two thirds majority necessary to change the party's
constitutional opposition to partitionist assemblies such as
Dáil Éireann. The debate was
charged with allegations of vote rigging and expulsions. When the
Conference went on nevertheless to pass a vote of confidence in the
official Army Council (which had already approved an end
to the absention policy)
Ruairí Ó Brádaigh led the
minority in a walk out. This group aligned themselves with the
'Provisional Army Council' and immediately became tagged by the
media as
Provisional Sinn
Féin, with the remaining majority becoming known as
Official Sinn Féin. Each rejected the tag,
preferring to indentify themselves by the location of their head
office, Kevin Street and Gardiner Place respectively. The name of
the ('official') party remained Sinn Féin until changed to
Sinn Féin the Workers Party in 1977.
The majority
Official IRA, under the
leadership of
Tomás Mac
Giolla, aligned itself to Goulding's Official Sinn Féin. The
minority, those supportive of
Seán Mac Stiofáin's "Provisional
Army Council", endeavoured to achieve a
united Ireland by force As
the Troubles escalated, this "Provisional Army
Council" would come to command the loyalty of the IRA national
organisation save for a few isolated instances (that of the IRA
Company of the Lower Falls road, Belfast under the command of
Billy McMillen and other small units
in Derry, Newry Dublin and Wicklow), and eventually become accepted
by the media as simply 'the IRA'.
The split of 1970 was not necessarily one between
Marxist-orientated innovators and Catholic-orientated
traditionalists. A key factor in the split was the desire of what
became the Provisionals to make military action the key object of
the organisation, rather than a simple rejection of leftism. On the
other hand, conservatives in the Republic of Ireland sought to use
their power and influence (such as through the
covert supply of weapons from elements of the
Fianna Fáil government of Ireland)
to dissipate the influence of the Marxists.
Political development
Although
the Official IRA was drawn into the spiraling violence of the early
period of conflict in Northern Ireland it gradually stepped down
its military campaign against the United Kingdom
's armed presence in Northern Ireland
, declaring a permanent ceasefire in May
1972. Following this the movement's political development
increased rapidly throughout the 1970s. On the national question
the Officials saw the struggle against religious sectarianism and
bigotry as their primary task. The party's strategy was based onthe
"stages theory": Firstly, view working class unity within Northern
Ireland had to be achieved, followed by the establishment of
a
United Ireland, and finally a
socialist society would be created in Ireland. In 1977 the party
published and accepted as policy a document called the
Irish
Industrial Revolution. Written by
Eoghan Harris and Eamon Smullen it outlined
the party's economic stance and declared that the ongoing violence
in Northern Ireland was "distracting working class attention from
the class struggle to a mythical national question." The policy
document used Marxist jargon, and identified American
imperialism as the now dominant political and
economic force in the southern state and attacked the failure of
the national
bourgeoisie to develop
Ireland as a modern economic power.
Official Sinn Féin evolved towards
Marxism-Leninism and became fiercely
critical of the physical force republican tradition still espoused
by Provisional Sinn Féin. Its new approach to the Northern conflict
was typified by the slogan it was to adopt: "Peace, Democracy,
Class Politics". It aimed to replace
sectarian politics with a class struggle which
would unite
Catholic and
Protestant workers. The slogan's echo of
Lenin's "Peace, Bread, Land" was indicative
of the party's new source of inspiration. Official Sinn Féin also
built up fraternal relations with
communist parties worldwide.
Throughout the 1980s the party became staunch opponents of
terrorism and were one of the few organisations on the left of
Irish politics to oppose the republican hunger strike of 1981.The
WP (especially the faction around Harris) was strongly critical of
traditional
Irish
Nationalism,causing some of its critics to accuse it of having
an attitude to Northern Ireland that was close to
Ulster Unionism.
As well as the developments at home international links were forged with the USSR and other socialist, workers' and communist parties from around the world.
IRSP/INLA split and feud
In 1974, there was a split in the Official Republican Movement over
the ceasefire and the direction of the organisation. This led to
the formation of the
Irish Republican Socialist
Party(IRSP) with
Seamus
Costello, who had been expelled from the
OIRA, as its chairperson. Also formed was its
paramilitary wing, the
Irish National Liberation
Army(INLA). There was a number of tit-for-tat killings in a
subsequent feud until a truce was agreed in 1977.
Name
Official Sinn Féin was sometimes called
Sinn Féin (Gardiner
Place) in the early to mid 1970s, using the name of the
location of its headquarters to distinguish itself from the rival
offshoot of Sinn Féin, called in the period
Provisional Sinn
Féin or
Sinn Féin (Kevin Street). For traditional
republicans, the mention of the Gardiner Place headquarters carried
symbolic power, because the Gardiner Place headquarters had been
the headquarters of Sinn Féin for decades before the 1970 split.
The name died out from usage in the mid 1970s.
In 1977 the Officials, renamed themselves
Sinn Féin The
Workers' Party, under which title they would win their first
seats in
Dáil Éireann. In
1979 a motion at the Ard Fheis to remove the Sinn Féin prefix from
the party name was narrowly defeated. The change finally came about
three years later. In Northern Ireland they were organised under
the name
Republican Clubs (a name that had first been used
to escape an earlier ban, introduced in 1964 under Northern
Ireland's
Emergency Powers Act)
until 1981 when they renamed themselves The Workers' Party
Republican Clubs. In 1982 both the northern and southern sections
became simply The Workers' Party.
Electoral performance (Republic of Ireland)
The Workers' Party became a significant political force in the
Republic in the 1980s, benefiting from disillusionment with poor
public services, high taxes and mass unemployment. The party made
its electoral breakthrough in 1981 when
Joe
Sherlock won a seat in
Cork East.
They increased this to three seats in 1982 and to four seats in
1987. 1989 witnessed the Workers' Party's best performance at the
polls when it won seven seats in the Irish general election as well
as winning one seat and 7% of the vote in the
European
election.
This was their highest ever share of the vote
in the Republic with over 70,000 votes in the Dublin
constituency being sufficient to have the party president,
Proinsias De Rossa, elected to
the European
Parliament
, where he took a seat with the communist Left Unity group.
Following the
split of 1992 (below)
Tomás Mac Giolla, a TD in the
Dublin
West constituency and President of the party for most of the
previous 30 years, was the only member of the Dáil parliamentary
party not to side with the new
Democratic Left. Although Mac Giolla was to
lose his seat in the general election later that year he would be
elected
Lord Mayor of Dublin in
1993. The Workers' Party also maintained elected representation on
Dublin, Cork and Waterford corporations in the aftermath of the
split.
In
recent years further electoral setbacks have left the party with
only two councillors in the Republic after the 2004 Local
Elections, both of whom were based in Waterford
. The party currently has one councillor in
Waterford and one in Cork
.
Electoral performance (Northern Ireland)
The party's fortunes were very different north of the border. They
gained ten seats at the
1973 Northern Irish local
elections. Four years later,
in May 1977, this had
dropped to six council seats and 2.6% of the vote. One of their
best results was when
Tom
French polled 19% in the
1986 Upper Bann by-election,
although no other candidates stood against the sitting MP and a
year later, when other parties contested the constituency, he only
polled 4.7%. Three councillors left the party during the split in
1992. One,
Davy Kettyles became an
independent 'Progressive Socialist' while the others, Gerry Cullen
in Dungannon and the WP northern chairman
Seamus Lynch in Belfast, joined
Democratic Left.
They held onto their
solitary council seat in the 1993 local elections
with Peter Smyth retaining the seat formerly held by Tom French in
Craigavon
. This was lost in
1997, leaving them
without elected representation in Northern Ireland.
In common with all other main parties, the WP is currently
registered with the British
Electoral Commission,
which covers Northern Ireland, with
John
Lowry named as its leader.
Provisional Sinn
Féin, the other party to emerge from the 1970 split, is
the party that is now commonly referred to simply as
Sinn Féin. They have had much greater
electoral success than Official Sinn Féin in Northern Ireland.
However, the provisional's electoral performance in the Republic
was poor until the IRA ceasefires of 1994 and 1997 and they have as
yet failed to reach the seven seats won in Dáil Éireann by the
Workers' Party in 1989.
The 1992 split
In early 1992, following a failed attempt to change the
organisation's constitution, six of the seven party TDs, its MEP,
numerous councillors and a significant minority of its membership
broke off to form
Democratic
Left, a party which would later merge with the
Labour Party in 1999.The reasons for the
split were twofold. Firstly, a faction led by Proinsias De Rossa
wanted to move the party towards an acceptance of free market
economics. Following the collapse of communism in eastern Europe
they felt that the Workers' Party's Marxist stance was now an
obstacle to winning support at the polls. Secondly, media
accusations had once again surfaced regarding the continued
existence of the
Official IRA who it
was alleged remained armed and were involved in fund-raising
robberies, money laundering and other forms of criminality.
De Rossa
and his supporters sought to distance themselves from alleged
paramilitary activity at a special Ardfheis
(delegate conference) held at Dún Laoghaire
in on 15 February 1992. A motion proposed by
De Rossa and General Secretary
Des
Geraghty sought to stand down the existing membership, elect an
11 member provisional executive council and make several other
significant changes in party structures was defeated.
Many of those who
subsequently remained with the Workers' Party in the wake of the
split regarded those who broke away as careerists and social
democrats who had taken flight after the collapse of the Soviet Union
and denounced those who left as
'liquidators'.
The motion to "reconstitute" the party achieved the support of 61%
of delegates however this was short of the two thirds majority
needed to change the WP constitution. There were also claims of
widespread vote rigging by the supporters of the De Rossa motion.
As a result of the conference's failure to adopt the motion, De
Rossa and his supporters split from the organisation and
established a new party which was temporarily known as New Agenda
before the permanent name of Democratic Left was adopted.
In the North before the 1992 Split the party had 4 councillors, Tom
French stayed with the party, Gerry Cullen (Dungannon) and Seamus
Lynch (Belfast) joined New Agenda/Democratic Left, and David
Kettyles ran in subsequent elections in Fermanagh as an Independent
or Progressive Socialist.
While the majority of public representatives left with De Rossa,
many ordinary members remained in the Workers' Party. The party
replaced De Rossa as President with
Marian Donnelly who served from 1992 to
1994. In 1994
Tom French
became President and served for four years until
Sean Garland was elected President in 1998. He
retired as President in May 2008 and was replaced by
Mick Finnegan.
The party today
The Workers' Party has struggled since the early nineties to
rejuvenate its fortunes.
Its best performance at the polls in the
Republic of Ireland has been in Waterford
where it performed well in the 1992 and 1997
general elections. Outside of the south east the WP retains
active branches in various areas of the Republic, including
Dublin
, Cork
and County
Louth
. The party has faced similar problems in
Northern Ireland in recent years. It performed poorly in the March
2007 Assembly election. No seats were won and its best result came
in West Belfast where it gained 1.26% of the vote.The party
maintains a youth wing, Workers' Party Youth, as well as a Women's
Committee. They also have offices in Dublin, Belfast, Cork and
Waterford. In recent years, apart from its political work at home
in Ireland, it has also sent numerous party delegations to
international gatherings of communist and socialist parties.
The party continues to hold a strongly anti-sectarian position and
supported an independent anti-sectarian candidate, John Gilliland
in the 2004 European elections in Northern Ireland.
In February 2008 Cllr John Halligan of Waterford resigned from the
party when it refused to drop its opposition to service charges. He
subsequently became Mayor of Waterford after joining a pact with
Fine Gael, the Labour Party and a number of others.
Mick Finnegan is the current party
President, having been elected at the party's Ard fheis on 16/17
May 2008 to replace
Seán Garland
who had announced his decision to retire from the position after
ten years. The General Secretary is
John
Lowry and the party's Director of International Affairs is
Gerry Grainger.
The Workers' Party called for a No vote in the June 2008
Lisbon Treaty referendum and was part of the
successful No campaign. It also campaigned for a No vote in the
rerun of the referendum in October 2009 in which the treaty was
passed.
The party fielded twelve candidates in June2009 Local Elections,
also the party fielded Malachy Steenson in the Dublin Central
by-election on the same date.
In the June 2009 local elections,
Ted
Tynan was elected to Cork City Council in the Cork City North
East ward.
Davy
Walsh retained his seat in Waterford City Council.
Alleged links with North Korea
On June 20, 2004, the
BBC documentary program
Panorama alleged that
party president
Seán Garland was
involved in counterfeiting of US
dollar.
On October 7, 2005, Garland was arrested
by the Police Service
of Northern Ireland at the party's annual
conference in Belfast
. He was released on bail pending an extradition hearing to the United States
. The US government alleges that Garland
conspired with the North
Korean
government to import counterfeit $100 notes into
the US.
Garland has since jumped bail and returned to his home to the Republic of Ireland, and "placed himself under the protection of the Irish constitution and court system." He had sought bail successfully on medical grounds and assured the court that he would reattend to face his extradition hearing. The US requested the extradition of Sean Garland in January 2009 and was arrested by the Gardaí outside the Workers Party Offices in Dublin.
Party Presidents
Elected Representatives
See also
References
- Sinn Féin: A Hundred Turbulent Years,
Brian Feeney, O'Brien Press, Dublin 2002, ISBN 0 86278 695 9 pg.
250-1, Sinn Féin: A Century of Struggle, Parnell
Publications, Mícheál MacDonncha, 2005, ISBN 0 9542946 2 9
- Official Irish Republicanism, 1962 to 1972 by
Sean Swan,2008.
- Henry McDonald, Gunsmoke and Mirrors, ISBN
9780717142989 p. 28
- Stephen Collins, The Power Game: Fianna Fáil since
Lemass, ISBN 086278588X, p. 61
- See Swan,(pgs 303,330) and Brian Hanley and Scott Millar,
The Lost Revolution, 2009 (pgs. 220, 256-7).
- The Politics of Illusion:A Political History of the
I.R.A. by Henry Patterson, (1997) and Official Irish
Republicanism by Swan.
- The Longest War:Northern Ireland and the IRA by K.
Kelly (1988) claimed that SFWP's attitude to the North was
“indistinguishable in its structural form from that held by most
Unionists”. See also Swan,Official Irish Republicanism,
Chapter 8, and Politics in the Republic of Ireland by John
Coakley and Michael Gallagher (2004), Pg. 28
- One of Harris' critics, Derry Kelleher, accused him of adopting
the "Two Nations Theory" associated
with Conor Cruise O'Brien; see Kelleher's
book, Buried Alive in Ireland (2001).
- See Armed struggle: the History of the IRA by Richard
English, Oxford University Press US, 2004.
- Ireland Today:Anatomy of a Changing State by
Gemma Hussey,
(1993) pgs. 172-3,194 .
- Upper Bann results 1983-1995
- " Workers Party (The)", Electoral
Commission
- Proinsias De Rossa, ‘The case for a new departure Making Sense
March-April 1992
- BBC Spotlight programme, ‘Sticking to their guns’, June
1991
- Sean Garland, ‘Beware of hidden agendas’ Making Sense
March-April 1992
- Patterns of Betrayal, the Flight from Socialism, Workers Party,
1992, page 11
- The 1989 Local Government Elections,
www.ark.ac.uk
- Independent candidate: John Gilliland,
www.bbc.co.uk
-
http://www.munster-express.ie/local-news/workers-party-asks-halligan-for-his-seat/
- Workers’ Party asks Halligan for his seat by
Dermot Keyes, Munster Express Friday, February 22nd,
2008
- Workers' Party elect new Party President
- Lisbon - A Treaty Too Far Workers' Party
Website
- Local Elections Candidates
- Ted Tynan Elected Cork Politics Website, 7th of
June 2009
- North Ward Waterford City Council - Election 2009
results RTÉ Website, 7th June 2009
- BBC:US says N Korea forged dollars
- Ex-Workers' Party president Garland arrested by
Charlie Taylor, Irish Times, Friday, January 30th 2009
Further reading
- The Politics of Illusion: A Political History of the
IRA, Henry Patterson, ISBN 1-897959-31-1
- Official Irish Republicanism, 1962 to 1972 , Sean Swan
, ISBN 1430319348
- The Lost Revolution: The Story of the Official IRA and the
Workers' Party, Brian Hanley and Scott Millar, ISBN
1844881202
External links